Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Is EVERYTHING in Fran's mind after all? Or is NONE of it? Is she completely insane, or is there nothing wrong with her at all? Is it possible to view anything in more than one dimension? I sure hope so! On today's episode we sort of find out what's going on, but are also left with more questions. Most importantly, why the HECK my kitty is taking so long to open the door!!

Files

This changes EVERYTHING about what Fran's been through - Therapist Plays Fran Bow - 10 (BV)

Is EVERYTHING in Fran's mind after all? Or is NONE of it? Is she completely insane, or is there nothing wrong with her at all? Is it possible to view anything in more than one dimension? I sure hope so! On today's episode we sort of find out what's going on, but are also left with more questions. Most importantly, why the HECK my kitty is taking so long to open the door!! Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/eurobrady #franbow #gaming #therapist #letsplay #reaction #narrative #therapy #psychology #analysis #eurobrady This content is for educational and entertainment purposes only and does not constitute clinical care, supervision, or advice.

Comments

worm conspiracy

i adore being left with more questions. lets goo!!!

Exlex

I was writing a v long (& honestly, emotionally charged) comment against PTG as a concept sort of, but after getting my thoughts out in Way too many words, I convinced myself of the opposite haha. Folks, taking a second to process works. Not that I have to agree w/ you on everything or that your view is the Only way, but I realized I couldn't reconcile my thoughts on last Fran Bow episode w/ my first reaction to this one, which was a pretty drawn out argument for the illness<—health spectrum with health at the origin instead of illness<—health—>wellness. It's just hard to view it neutral & not as justifying negative things,,,, for me @ least Dr. Deern is so. Hm. Let's just say I'm looking forward to seeing what you think abt his actions in the rest of the story haha Anyway. Ik that the first two chapters are the most popular in the game (they're even what I myself remember most details abt), but the viewer decay after those chapters for this series rlly sucks bc these next parts are where the STORY rlly gets going,, I feel bad for everyone who fell off bc we're abt to rlly get into it Ty for the episode again :) EDIT: this is the LAST TIME I'll ever bring it up (I don't mean to b a "day 999 of reminding you abt this" type commenter), but there's a line in N2N that makes me cry every single time, & just based on everything you've said This Episode (& tbh the entire Fran Bow series), I just know. I just know it'll hit you, too

Sardonicus

Personally I see what happened with Doctor Deern as definitive proof that cemented it for me that she is genuinely connecting to some alternate reality. The things the alternative version of himself said was just so specific to his trauma, and she seemed right on the money about what happened to him since he confirmed that what she said about his past was indeed true, and he seemed confused at how she knew that. He also showed absolutely no outward indication, or said anything in the time since she met him that implied that he suffered from trauma for her to be able to pick it up from context clues, and figure it out through sub-conscience inference. She's barely interacted with this man outside of a very professional setting, so I don't buy that she was just picking up on his vibes and figured it out that way. Not to mention how specific it is. He specifically tells her the dad uses a knife on him causing his arms to hurt and also harms his mom if he tells her. This isn't some vague prediction she made, but something pretty specific, and the man confirms it. She also knew about the twins including their names and then Deern mentions it as a case that he remembers happening, and went very similarly to how the twins and Itward's theatre presentation described as having happened. She even knew they were thrown in the well. She is able to access knowledge she should have no way of having. Not only that but if she talks to the Kamala's while in the asylum, they will poetically describe the exact trauma the child is suffering from with specific details related to which family members did it, that can later be confirmed as accurate after reading their clipboard charts that explain what happened. She will have this information from the Kamala's including when she doesn't look at the clipboard at all. I don't see how else she has access to such specific information without just accurately guessing time and time and time again which seems statistically improbable. This isn't me saying that every single thing she is seeing is 100% real. It seems like her trauma also influences what she see's but that the core of these alternate dimensions are real and is effected by her perception of them. KInda like her own perception of the dimension can be influenced by her trauma, maybe even feeding off of it like the Kamala's but the dimension itself is real and may be perceived differently by someone else looking at it. I take the things she can see but her kitty is confused and says isn't actually there as an indication of when she's having a genuine hallucination like when Fran saw that vision of her mom asking for her to join her, and her cat said no one was there.

Sardonicus

I think Deern genuinely means well. He's just from a time when psychology was still pretty barbaric, and was trained to think that stuff works and helps. I sense no malice from him.

Exlex

I definitely agree that he means well, & he's a saint compared to [SPOILER REDACTED FOR BRADY] & [SPOILER REDACTED FOR BRADY] if you know who I mean

Sardonicus

yep, sure do know. I just think some people are kinda hard of Deern for helping prop up psychology practices that we now know are adverse towards helping people based around our modern understanding of things that Deern doesn't have access to. Dude is a product of his time.

