Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

WARNING: If you enjoy Star Wars or the theories of Joseph Campbell, DO NOT WATCH THIS VIDEO! However, if you find yourself wondering what went wrong with Star Wars and pop culture in general, or why all stories seem to be the same, then this might be of interest.

I'll be back to tuts soon!

Comments

Scott C

It’s had a pretty positive effect on my life so yeah will skip this one - Can’t just assume that because things are popular or connect with audiences with a lot of people they’re automatically “slop”, which I got was the implication from the first few minutes. That’s kind of the film discourse now because this past decade has had a lot of poor blockbusters, and it’s really frustrating to me. Doesn’t mean they’re good but also not necessarily bad I think all the stuff about self belief and self improvement are very important in surviving life and also fascism is not that bad of a target to take down. The whole message of the original 6 is about not falling into despair, in the bleakest of conditions, and helping people fight against authority (Obvious Anti-Nazism/ British Empire but also inspired in part by the US’s Imperialism in Vietnam), I think there’s way worse problems in the world. And I think all the myth stuff has some validation because people all over the world resonated with it deeply instantly, you know for good or bad messages patterns did emerge through time Lucas tapped into (and I think here they were great characters and messages). It’s not all just a copy/paste either, Clone Wars is dealing with different themes than Andor, they both contain a lot f interesting work. It’s all loosely based around transcendentalism, themes of progressivism, individual expression, collaboration/teamwork, anti-imperialism and antifascism which, I think there’s much worse ideologies out there. The hero’s journey is also just a form of thesis-antithesis-synthesis, aka characters learning from their experiences, that has existed long before and after Star Wars and will always exist. It’s a good articulation of patterns, as problematic as Joseph Campbell the person could be. That’s not dirty to me, that’s just basic life for everyone growing and learning (as why the characters are relatable despite being space pirates and robots), the concepts that it’s working with still apply For the John Williams soundtracks alone I wouldn’t instantly delete them and that’s also throwing away all the iconic work from the other artists. Like what are we doing Sorry to be annoying or jumping the gun on any assumptions but that’s all my perspective on it. I think there’s a lot more to be gained from positive faith interpretations.

Smo

Ut oh is Dermot about to tackle the hero’s journey? Looking forward to warchin

johnjoeparrot

When I got into making films I studied the “Hero’s Journey”. I didn’t enjoy that process and found it quite boring. After watching the film “A Chump at Oxford (1940) - Laurel & Hardy” it blew my socks off cause they filmed straight ahead it seemed like. I have way more fun making films with this approach. Starting with a simple idea, begin making the film and add gags or twists as I go along.

Animate with Dermot

Best I can say is that it's A formula, not THE formula. A whole lot of cherry picking went on with the bauld Joe!

Animate with Dermot

I watched all the Moyers PBS stuff back in the day, and was one of the many who thought that this guy really knew his stuff. But any close inspection and the whole edifice falls down! I quote Patrick Kavanagh's Great Hunger (one of the great Irish epic poems of the 20th century). literally NOTHING happens. it's a man who is trapped in his small farm until he dies. It's just amazing - hard to stop reading it once you start. Friedkin's 'Sorcerer' is another - there are no heros or villains it's just people thrown into a meat grinder, some by chance, or greed, or whatever. And it's great! I genuinely don't know why this thing still has traction with anybody.

Smo

I can't say I disagree on where things went. Ironically Lucas used to fund really inventive projects like Twice Upon a Time which imo is a hidden gem [I just got the university I teach at to digitize it for me] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pqCRgiHHvB4

Smo

I am refraining from live commenting [sort of] but professor kermit hahaha, this is gold.

johnjoeparrot

Was film or animation festivals popular in your area at this time? It seems like the best creative explorations come from the festivals I also been watching some of your other film recommendations. I’m looking forward to watching these you mentioned

Smo

I animation directed a star wars youtube cartoon [droid diaries] so I'll keep this to patreon BUT when you get into the bigotry of it a switch flipped in my brain. I used to like that bill moyers interview series they did at skywalker way back a bit, but that was pretty benign. The idea of a formula for story a sort of "must do" path, and the slippery slope to "a certain political movement" is what I've been saying about AI for a very long time. It is wild to see this connection. I always looked at the heroes journey as A way to tell a story not THE way. I really like some folklore researchers on youtube, and there are so many insane fairy tales that do not fit into this at all. Guess we gotta break the mold!

Animate with Dermot

100%, I have a copy sitting on my desktop to watch! So many of the talented people of the 70s went to hell in a handbasket in the 80s and beyond. Directors and actors, you see them turn into self-parodies in the 80s. Even people like Bogdanovich and Friedkin, Spieberg was so lean and Hitchcockian in the 70s, but turned into a Disney tribute act. Actors like Pacino and DeNiro, and look at what they churned out in the 80s, some awful stuff. It's almost as if there's a person who gets one good decade and should quit when it's done. but they keep going!

Animate with Dermot

Regarding bigotry and pathways: what's been shocking to me as time passes is seeing the multiple pathways into actual fascism. I've seen a lovely friend of mine (guy on FB we never met in person). He was a really nice hippie type, pics of him on the farm with his dog, charming stuff. He went full fash. Friends in Ireland were amazed when I told them about the hippie to F pipeline, it does happen more than people think. Liberal to F, Communist to F, you have to watch like a hawk! Really upsetting when it's a friend or someone whose work you respected. Maggie Mae Fish's video pointed out the irony of Campbell talking about the callto adventure - but when his call came in 1941 he said to avoid the fuss between "Mr. Churchill and Mr. Hitler". Very "strange" as Thomas Mann said, but I think I can hazard a guess. It's either cowardice (fair enough, I'm a coward too) or he was picking a side and didn't want to say which one.

Animate with Dermot

I don't remember attending any sad to say! I do intend to do a few "watch these" movies for here and YT after the bashing ones. There are some great movies that many younger people don't know exist.

johnjoeparrot

Can’t wait! I like drawing the poses of the characters while I watch the films