Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Sean and Varn continue to discuss the current energy crisis, broadening out from current events to talk about the context and ramifications: US blob's energy war against BRICS, European industrial collapse and bankruptcy of the Atlanticist center, bond market chaos and more.

Files

Comments

Tvvvv

Speaking to normalcy bias, it’s seems that Melenchon only tepidly endorsing the protest/riots in France has missed his moment to show leadership. He will inevitably be tarred with leading them by the media and French government and possibly removed from elections no matter what he did. Seeking to lead them or control them could have led in a different direction where the popular front political coalition merged with an on the ground movement of people. We do not live in a time where the masses of people and the political classes see themselves as one or motivated towards the same goals seemingly anywhere in the west outside of cultish populist right movements.

Tvvvv

Though they are right wing ethno nationalists, the former Danube Institute intellectuals or whatever you would like to call them have been seemingly correctly calling their shots on emerging events. I’m thinking of Malcolm Kyeyune and Phillip Pilkington.

Tvvvv

Mamdanism is PMC princesses and princelings trying to hold onto daddy’s welfare and busy-town make-work jobs through political forces. It’s not replicatable and is only in new york due to the hipster millennial demo that has been present for the past 20 years in that city and its pedestrian city layout. No other place outside of maybe LA has that demography or already close ties to power within its population. It’s the nepobaby in political form.

Cole

What would LFI leadership have looked like more than what they’ve done? Saying ‘we are the leaders of this movement’?

Tvvvv

Yes

Cole

What do you mean

Tvvvv

Inevitably the state was going to tar them with the accusation that they were behind it. By taking the reigns, at a minimum, they at least don’t appear to be pussies and that they have the actual backs of the people. Maximally, they can actually lead it and steer it towards a productive end. Imagine if simply they stated that they would hold a rally during the riots and make a speech where they declared they would address the issues of the people and that everyone should go home for the time being. At a minimum, they look courageous and noone listens to them, at maximum they actually lead.

Cole

Haven’t they done that though, they’ve held several rallies throughout this whole thing and said that the protestors are in the right. The LFI mayor of St Denise even gave his support and marched with the protestors. And why would they tell people to go home, that wouldn’t make them look in charge it would make them look like they’re siding with the state. They seem to have largely done what you’re suggesting except for trying to take control of the whole thing which is both nonsensical and would make them look silly. It’s a spontaneous youth movement, the LFI isn’t so hegemonic they can just wave a magic wand and everyone falls in line. That reminds me of the ridiculous grandstanding of the sects we have in the states

waterbird

i agree but id like to think that they’ve only been super relevant in this miserable period where things are getting really bad and the working class/social movements havent really entered the chat yet.

Tvvvv

When the left was dying, it retreated to the universities and media. The world we have now has been a right wing one that has reigned for more than a generation. Even the morally defensible sides of modern conflicts are far right wing (hamas, Iran). It’s their world, man. That’s why they can describe it best. We are minuscule commentators and gawkers within it. Maybe one day something new will emerge but there are no present vibrations of it, just a rotting corpse.

Tvvvv

If they told people to go home and they went home, then they would be exercising power that noone else holds besides the oppressive hand of the state. What else can be accomplished with the undirected flow of protests other than having people turn against them. The point they were trying to make was made initially. It has no potential to form into something else in the current state without organization and leadership and said leadership being able to control it.

Jim

Krassner survived as Philadelphia DA? Boudin in SF or Mike Schmidt in Portland, no. Still a valid point / probably largely an ineffective or bad strategy, and idk what helped Krassner hold the seat? He’s not super ancient and is hanging on tho?