Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Been a while since we've done one of these so AMA (that means Ask me anything...though technically it should be ask US anything....you get the point) And if you're looking for a theme why not "best, worst, _______est of 2021."

Comments

Adam Martin

Best and worst movie you had to watch for GAM?

Ilan Woll

Can you tell us the story of the Liquid Death Water parody reaction. It sounds like they blew a gasket

MrHolbyta

Best and worst comment/email in response to your work

John

Best and worst VR experience/story? No porn, Heath.

Martin House

Funny story when Eli did something stupid

Stormy Decisis

What was the most reasonable thing that Andrew still vetoed (i.e., the thing you were most surprised to find out was legally questionable)? What was the most surprising thing that Andrew okayed (i.e., the thing you thought was definitely not going to be okay, but was)?

Stormy Decisis

In a prior AMA, Eli said he had a lot of plans and schemes, money-making and otherwise. Let's hear about some of Eli's proposed schemes that got shot down.

Taylor

Favourite cruciferous vegetable?

Matty B

Was gonna ask the same

Dale Cope

Best and worst jello flavors.

Dale Cope

Best and worst guests/guest hosts.

Bobby Tropicana

Best/worst secular film you each saw in '21?

Ashley Kennett

Best worst interaction with an anti-vax/Covid denier.

Julie Wine&Reason

Best/worst headline or headline segment of 2021.

Daniel Mancini

This doesn’t follow the loose theme but it is something I have wanted to ask Eli for a while: in the Star Trek universe, food products on starships are made by replicators that use random particles to make stuff. My question is would a pulled pork sandwich with cheddar cheese by considered vegan if it was made by one of these replicators using no molecules that came from animals?

GeekOfDoom

Best and worst religious aargument/debate? I would also like to hear about when Heath made that girl cry.

Matty B

If you had to re-roll a D&D minus character, what's your character concept. Eli, what would you play in your world if you weren't God?

Kroll the Swolbold

If Tom and Cecil joined D&D Minus, what do you think they would play? Same for Tomas and Andrew.

Raymond Babb

The stupidest comment you heard in support of religion in 2021.

Matty B

Best argument that almost changed your mind. Not necessarily religious, just an argument that almost swayed you away from a strong position.

every voice listening

Would you rather: 1. Be able to teleport forward one inch 2. or be able to make four quarters by putting a dollar in your mouth?

Matty B

Rank worst to best; candles, incense, plugins.

Mark H

How did your Cuts Clothing sponsorship survive the “date rapist’s suicide note” comment? Also, how is your relationship with Manscaped, given your manscaped? I can’t imagine all those manscaped man bits are kosher.

Jason the Beav

I’ve always wanted to know the story of the host that never was. You’ve mentioned rejecting a possible host back in the beginning. Can you tell that story?

Ray Kosby

Best, worst conspiracy theory of 2021

Jason the Beav

Oh and on the subject of gossip how about a worse time with a Gam guest? You eluded to one once but I’d love to hear the story.

Ed “Short Arms” Marcus

Eli how did you come up with the Jon Benet Ramsey running joke & to all 3 of you how approachable are you guys in the wild (atheist humanist gatherings etc )? Btw please come to Florida !

Luce Cruz

Best and worst food and/or drink (maybe even drunk as fuck if it's a good story) of the last shitty year gone by. For me it was finding out that honey is excellent on pancakes and cheaper than real maple syrup, and Hop Valley Brewing has made a fair amount of profit off me last year.

Matt Griggs

Noah, what do you print with your 3D printer and what model/models do you have?

Kevin

What are your predictions for how Trump's legal saga ends? Alternatively, what's your dream scenario?

-

Best / worst thing you had to edit

Keith Bohannon

I told my mom that trans people can’t be doing this on a whim, as it’s hardly the path of least resistance. A day later she responded that she and jesus don’t hate them, it’s just icky. My question is how to get her to realize that’s also true of basically all of the right wing crap she believes in, and start voting democratic because her favorite dead guy would have

Kevin Stulen

What do I have to do/give, apart from creating more time, to get you all to do a Scathing Gamer show? Just once in awhile? Maybe?

Hail Stan

What's the story behind GAM getting the "Animal House close" wrong unless Noah has the week off?

Neale

So in the thoughts and prayers realm, why aren’t we asked to pray that some stuff didn’t happen?

Dan Dusterhoft

Do you think that America will be ok? How do you guys keep the faith, so to speak? Love you all, thanks for helping keep me sane.

Alex Hencken

Heath - Best/worst part of life in Ann Arbor?

Ferret Maestro

Side question... Is cheese on a pulled pork sandwich a thing in some parts of the world? Cheese and BBQ... I have not seen that.

