Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

On this week's episode: Mike Johnson gives a whole new meaning to Christian apologetics ... Brett Weinstein tries to improve his image with some Russell branding ... And Marsh tells us all about a woo proponent whose ideas really don’t add up.

---

To make a per episode donation at Patreon.com, click here: http://www.patreon.com/ScathingAtheist

To buy our book, click here: https://www.amazon.com/Outbreak-Crisis-Religion-Ruined-Pandemic/dp/B08L2HSVS8/

If you see a news story you think we might be interested in, you can send it here: scathingnews@gmail.com

To check out our sister show, The Skepticrat, click here: https://audioboom.com/channel/the-skepticrat

To check out our sister show’s hot friend, God Awful Movies, click here: https://audioboom.com/channel/god-awful-movies

To check out our half-sister show, Citation Needed, click here: http://citationpod.com/

To check out our sister show’s sister show, D and D minus, click here: https://danddminus.libsyn.com/

---

Headlines:

How Mike Johnson is using faith to shield his racist colleague from accountability: https://www.friendlyatheist.com/p/how-mike-johnson-is-using-faith-to

Ryan Walters wants Oklahoma taxpayers to spend $6 million on public school bibles: https://www.friendlyatheist.com/p/ryan-walters-wants-oklahoma-taxpayers

Bret Weinstein’s Rescue The Republic concert

https://x.com/i/broadcasts/1mrxmMbvqokxy / https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_AgzlWwKHAY

Comments

Winter

I had the exact same conversation Eli is describing at the beginning with a younger friend - I was telling her this election is a trolley problem - after I made sure she knew what a trolley problem was she told me Harris and Trump are equal because they are both corrupt AND she’s a feminist … I just can’t with these people anymore …

G_the_D

And I put my phone on the charger at 88%. And that means absolutely nothing...

G_the_D

I kinda feel that the eliatribe needs to be topical for the time that it is recorded. It is within the timeframe and it is topical. I also feel that Eli is trying to give the audience talking points when trying to engage with others. There are many reasons to endorse one candidate over the other, and that should be reinforced. Roan simply expressed her opinion. I think most of the audience would land much harder onthe Harris side. Eli just pointed out that the opinion expressed by Roan is weak according to where most of us stand.

Scot Boeringer

Both sides-ism – – I used to see it with trolls over on fark.com no less than 20 years ago. In fact, it was one of their most effective arguments because of the insidious nature of it. You’re not saying that one candidate is good, and the other is bad – – You’re just saying that neither side is saintly and beatific. And that lacking both of those traits, one therefore gains the ability to, without damage to one’s conscience, vote either way or not at all. Or for Jill Stein. It’s extraordinarily hard to get some people to deal with their cognitive dissonance by working through it logically, and that one needs to vote for the lesser of two evils, even with a given that both sides are evil. It’s the only way you can make steps towards good. Or alternatively, people need to be taught how to vote in their own best interests rather than the interests of the extraordinarily rich, powerful, or in possession of social platforms, which give them to influence others. Even coming out and just simply saying one is voting one way or the other because it’s better for them, is better than coming out and announcing that it’s really not that important, because both sides, blah blah blah.

Scot Boeringer

Please excuse the voice to text translation of my above, overly long ramble. My iPhone seems to think that sometimes, especially late at night, I sound like Ozzy Osbourne on Xanax.

james devine

Are Noah and Lucinda OK in the wake of the hurricane? and much worse, trumps visit?

Ann Pollard

So here's my (69/F) question about Chapel Roan. Who the hell is Chapel Roan?? (Never mind, already don't care.)

Kitsunelaine

My Sheets Rock: Not to be confused with their competing brand, My Sheet's Rock, which makes the absolute worst linen in the world.

Oke518

The Republicans are just Faith from We Are Legion we are Bob....it is truly horrifying

Winter

This gymetria stuff sounds a lot like the special messages Manson got from the ‘White Album’ … Though ‘Back to the Future’ is much funnier source …

Winter

It all translated better than me typing without my glasses on :) - I really like her (like in a plutonic mentor way - she’s over half my age) and she really likes the philosophy and psychology (my PhD is in psychology and studying philosophy/religion is my hobby) - however she won’t read ancient philosophy books because ‘it was all written by old white men who owned slaves …’ - then this trolley problem thing came up and we have a co-worker who is JW and invited the entire office to her mom’s funeral (of course I’m going because I enjoy learning about other religions and my tattooed, pierced, and trans ass does not look like what JWs would like) … my friend told me that she wouldn’t go because it was a sexist religion - which it is - but I told her that feminism allows any woman to take on any role she chooses (of course there are enormous social pressures from religious culture - I’d bet everyone on this Patreon has experienced that - but my JW co-worker works online - she is aware of other ways of being a woman) - I was explaining to my friend that it is freedom of choice for women and she didn’t get to impose her will on women either … haven’t heard a word back after that …

Andrew Billings

This must be the first time Scunthorpe has been mentioned on an American podcast!

Fame and fortune guaranteed in the state of Tintucky

@0:1:00 I am so primed for that "both sides" misdirect that when Eli started I flew into a rage. If it is allowed to boil for more than two turns than I gain the ability to teleport and kill people with Bloody Mary magick.

