Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Poll: What Season of a Show Should We Watch Next?

  • Pluribus 90
  • A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms 71
  • The Pacific 33
  • Fallout: Season 2 62
  • Twisted Metal: Season 2 7
  • The Haunting of Bly Manor 33
  • 2026-09-22
  • —2026-09-28
  • 296 votes
{'title': 'Poll: What Season of a Show Should We Watch Next?', 'choices': [{'text': 'Pluribus', 'votes': 90}, {'text': 'A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms', 'votes': 71}, {'text': 'The Pacific', 'votes': 33}, {'text': 'Fallout: Season 2', 'votes': 62}, {'text': 'Twisted Metal: Season 2', 'votes': 7}, {'text': 'The Haunting of Bly Manor', 'votes': 33}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 9, 28, 15, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 9, 22, 21, 58, 43, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 296}

Content

Hi Everyone!

The winner of last week's Horror Poll was Event Horizon! We can't wait to get spooky with y'all!

And speaking of getting spooky, we're halfway done The Haunting of Hill House, so we want to know what to watch next. We're enjoying having a TV slot in our schedule that rotates between shows more regularly, so for this poll we're going to keep it to shows that are either only 1 season so far, or the next season of a show we've already started.We're also making the poll multiple choice, so choose as many as you'd be excited to watch with us!

Comments

CraigoD96

Keep on keeping on with the Expanse, if not defo Pluribus

Abby

Just double up on Buffy 🤣💕

Brian

The Expanse! 🙏

Chris

Okey dokey 👍

John Colson

I would recommend Severance

Thadman

Voted for AKotSK, it's short and sweet, but I also wouldn't mind Pluribus or Haunting of Bly Manor.

Tony

Double Buffy episodes would make my month!

Matt Rowland

You've watched Karate Kid 1 and 2, I hope you check out Cobra Kai at some point. 😁

JC

Keep with Buffy vibes and go Veronica Mars

Sean, aka Turd Ferguson

Must must must watch Pluribus...Severance season 1 was great, but season 2 made me never want to watch it again.

Dave Mansker

You could not have done a better job of stumping me on this one. Ultimately I voted for The Pacific, but Plur1bus and A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms are two more favorites. I mean you just cannot go wrong with all three of those.

Joe W

Double Buffy! If you don't, then combined with the Angel show, it will take 5 years to finish this.

Todd Bolton

Double Buffy! but I voted for Pluribus. Happy either way. (I'd also watch Haunting of Bly Manor. I wasn't a *huge* fan but liked enough to watch with y'all.)

temsik28

Double Buffy. Double the fun?

Harris Widdicombe

A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms. It's six short episodes and I can't recommend it highly enough. You could binge the whole season in an afternoon.

Jason Douglas

NO! Buffy is so silly and boring.

Jason Douglas

More Expanse!! And if you like it, think about watching the new Battlestar Galactica series.

Artanis

Fallout and Knight would both be amazing.

Wild_Lee_Coyote

Babylon 5, it is the origin of serial Sci-fi Television shows. It has some of the best character development of any tv show.

danzthename

As much as I love the idea of more Buffy, Plur1bus is incredible. Can't recommend it enough.

Joseph Olson

I hesitated to vote for either Knight or Pluribus, only because they’re both only one season and we won’t see season 2 of either for quite a while. They’re the only two of these I’ve seen though.

Joe W

The comments here would disagree with you.

Todd Bolton

Actually, Buffy is the most profound show there is, and, certainly, never boring, but I can understand if one doesn't really know the show, how they might think otherwise.

Todd Bolton

I agree but I do wish people wouldn't reveal the name of the spin-off so early. It's rather a spoiler.

pinkdino99

Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. or Westworld or Sandman. These shows are top tier.

N.T. Stars

I enjoyed a few of these, but Pluribus has been stuck in my brain since I watched it.

Matthew

you should begin Angel when the time is right, and watch it with Buffy.

Over50Gamer

All of these I'm not exactly jumping to watch (except for one show), but i did vote on three of them I'd be interested in. I would vote for Pluribus (the one show!), but i don't have a sub to Apple.

King_Panarisi

Damn, no love for the Pacific. I believe it’s a must watch tho.

Joe W

My man, the show has been out for 30 years almost...