MourningKnight

My creative writing teacher a billion years ago (cause I’m old xP) didn’t have a lot of things she said were strict no-nos in writing, but she strongly advised against the “it was all a dream!” (or a bout of psychosis or the last delusions of a dying mind or any other variety of “everything in the story was a lie, *even in the world of the story,* and none of it mattered even *that* much, gotcha sucker!”) plot line, because it tends to piss readers off if you don’t pull it off PERFECTLY. For basically all the reasons you’ve said, and especially for the resistance and mild irritation you’re already exhibiting to the idea. Unless it can pull off a The Usual Suspects “whoa!” that recontextualizes everything you’ve experienced in a cool way, challenging and inviting you to reconsider the story with new understanding? It just feels like you’ve been cheated by a lazy author who wanted to hit you with a lot of drama and trick you into investing in things that, yeah, have no real meaning or importance in the end. It can be done, anything can, but it’s gotta be pulled off with a particularly deft hand, and if you’re not an Ambrose Bierce level writer, you risk leaving your audience feeling like you deliberately wasted their time. Or arguably worse, like you’re such a crap storyteller that you never had a plan, just vibes and ambitions that were bigger than your ability to deliver, and you had to take a cop-out when you ran out of time and ideas. I didn’t watch it, but I think a lot of people accuse Lost of this? An unresolved is-it-real-is-it-not back and forth is much easier to pull off, even “this little bit was all a dream, but now back to the story!” especially in shorter form works. The bigger the investment of time and emotional energy a creator demands, the worse it feels if they hit you with, effectively, “but haha, nvm all that. Anyway, The End or whatever.” There’s a reason I can’t even come up with a way to describe that style of ending that doesn’t include an explicit “so fuck you for caring” aimed directly at the reader/viewer/player. None of this being a comment on how Fran Bow ultimately takes things, no spoilers, just to give a bit of perspective on how normal and predictable resentment of the “it was only a dream” trope is. It’s probably already come up but I’d add Pan’s Labyrinth to the recommendations for gorgeous (but graphically violent 😬) magical-realism-or-maybe-it’s-all-imagination-and-delusion? movies, particularly ones following a plucky, imperfect, determined, but very vulnerable young girl. Though I think Del Toro has Word of God’ed that it’s supposed to be real and the proof is in the movie. The Fall with Lee Pace, too, although Pan’s Labyrinth and The Fall are both less clinically/therapeutically themed than Fran Bow or Return to Oz. But good golly, are they not short on trauma. (And the surrealism and imagery? Guh! Love!!!) Although… I think The Fall does largely take place in an old timey hospital (been a while since I rewatched) and there might be more direct mental health stuff going on than I remember or particularly took note of? It’s not a mental hospital, but Lee Pace’s character is definitely Dealing With Stuff and might be under some form of old-school psychiatric care? Ofelia (Pan’s Labyrinth) has a lot of Fran’s unflappable determination in the face of the horrifying and fantasic; Alexandria (The Fall) has a lot of her heart-breaking/uplifting innocence and focus on helping others, even when she doesn’t understand what’s being asked of her.

LetThereBeLarceny

My personal preference is that a non-insignificant portion of what we're seeing is a product of Fran's imagination. It's a lot more fascinating and meaningful in my opinion to consider how Fran's trauma influences the things she is experiencing, and why she would subconsciously choose to interpret things the way she does. To me, the notion that "Ithersta was all in Fran's imagination" (or any other fantastical portion of the game) doesn't make those sections any less meaningful or somehow invalid. After all, she still experienced them, and to her those things felt very real. And I think there's a lot of meaning in interpreting this as Fran's mind creating these realities for herself in order to give her direction, comfort her, and help her make sense of something utterly incomprehensible. I'm biased because I find a lot of comfort in stories where characters utilize their imagination and creativity to pull themselves out of a real situation that feels impossible. At a point in my life where I felt I had nothing to live for, dissociating into my own fantasy world full of adventures and action was ultimately what saved me. I knew it wasn't real, and yet the things I experienced and the stories I told to myself had a very real impact on how I acted and felt in the real world. I was able to convince myself that there were things to live and strive for, and that kept me afloat long enough to pull my real life back together and get myself to more stable ground. Anyway, I know there is a lot of proof that at least some of the fantastical things are real, and I don't really have any objective or factual argument that any portions of the game *aren't* real. And I can imagine that it would be very meaningful for some folks to have a story of a girl genuinely experiencing these fantastical things, only to get dismissed as crazy and delusional. So I don't mean to argue that my opinion is the 'correct' one! That's just how I personally prefer to interpret the story.

Sardonicus

I get the appeal of the aspect that if it's in her mind it means we're getting an unfiltered view of her imagination and inner state which is very interesting. You can sense her fears and hopes through her imagination. Personally I don't see why it has to always be framed as one way or the other. I think the most common theory people have is that the ultra-reality is both a real place and also that how it appears is influenced by Fran's imagination and trauma in relation to how she perceives this reality. That this same reality may look different to another person perceiving it. I feel like this just gives everyone the best of both worlds. They can both analyze how the imagery relates to Fran Bow's imagination, and people who like a more concrete world than the the "it's all a dream" trope also get to feel she is experiencing the supernatural.

LetThereBeLarceny

That's a very fair perspective, I'm definitely a lot more open to accepting that ultra-reality is real, but the way it is accessed/experienced by Fran is highly influenced by her own imagination and experiences. I appreciate that the game leaves it somewhat open to the player's interpretation.