Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 779687243.mp4

Downloads

Content

This is it. This is the moment where Max's power, her REAL power, needs to prove itself. No, I'm not talking about the time travel thing, that's basically useless. I'm talking about her nosiness, her snoopiness, & her meddling ways. These are the skills that Max has crafted and honed. I just hope they will be enough.

Files

Comments

Red

Dropping everything to watch this immediately omg

Simon Danler

omg... i was waiting for this to happen, im so excited

Kimber (CaptQuesadilla)

I really appreciate how you address the way people throw around statements like “you’re just doing this for attention” to invalidate. People do need attention and community. If they are going to extremes to get it then they are probably lacking important support.

Лана Ахадова

What's the most heartbreaking thing to me in this episode is that this stuff continues to happen all the time in real life. Recent Cornell 7 case as an example.

Amy Crutcher

Oh boy this is going to be a hard watch for me, have been struggling with suicidal thoughts a lot lately 🥲

AV

im so excited you uploaded this today I needed this so bad today u dont even know

Lena Talbot

The social game has never made much sense to me as an autistic, I never got the urge to compete with people for friends and validation. Like I didn't understand why people were putting others down or why anyone would want to climb the ladder (or tbh for a while that there even was a ladder). I just wanted to be treated with the basic amount of respect and kindness as a fellow human being, nothing more and I wanted to treat others the same. To be honest I never understood a lot of things. Also it's right that being liked isn't a finite resource it's just there amongst everyone else that's liked. I absolutely love your life is strange playthrough, I'm learning tons and I get to finally see what this game is about.

Henry Williams

Hope you start to do better soon. I know I’m just a stranger on the internet, but if you ever need someone to talk to, I’m more than happy to listen. I can’t promise I’ll have any answers, but I can offer a friendly ear!

Pat Gunn

One of the better responses is based on available information, Mr Jefferson's stance is reasonable given that he doesn't know what Max knows. It doesn't make sense to treat accusations as proof.

Sardonicus

Strongly disagree and strongly agree with how Brady reacted to the situation. I think what he does there is disgusting whether he believes the accusations are wrong or not. For one if a student is coming to you saying they were potentially s/a'd I don't care if you believe they are lying, you take it seriously in case they are telling the truth. To make the assumption that she's probably lying is just such a terrible thing to do. Do you know how rare that actually happens? You have an obligation to take it seriously. You are considered a mandatory reporter of this kind of thing as an educator. All I saw from Jefferson was a disgusting lack of empathy and a victim blaming mentality. Some of those lines are seriously so tone deaf and awful. "maybe Kate brought this upon herself" "Maybe you're looking for attention." Seriously some of the worst things you could say about a potential drugging and S/A. I see no excuse for how he responded, including ignorance for treating her that way. I remember the first time I played being so disgusted with his actions that I told the principal he was at fault. That was after having no problems with him before that point. Especially disgusted as someone who works with children and knows what the proper procedure he should have followed was.

Pat Gunn

I think he was also deeply insensitive; I don't think it makes sense to ever treat accusations as proof, but that doesn't mean it's ok to treat Kate so badly in that conversation. The sensible position is to be kind but avoid conclusions.

Sardonicus

Usually I get nervous when someone gets to this part of the game since Kate's life is in a very fragile balance in this part, but I knew you'd be able to save Kate. Didn't doubt it for a moment. You're just too good at snooping.

Mara

Please consider skipping parts if it's too much! It is a very intense segment and your mental health is more important. Sending you hugs ❤️

Artie Pavlov

OOOhhh, Brady is getting all riled up at Jeffyboy!

Holly

Wish I could give this a hell of a lot more than just one heart. *Nothing* about Jefferson's response in that moment was reasonable. Nothing!

Awespren

huh, I didn't remember that convo between kate and jefferson. Great video!

keinpvl

Time is a finite resource, and we’d all do better with sharing

Kirst

Agreed, I actually chose to blame him due to his interaction with Kate.

Alli

YESSSSSSSSSSS. I'm here for all of the suspicion.

Dani Pillar

So stoked for this video. Love your insightfulness, Brady!!!

Sardonicus

Yeah no. I think the absolute appropriate thing to do is to draw conclusions from the situation. I don't think that people should be impartial about this or not make assumptions. False reporting only happens 3% of the time, meanwhile , over 60 percent of victims say that they never even report the crime , because they don't think that anybody will believe them. We don't hold this standard for any other kind of victimized people. Somebody doesn't say that they got robbed and your first assumption is that maybe they lied and that the robber is the real victim and that we need to understand both sides of the situation. In most situations , we presume the victim's innocence without them having to prove that they're innocent. This only seems to be a thing that people really strongly push when it comes to women's getting assaulted by men. The victim blaming mentality and the barrier for being believed is so strong against people who this has happened to that I don't ever want to add to that. Nothing stopped everybody from making assumptions that Kate was just a slut who brought this upon herself. I refuse to add on to rape culture by not believing a victim, and leaving her with just another person that doesn't accept that what happened to her happened to her. No, if this ever happened to me, and somebody came up to me and trusted me about this you're goddammit right, I am gonna make assumptions in favor of the victim, and i'm gonna do my best effort to advocate for them. If it does turn out to be one of those extremely rare instances where it's a false accusations, then the rich boy is gonna have like a 1000 people on his side when that happens, including every single man who's a part of rape culture who wants to believe that all women are liars. He's gonna get out of the situation just fine if he's innocent. We already know how this country treats rapists. Just look at the Cornell 7. People like Nathan don't need any more advocates for them, and more people to undermine and baby his actions. They got plenty. This is a man who's been constantly shielded from the consequences of his actions his whole life. People like Kate who are alone and vulnerable and have no support or anything are the people who need advocates. Rape and sexual assualt victims rarely get advocates that actually genuinely believe them and take them seriously It's lways assume you have to either stay impartial or assume the victim is lying.. I don't see this as a situation to stay impartial when it is seriously so common for girls to not even come forward at all because they're afraid of people not taking them seriously. I will always take somebody who says that they were a victim of rape or s/a or a drugging seriously, and presume their innocence. I will never automatically assume that they could be lying. I will not stay impartial and assume that either side could be true. Sorry , but I do not accept the idea of staying impartial. Not on this kind of situation. I think our automatic assumptions impartiality is in part why so many victims are afraid of even coming forward.

