Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

You might have noticed that my 1A discharge curves are a lot wavier than the higher current discharges, with some parts steeper and some parts flatter (see red plot line above), and wondered what the heck was going on. What we’re seeing is how the anode’s graphite “delithiates”, how it loses its lithium ions as the cell discharges.

It’s not a balanced flow out of ions from all of the empty spaces between the graphite sheets at once. As the cell discharges it becomes more advantageous electrochemically to start pulling fewer ions from all layers and start pulling from some layers more than others.

As more ions are pulled out the anode’s structure changes from LiC6 to LiC12, more carbon for each lithium ion. This continues as the cell discharges, forcing the anode into structures with higher and higher carbon-to-lithium ratios.

This doesn’t happen in a nice linear progression, it’s a messy mix of different structures within the anode and that’s a lot of what we’re seeing in the discharge graph. Each structure has a different voltage and those structures can be mixed in different ratios as the cell discharges, forming steeper and flatter areas on the discharge curve.

The second image above shows this in a simplified way using three different “models” that try to explain this cell behavior. Starting on the right, in Stage I, we have a fully charged cell with all the spaces between the graphite sheets filled (in a very orderly way and more randomly).

In Stage II we can see the top model’s example of nice and orderly transition to only every other layer being filled with ions. The center model shows emptying of just every other “local domain” of ions on all the layers. Same end effect as the top model but different local ion arrangements.

The bottom model, created later then the other two, shows a much more chaotic arrangement of graphite layers and ions. A paper detailing the researchers efforts to create this model is here: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/cey2.224

These researchers feel this is a much more realistic model of what is actually going on inside a cell. And by knowing this the cell manufacturers can better tune their defect reduction efforts. Knowing exactly what the ions are doing at every point also helps them to design cells with higher charge and discharge rates.

As the current increases though (green and blue plot lines) we don’t see this waviness as much because other effects start taking over. Things like the bunching up of ions across the cell, causing voltage sag, create more of a voltage change than the anode restructuring does.

The cathode restructuring during charge/discharge also contributes to the waviness of the plot line, but typically not as much.

The silicon being added to more and more “standard” Li-Ion cells lately can either increase or decrease the discharge curve’s waviness, depending on how much silicon there is and what form was used. The graphite is typically delithiated (emptied) first with the silicon starting to contribute more and more ions as the voltage drops.

So while it doesn’t really affect anything we might want to do with a cell these wavy lines can tell us a lot more about what’s actually going on inside a cell than just its voltage.

Files

Comments

No comments found for this post.