Monthly yap blog #2: Toy vs Game (Patreon)
Content
Hi ya'll,
Technically this is the yap blog for November which ended up getting a little delayed due to a certain turkey-based holiday over here.
Hope reading the last blog was interesting or helpful for you. I'm not actually super well read on game design theory and basically follow my gut so I hope some of this doesn't come across as a repeat of something someone's said elsewhere, but more coherent and with 50% less dad brain. When I describe myself as a gorilla with a tiny hammer, I mean it.
Game design thought of the month this time is about tabletop role playing games as games vs toys. I read an excellent blog I stumbled across on bluesky (which I cannot fucking for the life of me remember or find a link to again). The blog was about points of good video game design, but one interesting point it made is the distinction between games and toys, that being that games, as defined as a course of activity with prescribed rules with no other purpose or meaning other than the game itself, and separate from a normal course of activity, are actually distinct from toys in one key aspect: games have an objective or a goal, whereas toys do not.
A soccer ball is a toy, and soccer is a game you can play with that toy. If you're just kicking the ball around to have fun, you are not playing a game.
There are some video games that actually lean close to toys, or at least are very loose enough in their actual procedure and goal that they approach toys. I can't think of any off the top of my head any that are actually purely toys but that toy-like quality is very present in a broad swathe of video games, especially in games from certain companies like Nintendo, who seems to value the experiential quality of playing their games as much as the game's hard rules, systems, etc (if you don't believe me, just try jumping in a 3d mario game and you'll see what I mean). I don't think many people play Animal Crossing to do their daily chores as much as they do to just set up a neat little island and collect furniture. Other 'games' that provide a social space also pass the toy test, like VR chat, where the space is the point, or even elements of games like Fortnite, with its concert and social spaces.
The rest of this blog was very focused on the mechanics and creation of video games specifically, but this one take away was very interesting to me, because sometimes I think game designers have a tendency to view tabletop role playing games very similar to video games, ie they think in terms of systems, dice mechanics, simulation, 'core' gameplay loops, incentives, etc. Certainly I think there is space for thinking this way about games, and it can be super productive and useful. I think your game's mechanics should above all be useful, productive, and help reinforce and create the fiction of your game, and paying attention to that can be extremely clutch when it comes to nailing down a good design for your game.
There's one thing though I think that designers often miss, which is that I think a lot of tabletop role playing games are actually closer to toys than games. They often have rules, procedures, and mechanics (like a game), but unlike a game they actually usually lack an explicit goal or end state. A game of dungeons and dragons doesn't actually end when you hit maximum level, or when you beat a monster, or when you acquire treasure. None of these are explicitly goals in the game, they are just things you can do (and often find yourself doing, due to the nature of how the procedures and mechanics of the game are geared towards these things). You can't beat a ttrpg.
Where it gets sticky is I think something like dungeons and dragons might sometimes acquire the properties of a game. In fact, I would say that dnd and many other ttrpgs that contain grid based wargames or procedure heavy combat rules (lancer, pathfinder, some osr stuff, etc) has a game nested in it (combat) where there sort of a goal (don't die, defeat your enemies). But even then, this gets muddy. For example, there's a culture of play at your table that might lean more or less into these rules, or away from them as needed, rather than playing the game strictly and as written. Most groups I find do not play dungeons and dragons where the gm attacks downed players to kill them, even though this is the tactically optimal move (per rules of the game), simply because it A. is kind of a dick move B. isn't very fun.
There's also the fact that most of these games are played as a simulation of a situation, rather than a separate game activity. You roll into these things saying 'let's fight these orcs' rather than 'let's play Tactical Combat, the board game'. You might do things not allowed in the game rules, or there might be bleed-in from the fiction or improvisation at the table. This is commonplace enough that I think it's more or less standard table culture and that's reflected in a lot of really popular places people are watching and playing rpgs nowadays (dimension 20, critical role), etc., where they hardly play by the rules at all.
I think you can kind of go through this thought and say 'well, let's design a better game for people to play where the rules are tighter and they can have a good, board game like experience without need to kludge it'. In other words, continue to think about and refine the game part of these games. I think sometimes people actually are here for the game that's nestled inside the tabletop role playing. Certainly that's what I tried to do with Lancer, for example, and it's hard to deny the popularity of games like Pathfinder, which does this to an exhaustive degree.
I do, however, as I've become a more experienced designer, think that approaching design this way you can really miss out on all the things that are interesting about tabletop role playing games in particular. You can get too focused on the mechanics, on the procedure, on the mechanical part of the game, to the point that it interferes with the looseness and flow of playing a ttrpg - of the immersion and verisimilitude. I think this is where OSR style games, and some (but actually, I think not most) story or narrative games, have a really interesting and productive approach. They push the rules out of the way or minimize them in favor of emphasizing setting, vibe, wordbuilding, etc - sometimes to their detriment (I think these games are famously hard to run for most GMs, for example), but often to their benefit, as it is very easy to immerse yourself in these games without their mechanical structure getting in the way (just look at mork borg, for example).
I used to sort of scratch my head at these games, and I certainly don't think they have enough scaffolding to work for everyone (try running mork borg for more than a few sessions for example). But now I think there's something very brilliant about them and I think largely the reason this second approach works (rules light, setting heavy, vibes heavy) is that, to put a point on it, I don't think most tabletop role playing games are really games at all, but lean closer to toys. They focus on the aspects of a ttrpg that are more important to the experience of play (immersion, vibe, verisimilitude, tone, etc) rather than the actual game rules.
I dunno where to take all this other than that in future I'm going to paying close attention to those qualities of my personal games (cain/maleghast, etc), which I think already kind of lean that way by chance due to being very art and vibes heavy. I think thinking about games as things to be played and experienced socially rather than games that have a definitive end state and goal is actually a lot more productive for your design in the long term.
Hopefully that helps someone untangle something in their own design. Let me know what you think, and see you in a couple weeks for the next one!