Pat Gunn

It is a basic principle of justice that we don't treat accusations as proof. Whatever your beliefs are about the numbers, beaching this gives too much power to an accusation and tells us we need to treat certain accusations over others. If one person says they're a victim of a false accusation and another the victim of an assault, nobody wants to blame the victim but it's not clear which actually is the victim. What's sensible is to act with empathy, put the pretend statistics away, and avoid conclusions. We can do this without being dismissive, but we do not owe anyone belief without evidence.

Sardonicus (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-08 21:00 These aren't "beliefs" about numbers. These are direct statistical realities i am pointing out. I used the most conservative estimates too. Actual statistics say that it's closer to 72%- 80% percent of rape that goes unreported. You can look it up if you think I'm fudging the numbers. Nothing I said was made up. If you think my statistics are wrong, can you go find the correct statistics and tell me how I am wrong or how the statistics I used are lies? Since you seem to have just dismissed them outright despite being completely true, it comes across at this point that you just don't accept reality, and are annoyed at me for pointing out the reality. The reality is that remaining neutral in the face of an accusation effectively maintains the status quo. Because an accusation challenges existing power dynamics or social standings, taking no stance practically functions as the same thing as a shield for the accused, allowing them to maintain their social or professional standing while the legal process unfolds. That's what neutrality actually does. It's there to overwhelmingly protect the perpetrator and hurt the victim. Sociological frameworks often reference the idea that in situations involving severe asymmetry or harm, neutrality is structurally impossible. Choosing not to support a victim effectively sides with the party holding more power or defense in that moment. To not actively support the victim is the same thing as to support the perpetrator whether you believe it or not because of this. The justice system also doesn't say that you are supposed to assume that a victim is lying, and yet it does actively assume the victim is lying most if the time, and puts all . This is referred to in psychology as "secondary victimization". This is well known about the justice system. This is a constant problem when women go to report sexual assault. The police will actively believe that the victim is probably lying and to shoo them away. Tell them that there's no point in even reporting the crime cause they won't be believed. That very thing happened to my mom when they convinced her that she shouldn't press rape charges because no one will believe her. So many women have gone through this. So when you claim that the justice system is supposed to not make any assumptions one way or the other, that's simply not true. It doesn't do that.. The justice system actively puts the presumption of doubt on the victim to have to prove that they are a victim, and automatically will assume that the perpetrator is innocent until direct proof to the contrary happens. They system is made basically so that all of the emotional and procedural burden of proof falls entirely on the victim. The accused doesn't have to do anything to be presumed innocent alternatively. He's automatically presumed innocent until proven guilty. This makes all the hurdles symmetrically applied to one party and not the other in our system. This can be extremely problematic in rape situations where it's a "he said , versus , she said" situation, as it's extremely difficult to prove that it actually happened. This is one of the reasons why rape is one of the hardest crimes to actually get justice for. It's one of the only crimes where it's assumed that the victim is probably lying. it's the only crime where are people constantly ask what the victim was doing to deserve this like "what was she wearing?" "Was she drinking?" and one of the crimes where t's usually one person's word versus another. I'd point out the statistics on the subject on how dismal the rates are of victims actually recieving justice are, and the number of rape kits that have never even been tested at all, but you've already shown that you don't believe that statistics are real or have any relevance or something. I still don't understand why that's your stance. I think statistics can be highly relevant to understanding the statistical reality of a situation. Secondly, i don't know if you've noticed this but you and I aren't the justice system, and we are not bound by the justice system. Unless you were like a court judge or lawyer or something, you don't have to follow court justice procedure.. The justice system is supposed to stay impartial. That absolutely doesn't mean that everybody in the public has to stay completely impartial all the times. That's not how things work at all. We know in the overwhelming majority of cases, the victim is telling the truth, so to stay impartial is actively ignoring that reality, to pretend like everything's always 50-50 is the opposite of staying impartial since it's actively ignoring the reality that this isn't a 50-50 situation. Staying impartial is ignoring how much victims need advocates and how much they desperately need to be believed for their mental well being to even have the strength to come forward at all. How much they need support. You're thinking of this from some impartial justice standpoint instead of thinking about the actual living breathing person who is hurt and traumatized who desperately needs you standing right in front of them. Are you gonna stay impartial if your best friend says that they've been raped and go crying to you for comfort? Are you gonna let your best friend know that she may not have actually been raped and that you're not going to take either side because it's very important for you to stay impartial. That no matter how much you trust her, you're never gonna directly believe her because you have to stay impartial, and so you're not allowed to comfort her or anything , because how do you know if she's telling the truth or not? What if you're comforting a liar? Is anybody ever allowed to believe a rape victim if being impartial is so freaking important? Is anybody ever allowed to comfort a rape victim until we can have 100% proof that they were raped? At what point are we actually allowed to accept and believe a victim? Do you have to actively watch it happen so that you can know 100 percent certainty that it actually happened? If she never reports , it does that mean it automatically didn't happen because only a conviction means it happens in your eyes and anything short of a conviction means you're not allowed to accept their reality? Are you only gonna comfort and believe your friend after she's had a successful conviction against the guy, cus following justice procedure is more important than being a good advocate for somebody you care about? More important than showing another human being compassion? To say ,"I trust you and I believe you because I know you." even without an ounce of proof, cause they need that so badly. Like , can you put yourself in the position of a rape victim at all and understand just how terrifying it is to not be believed? How staying impartial comes across as the same thing as not believing them? To need a justice system to have to prove whether your reality is true or not ,in the eyes of everybody else even though you know it's true cause you went through it? What if the justice system decides to rule against you? Guess your rape never happened no matter how much it traumatizes you. Do you put this extremely strong standard on rape victims and yet no other group of victimization ever gets treated like this? Is your assumtion when somebody says they were robbed, that you need to stay impartial , cause they're probably lying. Or do you comfort that person? Presume that they're telling the truth. If somebody's gonna come to me about something like that , i'm gonna presume they're telling the truth. I think you have a very backwards notion of morality to do otherwise. I think you're mistaking the fact that the justice system should be impartial( even though the justice system isn't impartial at all and actively does everything possible to make it harder for a victim of assualt to get justice) to the idea that you should personally treat all cases as equally impartial. I alternatively have the stance that we should believe victims, and treat them as victims until the point in which it's been proven that they aren't. I think that to do anything less than that its to actively promote rape culture. It's the justice system's responsibility to prove things one way or the other, not mine. It's my responsibility to treat people with humanity and love.
