Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

YouTube: https://youtu.be/qzgaPKBECBo

Files

Andor: S2, Episode 8 (Who Are You?) - Patreon Version

Comments

Darian Harman

This arc, for me, is where Andor stops being "a great show", and becomes an important, urgent work of art. I've got my tissues, and I'm going in.

N.T. Stars

I like the discussion at the end! Regarding the question of where Syril's arc would have gone, I think one of the big points that the show makes on a handful of occasions is that "turns of heart" do not erase bad deeds. If you align yourself with authoritarians, you've put a black stamp on your soul. Even if Syril had joined up with the rebels, someone who was impacted by Syril's work for the empire might have zapped him in his sleep. And he probably would have deserved it! His actions led to so much death and misery. I believe this is what the show is saying: Thinking "Maybe I'm wrong" doesn't save you from a blaster shot to the temple.

Jon Johns

I rewatch this show so often, with reactors, and without. This episode, I always must mentally & emotionally prepare myself for. The story is engrossing, engaging, even traumatizing, and it's incredibly difficult to step back and look at this show during this episode, at least for me. The acting is incredible. The set design is outstanding. The music is sublime. This show... It's some of the best television ever created. It won so few television academy awards (Emmy's ™️) though it was nominated for like 14? I think? Sad for me.

Helly R

Advocating murdering people in their sleep is certainly a stance.

Jon Johns

I listened to a podcast recently about the historical events and characters that influenced the writers. The head show runner, Tony Gilroy, famously read many books & biographies about revolutions & revolutionaries, and they heavily influenced his writing here. It's eerie how... Relevant so much of this in today's world, but this was all written and put to film years ago. It only shows how much history repeats itself 😭.

Helly R

The "Who Are You" moment is a brilliant capper on Syril's arc. All of that and his faith in the Empire was for nothing. I don't think Syril was going to go back to the Empire. He's broken at the end there.

Jon Johns

It is kind of a new tradition to watch / rewatch rogue one after Andor. No need to release a new YouTube edit if it already exists, but a Patreon exclusive rewatch would be fun!

Jon Johns

The "trigger" imperial commander is such a complete ick. 🤮 You might have noticed a scar on his face. This is reminiscent of particular WWII German officers who had the same scar, a dueling scar they received as a kind of hazing ritual. You can learn more on wikipedia, "Dueling Scars".

Joseph Olson

This is always a hard episode to watch. Even when you know what’s coming, it’s tough. You’re right about the dread building and building. Dreena’s desperate plea for help over the radio always gets me. It’s so forlorn and heartbreaking. The person I wanted to die the most was the smirking Captain Kaido (the trigger), but no such luck. I wonder if Syril would have joined the Rebellion had he survived. He saw how he was manipulated, and what his devotion to his concept of law and order led to. When he saw Cassian, his rage exploded. He had to blame someone. Then he found out that the man he’s been obsessed with for 3 years didn’t even know who he was. I think the show had to kill him. He helped facilitate a massacre, however unwittingly. His redemption came when he lowered his weapon. I’m not sure if Dedra knew that Syril was dead, or if she was just shaken by what she had unleashed. Either way, she straightened out her uniform like she was trying to smooth out the genocide wrinkles. Great reaction. What’s crazy is that, in my opinion, this isn’t the best episode of the series. That’s still to come.

Jon Johns

I don't think it is explicitly expressed, but I believe the KX droids continue killing everyone not in an imperial uniform until they can't find anyone else, exterminating the ghor. Also, the guy driving the truck that cuts the KX droids in half is the guy who accidentally killed Cinta 😭

Darian Harman

There's so much in the line, "Who are you?". For most of the series, Syril is not explicitly depicted as a POV character, but in this episode, it becomes very clear that he 100% is. So, when the question, "Who are you?", comes up, I cannot help but think that this question is being asked of the viewer. This episode spent most of its time placing a capstone on what late-stage fascism ultimately amounts to, and basically says to the audience, "So, where do you stand?". Perhaps it's just me reading way too far into it as someone who has followed events in Ukraine for over a decade, but given the nature and subject matter of the show, I really don't think I'm making too unreasonable a stretch.

Maplenuts React

I can't imagine there being even better episodes, but it keeps happening so I'll believe you haha. You also make a lot of great observations. I especially like how you put Dedra straightening her uniform. So dark, but so true.

Christopher Runyon

Syril was the ultimate believer in “the system”. He believed law, order, and stability was what the Empire brought to the galaxy. A force of good and order against the chaos of the rest of the galaxy. He sees the rebels and specifically Cassian as criminals and doesn’t take the time to really see why they might be against the Empire (tho to be fair, Cassian is a criminal). I completely understand his desire, obsessive it may be, to bring someone like Cassian to justice. To see the Empire as the evil it truly is, and him being a willing pawn, no matter his intentions, I think broke him in a way. He is by far my favorite character in this show.

James M

A few remarks being made on the titular line "Who are you?" I believe it's something Andor asks simply but Syril experienced existentially. Syril believed he knew who he was and what his life was all about but everything fell out from under him. That moment was not a moment of realization, it was the final moment of loss. He didn't know who he was or what his actions meant or what he had accomplished. He didn't know what it meant to kill Andor or to capture him or to let him go. He didn't know the answer to the question he had been asked. There is a great film about revolution you should see. "Battleship Potemkin" (1925) is a silent film by Sergei Eisenstein made in the Soviet Union. It portrays a 1905 mutiny against Tsarist officers. This is a tribute to men who stood against the repression of Russia. The events foreshadowed the Russian Revolution. While Andor is a great drama, it's fiction. Potemkin is a drama about true events.

