Rules and Roleplay
- Hard roleplay mechanics 67
- Soft roleplay guidelines 145
- No roleplay elements baked into the game 39
Do you like have hard mechanics for roleplay, softer structures that are more suggestive for players, or no guidance baked into the game at all?
Let me throw out some examples.
A hard roleplay mechanic enforces character actions. Let's say you have a Greedy character trait. When you have the chance to make money, you might roll against it. If you give in, you either have to be greedy and take the money or suffer a mechanical penalty.
A softer mechanic isn't a really a rule but a structure. The game might have you choose a flaw for your character. If you choose greedy, there are no rules that force you to act greedy and no mechanical penalties for going against the trait.
A game like Call of Cthulhu or Traveller has no RP guidance baked into the game. There are no alignments, and you are free to sketch out as much or as little of your personality as you wish.
What's your preference? I have my own ideas that I have written up for Odyssey, but I am curious to see what folks prefer before I share my rules. Of course, I might present an approach that this poll verifies as deeply unpopular, but that's the fun of designing in public.