Damage Types, Yes or No?
- Keep them as they are in D&D 50
- Use this approach 134
- Use a different approach 36
If you had a chance to read over the first draft of Odyssey, you can see that I've dropped damage types from the game.
Instead, I'm using a system of tags to describe objects in the game. Weapons are labeled as bludgeon, blade, and so on.
If it's important that a creature interact with these, it could have a feature like this:
Brittle: If this creature takes damage from a bludgeon, it must make a trained Constitution check (DC 15) or take an additional 2d10 damage.
For things like energy resistance, I'm considering adding a clause to specific spells like this:
Fire Creatures: A fire creature takes no damage from this spell.
A fire elemental would be a fire creature. Here's a counter example. Imagine a spell that fires a jet of water to knock a target back.
Fire Creatures: A fire creature takes an additional 2d10 damage from this spell.
The benefit of this approach is that it allows more interesting spell interactions and gives a designer finer control over how spells work, at the cost of added complexity.
To keep things simple, I'm removing the distinction between resistance and immunity. I'd rather have a bigger effect, than one smaller one and one larger one. It reduces complexity and means that we have only one tag to add to a creature.
My sense is that this would mean that damage types overall become much less important. They are no longer attached to every spell or attack. When they matter, they have a bigger impact and are worth the slow down.
What are your thoughts on damage types?