Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Evening everyone! We hope your week is off to a great start ❤️Last week's Modern Horror poll winner was Get Out. We're both very excited and nervous to see it haha. This week instead of our regular poll, we're doing the thing where we ask all of you for 1 - 2 recommendations of what TV shows you want to watch with us! We'll round up your suggestions and use them for a MEGA POLL next week. We did this last Fall, and it helped us out a ton with choosing what to watch up until now. So, please write down your suggestions in the comments below and tune in next week for the poll!

Comments

Belly

arcane

Belly

sherlock

Oliver

Stranger Things to keep with those 80'd vibes.

Drell77

Stargate sg-1

N.T. Stars

I'd recommend Severance or Arcane. I love both of these, I think you'd both enjoy them, too, and there's wild moments in both that would make for great reactions.

Logan Bruin

Pushing Daisies, The Prisoner ;o)

Darian Harman

If you've seen 2022's The Batman, then I would highly recommend The Penguin. Remarkable. If you haven't seen Battlestar Galactica, it is very noteworthy. The 90-minute pilot is a great introduction, but once the series begins, OMG. Some of the greatest science-fiction storytelling ever.

Andrew R

Rome HBO (2 seasons)

deific

The Expanse

thebeefmaster

Short Series: Sense8 or Dead Like Me Long Series: The X-Files

GD

Deadwood Sopranos Lonesome Dove (miniseries)

ChiefWill15

Stranger things Its always sunny in philadelphis

Jay Johnson

to switch things up, are there any Canadian shows that American viewers might not be familiar with? (or maybe that wouldn't generate enough views/interest to be worthwhile) or maybe Letterkenny

Ian A

Miniseries I loved Devs-2020 1 season Moon Knight-2022 1 season Everyones suggestions sound awesome. Good luck!

TONY T

Mind Hunter

Cameron

Battlestar Galactica (probably first to get a good start on amazing sci-fi) I would suggest all of Stargate because I'd love to see it, it's just soo many episodes The Expanse, is a must at some point There's others here that are great suggestions also

Nathan Jasper

Snowpiercer 12 Monkeys Broadchurch His Dark Materials Been wishing a reactor would do those for a while now!

JaxonDanger12

Battlestar Galactica (2003) Expanse

Dor

Battlestar Galactica The Wire

Andy

I usually always recommend Orphan Black. Fun little sci-fi type show. 5 seasons Tatiana Maslany does a great job.

Gary Leyh

I'll second Battlestar Galactica, such good Sci Fi!

Andy

I really enjoyed Deadwood. Ian McShane was freaking awesome.

Alexis

Sherlock Black Books 24 (maybe just first 2 or 3 seasons)

Michael Jones

Ted Lasso. Or maybe Ted Lasso. Then maybe Andor, and some Ted Lasso.

Scott Lindsey

For spooky season I would suggest The Haunting of Hill House, it's a 10 episode series so kinda short. Otherwise The Expanse is great sci fi and The Sopranos is always a must watch. For an amazing animated series i'd suggest Arcane.

John Conti

Westworld amazing show HBO

DirtySteve

Twisted Metal season 2 Sherlock

Clara V.

Black Sails 12 Monkeys (the show, not the movie)

Kenny Teeology

The show "Legion". It's a very weird show and one of the best superhero shows ever made, with horror elements. It's very loosely a part of the X-Men universe but you don't need to know anything going in. Also the recent show "Paradise" is very good.

Ryan W.

Severance

Bill J

The Man in the High Castle, excellent alternate history show

VirtuallyVeronicka

Stranger Things…get ready for the big finale in November!

Dan Hughes

Burn Notice, fun spy show.

Stropheum

Would you guys consider doing any anime? I think you would really enjoy some stuff. The Bear is an amazing tv show though

Dan

"Justified" with Timothy Olyphant isn't known well enough but it's better than almost any suggestion you're gonna get. I'd put it right below Breaking Bad and on par with Better Call Saul. For a movie, you'd love GATTACA with Ethan Hawke, Jude Law, and Uma Thurman

MaggieS61

You would absolutely love The Walking Dead!! One of the greatest series ever.

BNR

Seconded: >> Justified! Modern Cowboy Epic!

Abby

my #1 Vote

BNR

"Jackie Daytona. Regular Human Bartender."

BNR

Battlestar Galactica (Movie + Series) and Lucifer!

