Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

[Poll] [Mylene Topic] Okay, I've gotten some feedback from Patreon.

  • Continue forward no changes Alpha Mylene all the way. Sadly no Mylene x Leon. 23
  • The Mylene, Mercelyne twins sounds like a fun altenative. 80
  • 2026-03-05
  • 103 votes
{'title': "[Poll] [Mylene Topic] Okay, I've gotten some feedback from Patreon. ", 'choices': [{'text': 'Continue forward no changes Alpha Mylene all the way. Sadly no Mylene x Leon.', 'votes': 23}, {'text': 'The Mylene, Mercelyne twins sounds like a fun altenative.', 'votes': 80}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 3, 5, 16, 37, 37, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 103}

Content

Let me first say that I'll always listen to feedback, but I will not necessarily follow it. Plus, sometimes it sets a bad precedent, and for me, if I'm forced to change things when I've planned a lot of these chapters in advance, I lose my eagerness to write them; they turn into chores. It took me a while to like writing These Tragic Souls again when I rewrote it.

But I understand that Mylene is a cherished part of Mobuseka, and I too think the same.

The reason I made Mylene this way is that there's no reason or scenario where this Leon/Shirou would ever flirt with or hit on the married Mylene, even if she's in a bad relationship. The only scenario Leon/Shirou I would think of that would follow that is if the king is a tyrant and he overthrows him, later somehow developing feelings with Mylene. But tbh, I like the King's character; he's the perfect foil to Leon/Shirou, and if not one, why not make it two foils (King and Queen), since cute Mylene x Leon/Shirou won't be possible.

And also, the main reason Mylene latched on to canon Leon was a misunderstanding/faux pax, which Leon did, and which, for some reason, blossomed; this Leon/Shirou would not have triggered that flag.

BUT!

I've thought of an alternative. I will poll you on it. I urge you to comment as well so I can hear your reasoning.

ALSO, even if one side won, I may not follow it, because someone in the comments might actually make a good enough reasoning not to follow the majority.

-=&<o>&=-

Alternative route

No changes needed on the latest chapter.

-=&<o>&=-

Origin: Both Mylene and Mercelyne were princesses of the Kingdom of Repard.

The Crisis: Mylene (the gentler twin) was arranged to marry an old nobleman from Rachelle—a political marriage neither twin wanted. Mercelyne (at that time was the closeted, bold, hedonistic twin) devised an escape plan.

The Escape: The twins fled Repard and sought asylum in Holfort. At the time, King Roland was young and ruling as interim King while his father was bedridden. Roland saw an opportunity to antagonise Rachelle and accepted them.

Roland's Condition: He'd grant asylum only if both married him.

Mercelyne's Counter: She would be the only one to marry Roland—but she would take Mylene's name and identity. The story they'd tell the world was that Mercelyne had died in an accident during the escape. This way:

"Mylene" (actually Mercelyne) becomes Queen of Holfort

The real Mylene disappears into the background as a non-entity/adviser/double to the queen—she sometimes is the one who personally goes to the Rachelle frontline instead of the Queen.

Rachelle loses their bride (the real Mylene is officially the surviving twin, now Queen—untouchable)

The dead "Mercelyne" can't be demanded back

The War: Rachelle didn't take this lying down. War broke out between Repard, Rachelle, and Holfort. Holfort—under young Roland—managed to push Rachelle out of Repard.

The Result: Repard became a protectorate of Holfort—functionally independent but under Holfort's umbrella, similar to Puerto Rico's relationship with the USA. Repard governs itself but relies on Holfort for military protection and foreign policy.

Sons and Daughters: Julius and Erica are Mercelyne's son and daughter.

Who knows: Lucas, the founding families' head of house, Vince Rapha Redgrave, Gilbert Rapha Redgrave, Angelica Rapha Redgrave (because of training), Julius, Erica, and Margot Fou Bellefleur.

What I like about this: I think the dynamic where sweet, clumsy Mylene would need to play body double and be forced to flirt with Leon/Shirou like her confident, brash, and hedonistic twin. Shenanigans would be fun, especially when Mylene starts to develop feelings, and Mercelyne would play matchmaker.

POLL:

Comments

Leo Varona

I just think the second option would lead to even funnier Events 😅

Silver Wolf

Honestly a more hedonistic Mylene makes more sense since there's no way this Leon would pursue a relationship with canon Mylene. It feels wrong just letting Mylene suffer in the background because Leon has zero interest with her so changing her character makes sense. Plus this is already moderately AU as it is and I happen to like what you shown so far. I figured it's best just to let things where they lie right now and stay the course. Readers will probably either accept or ignore Mylene going forward. Maybe write an omake with Canon Mylene and this Leon and see how readers react to that if you want to better gauge our response. The current backlash feels too knee jerk to be warranted. As it kinda feels like people are just complaining because you messed with their favorite waifu.