2026-11-08 08:46 These aren't "beliefs" about numbers. These are direct statistical realities i am pointing out. I used the most conservative estimates too. Actual statistics say that it's closer to 72%- 80% percent of rape that goes unreported. You can look it up if you think I'm fudging the numbers. Nothing I said was made up. If you think my statistics are wrong, can you go find the correct statistics and tell me how I am wrong or how the statistics I used are lies? Since you seem to have just dismissed them outright despite being completely true, it comes across at this point that you just don't accept reality, and are annoyed at me for pointing out the reality. The reality is that remaining neutral in the face of an accusation effectively maintains the status quo. Because an accusation challenges existing power dynamics or social standings, taking no stance practically functions as the same thing as a shield for the accused, allowing them to maintain their social or professional standing while the legal process unfolds. That's what neutrality actually does. It's there to overwhelmingly protect the perpetrator and hurt the victim. Sociological frameworks often reference the idea that in situations involving severe asymmetry or harm, neutrality is structurally impossible. Choosing not to support a victim effectively sides with the party holding more power or defense in that moment. To not actively support the victim is the same thing as to support the perpetrator whether you believe it or not because of this. The justice system also doesn't say that you are supposed to assume that a victim is lying, and yet it does actively assume the victim is lying most if the time, and puts all . This is referred to in psychology as "secondary victimization". This is well known about the justice system. This is a constant problem when women go to report sexual assault. The police will actively believe that the victim is probably lying and to shoo them away. Tell them that there's no point in even reporting the crime cause they won't be believed. That very thing happened to my mom when they convinced her that she shouldn't press rape charges because no one will believe her. So many women have gone through this. So when you claim that the justice system is supposed to not make any assumptions one way or the other, that's simply not true. It doesn't do that.. The justice system actively puts the presumption of doubt on the victim to have to prove that they are a victim, and automatically will assume that the perpetrator is innocent until direct proof to the contrary happens. They system is made basically so that all of the emotional and procedural burden of proof falls entirely on the victim. The accused doesn't have to do anything to be presumed innocent alternatively. He's automatically presumed innocent until proven guilty. This makes all the hurdles asymmetrically applied to one party and not the other in our system. This can be extremely problematic in rape situations where it's a "he said , versus , she said" situation, as it's extremely difficult to prove that it actually happened. This is one of the reasons why rape is one of the hardest crimes to actually get justice for. Only a 3% conviction rate. It's one of the only crimes where it's assumed that the victim is probably lying. it's the only crime where are people constantly ask what the victim was doing to deserve this like "what was she wearing?" "Was she drinking?" and one of the crimes where t's usually one person's word versus another. I'd point out the statistics on the subject on how dismal the rates are of victims actually recieving justice are, and the number of rape kits that have never even been tested at all, but you've already shown that you don't believe that statistics are real or have any relevance or something. I still don't understand why that's your stance. I think statistics can be highly relevant to understanding the statistical reality of a situation. Secondly, i don't know if you've noticed this but you and I aren't the justice system, and we are not bound by the justice system. Unless you were like a court judge or lawyer or something, you don't have to follow court justice procedure.. The justice system is supposed to stay impartial. That absolutely doesn't mean that everybody in the public has to stay completely impartial all the times. That's not how things work at all. We know in the overwhelming majority of cases, the victim is telling the truth, so to stay impartial is actively ignoring that reality, to pretend like everything's always 50-50 is the opposite of staying impartial since it's actively ignoring the reality that this isn't a 50-50 situation. Staying impartial is ignoring how much victims need advocates and how much they desperately need to be believed for their mental well being to even have the strength to come forward at all. How much they need support. You're thinking of this from some impartial justice standpoint instead of thinking about the actual living breathing person who is hurt and traumatized who desperately needs you standing right in front of them. Are you gonna stay impartial if your best friend says that they've been raped and go crying to you for comfort? Are you gonna let your best friend know that she may not have actually been raped and that you're not going to take either side because it's very important for you to stay impartial. That no matter how much you trust her, you're never gonna directly believe her because you have to stay impartial, and so you're not allowed to comfort her or anything , because how do you know if she's telling the truth or not? What if you're comforting a liar? Is anybody ever allowed to believe a rape victim if being impartial is so freaking important? Is anybody ever allowed to comfort a rape victim until we can have 100% proof that they were raped? At what point are we actually allowed to accept and believe a victim? Do you have to actively watch it happen so that you can know 100 percent certainty that it actually happened? If she never reports , it does that mean it automatically didn't happen because only a conviction means it happens in your eyes and anything short of a conviction means you're not allowed to accept their reality? Are you only gonna comfort and believe your friend after she's had a successful conviction against the guy, cus following justice procedure is more important than being a good advocate for somebody you care about? More important than showing another human being compassion? To say ,"I trust you and I believe you because I know you." even without an ounce of proof, cause they need that so badly. Like , can you put yourself in the position of a rape victim at all and understand just how terrifying it is to not be believed? How staying impartial comes across as the same thing as not believing them? To need a justice system to have to prove whether your reality is true or not ,in the eyes of everybody else even though you know it's true cause you went through it? What if the justice system decides to rule against you? Guess your rape never happened no matter how much it traumatizes you. Do you put this extremely strong standard on rape victims and yet no other group of victimization ever gets treated like this? Is your assumtion when somebody says they were robbed, that you need to stay impartial , cause they're probably lying. Or do you comfort that person? Presume that they're telling the truth. If somebody's gonna come to me about something like that , i'm gonna presume they're telling the truth. I think you have a very backwards notion of morality to do otherwise. I think you're mistaking the fact that the justice system should be impartial( even though the justice system isn't impartial at all and actively does everything possible to make it harder for a victim of assualt to get justice) to the idea that you should personally treat all cases as equally impartial. I alternatively have the stance that we should believe victims, and treat them as victims until the point in which it's been proven that they aren't. I think that to do anything less than that its to actively promote rape culture. It's the justice system's responsibility to prove things one way or the other, not mine. It's my responsibility to treat people with humanity and love.

