Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi ya'll,

As promised, here's the first of my little writings about my random or obsessive RPG design thoughts. You'll often catch me on the discord rambling about this or that, and I've caught my wife up in terrible conversations about game design that I'm certain she is not that interested in, so I thought this would be a good place to put them so there are safely kept away for the sickos and won't bother anyone else. I'll try and post these at least monthly, whenever I have something to say.

So recently if you've been following me on social media, you'd know I've been playing Draw Steel (as a player, finally), which has been a great load of fun. The game master, Ben, has been excellent and it's been a good experience, not the least of which is me actually getting to see things from a player perspective for once, when I'm usually the one running games.

Something very interesting happened during the game though that I wanted to talk about. Ben ran a little 'prologue' for our characters - we got to see what each of them was up to before coming together as a party. My character, being a skeleton, woke up in a coffin. I was expecting Ben to kind of smooth things along to where my character could quickly do the cool thing and climb out of an open grave and really scare the shit out of someone. I did get to do that eventually, but interestingly, he first had me make a skill check to actually get the lid of the coffin open.

This ended up fascinating me, because normally this kind of thing really slows the hell out of a game and can cause things to drag, so I tend to avoid it. As I've run games over time, I've learned to lean away from checks like this. I mean, it's a foregone conclusion that my character is going to get out of the coffin - otherwise I wouldn't be an adventurer running around. It's not something that's very interesting to contend with - the minutae of things like opening doors, shopping, tracking currency, rations, doing travel checks, etc that tend to clog up the pipes, so to speak, of running a game like DnD, especially when you're a new GM.

If you are an inexperienced or somewhat clumsy GM, it's really easy for these kinds of situations to get stuck. If you've ever been a player in DnD before, over time you will come to learn the frustration of sitting in front of a locked door that your party just keeps whiffing checks to open over and over again. It would be very easy for a misanthropic or less deft GM to have my character just get stuck in that coffin, unable to open the lid, because it's a closer simulation of what would actually happen - but not a very interesting story.

Fortunately, Ben is a quite good GM, and when I whiffed the check to open the lid, the noise alerted another player character nearby who was able to get me out, and led to a pretty good (and satisfyingly spooky) scene - so things moved forward. Afterwards, though, something tickled me and I had a think about that check and the purpose of making all these little mechanical interventions into a narrative. I think in a lot of situations, they really do bog down a game, but in this case, they gave the game a quite satisfying texture.

Later in the game, we had to get up a river and had a whole little barter with a ferryman. Again, this was a prologue, so it was sort of a foregone conclusion that we'd get up this river and get to our destination. There was really no point (narratively) in making skill checks that would prevent us from getting there. Yet that whole exchange, figuring how to get somewhere, and having to haggle and maneuver around it (rather than just doing the whole thing in montage, for example) created really interesting friction. It was immersive - it lent to that sense of weight and verisimilitude that the world was a real place, governed by the laws of reality, that did not respect that we were heroes or characters in a story - and that things should not automatically bend our way just because they are convenient.

As I previously mentioned - this is something I have almost entirely eliminated when I run my own games. If a door has to open, it opens. If a merchant must be haggled with, they either agree or not, depending on what needs to happen to get the story moving. If we travel someplace and it's not particularly dangerous, we don't really care about how we get there. I like things to be snappy and smooth! I think it's something that most more experienced GMs lean away from in their careers because leaning on these kinds of gated checks (can you get into the city, there are guards at the gate! did you pay the gate toll?) can lead to dead ends and circular play that can bog down a game. It's something that, in my design, I have tried to eliminate by going towards leaner mechanics that don't require a lot of rolling at all - only in situations that are tense, risky, or unclear.

Excellent and very popular games like Apocalypse World or Forged in the Dark, some of my favorite games, have kind of furthered this trend by centering the mechanics and design on the the story. They are games about a story, and they run off the rules of story, not a simulated world. You don't make little friction checks in these games, the rolls basically are about the story and narrative - a brilliant conceit for fast and interesting game play, but one that also starts to feel sometimes like you are playing through a (usually pretty excellent) book or a tv show rather than fully secondary world, precisely because of this lack of friction. The GM doesn't typically roll at all in these games, for example - but rather reacts based on player action, because these games, perhaps rightly, recognize that the players are the protagonists and the story will move forward with them. They would not dream of having you make a check to open a door or pick a lock or bust open a coffin lid or haggle prices with a merchant - unless that was narratively interesting.

In the end though, I think running or designing a game where you smooth out these details, you ultimately remove a lot of this small and very interesting friction that puts players in the headspace of their characters - that makes the world feel real, lived in, and alive in a way that is not purely reactive to the players. It's an interesting conundrum as a designer, because this friction can really grind down games to halt. I think you have the natural instinct to get rid of it. I'm going to see in my future games if there's a way to productively add a little bit of it back in.

Have you noticed this running or playing your own games? Let me know what you think in the comments, I'd be very interested to see.

Catch you next time, you little monsters.