Tom Evans

Black Sails Queen's Gambit

Michael Short

Stranger things and Vikings (if you liked game of thrones you will love Vikings)

Darian Harman

"I need you to respect the staff. I need you to respect the diners. And I need you to respect yourself!".

Matt

Stranger Things, GLOW, Squid Game, The Boys, Invincible, Daredevil

Kayshinae

I can't suggest Firefly, because that's how I found you guys! I judge all people by their reactions to Firefly; no one needs to be around people who don't like the crew of Serenity. XD That being said, Stranger Things is a GREAT call. It has a little bit of everything, and wonderful 80s nostalgia.

RP

The Expanse (please please please) Arcane Shogun 🍻

Cliff Adams

The Prisoner (Patrick McGoohan)

William

Derry Girls

Irby

Yellowstone, Outlander

Muttley's Foundry Development

The Expanse. Probably the greatest sci-fi TV series ever made (made in Canada no less), with deep characters, a plot that will keep you on the edge of your seat and a great cast.

Joshua Gideon

Legend of Vox Machina it’s on Amazon Prime and possibly Agents of SHIELD on Disney +

Hans Engelen

Expanse is must see, hooked for sure on either episode 1 or 4

Mark D

Mr. Inbetween.

Tony Rogers

For a really heart warming and wonderfully philosophical series I suggest you check out The Good Place. It is absolutely excellent.

Guillaume Huet_rennibou

Two recommendations from me. Black Sails is a cool adventure/pirate series inspired by actual places and characters of the "golden age of piracy". Rome is a very well done series in two seasons, also inspired by history and characters of antic Rome. Both shows have a lot in common with GoT in terms of action and "dark" politics. Except, they are based on actual characters and events.

SbE

The Pitt (2025) on HBO Max

Sobizle

The Expanse and Dark

Vince

Fargo (season 1-2-3) thanks !

Barry

Dead Like Me (2003-2004), 2 seasons, 29 episodes + a direct to DVD movie

Barry

The original Battlestar Galactica (1978) (1s, 24ep unless you include Galactica 1980) or Buck Rogers (1979-1981) (2s, 32ep)

thomas king

Sopranos, The Wire, Boardwalk Empire, Entourage, Power

jasonm

Dollhouse, if you haven't seen it.

ZoeLo

Freaks and Geeks

Nuther_Doug

The Haunting of Hill House is a 10 episode miniseries on Netflix that is amazing. I highly recommend it.

neil katz

YES, the Expanse pluuuuuease

Andrew Heller

The haunting of hill house Supernatural (thats alotta seasons) Reacher Banshee

JP

Dark

Tommy

ENTOURAGE!

Tommy

Entourage. A classic HBO comedy /drama series loosely based on Mark Whalbergs life as an up and coming star in L.A navigating the movie business with the support of his friends. Countless cameos from Movie stars and directors who play themselves in the show.

neil katz

My first choice is The Expanse. Second choice would be Lucifer. It’s a lot of fun Battlestar Galactica, the 2003 reboot is excellent.

Raven Dark

I see a bunch of people recommending Stranger Things, but aren't you guys starting that series soon, or has something changed? Assuming you're still going to react to that, my two recs would be: -The Walking Dead -Cobra Kai (but you have to watch the first three Karate Kid movies first, though you'll love them).

Matthew D Newman

Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Angel, 24, Alias, Six Feet Under. All 10/10 shows.

Matthew D Newman

I forgot X-files and Star Trek (The Original Series). The Expanse is good but it ends really badly as they have to finish 4 books in one season.

Evan

The Sorpanos or Modern Family? Two very different vibes

Gilbert

since you love scifi! i reccomend 1st season "altered carbon" and l,ets throw in Fargo Season 1, 2 and 3

KamikazeCDN

I'd love to see you guys react to Sons of Anarchy. That show doesn't get enough attention but it's so good. Plus as much as I do enjoy a lot of the commonly suggested shows...I need to admit I would enjoy something different for once. Vikings would also be a lot of fun to watch along with you guys.

KamikazeCDN

The reacting world needs more attention on Sons of Anarchy

Togs101

Justified, The Good Place

ShadowDrgn

I loved Altered Carbon. So sad it was cancelled. That and Badlands was amazing

Drell77

For All Mankind is really good. There should be a season 5 coming early next year also, or maybe late this year.

Kayshinae

And follow it up with Elementary!

Kayshinae

Ohhhh, good one! I didn't think of that, and they did love the vibe and humor of Firefly. Totally different premise, but of course same creator.