Dan Harris

The final four episodes really don't let up. Can't wait for next Monday. Loving the reactions.

Michael Jones

Star Wars had referenced "The Ghorman Massacre" for years, in books and in Rebels, but I don't think anybody realized we'd actually be seeing it. This is an amazing hour of television, but it is so hard to watch. So brutal, so close to things in the real world. They made us care about the Ghormans, then mowed them down. Going into it, I already knew about the Massacre. It's what Ghorman is known for in extended Star Wars. That didn't really make it any easier to cope with. I think Syril would have not killed Cassian. He had built up this nemesis in his head, probably imagining that Cassian was thumbing his nose at him, taunting him to find him, and then it turns out that Cassian didn't remember him at all. It makes sense. A lot of things were happening to Cassian the one time he met Syril. Syril was nobody! Why would he waste the brain cells. I think Syril realized that the last few years were wasted, and he was on the wrong side. We'll never know. I remember when the trailers for Season 2 came out, there were shots of Dedra in the Imperial Panic Room clawing at her uniform collar, and people were saying "She's being Force choked by Vader!" I had to respond "Does this look like a 'Force choked by Vader' kind of show?!"

thebirdcatcher1

Damn is this not one of the best episodes of television ever?

Over50Gamer

I thought that was brilliantly acted by Denise Gough. I almost felt like she did get word that Cyril was killed. The cut shots between her wanting to rip off the uniform (clawing at her collar), then looking like she was so sick with grief and regret for everything that's happened, to trying to accept, then straightening her uniform but still completely shaken. The Empire was her life and she wasn't going to just give it up; that would be suicide to her.

Over50Gamer

YES! I'm in the same boat. I was about to watch the reaction to Rogue One before MapleNuts started their Andor run, then when they started it, I thought, oh hell, I'll wait and watch this so I can get a different perspective on R1.

Over50Gamer

Cyril really surprised me in this one! I thought he didn't have much of a spine and was just always simping for Dedra, doing whatever she asked without question. He grew that spine REALLY quick and, while I don't like his nearly choking the life out of Dedra, when he saw how much Dedra manipulated and held the truth from him, his feeling of betrayal felt so real when he confronted her and then said goodbye.

HauntedAtoms

Ahhh, this episode is so fantastic. I really love how they let Cyril just kick the shit out of Cassian for the first half of the fight, to the point where he simply replies with "WHO ARE YOU?!"

Thadman

I always thought that when Cassian asked him that question, he put the gun down because 1. he didn't know who he was anymore and 2. he thought, "I'm...the bad guy here," and therefore Cassian, who he's been chasing this whole time, might not be the bad guy. We'll never know exactly what he thought in that moment because he never got to vocalize anything, but that's what I was thinking he might be thinking when he was shot.

Maplenuts React

I can't understand why it wouldn't have won more awards.

Thadman

I never thought of him as not having a spine. I thought of him as kinda obsessive compulsive or something because he was always doing things that HE thought was right, in contrary to what his superiors thought (altering his uniforms, pursuing the "murderer" of the corpos against the express orders of his superior, and even when he was being interrogated and he stared at Dedra and said, "ONE would be WRONG" when she said something about "one would think you'd want all of this to go away" after the Ferrix debacle and he'd kept trying to find Cassian) He seemed to have an extreme jones for order and justice. He saw, in Dedra, a kindred spirit, but deep down they are very different. She follows orders to a fault because of being raised in the Empire while he gets obsessive about bringing criminals to justice. I feel him grabbing Dedra was him realizing his idea of her being like him was completely wrong and that she doesn't really care about justice, just following orders. He lost all respect for her.

Jon Johns

Well... Lots of other shows? The system of awards shows is both political, and "pay to play" unfortunately. 🤷‍♂️ This show won many other awards! From different organizations, so it got recognized, just not from Hollywood. On a big celebrity podcast, a guest was asked what they've watched & enjoyed recently, and the guest raced about Andor, and the famous host just replied, "Ugh." As if Andor was just... Too much, too heavy. The guest asked a couple of follow up questions revealing the host hadn't even watched it. These are the folks that vote in America. So, I'm disappointed, but not surprised. Some younger folks I know don't want any tragedy in their entertainment, they want happy distraction from the tragic reality they are living through. But, hey, I'm a cynical old man, what do I know? 🤣

Clay F

"Rebellions are built on hope." “Who are you?” The episode title fit. "This is Palmo One... This is Palmo One. We are under siege. We're being slaughtered. The Imperial murder of Ghorman has begun." Andor S2E8 (IMDb 9.7/10)

pawpaw72546

At participating U.S. restaurants and while supplies last, enjoy a lineup of out-of-this-galaxy menu items, including: - BBQ Bounty Whopper! - Grogu's Blue Cookie Shake! - Grogu's Garlic Chicken Fries! - Imperial Cheddar Ranch Tots! Along with four exclusive collectible cups. Together, we're giving fans and families a fun and delicious way to connect with the excitement of the galaxy. Limited time items available at Burger King starting May the Fourth. Lucasfilm's "Star Wars: The Mandalorian and Grogu" opens exclusively in theaters May 22.