HSU: Ch. 419 (Patreon)
Content
To be honest, Masashi had come into this with pretty high expectations for Hagoromo's ability to get a point across.
The logic was simple. A man who had saved the world from disaster, personally brought about the age of chakra, and founded Ninshū should have been good at persuading people. Maybe not perfect, but at least sharp. Out of a hundred points, Masashi would've given him ninety-nine without much hesitation.
The old stories had made Hagoromo sound like someone with presence. As for why he had solved his biggest problem by fighting instead of telling everyone the truth from the start, Masashi had always blamed that on the way legends were told. A story needed a climax, so of course the Sage of Six Paths had to have one too.
But after seeing the man in person, he only had one thing he wanted to say.
Could you at least try to live up to your own legend?
The legend had a reason to be dramatic. This was real life. Did the Sage of Six Paths really need to follow the same kind of script? What was he supposed to be, some ancient god who wouldn't show up unless someone paid the entrance fee first?
Then again, with how long Hagoromo had existed, calling him ancient wasn't unfair.
Still, people really did look better from a distance.
"Can you just get to the point? Tell Madara directly that the God Tree doesn't have the ability he thinks it has. This plan couldn't have worked from the start."
He was officially tired of listening to the Sage of Six Paths circle around the issue for ten minutes.
Something was wrong with the way Hagoromo looked at people. He seemed convinced that, aside from himself, nobody could resist real power, and that anyone who touched the God Tree would fall sooner or later. Masashi didn't know what Hagoromo had been watching over the last several thousand years, but it had obviously twisted his view of humanity. There was no way several thousand years had passed without a single ordinary, reasonable person showing up.
This was the kind of thing that could be explained in two sentences, yet Hagoromo kept making it sound complicated.
Did fewer deaths somehow make him uncomfortable?
"That doesn't sound like you." Even Madara seemed to find talking to Masashi easier than talking to Hagoromo. "You and I both know every technique is created to meet a need, by someone with a reason. If the God Tree can create a world, then a technique built on that principle should be possible. Didn't you build a world of your own that could pass for real?"
"Stop arguing just to argue." Masashi looked at him flatly. "A real world is one where people can have children. Can you have children with a woman in there?"
"Nobody alive can keep pace with me."
"Now you're just being dramatic. You and I both know you were in love once."
Madara had been young too, awkward feelings and all. He hadn't been completely without someone by his side back then either.
As for who that person was, Masashi had seen her in his previous life.
"Nonsense." Madara's expression turned serious. "I got rid of that weakness a long time ago."
"If you say so. That's not the point anyway. Developing a technique still has to move in the right direction. I'm not going to lecture you about that, but the God Tree is, at its core, something that devours life. Put it that way, and you should understand what I mean."
"It doesn't need to be copied. What I care about is its other function." Madara turned to Hagoromo. "I've heard that the old Ninshū could use chakra to connect people's minds directly. Since you claim to be the Sage of Six Paths, I assume you can answer that and prove it."
"That was the original purpose of chakra." Hagoromo straightened, seeing this as a chance to correct Madara's understanding. "When I first understood chakra's true nature, I taught it to everyone I knew. People were overjoyed because..."
"Because they could suddenly do things they had once believed only gods could do." Madara cut him off, his patience wearing thin. "I was born in an era where surviving to adulthood without chakra was rare. On this subject, I have more right to speak than you do. I only want to know how you used chakra to make people set aside their conflicts, even temporarily."
"It wasn't that complicated. I simply awakened the kindness that already existed in people's hearts. Once people could truly understand each other..."
"That's fine. You don't need to continue." Madara waved a hand, thoroughly unimpressed. "If that's really all it took, Konoha already has that."
"That's... true," Masashi said dryly.
There was nothing he could do to help here. Even if he wanted to support Hagoromo on this point, he couldn't make himself say the words. Every time Hagoromo opened his mouth, it sounded like empty preaching.
Masashi was more inclined to believe that people back then had stopped fighting because they had been scared straight by whatever the Ōtsutsuki family drama had looked like from the outside.
Besides, after Kaguya was sealed, Hagoromo had carried the full power of the Ten-Tails and become stronger than she had ever been. At that point, nobody alive could take even a casual hit from him.
When the power gap is wide enough, people learn to love peace very quickly.
As the current Hokage, Masashi could speak on that with some authority. In the shinobi world as it stood now, there wasn't a single village that could talk tough to Konoha's face.
Several decades earlier, when Hashirama and Madara had still been close, the shinobi world had also looked like it might drift into some golden age of universal harmony.
Seeing the expressions on both men, Hagoromo tactfully let the subject go.
"Neither of you agrees with my view on this, so I won't push it further. If you plant the God Tree, I'll have no choice but to stop you. I hope it doesn't come to that, and I hope you deal with that Ōtsutsuki. As long as he's alive, he's a threat to this world."
Madara only smiled.
The probing hadn't been wasted. He had already gotten a solid read on Hagoromo's real strength.
Hagoromo was powerful, certainly, but he didn't have a physical body. He was only a mass of chakra, and that limited what he could do to stop anyone. As a threat, he didn't come close to Masashi.
Masashi, meanwhile, decided it was time to move on to plan B, though looking back, he probably shouldn't have expected plan A to work in the first place.
"That's enough, both of you." He reached into the mindscape with his ocular power. "Let's bring Kaguya in and have her explain it herself. No one understands the God Tree better than she does."
Then he looked at Madara and added, "If your plan had even a chance of working, I wouldn't be trying this hard to stop you."