MaplenutsReact

Sadly we can't do Anime yet, because it very often gets copyright strikes which risks our channel getting taken down. Some other channels have gotten around this by having their own website and not using YouTube though, so that's definitely an option we're considering for when we have more time!

MaplenutsReact

Yes, we're watching Stranger Things for sure this fall!

Brien

The Sopranos, Stranger Things, You, The Haunting of Hill House

Flexwave

So many great suggestions, my favourites from them would be Sherlock BBC series The Expanse Battlestar Galactica Walking Dead Heroes S1

take it easy (tkitez)

Travelers (2016) and I think you guys may enjoy Legion (2017). Both around 30 episodes.

Max Hassam

Sherlock, Doctor Who, Fawlty Towers, IT Crowd :)

thebeefmaster

Yes to The X-Files and Star Trek (TOS)

David Caine

The one "show" I would love for you both to watch is an anime — Attack on Titan. Not sure how much or how little anime you are familiar with, but this one does not fall into the "infamous" tropes of the genre, and several of my other favorite reactors always at a certain point along the journey go on to say that this is not only of the best "cartoons" they have ever seen, but one of the best shows period — which it is. It is my favorite alongside Breaking Bad, Better Call Saul, and two others. Please consider it, but for a first time watch the subbed version would be the best way to experience it because of the superior acting and a proper rendition of the dialogue, which the dubbed version messes up and tweaks for the sake of tweaking more often than necessary. Another couple of shows I hope you consider.... LOST, which was an extremely big deal for network television during its run, an online event after every episode, and although time has passed considerably, the acting is superb, and it is still extremely unique and insane. From that same era as well, I also suggest Battlestar Galactica remake. Another great must watch show, a sci-fi epic that goes where you don't expect it. And I hope also someday you guys discover the greatness of the Buffy universe, which I hear is getting a revival of sorts.

Matthew Langley

The Magicians! Basically Harry Potter + In College + Narnia + Dark Humor.

Alecco

100% DARK on netflix its only 3 seasons with 26 episodes, but it will blow your mind (watch it in the german original, with english subs!)

WastedPo

Only Murders in the Building. That's really the only suggestion I can think of. I hope I'm not too late.

Brutally Goofy Buddha

CANNOT SECOND THESE TWO CHOICES ENOUGH. TWO OF THE BEST SHOWS EVER MADE!

Brutally Goofy Buddha

The Magicians Sense8 Black Sails Spartacus Rome (HBO) Altered Carbon Battlestar Galactica Lost in Space Vikings The Expanse Deadwood Hell On Wheels Sherlock Holmes (BBC) 12 Monkeys Westworld Sons of Anarchy Queen's Gambit Agents of SHIELD Daredevil

thebeefmaster

I liked Travelers. Have not seen Legion.

Michael Short

you missed the "1 - 2" part of the request, didn't you? :P

Jay Johnson

Dr Horrible's Sing-along Blog not sure if it qualifies as a "TV show", as it was released online during a writers strike, back before streaming was as mainstream as it is now. also, it was only 3 parts/episodes. It was written by Joss Whedon, who created Firefly and stars Neil Patrick Harris, Nathan Fillion, and Felicia Day. It is super silly and cheesy at times, but hilarious. I think you'd enjoy it and I'd enjoy seeing your reaction to it.

Steve Chase

There is a limited series that is absolutely a must see. The series is called "When They See Us". It's a true story based on the "Central Park Five". They were 5 youth who were wrongly convicted of a rape of a jogger in central park. There are only 4 episodes to the series. Please consider.

Michael Rawson

Death by lightning (Netflix) - can’t recommend enough, it’s only four episodes Rome Walking Dead

Jeffrey Fisher

Late to the party here, but I just joined your Patreon (for Better Call Saul, one of the best TV shows ever). I will suggest one of the greatest cop TV shows ever, The Shield. The Shield, along with BCS and BB are my 3 favorite TV shows ever. All 3 of them are damn near perfect shows.

MaplenutsReact

I'm so glad you've joined us for Better Call Saul! I've never actually heard of the show The Shield, but you've definitely peaked my interest. I'll have to check it out, thanks for the recommendation!

penoyer79

I'll second The Shield. Great show. And they stick the landing.

penoyer79

The Shield. The Sopranos

Chryss Guiler

WKRP in Cincinnati, a fantastic show! Or, more realistically since WKRP might not be easy to get (It's at SHOUT! Factory, who restored almost all of the great rock 'n roll songs.) ... Babylon 5, one of the best scifi shows ever!