Monthly Yap Blog: Tactile RPGs and in defense of simulationism (Patreon)
Content
Hi ya'll,
Quick blog this month with some Big Think (tm) spurred on my recent experience with Draw Steel. As some of you might know if you've been following my bluesky, I've been in a Draw Steel game for the past several months that's gone about 10-12 sessions (a pretty tall feat for most games!). It's been a great deal of fun and I've definitely learned a little bit as a game designer, mostly things that have been surprising or interesting that I wasn't expecting to find (like my previous blog about the importance of a little bit of friction in RPGs, also something I learned from our early Draw Steel sessions).
Draw steel is a fairly crunchy game, and wears it proudly on its sleeve. It's more streamlined that similar games (like Pathfinder) in ways that I think are generally somewhat limiting to the design space, but are otherwise a huge boon to the ease of running and playing the game. The game is heavily focused on a very punchy, kinetic tactical combat with a lot of emphasis on movement, space, and pushing or pulling characters around.
When I first read through the game, I was struck by the degree of granularity with some of these movement rules. It makes concessions to simulationism that I generally try to avoid with my own game design. For example, there are rules like this:
The first rule (falling more than 100 squares) is patently ridiculous, as I think there's very few situations you would survive this, and scant few it would come up. There are like 4-5 other sub-rules on falling by the way, including falling on creatures, falling while being pushed off cliffs, etc.
The second and third ones are very interesting because they add this weird level of granularity to the world. Climbing creatures and punching someone through a wall having tangible rules simulate something that might otherwise by ruled by improv, dm fiat, player suggestion, etc, and bring it into a tangible space where it is now part of the game's lexicon of situations that might occur while playing this game.
I tend to avoid these kinds of rules because they create all kinds of weird edge cases and exploitable gameplay that kind of avoids the point of these rules in the first place (to simulate a game space that obeys some kind of tangible law). For example, one of the most efficient things you can do in Draw Steel, damage-wise, is to slam people into walls over and over again or knock them off cliffs. It's guaranteed damage and positioning that you can get by trading in a manuever (a bonus action if you're thinking in dnd 5e terms). Flying creatures in Draw Steel can simply hover around and not interact with much of the gameplay space, making them a nightmare to fight if you're relying on melee. One of the most damaging things you can do is with a flying creature as a draw steel director, outclassing nearly all abilities, is simply grab someone, fly straight up in the air as high as possible, and drop them.
Lancer (my own game) had a huge problem for a while, for example, with similar rules around falling, flight, etc, so I highly limited or simplified them. In my most recent big game, Icon, flying is a status effect and looks like this:
There's no 3d space in icon because (as always in games like this) it is a huge pain in the ass to track. Punching people into walls does nothing by default because I (probably rightly) understood this would get abused by players seeking to maximize their damage output on their turns).
You might take this even further and do away with tracking space entirely, like Daggerheart.
In Daggerheart, the space is entirely abstract, there isn't even any grid. We instead operate on vaguely defined range bands. The game does just ok at this I think and certainly leaves a lot to be desired, but its functional. Other games without map based tactical combat like Mothership or certain OSR games also function this way. You could push it all the way and remove the tactical space entirely, but then you'd be playing an entire different (some would argue) genre of game, so we're not going to bother with it.
As you can see, I've sort of settled on one space removed from the kind of crunchy spatial rules that Draw Steel has. Draw Steel, itself, is one step removed from games with even more specific space and movement rules, like Pathfinder. I find these kinds of rules really slow down gameplay, create weirdly perverse game incentives, and create lots of odd edge cases that take a while to adjudicate.
And yet!
I think they have one huge virtue. In my most recent Draw Steel game, we were trying to fight a Thorn Dragon.
Fuck this guy by the way.
We had a good shot at taking him out, but to do so, my character had to figure out the following steps:
Jump 10 feet in the air to maximize fall damage straight off a balcony
Fall 55 feet.
Hit the dragon by falling on him, dealing damage to both of us
Get punted into an adjacent space, bouncing off the dragon like its fucking super mario, then fall another 25 feet
Get to my feet, then do another standing jump in the air (10 feet) so that my 10 ft reach whip could hit the bottom of the dragon (hovering at 40 ft in the air with his head at 50 feet because he occupies a 10x10x10 block of space)
The calculus involved in this was a good 10-20 minutes of real time, mostly involving how not to instantly die in the middle of this sequence of events. It massively slowed the game down. It was fiddly and required a lot of going over rules. For a lot of people, this would be a death sentence for a game.
Why the fuck are we simulating this degree of granularity? Couldn't we have used the power of role playing games to imagine this situation our head and skip all the process of calculating fucking fall damage? If this were a pbta game or some sort of other narrative game like austin walker's Realis, this would have been one roll or one short conversation and would have been resolved in 5 minutes max while still retaining a lot of the drama.
The answer, I think, is twofold:
First, rules like this heavily engage you with the space of game you are playing. They force you to actually pay attention to the battlefield and its shape. They create an awesome open space for player expression with their abilities. I actually love this aspect of Draw Steel. You don't just look at walls and floors and castles and hills any more. You go 'Hey, I could throw that guy through 3 blocks of solid stone and it would do a shit ton of damage and be cool as shit'. Because there are rules for that! The world has a tactile shape and quality that you lose heavily with more narrative games. You don't really think at all about the shape and space of things when you are playing a narrative or more abstracted game. The more you move down the narrative scale, the more removed you are from this 'tactile' feel. The world feels more real and grounded, because it, in a sense, is - it is governed by rules much like our own that can create spontaneous and interesting gameplay situations.
This aspect of games like these isn't for everyone, I will admit. Some people heavily bounce off this kind of game for exactly the reasons I am describing. They want something loose and fast and narrative. They don't want to calculate the relative speeds of a quetzalcoaltus and a steam train to figure out how long it will take to catch up (something we actually did in a DnD game I was part of). I'm often among these people! But I think this misses the second point which is:
Second, I think these kinds of rules create somewhat healthy engagement with the game as a rules construction, ie the game in the game. I think I've said previously that I think RPGs are basically toy-like in their construction, and often contain games (ie, dnd contains the game 'dnd tactical combat'), rather than being traditionally defined games themselves. Narrative games still generally contain rules that govern their play space that players will engage with in the way that players always engage with rules, which is to maximize their value (ie play in an 'optimal' way).
Something that often rubs me the wrong way is that games will often try to claim to not be about these rules, like the laughable claim that dnd fifth edition is not primarily a (very mediocre to bad) tactical game, when something like 80-90% of its rules are about that space.
I think sometimes rpgs are embarrassed to be compared to board games or war games, but I think this is entirely wrong. This is actually a huge virtue of these kinds of tactics rpgs. I don't think a lot of people come to tactics games expecting freeform improv theatre with some light elves attached. I think they are looking, basically, for a cooperative war game or board game with some role playing on the side. Playing war games or board games with your friends is fun as shit! It's part of the reason I think Lancer has taken off. You get to do cool, outlandish shit, using the game rules, and you get to do it with your friends.
If I had to do one roll, pbta style, to stunt on this dragon, it wouldn't have hit as hard as that 15 minute turn where I had to engage with both the game rules and the simulated game world in order to get an outcome. It feels both grounded and immediate. I crit that dragon and beat his ass and it felt amazing, because every step of it was squeezed out of some mutual adjudication with the game world.
Anyway, I don't think I'm won over to this kind of rule yet, but it did get me thinking about engagement with the play space in tactics games. Much to consider for Icon and future designs! Let me know what you think and if you've had any similar experiences.
-Tom