These aren't "beliefs" about numbers. These are direct statistical realities i am pointing out. I used the most conservative estimates too. Actual statistics say that it's closer to 72%- 80% percent of rape that goes unreported. You can look it up if you think I'm fudging the numbers. Nothing I said was made up. If you think my statistics are wrong, can you go find the correct statistics and tell me how I am wrong or how the statistics I used are lies? Since you seem to have just dismissed them outright despite being completely true, it comes across at this point that you just don't accept reality, and are annoyed at me for pointing out the reality. The reality is that remaining neutral in the face of an accusation effectively maintains the status quo. Because an accusation challenges existing power dynamics or social standings, taking no stance practically functions as the same thing as a shield for the accused, allowing them to maintain their social or professional standing while the legal process unfolds. That's what neutrality actually does. It's there to overwhelmingly protect the perpetrator and hurt the victim. Sociological frameworks often reference the idea that in situations involving severe asymmetry or harm, neutrality is structurally impossible. Choosing not to support a victim effectively sides with the party holding more power or defense in that moment. To not actively support the victim is the same thing as to support the perpetrator whether you believe it or not because of this. The justice system also doesn't say that you are supposed to assume that a victim is lying, and yet it does actively assume the victim is lying most if the time, and puts all . This is referred to in psychology as "secondary victimization". This is well known about the justice system. This is a constant problem when women go to report sexual assault. The police will actively believe that the victim is probably lying and to shoo them away. Tell them that there's no point in even reporting the crime cause they won't be believed. That very thing happened to my mom when they convinced her that she shouldn't press rape charges because no one will believe her. So many women have gone through this. So when you claim that the justice system is supposed to not make any assumptions one way or the other, that's simply not true. It doesn't do that.. The justice system actively puts the presumption of doubt on the victim to have to prove that they are a victim, and automatically will assume that the perpetrator is innocent until direct proof to the contrary happens. They system is made basically so that all of the emotional and procedural burden of proof falls entirely on the victim. The accused doesn't have to do anything to be presumed innocent alternatively. He's automatically presumed innocent until proven guilty. This makes all the hurdles asymmetrically applied to one party and not the other in our system. This can be extremely problematic in rape situations where it's a "he said , versus , she said" situation, as it's extremely difficult to prove that it actually happened. This is one of the reasons why rape is one of the hardest crimes to actually get justice for. Only a 3% conviction rate. It's one of the only crimes where it's assumed that the victim is probably lying. it's the only crime where are people constantly ask what the victim was doing to deserve this like "what was she wearing?" "Was she drinking?" and one of the crimes where t's usually one person's word versus another. I'd point out the statistics on the subject on how dismal the rates are of victims actually recieving justice are, and the number of rape kits that have never even been tested at all, but you've already shown that you don't believe that statistics are real or have any relevance or something. I still don't understand why that's your stance. I think statistics can be highly relevant to understanding the statistical reality of a situation. Secondly, i don't know if you've noticed this but you and I aren't the justice system, and we are not bound by the justice system. Unless you were like a court judge or lawyer or something, you don't have to follow court justice procedure.. The justice system is supposed to stay impartial. That absolutely doesn't mean that everybody in the public has to stay completely impartial all the times. That's not how things work at all. We know in the overwhelming majority of cases, the victim is telling the truth, so to stay impartial is actively ignoring that reality, to pretend like everything's always 50-50 is the opposite of staying impartial since it's actively ignoring the reality that this isn't a 50-50 situation. Staying impartial is ignoring how much victims need advocates and how much they desperately need to be believed for their mental well being to even have the strength to come forward at all. How much they need support. You're thinking of this from some impartial justice standpoint instead of thinking about the actual living breathing person who is hurt and traumatized who desperately needs you standing right in front of them. Are you gonna stay impartial if your best friend says that they've been raped and go crying to you for comfort? Are you gonna let your best friend know that she may not have actually been raped and that you're not going to take either side because it's very important for you to stay impartial. That no matter how much you trust her, you're never gonna directly believe her because you have to stay impartial, and so you're not allowed to comfort her or anything , because how do you know if she's telling the truth or not? What if you're comforting a liar? Is anybody ever allowed to believe a rape victim if being impartial is so freaking important? Is anybody ever allowed to comfort a rape victim until we can have 100% proof that they were raped? At what point are we actually allowed to accept and believe a victim? Do you have to actively watch it happen so that you can know 100 percent certainty that it actually happened? If she never reports , it does that mean it automatically didn't happen because only a conviction means it happens in your eyes and anything short of a conviction means you're not allowed to accept their reality? Are you only gonna comfort and believe your friend after she's had a successful conviction against the guy, cus following justice procedure is more important than being a good advocate for somebody you care about? More important than showing another human being compassion? To say ,"I trust you and I believe you because I know you." even without an ounce of proof, cause they need that so badly. Like , can you put yourself in the position of a rape victim at all and understand just how terrifying it is to not be believed? How staying impartial comes across as the same thing as not believing them? To need a justice system to have to prove whether your reality is true or not ,in the eyes of everybody else even though you know it's true cause you went through it? What if the justice system decides to rule against you? Guess your rape never happened no matter how much it traumatizes you. Do you put this extremely strong standard on rape victims and yet no other group of victimization ever gets treated like this? Is your assumtion when somebody says they were robbed, that you need to stay impartial , cause they're probably lying. Or do you comfort that person? Presume that they're telling the truth. If somebody's gonna come to me about something like that , i'm gonna presume they're telling the truth. I think you have a very backwards notion of morality to do otherwise. I think you're mistaking the fact that the justice system should be impartial( even though the justice system isn't impartial at all and actively does everything possible to make it harder for a victim of assualt to get justice) to the idea that you should personally treat all cases as equally impartial. I alternatively have the stance that we should believe victims, and treat them as victims until the point in which it's been proven that they aren't. I think that to do anything less than that its to actively promote rape culture. It's the justice system's responsibility to prove things one way or the other, not mine. It's my responsibility to treat people with humanity and love.

