Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this week’s episode, sane America clenches for four more years, Tucker Carlson grapples with his outer demons, and we’ll read some more of the upcoming Oklahoma science curriculum.

---

To make a per episode donation at Patreon.com, click here: http://www.patreon.com/ScathingAtheist

To buy our book, click here: https://www.amazon.com/Outbreak-Crisis-Religion-Ruined-Pandemic/dp/B08L2HSVS8/

If you see a news story you think we might be interested in, you can send it here: scathingnews@gmail.com

To check out our sister show, The Skepticrat, click here: https://audioboom.com/channel/the-skepticrat

To check out our sister show’s hot friend, God Awful Movies, click here: https://audioboom.com/channel/god-awful-movies

To check out our half-sister show, Citation Needed, click here: http://citationpod.com/

To check out our sister show’s sister show, D and D minus, click here: https://danddminus.libsyn.com/

---

Headlines:

Election results: https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/06/us/politics/trump-wins-presidency.html

Lieutenant Governor of Florida tells people not to “vote like an atheist”: https://www.friendlyatheist.com/p/at-anti-abortion-rally-florida-lt

Thanks to RFK Jr, Trump is considering a ban on vaccines, water fluoridation, and Cheez-Its: https://www.wonkette.com/p/trump-may-end-water-fluoridation

The video Heath was talking about: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0_OjKe4BuDE

Afghan women barred from speaking to one another: https://www.the-independent.com/asia/south-asia/afghanistan-taliban-bans-women-voices-education-b2641453.html

Tucker Carlson claims a 'demon' attack left him bleeding in bed: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/nov/01/tucker-carlson-demon-attack

Comments

CarrieBoo

I love you guys. I hope you know we're here for you as much as you are for us. Don't wanna do this again, but here we go.

We can feed everybody

Waiting for this since last night. Glad Noah didn't have a coronary before this diatribe that we all needed.

Laura Lusby

The diatribe broke whatever wall has been holding back my tears all day. Dammit where’s my tissues?

SweetAfton

Just fuck indeed. God dammit Fuuuucccckkkkkk

Callisto

All I have to say is "here fucking here". *Raises glass*

Annette Edelman

I've been standing in my Northeast Ohio backyard after my entire family voted a straight blue ticket, struggling with the feeling it was all for nothing. "The absence of hate is acceptance" speaks to me.

SonWinks

I have tears all the way from New Zealand! It’s so devastating! I can only imagine how much more devastating it must be for my American friends, especially women, POC, LGBTQIA+ and marginalised groups. I’m so sorry….

Miles G

I spent the entire day at work trying not to cry in front of everyone else. I'm so tired. I was emotionally prepared for him to win the EC, but I was absolutely blindsided by her losing the popular vote too. What the fuck is wrong with this country? This isn't a fluke like 2016, this is the ugly truth about who we are as a nation

Meghan Baldwin

I'm now convinced that I'm on the "wrong" side of everything and just want to leave the usa, clearly I don't belong here. The majority of people I know and treat are monsters. I have dedicated my life to treating cancer and all of the idiots I saw today gloated about Trump's victory. Fuck these mother fuckers... As horrible as it may sound I hope they lose their Medicare and social security, I'll never get it anyways so they should feel the burn of what they've done...

Jennifer Gorman

Listened to the diatribe and saving the rest for not right now. But fuck yes. As a queer woman I've been so goddamn tired of "love is love" and "love who you want" because it's not about that. It hasn't been about that for a while. I want my trans friends and family to LIVE. That's where we've been and that's what we're fighting for.

PoEfanatic

As an Australian may I ask what the actual fuck are you doing over there!?

Sumthinstupd

I love you guys. Fuck this country. Spread that righteous hate. I will hate these nazi fucks forever. Never waver.

Sham Hunter

A fuck. I’m still so angry and sad that I don’t think I can listen to the diatribe without crying. Im not ready to process and I think this is going to make it real

Pär Dahlström

You do deserve the breaks for Thanks giving and Christmas. Take care of your self. Love you guys.

Simon Canter

I was drained regarding this subject until that diatribe and now I'm burning again. Thanks and major love to you Noah. The fluoride thing made me laugh as a chemist. I was thinking of the heavily toxic metal and deadly gas we put on our chips but the exploding toilet was an amazing mental image.

every voice listening

Thank you three and Lucinda for what you do. I'm still too numb for tears and I'm scared for what's coming in the next four years.

