Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

What's up ya'll!

Quick one this month. I'm now about 5 sessions into a Daggerheart campaign (I'm a player, which has been interesting) and I thought I would talk about some of the experiences I've taken away from it. As some of you may know I actually did a little consulting work on the game on the back end (specifically for the combat system), mostly just to look at it and give feedback, a lot of which they incorporated. I haven't had the actual opportunity to play it until now.

My overall feeling about the game prior to playing it was that Daggerheart seemed to me to be a game that plays the way most people already play fifth edition DnD, or think it should play, or watch it played (via youtube, twitch, etc), which was a game I thought someone should have made a long time ago. I was pretty ready to recommend it over 5th edition DnD to anyone trying to start something up. It has a more interesting mixed resolution out of combat rolling system and (in theory) is trying to streamline the tactical combat into something more loose and quick to play.

I think my impression of Daggerheart prior to playing it (perhaps uncharitably) was this was a game cosplaying fifth edition dnd. It's a game that gives you the vibes of playing a tactics game, instead of actually being a functional tactics game, which is largely true and I think remains so after my experience playing it. I don't mean to deride the game this way, I actually think this is the experience a lot of people want coming to these kinds of games. They don't want rules that are too tight or dominate the session too much, they want to be involved in the fiction, they want to do cool stuff with their characters, roll some dice, etc. Daggerheart allows that and gives you a degree of flexibility because the game is so loose, so nebulous with its rules that the GM ignoring half of them is sort of how the game is supposed to be played.

After playing in a Daggerheart game for five sessions now (and three combats) I can comfortably say this game is not for me at all. I actually don't know if it's an improvement over playing 5e. All the worst parts of 5e, where the game is trying to bend itself around trying to be simultaneously a rules forward tactics game, a simulation, and a storytelling device, are equally as present here mostly because Daggerheart just doesn't really work very well, especially the tactical combat part. It has the exact problems I thought it would have looking into it when it first game out in playtesting.

In combat, the rules are both not specific enough and also not detailed enough to function as a tactics game.

They are also slow and clunky. Shit is so nebulous you constantly have to adjudicate distances, ranges, targets, things you can do, etc. The bizarre turn taking system makes things feel super uneven. The gated hp system where you're rolling bucketloads of damage dice but still just marking 2-3 hp is somehow slower and feels worse than just rolling dice and doing mat. The incredible weightiness on rolls with triggers, added effects, etc (when you deal damage, when you mark armor, etc you might be adding or checking for like 3 different things) and constantly checking for hope and fear slows the game right down. Combats in this game take as long if not longer than 5e combats and are vastly less interesting.

There are also huge problems that create really bad feeling situations. You can still miss and do nothing with your entire turn. There are effects that last until the GM decides they shouldn't (including high level abilities), effects that rely on actions taken (yet nothing is tagged as an action), the entire turn taking system is a huge mess, the math on foes and player resource attrition is whacky and favors the players to an extreme degree, etc.

My main feeling though, which is kind of the point of this post, is the game doesn't create any interesting tension with its rules, because the rules are not tight or defined enough in the first place.

Let's look at a really simple situation in daggerheart and dnd 5.5e. My friend is about to get stabbed by an orc, and he's some distance away. I have a healing potion I can get to him. I have to run past another orc to get to my friend.

In daggerheart, you would simply move to your friend (if he's close), since nothing says you can't move through enemies. The orcs do not react or do anything actually. We don't actually track how far away he is. There's no grid or really well defined movement rules. If he's not close, you make a roll and potentially end your turn if you fail, which feels fucking awful. Once we get to him, is handing him a potion an action? Does he then have to drink the potion as a separate action? (ie do these tick down abilities which track 'actions taken', which exist - the game does not say!) Do we just get to do these two things without rolling, then take a turn as normal? Play only passes back to the GM as a response when we roll, so assuredly yes. But that doesn't create anything interesting. The two situations actually adjudicated by the rules here suck. Either our friend is too far away (which the GM gets to decide arbitrarily) and we roll and potentially end our turn without doing anything and pass play back to the GM, which is dogshit, or we just walk up to our friend, pass him the healing potion, and he drinks it, and then one of us takes a turn. Nothing has happened here either way. The foes do not feel real because there is no friction here. The stakes do not feel real because the GM is basically arbitrating half of this situation based on vibes, because the rules don't cover them.

In DnD, you would actually check your movement speed to see if you could get to your friend or not (a tension point - maybe you have a tool or someone can move you closer before you take your turn). You might have to shove through an enemy space and make a check (a tension point). The orc in between probably gets an opportunity attack on you (a tension point). Handing the potion to your friend is probably not an action, but drinking it is a bonus action, which your friend cannot do until he takes his turn (a tension point, what if the orc strikes him down first?).

Other games like Draw Steel, which I have been playing, have the exact same cadence, and does it better than dnd. Every limitation or rule is an invitation for players to reach into a toolbox, ask around for help, scheme or plot, do something cool or powerful to reverse the situation and resolve the tension. Without these naturally occurring points of tension, there's nothing there. You're just rolling dice and doing math. There's nothing tying you to the act of playing the game. You check out!

Anyway, check out and play Daggerheart if you can. It certainly has its virtues over the current edition of DnD and I think I'd still give it a recommend. But it's definitely not for me.

