Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 759870325.mp4

Downloads

Content

I review a post by a well-known youtube artist, giving my take on the 'mannikin' approach to figure drawing. TLDR: I don't like it one little bit.

I'll be uploading the drawing tutorial segments from this video (where I talk through the process) tomorrow. They'll be for the paying patrons.

Files

Comments

Still Water

Would you be able to create a video addressing common anatomical errors made by beginners? I believe many artists still struggle with the practical application of muscle structure.

Animate with Dermot

Great idea! I'll see if I can find beginner images on reddit - there's usually a lot there, WIP stuff. Super busy right now but I'll add to the list.

Sidecar Animator

Absolute riot, enjoyed this very much. Something I thought about while watching: I wonder if this trend comes from anime? Lots of anime drawing instruction books I've seen have focused on precise and geometric drawing... I always notice it in the feet. The feet always look very boxy and have no life. Somehow hands remain nicer but even they can look a bit formulaic. Wondering if that's partly where all this boxes craze started?

Smo

I've been eating this up over on youtube. It's tough for me not to stop every section and write something so I jumped here haha! Clearly you're really nailing it! It's crazy to see how these influencers act like they invented dirt, and then this kid is to his credit, trying to credit those people...who didn't credit where they pulled things from. Stuff like that continuous contour is from drawing from the right side of the brain. You're catching loomis and all sorts of examples of the same thing. All the exercises worth noting are pulled from somewhere and are likely older than those sources even. I think I spotted some slightly more modern ones from RAPIDVIZ but those are meant to help you get ideas down fast. The whole influenceryness of it all drives me nuts. I see it in a lot of animation tutorials too I hate it. I really appreciate you doing this. I know it's a ton of work! I also feel vindicated in still using my grey cintiq so thank you for that too haha!

Animate with Dermot

It may well be. Someone also speculated that it's a CGI crossover, as it's common to model figures from cube primitives.

Animate with Dermot

Many thanks! "Invented dirt" - I hope you don't mind me stealing that. I'll keep it in the bag! Yeah, when I saw Loomis's perspective stuff it was amazing. It's a thing that works, but it's WAY too complex. They're elevating things they shouldn't and editing out things they should keep in (Nicolaides). And of course inventing pure streams of algo-friendly bull$. The only thing they're qualified to teach is Marketing. In that, at least, they are the masters.

johnjoeparrot

Thanks for your nice responses in the comments here and YouTube! Your responses are well written and constructive. I see some of the comments that come in and some of them are outlandish and wild. Those comments I feel that are outlandish I find they prefer to argue about art then draw or paint themselves. I would crumble with some of the comments i see that come on on YouTube and you approach them with grace. All I know is you brought animation into my skill set and drawing is fun following along with your vids. I appreciate your videos man

Animate with Dermot

Thanks for that! I have to remind myself that some of these people are probably on the young side (so I shouldn't go too hard on them, haha). But an occasional "sceilp" as we say in Ireland is sometimes needed. I can tell the ones who didn't watch all the way through - it's youtube of course, I know the deal. The tap-out and comment brigade, poor saps, they just end up looking stupid of course. I'll be posting the master study by itself next week - as a lot of people might not have stuck around that long - and I have to thank Brokendraw for that, as it was his recommendation that gave me the idea. I've been digging through a lot of anime/japanese stuff to look for construction / rough drawings and did find a few. No boxes of course, but it's always good to have that in the chamber in case of the ridiculous comments that "It's an Korean/Japanese thing to draw with boxes". It very definitely was NOT in the 19th century - and I've seen those up close in person at the Norton Simon in Pasadena in 06, and it's clear from the sketch/studies from Japanese studios that they either go in with a character line or construct with spheres.

Josh

Incredible video. Your enthusiasm and passion in the way you speak about art/ animation made me instantly want to sign up to your patreon. Here's hoping it wont take me long until i feel confident enough to move up to the higher membership tier so i can get you to review my work as at this moment im still VERY in the early stages of finding my feet in this hobby/ art form again.

Animate with Dermot

Thanks Josh! It's great to see the new videos resonate with people. I'm trying to turn my patreon/YT into a full-time job, as it's been a very part-time project until this year. I really kicked off in January with courses here - until then I'd been working with Lynda/Linkedin-Learning but TBH I think it's a lot more fun to deal directly with students!!! They were great to work for, but a bit of a walled garden. Way more teaching freedom by myself, it's more work but a lot more fun.