TenaciousB

When they go low, we grab them by the hair and knee them in the face.

Talyn

When you get scared for Noah's heart during the diatribe you know it's bad...

J. Vizzle

Hate is the only thing I feel and I have decided to go ahead and follow Noah's advice.

Heath Enwright’s Husband

There are few things that can sum up this outcome, one of them being “Grindr sent out the Suicide Hotline number to all its users that next morning”

Austin Enverba

In the middle of the diatribe I’ve been expecting and dreading the part about standing on top of the hill of bones did make me laugh in a twisted way so thank you for that

J. Vizzle

I'll also marry you, Morgan!

Notsuperstitous Littlebitstitious

When I was a child, I got into a wonderful relationship with two ladies named Hope and Optimism. They made me feel good. They encouraged me to be my best self. They told me I could do anything. Be anything. They helped me help others and stand up for what is right. They taught me all about justice and compassion. They poured empathy and patience into me and it made me love others and care about my community. They told me that I could change the world. Even when I experienced childhood trauma, they helped me heal. They kept me healthy and on track. But as I grew older, a monster attacked me. His name is Betrayal. He comes after me sometimes, and abuses me. Tortures me. Breaks me. And in my brokenness and pain, I break up with Hope and Optimism. And I am all alone and empty and that feels worse than anything. That emptiness makes me feel like I don't want to live anymore. And then I met some twins named Anger and Hate. They helped me heal from the wounds Betrayal inflicted on me. They help me process my trauma and give me a sense of purpose and a reason to live again. But these two are very toxic. They emotionally abuse me all the time and they make me feel exhausted. They bring out the worst in me. They won't let me keep my compassion, patience, or empathy. They control all of my thoughts and emotions and tell me what's good for me, like I'm not allowed to decide for myself how to feel about things. But they are always there for me when Betrayal attacks me. And, they keep me focused and productive. But I was getting tired of their abuse, so I reached out to my true loves, Hope and Optimism and they saved me from the toxic twins. Once again, I felt like myself . Hope and Optimism came back into my life and saved me this summer when Kamala Harris took center stage in the political race. My old buddy Patriotism even entered the chat. It was so nice to spend those days with Hope, Optimism, and Patriotism. The toxic twins never called or texted me once. And then, Election Day happened. Betrayal came back to hurt me again. He battered me so hard I thought I was gonna die. He even attacked Hope and Optimism. Patriotism ran away screaming like a little bitch. Fuck that guy anyway. He was kinda weird. But anyway, that monster killed my loves! Hope and Optimism died and I am empty again. And of course, who jumped into my DMs but Anger and Hate. They want me back. But I looked over there and I saw her. Apathy. She is big, beautiful, sexy, and satisfying. She's over there shaking her titties at me, promising to fill all my holes and she even brought her cousin. Nihilism. Nihilism has a giant cock and he's ready to rail me in all the ways I want. They also have a first aid kit and pain meds ready to go and not only did they say they can heal me, but they can make sure that Betrayal never hurts me again. But Hate and Anger told me not to be seduced by those two, because I'm never going to get anything done. I'm not gonna be able to focus on or care about anything. I won't even feel alive anymore if I go with them. So here I am. Back in the toxic twins arms. And they are telling me that everything is gonna be alright.

fried goo

I can relate. Also NEO. (Akron) Also straight blue, for the sake of making sure it was correct. Also coming to terms with the hate that's apparently needed in our future. If it helps, We may be outnumbered but we aren't alone.

Stella

My throat hurts from screaming in the car on the way to and from work yesterday. I still can't believe it. Everyone, take care of yourselves.

Olivia Wolfe

Just thinking out loud here, but I'm Canadian, queer, and polyamorous. Let's get married, dual citizenship, and keep voting out fascists in 2 countries!

Zachary Z

I'm gonna need a link to the diatribe to share with the people I still love.