Hans Engelen

I challenge you to a spaghetti noodle fight for that blasphemy!

Dave Mansker

I totally agree, I also voted for The Pacific. The historical importance alone makes it a must watch.

Kazza

I would love double Buffy episodes.

Todd Bolton

Doesn't mean they know the shows are related, and it is a spoiler if they don't. Maybe a minority opinion (not that it is a potential spoiler - it *is* - but that it matters). People don't generally have problems mentioning it, even this early.

George

The walking dead when?

Temujin

I agree more episodes per week would be awesome

ShadowKnight

Well, it has been two years since you reacted to Band of Brothers, it's about time you get started with The Pacific, but judging by the poll I see It's not going to happen🙁, sadly. It's a must watch after BOB you should know and see what it was like on the Pacific Theatre of WW2, I even prefer it over Band of Brothers in a way, regardless of the "popular" negative opinions some about this one, couldn't care less.

David Caine

NO ONE that ever watched Buffy and knew what it was really about would say it was "boring." And any silliness is on purpose, for comedic effect, and with great payoffs later on. We haven't even started on the real substance of the show. I say, triple the Buffy episodes a week!!

DazzMetalStorm

Its still a spoiler and not good for fresh reactions. please delete it

James M

I never liked Buffy. I do get that others love it. I would never say it's silly and boring... out loud :)

James M

I see all the Buffy fans are roaring. Let me be the one to add: Absolutely do not watch two episodes of Buffy a week. Because that will be two of your releases I skip every week instead of one.

Joe W

No. It's a 30 year old show. And I don't bow to peer pressure.

David Harvey

I would have loved seeing a comedy series as a choice, like "The Office", "Parks & Rec", or "Veep".

Hans Engelen

If you really want a a suggestion for a killer show that only got 1 season, and is right up your alley here is two that cannot get enough praise from me: - Surface (my god I wish it was not a 1 season show, I was invested in that) - Terra Nova (same thing, what a unique concept too ... well at the time, since then a few extra shows came with sort like ideas)

OddThomas

Bly Manor & Pluribus

Barry

I 2nd B5.

Dave Mansker

Another one you should put on a future poll is Barry. Wow, so good

Rob

Joe, you suck. You are easily the most inconsiderate person alive giving away a spoiler like you did. I can't believe that someone could be such a jerk. You could have waited until the appropriate time a couple seasons down the line. But no, you had to feel important or something. The fact that you don't delete your mistake is just plain selfish and makes you even more of a jerk.

Rob

I think that you should double up on Buffy. You are really enjoying the variety and uniqueness of the show and there is so much to see.

Matt

Fallout is soooooo much better than the rest!

Alpa Chino

How about The Sopranos?!!

John Conti

A knight of the seven kingdoms amazing show.

Helly R

I can see someome thinking it's silly if they've only seen season 1 (boring I don't get). But it doesn't reach its greatness until a bit later.

Ken Zarn

Finish Hawkeye

Matthew Maxon

please consider Battlestar Galactica if you havent watched it already. its only 4 seasons.

Tony Hofmann

I voted for The Haunting of Bly Manor... but to hell with it - Double Buffy!!!!

Todd Bolton

Helly R. I wouldn't even call season one silly. It's *only* fun, maybe, until "Nightmares" (so for nine episodes) but it begins to find its footing in serious intent then. But, obviously, we fundamentally agree.

Patrick R.

Chandra and Jordan, have you guys stopped the public Youtube uploads of The Expanse? If so, will it return?

John Conti

Pluribus over Knight of the seven?Seriously?

JoeyVettes

Has anyone ever seen Extinct?

Dallas Knight

To be honest, I've not seen any of them. I've watched the first season of fallout and I loved it cuz I loved the game

Dallas Knight

Cyclops light up for Chandra. Off

Dallas Knight

ON light Up the whole room. It's insane

Maplenuts React

It will return in November! We're releasing a tiny video on YouTube, where we explain why we do this.

Patrick R.

Super! Thanks for the reply! 🇨🇦

Gareth

Oh wow, I completely missed this poll haha. Happy to see Pluribus won it, amazing show, and I'll be watching it again with you guys for sure!

Jon Johns

Has anyone suggested the X-Files? I'd be interested to read y'all's thoughts; is it too long, is it outside their interests?