Holly

And by 'pretend statistics' you mean ....*actual* statistics? Yes, let's put facts away shall we. We don't need to take those into consideration. 🤦 And maybe you missed the part where she brought up the reality that we. don't. treat. any. other. claim. of. a. crime. this. way. If someone claims they were robbed, the police's first reaction isn't 'Well maybe they're lying. We need proof first.' The default assumption is that they are telling the truth. If someone's car is stolen, the cops don't show up and say 'Well maybe they're just hiding their car so they can get insurance money. Until we see the car show up in a chop shop somewhere, we don't actually have proof that your car was stolen.' Or let's use a very closely equivalent situation- if a *man* walks into a police station saying that he was attacked or assaulted, their first thought is not going to be 'well let's get proof first because maybe he's lying'. Now yes, if someone intends to take any these situations to *court*, then evidence has to be gathered...but the point is that when the claim is first made, in every single case of *every other* type of crime, the default assumption is that the victim is telling the truth. The only time that's *not* the case is when a woman comes forward saying that she has been raped/drugged/assaulted etc.... Then it's 'Ok hold on now, let's get his side of the story' Hearing a woman make a claim and *believing her* is *not* the equivalent of a court conviction for the man. It is simply giving her the benefit of the doubt. (A '97 -percent -chance -that- shes- telling-the-truth' benefit of the doubt)

Pat Gunn

We treat every claim of a crime this way. Police are not there to determine guilt. They don't need to assume it, they're there to gather evidence and have a process with the courts that we hope on average produce justice. The general public also doesn't assume accusations of other crimes are all accurate; we rely on the courts. If two people have a dispute over some property nobody comes to us and demands we take their side. We can show empathy to distress, and try to make sure the process gets followed, but we don't just decide one person is the victim and take their side. Same process. Show empathy, don't take a side.

Pat Gunn

I apply the same standards for all crimes. I don't want police to treat sexual assault any different either; it's not their job to judge, nor is it mine. Police are there to gather facts and people and prepare for the courts to handle it. Ideally they show empathy to people making claims of assaults (and all other crimes). Not to shoo people away, but not to react as if there's a guilty verdict in hand. That's what justice requires.

Holly

Wow. Tell me you haven't actually witnessed or been a part of anything like this without actually telling me. We treat every crime this way? Ummm No. We. Don't. "Police are there to gather facts and people and prepare for the courts... To gather evidence and not judge" you say? Do we live on the same planet? Yeah in an ideal world maybe. But here in the real world, victims of all of the other types of crimes I just gave you examples of - yes, the police will show up and ask them questions. Neutral, fact gathering questions like 'What was taken?' 'Did you get a look at the person who attacked you?' 'Where was your car when you last saw it?' (Addendum- assuming you're white, of course. People of color might have a completely different experience with this) Do you know what they ask when they show up to question an assault victim? 'Did you say yes at any point? Did you lead him on? Were you drinking? Is it possible maybe he just misunderstood? Did you do anything to upset him or make him angry?'.... I could go on. And don't tell me that they don't, or that this isn't a common way that victims get interrogated. I have personal experience with this, and so does almost every woman in my family.

Pat Gunn

I am aware of these things, and have seen them up close in a time I worked at a shelter. The answer to these questions is not to toss out due process, nor is it to have people in society equate accusations as guilt. It's in training and monitoring police in public interactions. If you would seriously advocate that the general public should treat every accusation as proof of guilt, you'll produce a backlash (and these bad ideas should produce a backlash). People know that that's a bad way to operate. The only sustainable long-term solution is to be empathetic and supportive but not to automatically believe, both on an individual level and in how our police and courts operate.

Holly

*sigh* Okay look. You keep equating two things that are not equivalent here, and so we keep talking past each other. You're not listening to the point that's actually being made. We're not talking about what happens in a courtroom. We are talking about when the *initial* claim is made, and and the reaction and *lack* of belief that victims are often faced with (despite the 97% likelihood that they're telling the truth) Let's use this video game as an example The hallway where Max and Mr. Jefferson are standing is NOT a courtroom. There are no lawyers present. Nathan is not being put on trial in this moment. They are talking about that video, and Jefferson's first reaction is 'maybe Kate brought this on herself' Your initial response was to say that given his lack of information, his response was appropriate. And sadly, his reaction is also the instinctive first reaction of many people hearing a claim of rape or assault. Now I'm going to say this again, for the last time, and then I'm done here. Believing the victim who is coming forward to make the claim of assault, and giving them the benefit of the doubt that they are telling the truth, is NOT THE SAME AS THROWING OUT DUE PROCESS AND CONVICTING SOMEONE IN A COURTROOM BASED ON NO EVIDENCE. You keep saying we shouldn't do that. Well guess what? NO ONE is saying we should do that. I'm not saying that. And that's not happening. No judge in any courtroom is saying "Well, we don't have ANY evidence, but she says you did it and that's good enough for me, so 15 years in jail for you." Okay that's not happening. But you're acting as though believing the claims of an assault victim could potentially *lead* to that happening. And with the *very rare* exception, it just isn't. But the fact that you are saying that a victim's claim shouldn't be believed without proof right from the outset, even the initial accusation, suggests to me that you're not actually talking about the legal system, or the courts, or due process or any of that. It sounds to me like you're talking about the court of *public opinion*. That we shouldn't believe victims without proof because otherwise some 'promising young man' might have to face the social consequences of having accusations thrown at him. Which if recent real world events have shown us, doesn't really have the negative consequences you fear it will have... In fact, very rarely are there actual any real world consequences to an accusation for the one being accused because in these situations the victim is often blamed, assumed to be lying, or *not believed* because 'there's no proof' And then all of those questions I mentioned earlier are thrown in *her* direction The classic 'What was she wearing? Did she drink? Why did she drink? Why was she at that party, she should have known better', etc etc. I'm not going to keep belaboring this. I'm done now 😔 (And now I can laugh at myself, because I knew this was a mistake as soon as I started to engage you with this. I mean honestly, what did I think was going to happen? That I was going to lay all this out for you and you were going to go 'You know what 🤔 she's right and I was being very short-sighted in my initial response'? I knew you would most likely just dig your heels in and that nothing I said would change anything, But due to my own experiences, I felt compelled to respond, and two messages into it I already regretted it)

Pat Gunn

We are talking past each other, and your response here shows part of that. Following your example, I know it's not a courtroom, although it is worthwhile keeping in mind notions of fairness that courtrooms chase and holding it as an ideal for ourselves too. My initial response was not that Jefferson's response was appropriate. I don't think it was, and you see in the back-and-forth in this forum that I criticised his response. It was not empathetic, and it was in fact cruel and inappropriate. I am not saying this for the first time in this thread with you; you'll find my having said that before. It is not appropriate to assume someone is a victim because they say they are, but when people make these claims, even if we don't know what happened, we can and should still react with empathy. If they straight-up ask if we believe them we can and should say that we're reserving judgement, but we can still be decent human beings and recognise the pain of the person in front of us, whatever the actual facts are. We don't need to believe to do that. I don't believe claims of this sort without proof. I won't call someone a victim because they call themselves one. But I also won't call them liars because I don't know that either. I will react with empathy without reaching a conclusion, and I think that's the right thing to do. I critique people like Jefferson, and I critique people who call for automatic belief in someone making a claim and who assume they're victims because they say they are. Without the needed info, we simply don't know, but we can try to be kind either way.