Natt Lavender

There's definitely a place for hatred: aimed squarely at the powerful people and policies that have disenfranchised and crushed the most vulnerable among us, and dismantled the systems that allow us to resist them. We just can't allow ourselves to be fooled into hating the wrong people. I think our hatred should always be aimed above us - the powerful and corrupt, the people and systems who depend on us hating each other enough that we think our fight is against each other instead of against them. We're not immune to propaganda either, and not all of it is as blantant as the MAGA stuff. Our real fight is against the fascists, but also against the neoliberal policies that have allowed the fascists to drag us so far to the right that the left-most only US party thought it was reasonable to run one of the most conservative candidates in our modern history instead of someone who actually wants to push back and change things. No matter who won this election , we would have moved to the right as a country, and that's unacceptable and dangerous - and a losing strategy, as we've just seen. Of course it would be so much better if we hadn't decided to hurl ourselves so far to the right that we flung ourselves off a cliff, but slowly allowing the Overton Window to shift further and further with increasingly conservative candidates is exactly why we're here right now. Like Noah said, there can be no reaching across the aisle to authoritarianism - they will only grab our hands and drag us behind it, and we can't afford to have leaders who just jog beside us while we're dragged waving rainbow flags in our faces and asking for donations. Our fight is against the status quo, and the powerful people who benefit from it and think the rest of us should settle for whatever crumbs of tolerance they're willing to throw our way. Fuck that, and fuck them. We're not letting them get away with that anymore. Anyway, I guess that's my own little diatribe today. Take care of yourselves, everyone, and make sure to reach out to the people you know who are in the most danger from all of this. We need each other now more than ever. You're not alone, and that's where the hope lives.

V0ldek

I am honestly thankful Noah's heart is still in the fight, figuratively and literally.

Madahoochi

Okay, I definitely should’ve kept listening before I started typing after the diatribe . I’ll leave this here though because I doubt it was going to be read anyway and I just wanted to scream into the void. I feel everything you said in your diatribe, I was lucky enough to be off work yesterday and only left the house to go to the grocery store and in that short trip into public it was hard not to hate everyone. However, I think your diatribe misses the one thing democrats got wrong the whole time, why they didn’t pull the center undecided voter, it’s because the thing we call hate the conservatives call love. They believe preventing a person from being trans or gay is a form of love, and preventing abortion is a form of love. The fact that we call it hate and villainize the people who believe that is why they voted red. There’s still enough Christians to create a red wave . Through social media, Rightwing Christian biased news sources, and preachers who now believe political engagement is part of church service they galvanized the Christian vote. It’s not just our grandparents anymore, through talking heads like Jordan Peterson and action star idolization of a character like Rittenhouse a younger generation has been tapped. The condemnation of figures like Joe Rogan has backfired. So when you try to tell them they’re crazy for racist speech like, “they’re eating the dogs and cats” and they say “it doesn’t matter if it’s true” , that was absolutely true, but we kept treating it like it was just coming from the mouths of Trump and Vance and not a reflection. They even told us, “we’re just saying what our voters and constituents are saying”. This whole time we’ve told ourselves Trump is crazy and says horrible shit, and he, from the beginning, has just been reflecting and giving voice to the social and economic grievances of the people that ended up supporting him. The Christian’s are convinced they just saved this country from evil. They don’t think what they did is hate. As long as conservatives have a stranglehold on the interpretation of the Bible and the Bible has a stranglehold on a majority of the population what we consider love has a political problem. Also, the painful part is democracy didn’t fail. Trump clearly won. What lost was news, social media, information, and communication, and the Democratic Party. Joe Biden screwed up by running for a second term and screwing Dems on the primary, and mostly for screwing Harris out of time to build a stronger campaign. But it wouldn’t have mattered, Kamala had the center left voter in hand, she had to sway the far left voter who’s only looking at Palestine and the center and center right voter who wants to roll back inflation and gas prices who’ve also been convinced that Dems want to take away parental control over the information and social cues their children consume. And even though I think this country will be unrecognizable from its present self in four years (maybe that’s hyperbole, but that’s how it feels right now) we can’t say democracy didn’t work, the people voted, and they’re going to get what they voted for. And the truly sad part, is that as much as we want to pull democrats further left, the lesson will be they need that more conservative center voter and democratic candidates are going to become 90s republicans. Democrats are like country music, it hasn’t been it’s own thing since Hank Williams, and not even at least a fusion of tradition with some modern fire like it was with outlaw country, and it’s been playing catch up about a decade behind every move in pop music and production since the late 70s trying to chase a hit with the lowest common denominator. It’s not odd though that the horrid monster that is modern country is almost entirely consumed by the conservative red voter because as art follows life the right political movement is chasing regression.

