Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Sci-Fi Comedy Poll!

  • Men In Black 19
  • Mars Attacks 13
  • Galaxy Quest 29
  • Spaceballs 13
  • 2024-07-10
  • —2024-07-15
  • 74 votes
{'title': 'Sci-Fi Comedy Poll!', 'choices': [{'text': 'Men In Black', 'votes': 19}, {'text': 'Mars Attacks', 'votes': 13}, {'text': 'Galaxy Quest', 'votes': 29}, {'text': 'Spaceballs', 'votes': 13}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2024, 7, 15, 14, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2024, 7, 10, 3, 11, 47, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 74}

Content

Hi Everyone! It was another nail-biter last week, but the  winner was True Lies! Total Recall was a close second though, so we'll keep that in mind for the future.

This week we're asking what your favorite Sci-Fi Comedy is! A few of these have been recommend by you before, so we're excited to see what wins. Happy voting!

Comments

djKENTO

The more familiar you are with Star Trek the more you'll get out of Galaxy Quest.

Nathan Jasper

How do you choose between four classics? I know! vote for all of them! 😂

Ronny Boss

You can't go wrong with anything on this poll, all a guaranteed good time. I had to go with Mars Attacks; it was a coin toss between that or Men in Black.

Raven Dark

I voted for Galaxy Quest, but djKento is right, the more you know Star Trek, the more you'll "get" Galaxy Quest. IF Spaceballs happens to win, you need to watch the three original Star Wars movies first, or it'll go splat on you. Both movies are great, though, as long as you are familiar with the material it's satirizing.

Simone's Coconut Squire

Oh man, what a tough 4! All extremely good and you should just watch them all really. Spaceballs is best if you’ve seen a handful of other movies first, and Galaxy Quest is good if you’re at least generally familiar with some sci-fi tropes. Mars Attacks is geared towards a more offbeat sense of humor. MIB is pretty good for everyone, but is most impactful I think for those of us old enough to remember the men in black as mythic spooks and government boogeymen before this movie made them a punchline.

dys

All great choices, but Galaxy Quest vs. Men in Black is such a hard decision. Had to go with Galaxy Quest because it's probably my favorite comedy of all time but MIB is right up there.

iOmegaTron

To note on what everyone else is saying about Star Trek and Galaxy Quest, they may be right but I've never watched Star Trek and Galaxy Quest is still one of my top 10 favorite movies!

iOmegaTron

AND I prefer it to all of the other options. It's just a fantastic movie!

mikethemotormouth

Re: Spaceballs, have you seen Planet of the Apes(1968)?

ButtercupsTrueLove

I've watched most seasons of ALL of the Trek series and you're right - there's plenty of humor and nods to Trek but fans will get more out of "Galaxy Quest" than the uninitiated.

Noah Vogt

I will be highly disappointed in the Maplenuts community if Spaceballs doesn't win this poll. That's not a knock on any of the other films, but I mean c'mon.

Raven Dark

Oh, shoot, right, I forgot to mention that too. mikethemotormouth is right, don't watch Spaceballs without seeing the first original Planet of the Apes film starring Charlton Heston beforehand. Spaceballs spoils an important part of that movie, and I highly recommend you guys watch PotA, because it's a great film.

sarCC

Men In Black is so great, so funny and inventive. But Galaxy Quest is undeniably incredible. One of the slyest and surprisingly heartfelt comedies of all-time. And it features so many great actors in some of their best performances.

This Justin

I donno. Galaxy Quest losses a bit if you have never seen a star trek show.

JM63

Like a lot of ppl have said, I think Galaxy Quest is funnier after getting familiar with Star Trek: The Original Series (TOS). You definitely don't need to watch the entire series (79 eps), around 10 is sufficient. This is a good watch/skip guide for TOS, I'd go with any episode rated 4 or higher (I'd also add Mirror, Mirror). The original crew movies are also really great if you haven't seen them yet. https://www.letswatchstartrek.com/tos-episode-guide/

Maplenuts React

Oh fun! We've seen all of TNG, but only a little bit of the original series.

Maplenuts React

It's true! We love TNG and have seen a bit of the original series too!

JM63

But like others have said, Galaxy Quest can still be enjoyed on its own. Just hoping for some classic Trek on the channel someday, it's a pillar of pop culture

Thomas Yanez

Regarding the "Galaxy Quest" discussion going on - I don't feel it is really a matter of whether you will enjoy the movie more or less based on whether you have seen the original Star Trek series. While there are definitely some Easter eggs and/or references that come straight out of the old series, I think that enjoying the movie is more based around knowledge of sci-fi tropes, fan convention culture, and background on some of the shared animosities that the cast of the original Star Trek series had with each other, and with their fanbase. The movie pokes more fun at William Shatner the actor than his character, Captain Kirk. That said, really looking forward to "True Lies".

Maplenuts React

oooooh okay! Well we both love Sci-fi, so we know some of the tropes, and we've been to a Comic-con before, so we know a bit about that too!

dys

Yeah it doesn't rely on direct references as much as Spaceballs or to a lesser extent Mars Attacks do, it very much has its own story that's in the mold of a Star Trek but not directly spoofing it.