Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

YouTube: https://youtu.be/2a-6E_1QCBU

Files

Pluribus: S1, Episode 3 (Grenade) - Patreon Version

Comments

N.T. Stars

Jordan's point at the end, about life feeling pointless and lonely in this new reality, is true only for the 13 immune. The hivemind has tons of purpose and everyone in the world to share it with. So, I'd say the world has more purpose and togetherness than ever! Yes, I'm just spreading pro-alien virus propaganda. But it's fun! 😆

Dave Mansker

I'm having such a great time watching you both watching this. Highlight of my week. LOL

ButtercupsTrueLove

When Zosia dropped by with the hand grenade, Carol was about to let her go but decided to invite her in. Carol wouldn't admit it but she wanted some type of interaction, even if it's with one of the representatives of the hive mind, because it sure beats watching endless reruns of "The Golden Girls". Listening to Zosia babble on with trivia would have made her a killer as a contestant on "Jeopardy". Her collective boundless knowledge of every topic on the planet would astound Ken Jennings or the late Alex Trebek, if they weren't part of the Collective.

pawpaw72546

It's interesting that the grenade scene, and Carol immediately coming to Zosia's aid as best she could, came right after the drowning metaphor discussion. Carol didn't hesitate to help, or weigh pros and cons, or wait for a consensus (well, a consensus of one is almost instantly achievable I suppose), she just reacted. It kind of makes me a little sad that I feel like neither of you has ever seen an episode of Golden Girls.

JBK405

You noticed something that a LOT of people seem to miss (at least until later in the season): The Hivemind does not behave like a combined personality of all the people on earth. We see this with their complete blindness to sarcasm, their ignorance over emotional pain, and everything else that pisses Carol off. The Hivemind has ACCESS to the memories of all the people on earth, so it has an intellectual knowledge that sarcasm is a thing, but it has no actual experience with any of these facets of humanity. It acts like an outside entity which is controlling all of humanity instead of being their gestalt consciousness. I for one find it very reasonable for Carol to think that the Hivemind gave her a fake grenade, because we have actually already seen them disobey an order and not comment on it until they were challenged about it. Last episode Koumba Diabaté ordered a lobster dish which they couldn't prepare since they don't kill, but they didn't tell him that when he ordered it or when presenting the rest of the food. They just substituted something else, and only explained when he asked where his lobster was. They've also been refusing to accept her "leave me alone" orders from the beginning. So if I was her I would fully expect them to not obey me for all sorts of reasons, and to play along by giving me something else and hoping I didn't recognize the difference. It's not until the end that Carol realizes they really will do ANYTHING she asks (except for not try to turn her into one of them). "DHL guy" (Robert Bailey Jr.) at the end was a surprisingly huge hit in the fandom after just this one scene. He seemed so awkward and earnest, but continuing to be so alien like all of the rest of the Hivemind. Such a huge impact from such a small role.

Thadman

I think that it (the joined) does have experience with sarcasm, it's just that it's different with different people and different cultures, especially, so it's more of an uncertainty. You're gonna have people who think it is sarcasm while others don't. They couldn't come to a consensus so they decided to air on the side that she actually wanted the grenade, so as to no disappoint her. I don't think it's an indication of some outside entity, like a queen, dictating anything. It's just a lot of "voices" and perspectives communicating all together and they take what most people agree upon (not everyone, of course) and they go with that, as long as it doesn't contradict their "biological imperative." About the lobster dinner, they told Diabate that they tried to find some freshly dead lobsters, but they could only find live fresh ones. So, they didn't tell him when he first asked 'cause they had every intention of making it for him, but couldn't find any. So, it wasn't them lying nor keeping anything from him in some nefarious way. I didn't think of them as being "challenged" either, he just asked and they explained to him why. It is definitely in our nature to distrust and definitely to distrust something that brought on an apocalypse, but I have not seen anything they have said to have been disingenuous, when asked. They substituted because lunch was quickly approaching and he wouldn't have had anything to eat, so they gave him something else they thought he'd like, which he did. They may not tell every detail, but not everyone wants every detail nor thinks every detail is important. Zosia throws out a lot of "fun facts," but those things don't seem to be interesting to Carol, but they are to some people, apparently. My point is that things COULD be nefarious, but so far, we don't have any real indication that it is and all we have seen is in keeping with everything they've said is happening. They have not completely left Carol alone, I think, because that is a bit of a vague statement and they took it as giving her space and they've been mostly staying away from her. They're still watching her, so they explained why they left the food for her. They are compulsively always trying to help and don't want her to die. You could guess why that is, but they've stated it's their biological imperative. Choose to believe it or not. I'd be testing them a lot more than Carol is.

Todd Bolton

Chandra gets the most insightful comment award: Jordan: “She wants to be independent.” Chandra: “But this isn’t independence.” My favorite line of the episode, on the conservation of energy by turning out all the lights, “You donated twice to the Sierra Club, so we felt you’d understand” – y’all seem to enjoy as much as I did.