Sarah_F

It's hard not to feel despair. Voices like yours and communities like this help so much. I'm grieving, and I'm ready to fight.

Ray Kosby

I hope that the horrific actions to come not only turn off multitudes of voters to the fucking GOP, Trump, MAGA, and authoritarianism, but also religion.

-

Why would that happen? They want that shit.

Ray Kosby

The severity of personal discomfort they feel and hopefully no natural disaster to blame his failures on.

Bra Straps and Bitch Slaps

I think I speak for all of us when I say ENJOY THE BREAK HOLY SHIT HAVE YALL EARNED IT. I don’t even mind getting charged for those weeks so Binky and Peekaboo have groceries. Call it a holiday bonus.

jane

I’m not going to hate. Nor do I think further pandering to a far left that has its own fascist and hateful rhetoric will help the Ds win any elections in the future. Moral clarity, understanding, compassion for others is still the key. And obviously the democrats did not succeed in listening to the primary concerns of a majority. Blaming the people for being “stupid”, “racist”, “sexist” and claiming the country is pure evil without any positive qualities to improve and build upon is a recipe for further isolating those who share those views from the majority of the population. I would like the pendulum to stop swinging so wide, which necessitates intelligent discussion and moderation. Not of our ideals, but through acknowledging that reality means incremental change towards those ideals, not demanding ideological purity.

Makin' do.

I'll be honest I've had a hard time listening to any of my news based podcast since halfway into Trump to presidency I couldn't handle it. I kept up with patreon but I just couldn't physically do it. I'm not doing that anymore They don't get to win They don't get to run me away.

Clockworkk

These past couple days are probably the most angry and bitter I’ve ever been. And while I’ve seen plenty of people online express their outrage over this, I still just felt really alone in all this (especially because I live in a red state). But hearing Noah’s diatribe just now made a big difference. It hits different when you can hear the anger, not just read it in a post. I’m not less angry, but I feel less alone. Thanks, Noah.

DataAngel

I'm so glad I found this community. I have a feeling y'all may be what saves my sanity

Nick Charles

"Both sidesing" MAGA fascism? Wow. This is exactly the problem.

Leon

I NEEDED this episode today! You sell yourself short on the diatribe. It brought me to tears.

Nick Charles

In 2016 I was listening to liberals calling for empathy and understanding, and how wrong it would be to do otherwise. Back then, what I said was that justice for LGBTQ folks started with the Stonewall Riots not the Stonewall Roundtable. But here we are ready to throw LGBTQ folks under the treads of the Project 2025 gestapo, and we still have pathetic bleating that we should find understanding rather than hate.

jane

Not MAGA, I’m comparing the far left to the center-left and moderates, enough of whom either sat out or broke red to harm the coalition.

Podkayne of Fourth Dimensional Mars

I guess I was the only person who was disappointed by the diatribe (aside from a couple of people on the subreddit). It sounded like the anger from 2016, which was at least in part born of legitimate surprise, and I just don't see how anyone can be surprised this time. Yes, the people who voted for Trump were doing a hate, but there were easily enough eligible voters to cancel all of them out, but many people (and by many I mean millions) are tired of the Democrats' strategy of paying lip service to progressive politics and then trying to out-Republican the Republicans during the general election and when in power (the exceptions to this pattern are rare and notable, like Ilhan Omar, Cori Bush, and Rashida Tlaib). Sure, they're the lesser evil, and pure practicality should have people voting for the Democrats for that reason if no other, but "punching the hippy," taking their base for granted, and treating previously-reliable demographics like monoliths has gotten really old over the decades and decades they've been pulling this shit. (I'm saying "they" because I'm registered NPA even though I usually vote Dem.) And the past year-plus of the genocide in Gaza has made the "lesser evil" argument much, much harder to make. I recommend the podcast "Bad Hasbara" for better commentary on that issue than I could ever give.

