Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

YouTube: https://youtu.be/B8uvGQ3LfsU

Files

The Good, The Bad And The Ugly (runtime 2:41:50) - Patreon Version

Comments

Jon Johns

As an older guy (60+) I have some unpopular opinions (what's new? 😂) about westerns! John Wayne, the most well know movie cowboy of all time, was making westerns from the 1930's until the 1970's! My only faves of his: The Searchers, The Cowboys, and Big Jake. Eastwood had a similar long career, from 1958-1992. Of his, I do enjoy this "no name" trilogy, but I prefer high plains drifter and unforgiven much more. A very few modern westerns I enjoy: Unforgiven, Tombstone, 3:10 to Yuma. And I put The Magnificent Seven (1960), True Grit (2010), Dances with Wolves, and The Revenant near the top of my lists... I've left so many beloved films off this, which I know, is very unpopular! But I'm picky, having seen 200-300 westerns in my life, my personal standards are pretty high! I hope you watch more in the coming years. The genre is pretty rich for storytelling, and often has beautiful cinematography!

Prof Moff

I agree with your Wayne take with 2 additions. The Shootist and El Dorado (because I think it is funny).

Mr. Writhms

I am SO glad you reacted to this one! A fun fact: The graveyard at the end of the movie was a full scale set. No matte painting or visual effects background. It was built by hand and left after the shoot. It was restored in 2017 in Burgos, Spain and is now a tourist attraction. Eastwood is well known for his westerns early in his career and has directed himself in a few. I suggest my two favorites of his: “High Plains Drifter” (1973) and “Pale Rider” (1983).

Lee N.

My recently departed maternal grandpa, rest his soul, introduced me to this genre when I was a little kid. He was especially fond of this series of spaghetti westerns starring Clint Eastwood. I'm looking forward to y'all watching the rest of the "Dollars Trilogy" with Fistful of Dollars and For a Few Dollars More. Here's a few other western movies y'all may enjoy: Maverick (1994) starring Mel Gibson, Dead Man (1995) starring Johnny Depp, Quigley Down Under (1990) starring Tom Selleck, Young Guns (1988) and it's sequel Young Guns II (1990) both starring Emilio Estevez, Little Big Man (1970) starring Dustin Hoffman, and 3:10 to Yuma (2007) starring Russell Crowe and Christian Bale. Here are my favorites starring Eastwood: The Outlaw Josie Wales (1976), Pale Rider (1985), and Unforgiven (1992).

Sobizle

Well now you must watch Leone's IMO best western Once Upon a Time in the West and then Unforgiven, which is directed by Eastwood himself and it's kind of his farewell to the old westerns. And fun fact about the bridge scene, when Jordan said that they'd actually built it and then blew it up... in reality they had to build it twice, because they blew it up accidentally the first time when the cameras weren't rolling.

Jon Johns (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-24 10:00 I did like some of his more... Lite westerns? The addition of a strong few co stars, experienced in comedy, really balanced things (Dean Martin!). The shootout I liked a lot, but... There is something about it that I don't like, so, I can't give it 100%.
2026-09-15 21:02 I did like some of his more... Lite westerns? The addition of a strong few co stars, experienced in comedy, really balanced things (Dean Martin!). The shootist I liked a lot, but... There is something about it that I don't like, so, I can't give it 100%.

I did like some of his more... Lite westerns? The addition of a strong few co stars, experienced in comedy, really balanced things (Dean Martin!). The shootist I liked a lot, but... There is something about it that I don't like, so, I can't give it 100%.

Paul G

This is a genre defining movie! The main musical theme has come to represent the western standoff. The secondary theme, which plays a lot in the second half of the movie and reaches it's climax when Tuco arrives at the cemetery and is aptly titled "Ecstasy of Gold" is also epic. Now that you've watched it you might want to reconsider a rewatch with the Extended Edition (runtime around 179 minutes) - it answers a few of your questions including how Angel Eyes got to the POW camp and why Tuco took on Carson's identity. A reminder that this is the third of a loose trilogy of movies starring Clint Eastwood; you should definitely consider watching the other two - A Fistful of Dollars (1964) and For a Few Dollars More (1965). Some more western suggestions: ~Once Upon a Time in the West (1968), in my opinion neck and neck with The Good, the Bad and the Ugly for best western of all time. ~Unforgiven (another Clint Eastwood) - (1992) ~The Magnificent Seven (1960)