Wankomancer

I think that's it's a good compromise. Mylene is such a beloved character that to change her so drastically was honestly kind of a giant whiplash. Like sure I'll probably adapt with time and maybe you have something amazing planned down the line, but the bar will be raised really high since you have essentially, in a sense, thrown away such a beloved character to do so. The new premise sounds both safer, allows more leeway and it also sounds quite fun and interesting. Of course, in the end it's your choice and I know very little about writing a compelling story.If you believe the story will be better for it feel free tk ignore my ramblings and go ahead with your original plans.

13thsephiroth

I will not reply to comments on this so that I don't influence new voters. But don't worry too much about me being forced to change things. The Marie/Taiga is a hill that I'm willing to die for, and I didn't even poll you for that. And there will be a reveal in Fate/Knights of the Heroic Throne that I know will get some reactions, and I'm not changing that. But for me, this Mylene thing is rather minor, so I'm willing to go either way. I'll make the deadline till before 8.3 is made public, which is so far away. That, or I've thought of a cool chapter for the new scenario. It really depends on whether I think of scenes for future chapters for either scenario.

Reiter

I agree with Leo Varona on that the second option is more likely to open the door to even funnier shenanigans. Plus it's the equivalent to having the cake and eating it, on one hand it gives Roland an equal partner that feel more like friend, lover and partner-in-crime than an imposed obligation (that's the feel I have in canon) that allow for Roland to not be a 100% contrarian asshole to Leon and his own cabinet/inner circle. And on the other hand also allow for the super teaseble canon!Myrtle to be accidentally seduced by Leon. ...Makes me wonder if he can find a crossbar to practice his high jumping :V

NeverwhereCM

I honestly think no changes is the better option. Technically I suppose adding the twin lets both sides be happy and compromise, but I also think that doing it dilutes things too much. Adding the daughter already changes things up with the royal family and adds another interest to an already kind of bloated roster. I was kind of relieved that the Queen was off the table because it means less of other characters being shafted for screen time.

L_O_S_TxWolf

I was definitely taken aback by how wild the two of them were acting. I haven't really watched the anime, so I cant really comment on which route you should take. Also, aha, I was surprised by Erica being another person from Shirou's world to reincarnate into that role. I really probably shouldnt have been. Lol. Looking forward to more chapters.

expect a typo

I chose the second option. My reasoning is that the potential highjinks could be extremely entertaining. But I think the omake idea a fellow commenter suggested is a solid way to test the waters. Forgive me for not expanding on my answer, I'm not good putting my thoughts into words.

Benjamin Lawton

Honestly, we didn't really need to construct this whole alternate scenario, just to get Mylene and Shirou/Leon together. Even if Shirou wouldn't be so brazen as to pull the same stunts that canon!Leon did, he's still got multiple girls already starting to fall for him, just by being himself – why not do the same for Mylene? What starts out as simple hedonism and lust, slowly evolves into something more, until ultimately she's fallen in love with him for real.

Romain

Normally my go-to-response would be for you to continue with your original plan (since your planning and motivation should be the main factor of decision). It was also gonna be my vote initially. Especially since I actually like your alpha Mylene and her dynamic with the king as a power couple. And then... I read your proposition of an alternative route... And now I am torn. I am voting in favor of the second route because of how fun it seems. Because I don't think that having many characters will be a problem for you. And finally, because I think that a fifth member of the royal family will permit you a lot of different interactions with the crown and might allow you to avoid having Shirou and the King in constant opposition. Those two are pretty opposed force even by themself. There is no way, that man will ever not oppose Shirou when his "baby" is concerned. I don't think they could really see eye to eye in matters concerning Julius either. Probably more than in canon still. So at best, they can suffer together that they can't disobey the woman/women in their life. So yeah, maybe having Alpha Mylene playing matchmaker could allow a more nuanced relation between the two. Or not. I am letting you cooking there. Their relationship is already way more interesting than in the original story. And I repeat, I really love your Alpha Mylene. Look like a blend of Mylene, Raikou and Morgan.

Manokla Mahogany

At first I didn't jive with this Mylene when I first read her on The Partner. After I continued to read I've come to like her more and do want to see more of this character. However even with all that it doesn't feel like Mylene any more and is a new character with her name instead. Like others have said Mylene is precious to the mobsuka story so I was really looking forward to her. Having said all that I'm okay with either option but prefer the twins because it gives us back the Mylene I was looking forward to as well as being super funny which always wins out. Either way I'm looking forward to whatever you write because what I read was genuinely enjoyable so best of luck.