Perniciousducks

I’m 100% embracing the hate. I see somehow a majority of Latino’s voted for Trump and in my neighborhood here in Southern California I’ve seen so many of them flying dozens of Trump flags. Well, if you want to be in the “Leopards ate my face” party so much, I have the number for INS. Enjoy your new team guys.

Nick Charles

When they go low we pancake them into the fucking ground.

Nick Charles

I want New England (& NY) to have a New Brexit. When in the course of human events, y'all reveal yourselves to be fascist motherfuckers...

V0ldek

I'd like to point out that Electoral Collage does play a role in this result as well. While Trump did win the popular vote, there's no way to say if in a normal system people wouldn't have voted differently, especially non-voters from firmly blue states. Under EC the votes from non-battleground states don't matter at all, which has to have *some* effect on the voting pattern of people in those states. What I'm saying is that EC is so toxic as a concept that it fucks up the entire election and people's mindset towards it, if you don't abolish it you'll never get any representative results.

Nick Charles

People deserve to have the autonomy of their choices and the consequences for their behavior. Don't infantilize them just because you think they made a bad choice. Supporting fascism is bad and worthy of hatred. If you spare them the consequences, why should they do anything different next time?

We can feed everybody

I have shared the diatribe widely, with requests for encores. Seriously, it knocked me back on course. Just one prob with the diatribe, and not tryna gloat, I am not used to hating. I understand systemic evils, but don't hate them, cause they aren't people. Probably a lot of who don't have much hate experience.

Emma Crawford

Pretty sure most women have been incandescent with rage for years, so this latest assault on our lives and rights is just compounding that...

Natt Lavender

I agree with you. I'm hoping that my comment didn't suggest that I believe people who support fascism should be infantilized or stripped of their autonomy, or that they should be shielded from consequences. Ultimately, no one can really be shielded from the consequences of fascism, except maybe the wealthiest and most privileged (until the people they're oppressing are able and willing to depose them). My thoughts are that we can't afford to waste our time and energy being angry with the individuals who have been taken in by decades (or more) of systemic propaganda, disenfranchisement, miseducation, and fearmonngering, because it won't change anything. We have to oppose them and we have to fight back against them, of course. But if we don't want this cycle to continue, we have to change the system itself, and that will require uniting against the ruling class that built and upholds all of it. They convinced more than half the voting population of this country that the rest of us are their enemy, which allowed them to elect the most blatantly corrupt politicians in our lifetime. If we decide to take up the same belief - that it's the people and not the system that created them that got us into this mess - we'll be playing right into their hands, and putting ourselves at risk of being manipulated and corrupted in exactly the same way the MAGA people have been. I'm not suggesting that we shouldn't be angry, or even that we shouldn't cut people out of our lives who support fascism. I also don't believe that MAGA people are poor little victims who couldn't have made any other choice - they could have and they should have, and their choices have put all of us in incredible danger. I'm furious at all of them. I hate that this is where we are as a country and globally. I hate the people and systems that put us here, and I hate the fact that marginalized people have been trying to warn everyone else that this was coming for decades, and have been ignored or dismissed. I just also desperately want us to be strategic in how we organize and fight, and I want to think as critically as possible about who and what the real culprits are.

Doogle

So your takeaway from the racists winning is to hate Latinos as a group?

Perniciousducks

Im just helping people get what they voted for. I consider it volunteering.

chilli

I wanted to take a moment to welcome Noah to the dark side 😈. Welcome to where I was last time this douchebag won. Don’t worry. The rage and hatred for Americans burns high and keeps it warm and cozy here 🤗.

Cabernet Theist

Great to see Noah grow a pair and accept that all being nice and playing fair gets you is disappointment

Oke518

Over 50% of the voters in our country have taken off the mask and shown that no matter the evidence no matter the information the facts that they don't support human rights and wish to deny them to other people. They revealed themselves as monsters everyone from the Trump supporters to the Independent party voters and those that didn't vote at all they're not human anymore they're simply monsters with human skin. They were nice enough to make this clear and this is how at least I will be treating them they don't believe in human rights since they're not human they don't get rights as far as I'm concerned

AtheistEagleScout

Hey Noah, my turn for the heart attack. Re listening from hospital....sigh... Catholic hospital... My normal response to their 'do you have religious beliefs that could affect your medical care' is ' I believe religion has no place in medical care'

Michael S

Is this diatribe available in text form? I deleted Facebook from my phone but would love to find this one in text form if possible. Do I need to upgrade my sub to get notes?