Cheers,

Tom

Comments

SamuraiSushi

I think this is a thoughtful take. I’ve made an effort to run as many games as I can across different systems and have the good fortune to have a small and committed group that plays almost weekly. We’re about six sessions into a Daggerheart of our own and I’d largely agree with your overall assessment. Only real difference is that we’ve ended up enjoying it. I’m running this one with a very small party, just three, and a group of players that also loved LANCER’s intense crunchy combat. I think as a much looser pressure release from a more tactical ruleset the system is pretty nimble and can move very quickly but it’s absolutely heavily dependent on the GM’s control of the situation and the table kind of all being on the same page. Scales badly as a result. As far as risk and combat danger I’ve done well so far creating little moments, but it does largely feel like open RP, winging it with some dice tacked on. I do like the fear system, as a GM. The slowly mounting dread as a party watches me stockpile fear for something to go very wrong all at once is a compelling metagame. I’d agree it’s not for everyone and it’s probably not really a 5E replacement but it also plays less like other things than I expected it to and we’ve been having a good time taking it fast and loose.

Benjamin Brownstein

This post is incredibly validating to me. I've started running Daggerheart for a group that only wants a game with 5e vibes. I'd heard over and over that Daggerheart was a great direct 5e replacement, and when I read it, it seemed promising. But actually playing it has been kind of a nightmare. In many ways, it wants to be a narrative game like PbtA, but the best PbtA games are incredibly explicit and intentional about how their mechanics are used. Daggerheart instead is often just loose DM arbitration. But then on the other hand it has tons of combat moves for the players and enemies, gesturing at tactical play, but it's all so thin that there's not anything actually engaging there. I've only ran one session so far, but I already have so many other quibbles (combat is so heavily biased towards the players, NPC allies not having stats, having to spend a resource to get any benefit from your experiences, the main resources for both players and GM being entirely randomly generated, etc etc) that I think I'm going to give it up and transition this group back to 5e

Newbie_101

I vibe a lot with this take, but I should note we have been playing Daggerheart via Foundry with battle maps and it's still clunky, but you can answer the questions about how far, etc. My frustration is that a lot of the super cool abilities you get require Hope, yet the GM is heavily incentivized to use boss abilities that take away Hope from the players. In a larger number of players (6-7), having two turns without Hope because you get unlucky rolls and not using some of the most fun stuff you have feels terrible.

Ian Hart

Draw Steel is so fun! I think your tension focused analysis is a great way of looking at "tactical" RPGs generally.

Newbie_101

Let me add a specific bit about the damage caps. 1. It definitely makes abilities that exceed the caps feel way more valuable. 2. Any kind of fight timer or pressure feels impossible to deal with, because you can only do so much damage and missing happens. There are very few levers and tradeoffs that specific classes have to help this, but basically, the timer feels out of your hands. 3. Reactions that deal damage are incredibly valuable because they can help insert bonus damage into the fight. 4. Because you have no idea who is going to go when, enemy or friend, trying to do any kind of tactical organization feels very fruitless. As a warrior, I am the only class that can make opportunity attacks and 9/10 times I pick the "does not move" option, because it is one of the few ways to help control space. Otherwise, you can try to plan something, but then your buddy rolls with fear, the GM uses a "all minions move and attack" ability and the board looks completely different. 5. Tag Teams should be super cool. They have a high Hope cost, but there is nothing better than having 2 (I wish it could be more) PCs working together to describe a sweet move that really changes the scene. Except with damage caps, you are still only ever going to do Severe damage, so it is not going to mechanically be any more effective. 6. Crits are valuable because they auto-succeed, give you Hope and clear a Stress. The bonus damage is largely irrelevant. There are abilities around crits, but by default they do not speed up the combat resolution much. 7. The caps sort everyone's damage into 3 categories, so everyone's abilities can start to feel similarly effective and not very distinct. You make one roll (or force a saving throw) and the result is Small, Medium or Large in Physical or Magical flavor.

Simon Marks

I think that I knew on my first reading that Daggerheart wasn't for me because of the issues you raise. I've been hanging around RPG theorists too long, and keep coming back to "system matters" - the rules should by the nature of following them produce the game you are after. You don't need a lot of rules - Wanderhome has about 1/2 a page of mechanics really - or very few rules - Ars Magica has a 700 page edition coming out. What it needs for me is that the rules push towards a coherent whole. World Wide Wrestling boils all of it's rules down to "Does this rule generate situations and results like those you see on wrestling shows." D&D 5.5 doesn't. GURPS claims not to, but very much does. And Daggerheart's rules say very little leading to your issues.

Safa Farhoumand

I'm reporting you to Matt Mercer and you will be chained to the flaying tree at the end of the universe where the great Roc endlessly torments blasphemers!

ABBADON

good luck buddy im behind 30 war forms

Lojaan

Great write up! Have you read Valeria's hilarious review, "Daggerheart - a Dishonest Review (full of Lies)". I highly recommend. I don't think she would agree that it is cosplaying as 5e, she sees it as a love letter to neotrad games. Makes sense when you think of it as a game made by folks who love 5e, and were forced to make their own system because of the OGL. I really like your take on friction points - I think they highlight what a person likes. If you like that friction then it is enjoyable, if you don't then it is tedious. The friction DH is designed for is narrative/dramatic rather than tactical so I think "giving the vibes of a tactics game without being one" is a pro rather than a con for people who like that sort of game. The folks who are not really interested in systems mastery where it comes to TTRPGS.