Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

James. Jaaaaaaammess. JAMES. What did you do, James? And why did you do it? I think this sequence might be the first time these questions have somewhat clear answers. Or perhaps its more misdirection? What's clear is there's hesitation, driven by fear and guilt and desperation. We've been to these places Maria is taking us before. What would be do differently there, given the chance?

Files

This is NOT the woman I loved..is it? - Therapist Plays Silent Hill 2 - 5 (BV)

James. Jaaaaaaammess. JAMES. What did you do, James? And why did you do it? I think this sequence might be the first time these questions have somewhat clear answers. Or perhaps its more misdirection? What's clear is there's hesitation, driven by fear and guilt and desperation. We've been to these places Maria is taking us before. What would be do differently there, given the chance? Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/eurobrady #silenthill2 #silenthill #gaming #therapist #letsplay #reaction #narrative #therapy #psychology #analysis #eurobrady This content is for educational and entertainment purposes only and does not constitute clinical care, supervision, or advice.

Comments

Amon Schwabe

Ive been checking my phone a lot lately just because I want to see more of your playtrough lol, love the analyzing!

ayumimarin

It's really strange to hear that people were trying to dissuade you from reading PH's scene the way you did. (You're correct in saying the internet is where nuance goes to die.) Perhaps it is because SA isn't *literally* happening. But it doesn't have to. It is clearly evoked in how PH is handling the mannequin and the subtext is clearly gendered SV. I wish people would keep in mind you haven't played the game before, and you are picking up what the game is putting down as you go through it and you are always willing to consider different angles and perspectives and readings, which is what makes watching so fun (ok also Mio working so hard and being a total screen and mic hog).

Amy Crutcher

Omg yes!! Can’t wait to watch this 😄

Nikitu

every email notification i get fills me with excitement in the case that it may turn out to be a new silent hill episode from you

Inkpendude

I expect people are gonna be making coments like that through his whole playthrough

穴したシア

I have been really loving your playthrough and the analysis on this game! As always, your attention to the details is so amazing. By the way, a little fun detail that has nothing to do with the story - the outfit that Maria showed to James in one of the rooms, asking if it would suit her, is actually a nod to the design of Maria from the original game :)

Miumiu

This playthrough is great, I'm only sad you can't get all the endings on your first run (you only get to have one of three out of eight)

Dirt_eater

if im remembering correctly, even masahiro ito (designer of the monsters) at one point claimed that the scene wasnt meant to resemble or imply SV, but like even then i dont believe him lmao. The creators of the game are on record saying that they felt to make a truly scary game they needed to "think deeply about death and sex" and i genuinely dont see how they could have accidentally made a scene as evocative of SA as this one by accident. Brady had the right take and as an obsessive silent hill 2 fan I will die on the hill lol. silently..

Brian Shannow

There's certainly something to be said about the animator not intending that to be the interpretation but everyone that's seen it viewed it as such

hil

your playthrough is sooooo addictive!!!

MourningKnight

This continues to be a very fun playthrough! There’s all the analysis, the dream/nightmare atmosphere, the deep introspection, but in these emotionally exhausting real-life times, it’s also just fun to watch you yelp and be low-key freaked and get all tense around the scares, in the kindest, better-you-than-me, way. I’ll definitely rewatch for the analysis because I enjoy that too, but not gonna lie, it’s also fun to just chill out and watch someone else lose their chill for a bit—with the nice built-in breaks to ponder what’s going on and what it might mean. 😄

MourningKnight

It’s one of the advantages of death of the author in analysis that “word of god” doesn’t have to mean more than headcanon (or personal interpretation) for a number of reasons, including the creator of a thing not necessarily being tuned in to all of their own biases and influences. In a place where we’re talking psychology, it’s no revelation to say a lot of us don’t recognize all of our own thoughts around a subject, so it’s also no stretch that someone can create a thing and not realize all that they’re implying with it, even if everyone else who experiences the thing sees it. And really, yeah, even if it was somehow something they really didn’t intend AT ALL… who cares? If it evokes a feeling or implication for other people then it does, the creator doesn’t have special ownership over the interpretation of their stuff once they’ve put it out for others to experience. It’s for the audience to debate it, and I don’t think “the dude who made it says!” is a very compelling argument all on its own. (Heh, and I've been watching the playthrough of The Beginner's Guide and everything I've just said pretty directly contradicts a lot of that, but I stand by it! If you make a thing and someone comes along and starts psychoanalyzing you over it, bad on them, that’s rude. But if you make a thing and personally put it out in the world at large for others to experience, then you have to get out of the way and accept they'll take it how they will. What’s in their head is theirs, the same as what’s in yours is yours.)

Brandon

If you've ever seen that old Simpsons gag where Homer is watching Twin Peaks and declares, "Brilliant...! I have absolutely NO idea what's going on," that's exactly how I felt when Maria showed up.

Veska

Maaaan this game is dark - I’ve only played silent hill F after watching you play it! This I think, I would not be able to get though. Thanks for braving it for scaredy cats like myself