Dave Pierson

Noah, very good diatribe and on point. We just need to make sure we focus the rage. One thing that the conservatives have done for as long as I can recall (and I'm a bit older than you) is the blind obedience that they use going forward. I am not suggesting that progressives follow their playbook exactly and become a cult, but progressives need to do a better job of unity of effort. Now for the conspiracy minded. Trump only cares about flattery and money. What if Vance was selected to be Trump's VP by the rich evangelicals to place Vance as POTUS? It can play out this way. Six months after Trump takes the oath, congress enacts the 25th admendment to put Vance as POTUS. At that point Vance can then run for POTUS for two addiitional terms.

Olivia Wolfe

I'm not saying running to a new country is the solution, even though it might feel like the safest option now. Honestly, things are looking pretty grim for our election next year, but there's strength in Numbers. I'm so heartbroken that Democrats didn't have them this time around.

Single Malt Sinner

I must admit, that very same thought about a Vance presidency being the conservatives’ endgame has been weighing on my mind. At this point, we don’t have the luxury of ruling out things that would have been deemed absurd paranoia a decade ago. If there ever was a rule book, it’s been burned to ash.

Single Malt Sinner

Christ on a fucking gluten-free vegan cracker! Where do I even begin?! Let’s start with the fact that fascism is definitionally a far RIGHT ideology. Please, do tell me of any leftist countries that are also fascist. I don’t know how long you’ve been a member of the PIAT community, but we generally pride ourselves on not using terminology when we don’t know what it means. The “Far Left” in the U.S. would be considered barely left-of-center in nearly every other advanced, developed country on the planet. The number of hardcore communists and socialists in this country is statistically insignificant. Most of us snooty, educated, pinko, commie liberals (FYI, I’m being sarcastic), understand that no ideologically pure system of governance or economic philosophy has ever survived for long. Pure communism is a morally noble but naïve pipe dream. Pure socialism denies the very human desire to have control over one’s own economic status. Pure capitalism inevitably leads to some form of feudalism where there is no middle class, only the very rich and the very poor (you only need to look back at America’s Guilded Age to confirm this). The best solution is a system that employs the best aspects of two or three of these philosophies You talk of moral clarity, understanding, and compassion for others, and I can’t help but wonder who the hell you think you’re talking to. I have many aunts, uncles, cousins, and highschool “friends” back in my home state that are all diehard Trump supporters. I made a trip back to my hometown to visit them just before Trump was first elected. One of my oldest “friends” - a man with a masters in non-profit management, and someone whom I considered to be relatively sensible and intelligent - proudly told me that he would do me the noble favor of putting a bullet in my head if I ever felt like I was a woman trapped in a man’s body. Does this sound like someone I should work to understand? You also recommend intelligent discussion. I don’t know where you live or who you typically talk to, but in my neck of the woods intelligent discussion is not a part of the typical Trump supporter’s repertoire. They don’t understand economics, global politics, biology, math, statistics, physics, etc., and THEY DON’T WANT TO! They take pride in their willful ignorance. They consider it a badge of honor, and they bully and resent those of us who try to explain the workings of reality to them. Please tell me why I should be the one who works to understand such people. Anyways… I’ve already ranted on too much. Almost certainly to no avail.

jane

Hi, thanks for the reply. You may have a point about semantics, but after that I feel as though you have still missed my point. I am not comparing the far left to Trump supporters in the MAGA camp. My point is that the democrats lost not due to the Trump base, who would never have voted for Harris, but due to defections from the party of high-enough percentages of working class people of color, and a switch back from suburban voters who had voted blue in ‘20 and ‘22. Also, the extremes of the left and the right are not two distant points on a line, but bend toward each other in a horseshoe. Not confronting the dangers of the far left at all, denying or excusing them, is not honest or helpful. I believe the far right and Christian Nationalism is currently the (much) bigger threat in our country, and voted accordingly. But when analyzing the election, just blaming the voters and not the fact that the D Party lost numbers of constituents they counted on is a recipe for continued losses. What turned those people off? I think there are a number of reasons, and am willing to look at and discuss them. Also, I love PIAT but rarely interact in virtual spaces. One of the reasons is because of the tone directed at me in both of the responses to my original post. Blame, condescension, misunderstanding, attempt to alienate, rather than an attempt to clarify or respectfully question my statements. This tiny space felt like a way to dip my toe into expressing my thoughts where I could expect a higher level of intellectual curiosity rather than reactive vitriol. And while I still feel that is the case, I also see how easy it is for many to reflexively try to shut people expressing something outside of the in-group mentality down. I will try to breathe through the anxiety that I get from posting in virtual spaces because I believe dialogue is imperative and I don’t have many in person opportunities. I hope that those who are inspired to interact with me choose to do so in ways that enable me to feel more comfortable, not less. I will do my best to remain open and respectful, recognize if my words have been unclear, and still articulate my thoughts.

