Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

YouTube: https://youtu.be/hhQnWeVAV6k

Files

The Expanse: S2, Episode 13 (Caliban's War) - Patreon Version

Comments

Mindbomb

Finally had a chance to catch up with you and looky here... All I'll say is we'll be constantly culminating... much culmination will occur.

Joseph Olson

“A bear that eats me in the woods is not malicious. It’s just doing what a bear does.” 😂 Listening to your post.episode discussion, I just want to say “ooh, you’re so close!” or “No, wrong track”, or “Nailed it”, but…🙊🙊🙊

Hans Engelen

Are we entertained yet !? How about that proto-molecule eh? Good thing that thing is on Venus.

Thomas Yanez

Gah... must have.. more... Amos and Prax... thank GOD you don't have to wait for a new season.

Freja Corbinne

The growing respect and friendship between Dr. Iturbi and Colonel Janus is a small but honestly underrated detail in this episode.

Lindsay Mathieson

Always nice to see characters evolve like real people, especially in an adult mnanner.

James M

I don't really understand Naomi's thinking: All the history of weapons and violence has never led to peace, therefore I had to share the protomolecule that everyone is trying to use as a weapon with the belt. I'm not sure how the two ideas connect. It seems as if the negative result of weapons would lead her to destroy the sample, not give it to someone who will make a new weapon.

James W.

It's not like being unarmed in the face of forces that continually and purposely target you saves you from annihilation. Not trying to be all ripped from the headlines or political but we have 2 examples that are in the news nearly, everyday, and many more in the history of our savage little species that show what can and has happened. Not sure if you have read the books or watched the series before but if there is a "point" to this series, an analysis of those competing ideas and ideals are what it is about. The Belters have been caught between Earth and Mar's little feud for generations with no military, or temporal power. While it just falls into the "mutually assured destruction" dynamic that isn't very productive it is better that perpetual subjugation by the inners, and at least gives them a hope of being able to use the proto-molecule to get a seat at the table. Just m,y 2-cents.

James W.

Janus getting back a bit of his joy for science was nice but I do wonder if as he is floating there, in the dissected debris of their ship, waiting for death or whatever, if he slowly turned to look at Iturbi and silently mouthed "I fucking told you so, there be dragons!".

James W.

Every season is amazing but even having seen it like a dozen or more times at this point, I love this particular transition between the seasons. The 1-ish book per 1.5 seasons structure is really cool, it kind of shows how having season being closer to the old 20+ network TV season structure helps us get connected to the characters. I was locked in after season 1 but by the end of season 2 I was thinking about cosplay opportunities and if I should get a "REMEMBER THE CANT" tattoo.

Shawn Anomaly

Congrats to finishing S2 and all the insanity that came with it! NOW, comes S3 and you might want to get "the juice" to prepare yourselves for the ramp up in Gs. Things have been LIGHT for you two but S3 takes off the gloves. Mike Tyson is now stepping in the ring to give it to you two with all kinds of absurd combos. I look forward to all the big eyes, jaws dropped, and complete silence from what's about to be witnessed! See you two next week!

Jeff M

So, fun fact - there is actually an altitude on Venus (around 50 km) where the temperature and pressure are comparable to the conditions on Earth. People could work outside at that altitude wearing just their regular cloths and with just oxygen masks to breathe. If the Arboghast was disassembled around that altitude, the crew wouldn't get crushed or melted or frozen or have all the air pulled out of their lungs, they would just slowly suffocate without any oxygen. Also, "Calaban's War" is the name of the second book in the series, the last episode of each season is named for the book (even though the first two seasons end in the middle of their respective books). Caliban is the name of a half-human half-monster character in Shakespeare's play The Tempest, so the name is an allusion to the human-Protomolecule hybrid.

James M

What you say is true. I just didn't really understand how the two ideas Naomi expresses relate. Perhaps she's saying it's pointless to hope for peace other than short interruptions of war. That's certainly a very American viewpoint today so maybe that's what the prelude about every new weapon just leading to more conflict meant? Personally I find it hard to identify with. I keep thinking if new weapons lead to new wars then maybe stop making new weapons. The book series was, as far as I read, a simplistic parallel to Cold War politics and how small nations are caught in the middle. But it was a very long series that I never finished.

Jason Weiner

Love this show but, Naomi and Alex are unbearable. Too bad TV shows don't eliminate the stupid and/or the weak links. Thankful for Amos, Avasarala, Drummer and Draper!

Trepanation21

The simplest and possibly most obvious parallel is nuclear weapons being wielded as a deterrent in the world in your lifetime. The concept being that if this horrifically powerful weapons and tech belongs to one side or another, then those parties in possession have ultimate power. So... you give them a reason to not try to step on your neck by *also* having the horrifically powerful weapons and tech that can be used against them if you're pushed far enough - annnnd voila; everybody knows the other person's capable of some serious shit, so everybody keeps their head on straight D:

James M

Honestly I grew up on Cold War politics and know every rationalization for more weapons. I agree with Naomi's first claim that new weapons never lead to peace. My takeaway is basically Holden's: since that's true we should toss this one into the sun. I'm not really asking for more rationalizations (that are not new to me) but asking instead why people think the same old failed approach will work better this time. As we are seeing so far, it doesn't. But maybe Fred is a miracle worker and will accomplish what no human has ever accomplished before. I somehow doubt it.

Jack Burton

Boy, she keeps hoping for things to be one way and then searches for tiny details to try and support those hopes. Good luck with that. :)

JBK405

I wasn't a huge fan of this series duringg the first season, and really struggled to see the genius that everybody else would rave about. Right about here is where it started to pick up for me and I began to go "Ooooooh, NOW I get it!" The way you were trying to look for that little remnant of humanity in the hybrid creature is exactly what so many characters do throughout the series: Anthropomorphizing it to fit into our human perspective. Without trying to demonize it, not trying to say it's "evil", the Protomolecule is firmly ALIEN. We can't connect to it the way we would another human, or even a non-human animal from Earth. We still don't know what it wants, or why, or how. So that thought of "Maybe it recognizes me and is trying to communicate with US", is like trying to ascribe human thoughts or emotions to the weather. Sure, sometimes the storm stops just in time for you to go out without getting wet and you may think your prayers were answered, or the lightning hits so close to you that you think it was aiming for you, but when it comes down to it the storm isn't trying to help you or hurt you. It's doing its own thing, with no care (Either good or bad) for the people getting rained on. It's got even less emotional connection than the bear that wants to eat me for dinner.