Holly

Oh excuse me I apologize.😒 I believe 'reasonable' was the word you used. You: "...based on available information, Mr. Jefferson's stance is reasonable given that he doesn't know what Max knows" Okay now I really am done Good night

Beth

Gutted that I’m working this weekend, I can’t wait for Monday to watch this. I’m covering the mental health crisis team for the weekend, I was going to watch on my break but I think this episode might be a bit too reminiscent of work and I need a proper break before getting back to it 🫡 At least if I watch on Monday it means less time to wait for the next episode afterwards!

Alva

Even though i knew you'd be able to save Kate, I still held my breath during that segment. Its still so delicate and nerve-wracking to this day

Lunosophy

You're certainly correct about how a criminal trial works. But human relationships are not criminal trials. I mean, are you serious? We're not supposed to believe people when they come to us with something until it's been demonstrated beyond reasonable doubt in a court of law? It costs you nothing to extend empathy to someone who is coming to you and it does nothing to harm the allegedly offending party. And it's arguably your duty to do so when you're a mentor figure to someone. Literally nobody said that anyone should be sentenced without an investigation first. Let the investigators do their job on that front, someone like Jefferson would have no role except to tell the truth if interviewed. And what you believe about people should never be dependent just on the outcome of a criminal investigation anyway—how then would people truly falsely convicted of crimes be advocated for if people in their life were compelled to believe whatever the outcome of a trial is? It's about listening to someone and hearing them and being there for them in that moment. Including letting them know you believe them, even if you are 99%, not 100%, sure they're telling the truth. Basic human relationship stuff. If a friend of yours came running to you in tears saying something extremely valuable to them was stolen, would you wait for a court to tell you whether to believe them? And that they aren't making it up and trying to frame the alleged offender?

Sardonicus

SO yeah the more I hear you talk and rationalize your beliefs the more I just see you as an open rape apologist and that you and people just like you are ACTIVELY the reason that only 3% of rape victims ever get any justice. You and people just like you are why rape culture exists. Whether you like it or not are directly and inexplicably one of the main reasons that most rape victims never even feel safe reporting. They know that people like you exist, who will never believe them short of a conviction, and think your lack of belief is just impartiality. Who believe you are being so supportive and empathetic despite the fact you admit that you think they could be lying which means you actually don't support them at all because you CANNOT be supportive of a victim of violence without believing what happened to them. Denying their reality is inherently unsupportive. Those are two opposing ideas. The reservation of taking a side is an active condemnation of the victims character by assuming they might be lying. To not accept on the surface level what happened to them happened is the exact same thing in practice as saying that they aren't trustworthy. Indifference and neutrality in the face of injustice always hurts the victim and helps the perpetrators in these situation. Just the same as reserving judgement about something like slavery does. If your friend was burglarized would your "support" of him be telling him that you cannot accept or believe he is telling the truth about being robbed and that you will reserve judgement for after the robber is convinced cause your friend may actually just be lying about being robbed which means you cannot take him at his word. Does this line of logic make sense to you for anything other than rape? WHen I was beaten up in school they didn't ask if it really happened to me and what I was wearing. That's something people only do when it comes to rape based around the false assumption that rape victims are just a unique type of crime that people are just constantly lying about to punish "innocent young men with a bright future/" Also every time you bring up the justice system and how they treat all crimes equally shows to me you know nothing about the justice system. With normal crimes they don't take sides, and will investigate and look into it. When a person reports a rape the first thing they do is try to convince the person to not report it and drop the charges, nearly every time. So many women have dealt with this. The justice system will treat them automatically from the spot as probably lying. My own mother was actively convinced out of pressing charges after the police convinced her that no one would believe her and that her name would be dragged through the mud and she'd be seen as the town bicycle. They told her that they were doing a kindness to her by convincing her not to press charges cause she would never get justice, so there is no point even trying. The first thing they did was terrify a scared 17 year old into not even reporting the incident. Please tell me any other crime that police automatically treat this way? Also can you explain why you think that you are the same thing as the justice system? You must believe that you are personally the person who convicts all rapists to constantly bring up the justice systems impartiality and say that it applies to you, a citizen who has no part in the justice system. I guess by your own logic no one is ever allowed to have an opinion on anything until it's 100% proven since we are all just mini-walking- justice systems who have to follow the laws of justice system at all times. Guess I can't have any opinions about crimes that presidents commit since legally a president can't be prosecuted for crimes they commited under office, and the only way a person can ever be judged is a conviction. Guess this means anyone who was victimized who never pressed charges just didn't get raped cause only a conviction means that a thing happened. Do you not understand why this logic is so backwards? Nothing about your opinion effects how the justice system is going to handle the crime. You don't decide based on your opinion whether justice happens or not. All your opinion does is let a rape victim feel for once like she's believed and not just going to be assumed a liar. And your opinion appears to be, "no screw supprting her cause it's way more important to protect the perpetrator from the accusation by pretending like my impartiality doesn't directly benifit the perpetrator and hurt the victim cause if I'm not personally 100% convinced through a conviction that she's telling the truth, than she might as well be a liar for how much I'm going to trust her word.. Oh but I'm so supportive and empathetic about it even though I refuse to believe that what she's saying is true" And for some reason you think that's justice, cause you think you're the justice system and must remain impartial. Or your false conflation that not staying impartial is the same thing as not letting justice happen. NO ONE thinks that someone should be convincted on only public opinion, or that a crime like that shouldn't have evidence, and an impartial justice system. It's that you conflate that as the same thing as you personally needing to stay impartial at all times, and like those two things are identical.