Zach Van Stanley

Well, after listening to the diatribe I became a patron. Now, I’m a patron for all your shows I listen to (this, Skepticrat, GAM, Citation needed, and D & D minus).

Zach Van Stanley

The idea of forgiveness of bad people is so terrible when the bad people won’t change. It’s one of the hardest burdens of Christianity to get rid of for me, and that diatribe really hit home how being compassionate to harmful people bites you in the ass. I know and love someone who was abused because their abuser was forgiven by the person’s parents and given access to them as a child. Fuck that. Fuck this tolerance of intolerance.

Jessica Oudbier

Yeah, you kind of called me (the farthest left person here, usually) a fascist. Not personally, of course, but with your words. And you also said the far left is why we lost the election? I voted. But a lot of my more politically aware comrades didn't for legitimate reasons. In my spare time from being a stay at home mom, volunteering at my kids schools, being a girl scout troop leader, I hit nazis with sticks. I put my physical body where my mouth is. Where were you? Did you attend any protests? Most liberals I know don't, but maybe you did. So yeah. When you show up to a virtual space and say mean things that are wrong, members of that group get to respond. That's a consequence. The democratic party did that and so did you... just now. The consconsequence is getting words back that you don't like for you and losing an entire election for the Democratic party and endangering the lives of everyone else in the country.

jane

Hi Jessica, I’m sorry my words impacted you in that way. I think the (visible/outspoken) far left is one of a healthy handful of reasons that we lost. This comment section was clearly not a time or place where many (any?) people are interested in looking at that aspect. I understand if people just want a space to yell and deride and not be introspective yet. I would correct my wording, but my feeling is that there’s not a lot of room or interest here right now for confronting some of the reasons why center-left/moderate voters moved so strongly rightward over the last few years. I hope there is space for that in groups like this soon. Yes, I have attended protests, though I currently do not have an active group that I feel total solidarity with. It is partly this isolation from previously inclusive spaces that makes me want to reach out to those who probably are in general agreement with me on 90+% of issues. If we aren’t able to have kind, constructive conversations with people who me mostly agree with, how can we hope to have them with those we don’t? Thanks for your reply and again I apologize.

Podkayne of Fourth Dimensional Mars

It'll be there. I've only been a fan since I learned of PIAT in 2021, and I went back and listened to ALL of the old episodes. When you listen to multiple weekly (and early ones were every other week) in a day, you kind of get a time-lapse view of the hosts growing as people. And that growth continues. I think the next few episodes (of Scathing and Skepticrat) will be more illuminating.

Ray Kosby

They care when they can describe how something hurt them directly.

Zach Van Stanley

There’s a big difference between people getting harmed from their own actions and you contributing to it.

Luke Simmons

Noah, I just listened to Jay from Skeptics' Guide lose his absolute shit, and it made me remember this episode. I'll tell you what I told him.. thank you so much for blowing your top. It feels so much better knowing that my rage is shared by rational, measured adults. I feel like my reaction to this reality is acceptable.. and I feel understood. If this isn't the time for yelling then yelling shouldn't exist. Thanks again man, we will get through this shitstorm together.

Fame and fortune guaranteed in the state of Tintucky

@0:00:05 I'll be fine. They are not coming for my group yet. You are screwed, if they have not yet come for you then they already have. Being an ally is less about aggressive altruism and more about defensive narcicism.

Winter

Months later - I can’t tell you how many people I have played Noah’s rant on this one for to describe the election …