It didn't take long for a powerful spiritual presence to descend into the mindscape. Kaguya appeared before them and the gathered tailed beasts while the Rinnegan on her forehead was open.
---
As soon as Kaguya stepped into the mindscape, her eyes found Hagoromo.
If Hagoromo still felt real guilt toward anyone, it was probably her. He had once chosen a group of strangers over his own mother. His reasons hadn't been bad, but no matter how anyone explained it, sealing away the woman who gave birth to him was never going to sound good.
Kaguya didn't seem interested in making that the focus. Her expression remained calm, and if she had wanted to hurt her son, she would've done it back on the moon. There was no reason to start a family argument inside someone else's mindscape.
"Masashi, why did you call me back?"
"I need your help with something. This is Madara. The last Ōtsutsuki who came through here seems to have talked him into some bad ideas, so I need you to tell him what the God Tree does."
"Momoshiki never had anything pleasant to say. I already locked him in a cage."
"You didn't kill him?"
That surprised Masashi. She hadn't shown Isshiki the slightest mercy.
"As if I'd let him off that easily. What I went through, he can go through too." Kaguya brushed it off. "Besides, I can always feed him to the Ten-Tails later."
Her attention moved to Madara, but after one look, most of her interest faded.
He was already dead in a technical sense, and Edo Tensei made him far less interesting to her. Still, Masashi had called her here for this, so she gave Madara the bare minimum of attention.
"A dead man wants my tree? Give it up. You can't handle it."
"So that's how it is. You're Ōtsutsuki as well." Madara didn't look surprised. After confirming Hagoromo's identity, he had already figured out most of the picture, and Kaguya only confirmed the rest. "It seems the chakra we all use came from your people. But I'm not after what you want. I only care about the God Tree's ability to link everyone's minds together. The Infinite Tsukuyomi is useful to me."
That made Kaguya take a closer look at him.
She had spent most of her time on this planet sealed away, so she knew very little about the years that had passed on the surface. Even so, there had been people on the moon, and after observing them for so long, she had learned more about human nature than before. She wasn't the same woman she had been thousands of years ago.
After studying Madara, she quickly understood what kind of man he was. A hopeless idealist, stubborn to the bone, and far too similar to her difficult son.
With that, the last of her interest disappeared.
"The Infinite Tsukuyomi is a punishment technique I used on people who deserved it. The God Tree only converts whatever is connected to it into chakra. Everything seen inside the Infinite Tsukuyomi lasts only a single instant in the real world."
Kaguya was already bored with the conversation.
She was only speaking to a dead man because Masashi had asked her to, but that didn't mean she would lie for his comfort. Whether he believed her was his problem.
She turned back to Masashi and said, "There is something I need to tell you. That cage Hagoromo built is useful. I've decided to take it with me."
"Do whatever makes you happy." Masashi looked a little confused. "It was never mine in the first place. You didn't have to ask me."
"That's why I'm telling you. I had hoped you would end up on my side. You helped free me, and I know that. But I also know that if I tried to plant the God Tree on this planet, you would stand against me, just as Hagoromo once did."
People liked to say some things were better left unsaid, but if Kaguya wanted to say it plainly, he wasn't going to pretend otherwise.
"I've thought about it carefully. In the end, I can't let it go. If I give up on evolution, everything I've done until now loses its meaning."
"I thought that might be your answer," Masashi said with a nod.
It was a little disappointing that the honeymoon phase had ended so quickly, but there wasn't much he could do about it. At this rate, Nagato would probably have to be the sacrifice.
Masashi glanced at Madara.
Madara's brow was furrowed, and he still seemed to be turning Kaguya's words over in his head. He was stubborn to an almost fatal degree, but he had never been someone who ignored the facts in front of him.
If he had been that kind of person, he never would have said what he said to Hashirama at the end in the original timeline.
The Madara from that timeline had been obsessed with protecting people, only to lose everything in the end, including that obsession itself. Masashi hoped this Madara could avoid walking into the same trap, mostly because Masashi had recently found a promising path toward early retirement, and that path depended heavily on Madara's cooperation.
The Hokage held real weight. That position shaped the rules of Konoha, and in many ways, the entire shinobi world. In the past, Masashi might have gritted his teeth and kept the job out of obligation alone. But the friction between the Uchiha clan and Konoha had already been resolved by the time he became Hokage, which proved there was no real wall left between them. After his time in office, the village had also remained stable from within, which meant the larger risks in the system were gone as well.
So he wasn't giving up on retirement.
Being a retired Hokage honestly sounded far better than being an active one. Minato was enjoying himself right now. Still, dreams had to wait until reality finished causing problems, and Kaguya, the true source of the current mess, was the one who would decide what happened next.
Masashi turned his attention back to her and waited for her answer.
"There is no need to be so tense. What I promised you still stands. Masashi, when you helped me out of that seal, I really did think about taking revenge on this world. But after that, I thought about it properly. In the end, they are only people who don't even have the standing to hold a conversation with me. I feel nothing toward them, and hurting them wouldn't bring me any satisfaction. So I've decided to keep doing what an Ōtsutsuki is supposed to do."
"So what's your final decision? For what it's worth, I understand what you're after. Everyone chases something different. All any of us can do is try."
"You have a broad mind, far better than my disappointing children." Kaguya nodded, looking rather pleased with Masashi. "I respect what we have between us, so I've decided to leave. I'll take those three with me, along with that rocky planet. I'll continue drifting through the stars and search for the next seedbed. If the chance comes, I'll stop by and visit again."