Pat Gunn

I extend that notion of fairness outside of criminal trials, but I support extending sympathy and kindness to people who appear to be struggling, without needing to take a stance on the truth of the matter. I won't say what I believe in such moments, but that's not really what's important. (with your final example, I would provisionally accept that it was taken, but if they said someone specific took it I would remain neutral on that part)

Lunosophy

All I can say is, I hope you find people in your life who think the same way as you do because it's hurtful for most of us not to be believed by someone who's meant to trust us. Also, most if not all beliefs are provisional in a sense, and belief doesn't have to mean certainty. But whatever floats your boat, if you're ok being treated that way too and can find others who agree.

JoBobby

So what I'm seeing is , the fundamental stance that you just keep repeating over and over in longer and different ways in every post here is: We should extend kindness and empathy to somebody struggling, or if they make a claim of some crime having been committed against them, BUT we shouldn't automatically believe what they say without proof. Is that right? Do I have that right?

Pat Gunn

We should not demand of people in our lives that they'll take our side in disputes without evidence. That's an unreasonable demand. We should expect them to show us empathy, and we should show them empathy.

Pat Gunn

Yes. That's what it looks like to try to be both kind and fair.

JoBobby

Okay. So - Someone comes to you and says that they have just been raped or assaulted. And you 'kindly and empathetically' tell them that you're reserving judgment until you have proof. What kind of proof do you need in this situation in order to believe them? What kind of proof needs to exist in order to satisfy you? So that you go "All right then. Clearly this happened and I believe you" What kind of proof does this person need to present to you?

Holly

Once again Sardonicus, I wish I could give this a thousand hearts.❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ Thank you. I try, but sometimes I can't articulate everything that I want to say as well as I would wish. You laid everything out so much better than I can. I got exhausted realizing I wasn't getting anywhere so I just bowed out.

Pat Gunn

That's not what is called for. What's called for is to engage and support them without commenting on the truthfulness of the matter. To listen. To offer sympathy. One avoids the topic of truthfulness and instead engage by listening, by talking about how they feel, by offering resources, and by being there for them. I generally am not going to be equipped to judge the truth; maybe that's sometimes possible, but it's rare, and it's not something I feel I'm obliged to do. You could in theory do this for people who mutually accuse each other (and I have in the past, with a lesbian couple I knew in college who had a range of things they accused each other of from cheating to abuse to other things - I didn't need to take sides, but I tried to be a good friend to both; at that point in my life I probably failed in some parts of it, but I still think or at least hope that I had the right goals and broad direction)

Holly

❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Pat Gunn

Holly, I hope you didn't read anything I said as disrespect for you. I don't want the disagreement to be tense, and I think you're coming at this with a good heart. That we don't reach the same conclusions doesn't mean we need to be angry at each other.

JoBobby

Okay, so it's at this point that I'm going to redirect you to Sardonicus's last two posts. I noticed you didn't respond to or address ANY of the points made in them. But I'll back up some of them here. I find it very convenient that your _unwavering_ stance is that we shouldn't believe people without proof. But then when asked, what kind of proof do you need? You say presenting proof is not what's called for, and it's not my place to judge. You say it's the justice system that should judge Well it does And it almost always favors the perpetrator Which Is why so few sexual assault cases ever result in a conviction And in a system that is so heavily skewed against the victim, maintaining a neutral stance is not the 'fairness' position that you think it is. Your neutrality also favors the perpetrator To ignore the 97% probability that the victim is telling the truth in favor of 'Well maybe it happened, maybe it didn't. I don't know' is simply ignoring reality. The proof you are demanding or that you say is required before you can believe them often DOES NOT EXIST. In most cases There is nobody in the room recording it There are no multiple outside witnesses to it happening. It gets treated simply like a he-said/she-said situation, except what she said is often scrutinized to high hell, while what he said often isn't And yes, this very attitude contributes to why rape culture is what it is, and it's why so few victims come forward to begin with. Because they know that they are likely going to encounter one of two responses: The people who immediately go to accusations and victim blaming, or people who just say I'm going to reserve judgment until we have proof. Proof that often does not exist.

Pat Gunn

I reject the premise that we either should look to determine truth or that that's needed to be a good friend or good person. The justice system is careful because it's trying to be careful around accusations and what we take as true. We should try to be as fair. If the evidence doesn't exist, it doesn't mean we need to decide one side is bad and the other good, it just means we should withhold judgement. Perhaps forever. As the courts do and should. This does not mean we should be cruel to people in distress (as Jefferson does in this scene). We should be empathetic and supportive, but without reaching judgement. It has to be good enough to show empathy without deciding someone is guilty without that evidence, because the alternative is worse. Even if your numbers are right. On the off chance evidence reaches the bar of "beyond a reasonable doubt", I would conclude, as a jury presumably would. But we both know (and you have said) that that's rarely going to be the case. In practice that means that I, like the courts, will remain neutral on these matters of fact. This is how it should be, because the alternative is worse. Moral judgement comes with responsibility to both the accused and the accuser, (not the victim and the perpetrator; we don't know that) to be fair.

Holly

Through my responses to you, I've made it clear that I myself and many of the women in my family have personal experience with these kinds of assaults, and the common reaction It receives when you try to tell someone. And you've made it clear, repeatedly, over and over, that you are just another in a long line of these people. That your position would be 'I'll 'kindly' listen to you, but I won't believe you without proof' But no disrespect meant 🙄 And I'm not angry After years of dealing with this kind of s*** and this kind of response from people, I don't have the energy anymore to be angry. I'm just resigned and sad 😞

JoBobby

Amazing. It's like talking at a brick wall. Everything we've all said to you just bounces right off, and you just keep finding new and more long-winded ways to restate your core position again and again and again. And again. Thanks to my economics classes in college, I'm familiar with the sunk cost fallacy So I think I'm with Holly at this point. I'm out 👋

Pat Gunn

It should not be surprising that as adults who've held our views and world-outlooks for a long time, we don't just casually convince each other towards totally new views. Your arguments have been about as novel as mine. I haven't convinced you, you haven't convinced me. I could express the same dismissal that you've expressed, but there's little point in it because this is how disagreements work.

