Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Audio from our live panel on Saturday, July 25 at Woodbine where we go deeper on Varn & Tutt's new book The People Are Not One, starting with some normie vs. Marxist LARPing and ending with a spirited Q&A featuring Ross Wolfe, Greg Butler, Platypus, Donald Parkinson, and more!

The event was sponsored by ILC of NYC

Song: Run the Jewels - Goonies vs. E.T.

Files

Comments

Yawae

Thanks for sharing this panel discussion. Found this to be a very intellectually serious critique of left populism. Particularly strong on class as a social relation rather than a cultural identity, the need to constitute the working class politically, professional capture of movements, the difference between democratizing access and socializing control, and the sectional and institutional divisions within today’s working class. However it remains more a diagnosis of strategic absence than a strategy in itself. Maybe that’s for a second book haha, but it’s what I found myself most wanting for at the end of this. The panel knows that workers need durable institutions, independent organization and a rebuilt collective life but it was less clear on how those institutions actually begin, how they scale, how they exercise power or how they should engage reforms and elections without being absorbed by them. The answers to the audience questions tended to return to theory, historical warnings and definitions. Those are absolutely necessary and there was a lot of new stuff in there I learned, but a politics capable of escaping left populism still eventually has to provide better practical answers than left populism does. Suppose serious workers accept this entire diagnosis of populism (I would say I do), what do we actually spend the next say, two years *building* and what should we specifically avoid? Either way, great discussion. I’m glad a lot of these questions are being talked about because they arise in one form or another in my rank and file caucus work. Thanks!

Mr knucklehead

I would echo the “what do?” of your comment