CarrieBoo

The Tommy Numbers "Whose Woo" has actually made me dumber. My brain is so mad at knowing about this guy and his utter nonsense. Extra pissed about the Back to the Future reference cuz I love those movies and now I have this shit in the back of my head. So mad.

Els

Note: I'm from Europe, so can't vote in us elections. Regarding Chappell Roan, and others with similar arguments, I have the feeling Eli has not really listened or actually heard their points. She said she'll vote for Harris! What more do you want? Yes, the most important thing is that Trump doesn't win, which means Harris have to win, but that doesn't mean people should be happy with the democratic party and their choices? They'll still fund Israel and help them bomb Gaza (which is one of the main reasons young people are not exactly happy with the dems). Which is also why the whole privilege part felt a bit out of place for me. Maybe I'm misunderstanding the point Eli tried to make, but it really came across as that critique based out of lack of privilege if you score high on another axis of privilege, should take the backseat? I see how it might be easy to skip feeling uncomfortable with your privilege, if you're clearly in some minority too, but who says that's the case? And about having to feel happy about being able to put a woman of color in the white house: thatcher was a woman leader too which was quite renarkable, but she was still a cunt.

chilli

What follows is a degree of openness that I hope I don’t regret. There’s not really a point to it (which perhaps makes my overly-wordy post even LESS excusable). Just meandering through some thoughts due to the particularities of the situation. I kinda doubt it’s of any real value, but here it is anyway… It was really interesting listening to the “Eliatribe” this week. It caused me to do some reflecting. I don’t know if Chappell will ever hear the Eliatribe, but one can be fairly sure that I’ll at least be chatting with her family a bit about it. A close family member is a friend of my better-half, which has made me well acquainted enough to listen to things from that perspective as Chappell has risen in fame. So, that’s what has caused some reflection (and will make for interesting conversation next time I see them). First, I should say that there’s nothing that Eli said that I disagree with. I think it really IS a responsibility of those of us with privilege and a platform to use that to better things where and how we can. And Eli is right about the binary nature of US elections. That being said, this has also caused me to take some time to reflect on how to engage and encourage people with such opportunities to utilize them, especially in light of conversations I’ve had. I’ve heard about how it all feels kinda like just trying to stay afloat in all the tumult of a family member’s fame and so forth. It really personalized and humanized that experience for me to hear it first-hand. I’ve found hearing that perspective changes someone from “a star” or “an icon” or “a famous person with a platform” (or whatever words you want to use) into a more whole person who gets confused and overwhelmed for me in a way that simple empathy from an observational distance never has. I’m pretty good at having high expectations of people (to a fault sometimes), and especially good at telling myself “do better, you moron.” And yet, when I’m face to face, hearing the complexities and concerns from the inside, the motivation for empathy, and nuance, and understanding of a slightly overwhelmed kid hits me in a way I’m not entirely used to. I guess in a way it gave me a better appreciation for how someone can simultaneously have so much influence, privilege, resources, etc. and still be saying “We’re not used to all this” and still be thinking “I don’t know what the fuck I’m doing.” That’s not leeway that I’ve really given myself, nor so fully extended to anyone in a position like Chappell’s before now. Whether that indicates a lack of full empathy on my part or just indicates a more general difficulty in doing so until someone is sitting across from you being open about it, I don’t know. But it sure has caused me to think about it and how I could use the experience to better my own advocacy and communication. Like I said, I think Eli’s right to point out the things he did. Leaving aside my disdain for our societal tendency to look to pop stars for all sorts of insights (quite possibly outside of their capacity/wisdom), there IS a certain responsibility to recognize such issues. And I DO hope that Chappell’s take matures into something reflecting those responsibilities. But for the first time, in a truly different way than before, I’m thinking about that other perspective more thoroughly and saying “I get it though. I get it.”

Doogle

I agree with Eli's points but I feel that it is a bit disingenuous to make a diatribe against Roan's criticism of Harris without even mentioning that as far as I can tell her main criticism is that Harris is supporting a genocide. I'm certainly not an expert on the situation but I feel like as the podcast is becoming more and more active in its support of Harris the hosts should be able to address what has become many people's (at least those vocal on the internet's) main reason to not participate in voting. I value the PIAT crew's opinions and I'm sure they can give us a good take that would ultimately help their cause of bringing in voters.

Andrew Hickey

I really hope Lucinda and Noah are OK. When it comes to the diatribes, I much prefer the scathing atheist to the whining intersectionalist.

Balloons in BOLD

The Eliatribe was a real bad take imo. Yes there is a substantial responsibility to an endorsement and the things Israel is doing to Palestinians with our funds is absolutely sufficient to withhold an endorsement, even with an encouragement to vote for Harris. If you don't want to talk about Palestine, fine. That makes me uncomfortable but I'll still support the show. But to take shots at Roan while ignoring the issue feels like a lie by omission.

Els

Exactly!

Stein Hytland

Elis point is that the real choice is between MAGA or not MAGA. Swallow even this huge camel is worth it