Sardonicus

"We should try to be as fair. If the evidence doesn't exist, it doesn't mean we need to decide one side is bad and the other good, it just means we should withhold judgement" Did you know your exact same line of logic was used for people who wouldn't take a side on abolishing slavery. Or giving women more rights. Or fighting against war crimes. All your thinking does is preserve the status quo, with a refusal to upset it in any way. If we only rely on the justice system for what we believe is true or moral we are forfeiting our minds to a blind trust in authority and a presumption that it was made to serve justice instead of the reality of our justice system that it's meant in most situations to preserve power in the hands of those who already have power at the expense of justice. If our justice system was anything less than a joke then money couldn't influence the results. Everything you're saying is based around this "fair world fallacy" where everything just works out in the end. Evidence presents itself and people take it into account. A guilty party is punished. The person who was hurt gets justice. That's not how this world works. That's naive thinking that's meant specifically to not address the actual problems in our world. It also is making an extremely unfair assumption. Which is that when a rape accusation happens that this is something that's a perfect 50:50 issue where it's equally as likely that she's telling the truth as she's lying. That the perpetrator is equally as likely to be innocent as guilty. We know though that the overwhelming majority of the time they are telling the truth. That false accusations are incredibly rare, and I feel like you repeatedly refuse to acknowledge this FACT. Yes false accusations happen sometimes, and that's why the justice system itself should remain impartial until proper evidence presents itself. It is unfair to then use that to basically say the victim is just as likely to be lying as telling the truth and to reserve judgement completely cause of some rare chance she might be lying, especially if you are a trusted figure to this person. This is like refusing to rescue someone from drowning until they can prove that they can't actually swim. This impartiality is actively hurting them. I also disagree with the notion that we should live our lives identical to a justice system and anything less is immoral. Cause I know as a fact that even you don 't live your life like a court. No one does. If you did you'd have to doubt every time anyone says anything to you no matter how benign. "Oh you were late to work cause of traffic? Can you pull up the traffic camera's to prove this?" To me you are mistaking two different standards of evidence for one another. If X says Y sexually assaulted her, I believe Y did it, but that's not proof beyond a reasonable doubt, so it should not be enough for a criminal conviction. It's literally just the concept of standard of proof - you don't need a very high standard of proof to believe something casuallly, but you do need it to revoke a person's fundamental freedoms and enforce criminal justice. This is why the justice system should stay impartial but also why WE should support those who are close to us. We do not in any other facet of life require a judicial standard burden of proof to believe another person, especially someone close to us. If your friend told you that they had cereal this morning would you refuse to make a judgement call on the truth of that? If your mother said she loves you do you need a cross examiner to make sure there aren't any holes in her story? If your friend got fired from his job and he says that his boss had been harassing him, are you going to ask him to present you with evidence this happened? You don't live your life like a courtroom in any other instances, why have you chosen specifically rape victims going to you for support to be the people you require this standard to believe? Are they just fundamentally less trustworthy than your friend saying that their boss was a dick? Once again this same mindset is used to excuse so many other types of injustices in the world. "Oh we should present climate denial and climate advocacy as equally likely to be true. After all it's only fair to both sides. We're going to hide that 99.9% of scientists are in agreement about this thing, and that people who deny it are considered a fringe group with no evidence behind it, BUT IT'S ONLY FAIR that we reserve judgement and treat these two positions as equally likely." That's your fairness. Not actual fairness. Just pushing the status quo of rape victim's not being believed IN THE NAME OF FAIRNESS! ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sardonicus

Also thanks for the compliments from the other people in this comment chain. I appreciate that. I am a caregiver in a mental health hospital who SPECIFICALLY works with patients who have suffered abuse, so I feel particularly strongly on this issue after all the things I've seen, and directly how I was trained to deal with people with these kinds of trauma. I don't think people like this guy genuinely get just how heavily stacked it is against the victims in this situation and how terrible the justice system is at doing its job. He's presuming the world is fair, and our justice system works how its suppose to.

Pat Gunn

It's inaccurate to compare a refusal to take side when there is not enough evidence to do so with a situation where people don't take moral stands when all the facts are on the table. You're grandstanding, which brings more heat than light to the disagreement. We don't need to live in a fair world to know that upholding reasonable ideas of justice makes the world a better place. We don't need to believe there's a 50/50 chance for an accusation to be true to know that it's unjust to take sides without evidence. When assigning moral blame on someone, we should try to get it right, or nobody should trust what we say and anything dramatic we might do downstream could add more injustice. I know the world is messy. I know that injustices are all over the place. But the way you approach these issues adds to them. I believe you have a good heart and mean well in what you say. I am not impugning your motives. But I think you're pushing for a shortcut for moral judgement and the more people that do that, the more tribal and unjust we'll end up. Good intentions are not always enough.

KittenDough

It’s fun that Brady brings up skateboarding in his analysis on game theory, when there literally exists a skateboarding anime where the entire crux of its narrative is “trying to be number one in everything is an unhealthy mindset, and that having fun in life is best when it’s within a community.”

Ashley

I could see you struggling but you held it together better than I did during that conversation with Jefferson about Kate lol. I was continuously cursing him out and flipping him off through the screen. I think it speaks well of Max that she disagreed with him and stood up for Kate despite how much she admires him and wants him to like her. That can be especially hard at her age.

Alex

I had the worst day at work today, this episode be heavensentttttttttt

Beth

Me: Oh boy I can’t wait to watch the new episode of Life is Strange! Brady: Hello and welcome to my video essay about toilet paper girl.

Melli Venom

Big hug coming your way, I have had depressive episodes since I was 13, C-PTSD and all. I am 27 now and I've never been happier. My C-PTSD has revised (basically healed as far as it is possible), I am on the right meds and much love around me. I hope you can hold on tight and learn to be there for yourself in a healing way. Hold yourself and give yourself a lot of grace, you are allowed to feel deeply and let it move through you. Best wishes 🖤

Dinolate

I think we all let out that sigh of relief you let out when Kate was finally safe, damn. If anyone is an appropiate player to save her, its you, and still it was so stressful ;; I'm absolutely loving your playthrough and analysis so far, even when I already know this game, your explanations bring so much new context and points of view to the characters. Keep it up!