David Harvey (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-19 16:00 Hi Chandra and Jordan - So Glad that you reacted to "The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly" (1966) an Iconic Western by Sergio Leone. It was produced primarily in Italy where the creative contributors and crew were, and it was shot primarily in Spain. The cast was international with Americans Clint Eastwood, Elly Wallach, and Lee Van Cleef in the main roles. As far as the script goes many screenplays contain far more setting and visual shot and sound descriptions than dialogue. Building sets and shooting in Europe was far cheaper (no unions yet) than in California. That is why they could use hundreds of extras for the battle scenes and build the wood sets in the desert landscapes of Spain. What makes this a revolutionary style at the time, the Spaghetti Western, are the use of Panaromic Wide shots with facical closeups, the long silences with glances and expressions, and the iconic score. This film was made for 1.8 million and made over 300 million worldwide in 1966. It made Clint Eastwood a Star. Another Western I highly recommend is "Once Upon a Time in the West" (1968) which is a other Sergio Leone film that has one of the most Badass Bad Guy Gunslingers in all of Film. Here's the Wikipedia link to "The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly" The Good, the Bad and the Ugly - Wikipedia https://share.google/JKQ349oCwr4FPM7Az Cheers! Dave
2026-09-15 21:43 Hi Chandra and Jordan - So Glad that you reacted to "The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly" (1966) an Iconic Western by Sergio Leone. It was produced primarily in Italy where the creative contributors and crew were, and it was shot primarily in Spain. The cast was international with Americans Clint Eastwood, Elly Wallach, and Lee Van Cleef in the main roles. As far as the script goes many screenplays contain far more setting and visual shot and sound descriptions than dialogue. Building sets and shooting in Europe was far cheaper (no unions yet) than in California. That is why they could use hundreds of extras for the battle scenes and build the wood sets in the desert landscapes of Spain. What makes this a revolutionary style at the time, the Spaghetti Western, are the use of Panaromic Wide shots with facical closeups, the long silences with glances and expressions, and the iconic score. This film was made for 1.8 million and made over 38.9 million worldwide in 1966. It made Clint Eastwood a Star. Another Western I highly recommend is "Once Upon a Time in the West" (1968) which is another Sergio Leone film that has one of the most Badass Bad Guy Gunslingers in all of Film. Here's the Wikipedia link to "The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly" The Good, the Bad and the Ugly - Wikipedia https://share.google/JKQ349oCwr4FPM7Az Cheers! Dave

Hi Chandra and Jordan - So Glad that you reacted to "The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly" (1966) an Iconic Western by Sergio Leone. It was produced primarily in Italy where the creative contributors and crew were, and it was shot primarily in Spain. The cast was international with Americans Clint Eastwood, Elly Wallach, and Lee Van Cleef in the main roles. As far as the script goes many screenplays contain far more setting and visual shot and sound descriptions than dialogue. Building sets and shooting in Europe was far cheaper (no unions yet) than in California. That is why they could use hundreds of extras for the battle scenes and build the wood sets in the desert landscapes of Spain. What makes this a revolutionary style at the time, the Spaghetti Western, are the use of Panaromic Wide shots with facical closeups, the long silences with glances and expressions, and the iconic score. This film was made for 1.8 million and made over 38.9 million worldwide in 1966. It made Clint Eastwood a Star. Another Western I highly recommend is "Once Upon a Time in the West" (1968) which is another Sergio Leone film that has one of the most Badass Bad Guy Gunslingers in all of Film. Here's the Wikipedia link to "The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly" The Good, the Bad and the Ugly - Wikipedia https://share.google/JKQ349oCwr4FPM7Az Cheers! Dave

Jon Johns

OMG, I cannot believe I forgot about Henry Fonda in Once upon a Time in the West! 🎶harmonica🎶

Justin Philbrook

Such a great movie and it was a joy to see you two so into it! I grew up watching this and my parents had the score on vinyl. This is probably the best movie score ever and was done by Ennio Morricone. (Last of the Mohicans' score is a close second). So many things to comment.... 1. This is the final, and in my opinion best, of the "Man with No Name" trilogy. It's not a true trilogy, the narratives aren't related at all. The actor who plays Angel Eyes plays a different character. in one of them, but they're ll of a very similar feel and by the same director (Sergio Leone) and starring Clint Eastwood as basically the same character. The other two are "A Fistful of Dollars" and "For a Few Dollars More." These are the moves that created the phrase "Spaghetti Western" because they were Italian films about the American West. It was mostly filmed in Spain. 2. I think Gettysburg, a great Civil War film has more cannons. 3. If you want to try a very good, but completely different style, of western, try Rio Bravo starring John Wayne. John Wayne did a lot of low quality cheesy westerns too, but Rio Bravo is VERY good and a must watch for anyone exploring the Western genre.

Richard Higgs

Just a suggestion for my favorite trilogy of Clint Eastwood westerns: The Outlaw Josey Wales (1976) Pale Rider (1985) Unforgiven (1992)

James M

This is a remarkable film. On the surface it's three guys trying to get a lot of gold in the middle of a war. (Compare the story to "Kelly's Heroes") But remember the movie name: this is Leone's examination of what is meant by good and bad in movies and in reality. He looks at the romanticized old west of good guys and bad guys and makes you wonder what makes them good or bad. And then he adds what is missing from tidy old western movies, the ugly. One thing to think about is that Leone was making this in post war Italy. He used the Civil War in his movie but Italians had just lived through WWII. When the officer is saying the side that can keep its soldiers drunk enough to fight and die wins, and that they are all dying over a useless bridge that he wishes was destroyed just so they didn't have to keep dying, that bitter cynicism came from people living through a war in their country. He used the Civil War to make Americans feel that tragic, pointless loss. Finally just as he's criticizing a simplistic Hollywood idea of the good cowboy, he's criticizing the simplistic American self-image. Real war is messy and ugly. The real west was also messy and ugly. There was no white hat good guy dispensing justice to everyone.

James M

Two film notes: The place to start with westerns is "Stagecoach" (1939). It was directed by John Ford and starred John Wayne. Watching it will explain clearly why they are both so well known and why they are especially known for westerns. Buster Keaton made "The General" (1926) set during the Civil War and it's the earliest war film I've seen. It's also an excellent first silent movie. If you watch it you may be surprised how contemporary it feels given that it's 100 years old.