-Tom

Files

Comments

Ramon Bhoorasingh

I also have removed those kinds friction rolls when GM and as a player it bums me out when other GM just default to roll for everything. For me a good plan/interesting plan works and rolls are really there for sake of tension or drama. It really what the outcome interpretation of the outcome of that roll is what really matters otherwise don't consult the bones.

Hugh Eckert

I'm just getting back into LARP writing and GM-ing, so I'm rusty. But- I try to balance the reactive and proactive modes while storytelling for my players. If there's a check they whiff, I try to make it part of the story. If they go haring off on their own wild tear, I try to make it part of the story. I generally have an ending in mind, but sometimes getting them there is more intricate than other times.

DragonKarma

It’s an interesting dichotomy to be sure. Dice rolling as a method of mechanically creating uncertainty in the narrative is a foundational building block of ttrpgs. One could even argue that it is *the* defining feature that differentiates roleplaying *games* from storytelling. Yet dice rolling is also frequently the place where the most issues can occur with slowing down the game, creating repetition, etc. I’ve also fallen into the trend of making dice rolls matter and ensuring that trivial things are merely flavor with no chance of slowing things down. Case in point, I’m currently running Daggerheart, which absolutely requires you to ensure that rolls are narratively relevant because of its mechanics. I’ve not really considered the value of calling for rolls purely to ‘ground’ the world, but I certainly understand what you mean. Definitely something I’m going to consider.

Olive Perry

I recently playtested a friend's game that's pretty much nothing *but* these sorts of friction rolls. It was about hiking/navigating/traversing a semi-fantastic landscape (flooded cities, old riverbeds with the exposed debris of extinct witch-kings) where the mechanical tension was how much time & effort it was going to take. I remember how much tension there was in rolling to make our way up a slippery hillside, praying that we roll well enough to make it to the top before dark and without accruing too much misery points from falling in the water. It makes me think about Peak vs Skyrim -- you don't have the freedom of scale to tell a dragonslaying story in Peak because you're getting slowed down in the level geometry that Skyrim famously lets you ignore, but Skyrim loses this groundedness that you're talking about because it's operating at a more zoomed-out narrative scale. It's making me think about what a system would look like that lets you shift between modes as the storyteller deems appropriate, and the tradeoffs of being generalized/modal enough to do that.

Rasalhage

I've been messing around with Fabula Ultima, a game that leans alllll the way towards paving over friction that inhibits the story; and I think this kind of nails what's been bugging me. I don't want, necessarily, to simply sit down and tell others how cool I am or we are and have that be the law. I want to get through a situation by the skin of my character's teeth. What's attractive about what you've described is that I get *more* chances to show off my character, and their mindset and worldview. I want chances to react to mundane obstacles that my character has never encountered. Tangential video game example: I've been playing V Rising; a survival crafter where you're a vampire, and I feel like the game is *more* fun when it's daytime. Normally at night, you can move freely, and that's that. Kill what you want, take what you need. During the day, you have to move from bush to bush or cover to cover in the shade to survive. What I like about this, and how it relates to Ben's DMing, is that it moves the question from "what do you want to do" to "how will you do it?". Answering *how* is almost always more interesting than answering *what*; doubly so when your gut answer doesn't work, and you have to really think about what your next-best approach is. Tell Ben he kicks ass.

Alan Wiggs

These little introductions of friction I find really useful, when I'm planning ahead well, to prompt character interaction and teamwork. I really like a system like Fate or the FFG Star Wars games that hands out narrative currency for failure or complication, so players are mechanically induced to think around problems. Make a bad call or a bad roll? You get a chit from the GM that says "take this failure as a role playing prompt and explain how it helps *someone else* succeed next time"

Kevin Edwards

I really think these friction points and how they are treated can be really essential for players and GMs. It helps keep in focus that failure at a thing does not need to grind a story to a halt, and I think it makes you think well what am I going to do if this doesn't work? It was honestly Lancer's downtime system that crystallized that for how I run games with my friends where failure can often mean it happens in a different way or become more costly. For example I've run that locked door situation where there wasn't any time limit or pressure to move them. I ended up just asking them if the characters would just keep trying and had it that the failure meant they ended up busting the door down in frustration and they took some damage.It becomes a trade with the players that "yeah, we can railroad this so that you can just get in, but it may cost something."

PotentPinion

Kind of like pins in an old pinball machine: ideally deciding where the ball goes in important ways, and annoying when they just... get the ball stuck, but there's wiggle room there. Sometimes it's just exciting to see another bounce even if there was no huge impact on the way the ball falls.

ABBADON

Yeah I think I like the pushback a little, I like things to be grounded sometimes and to feel like something has eluded my grasp

ABBADON

yeah that's generally my attitude, but I do like it when the game pushes back at you a little bit in interesting ways

Ramon Bhoorasingh

Same i don't mind a game's system being like that, but the key it has to be interesting and that's on the GM not the system not the mechanics. When the GM is relying too much on mechanics to move the story a long or resolves things it gets just gets tedious to me.