Ryan Enbom

What has everyone's go-to takeout dish been in these pandemic times?

Ian from wine country

Eli clearly still has a bunch of side hustles. Do Noah and Heath have side jobs other than the casts?

Ferret Maestro

Best and worst government policies (state/federal/local) of 2021. Or if you want a lighter topic: best and worst search terms you used on youtube like services. I'm curious if Noah has searched 'cute cat videos' 365 times.

Claudia

Who (if anyone in your household) cooks? Or do you survive on takeout? And....everyone's favorite chocolate dessert?

September McGee

Best debates, science news, science discovery, videos, docs, movies or books that promote or enhance the atheist view point.

LisaLisa

I'm interested in reading books on history, but I'm not sure how to choose a reputable author. What are some good authors to start with?

Danielle Kemmer

I would love to know best worst statements you guys would like to keep or take back. For this year but maybe also for the entirety of your podcasts

Danielle Kemmer

Best worst how you dealt with the presidential election stories. For example bush vs gore

Brandon Talbot @ sponsormycasket.com

Best worst anti-vaxxer excuses for not getting vaccinated. Best worst reasons why we still have a fucking pandemic! Best worst things that have changed since Trump left office

Danielle Kemmer

I know Heath shouts “You should’ve voted for Hillary Clinton!” And I totally get it because the 2016 election guaranteed the Supreme Court disaster we are dealing with and I knew it then even before Kennedy retired. Not counting ALL the other shit. But what is your best worst reactions to republican shenanigans

MutatedWisdom

Tell me your Best Worst "holy fuck we're all boned" moment of 2021.

Subatomicfish

Best, worst, most disappointing/meh video games of 2021?

Peter Graham

You always end the podcast saying “legal services are provided by…”… my question: has Andrew ever had to actually go into court to defend you guys, and if so, any stories about that???… I, for one, would pay good money to see Andrew defend you guys in a court…

Grace Hughes

Does Eli still do professional magician consultations for tv/movies/etc.? If so, what was the most ridiculous consultation he did? Beside the reporter that had to ask him the hypnosis kavanaugh accusation?

John of the bankruptcy pirates

Do you ever get tired and just wish you could fool yourself into believing the nonsense of Christianity? Asking for a friend.

Megan

What’s the funniest/most inappropriate/oddest thing Eli has asked or talked about in the group chat?

Steven

I don’t know if this was addressed before I started listening a few years ago, but what are the rules to the game you play during commercials that’s has something to do with the way you say “what’s…….. XXXX?”

Taru Tikkanen

What’s the best/worse response you got from a sponsor in 2021? What’s the best aspect you discovered about yourselves in 2021? What’s the best that D&D Minus offered to you in 2021?

Dan Duivel

Does Eli ever regret not using a pseudonym? For Noah and Heath: If part of your message is being an out and proud atheist and not being afraid of the label, do you feel you're undermining that message by hiding behind a pseudonym? While I understand you're on a public platform, deserve some anonymity, and may be openly atheist in your day-to-day lives, it does seem like a bit of catfishing. Not demanding you "out" yourselves or anything, just curious of your reasoning. Thanks.

Dan Duivel

What can I do to make Heath turn gay and move to Canada? I could listen to his laugh all day.

Pyre Temb

I had the same question, but for Australia.

Pyre Temb

You're in a position where hundreds of people would love to guest on your show, but the people that do are technically doing the work you get money for. This got me wondering, do you pay your guest hosts? Is this also why you have the same five or so guests on instead of all different people?

Fiona Thexton

I first started listening to the Scathing Atheist when you were suffering through the Bible. The Quran and book of Mormon were probably even worse. Have you considered the books of Scientology? They are, at least, written by an author of other fictional books and should be good for a laugh or two.

mimo

Anna, I have a big gay crush on Eli. I was wondering if, after the pandemic, I could take Eli out on a date? You and the baby can come, too.

Scifi Wars

What are your starter Pokemon?

John

I know they've answered this in past AMAs and probably won't on this one since they try not to do repeats. So, the short answer is that Noah and Heath both had jobs when they started the podcast and being an out atheist with a show like the one they have would have put their careers in danger. Noah kept using the pseudonym because by the time he could have used his real name without meaningful consequences he was already well established as "Noah Lugeons" and it didn't make sense to stop using the name. He's also come out with his real name in the diatribe before though I don't remember which episode it was. Heath, I believe, is just a private person and doesn't care for his real name being out there so much. But I believe his mom real named him during a livestream last year.

Kristian Jensen

Are the "Bible Piece Theater" episodes available for purchase or download as a series? I am a marine captain and, should I be asked to perform a religious ceremony from anyone who may have been watching a bit too much Titanic, I would love to be able to make use of your interpretations.

Bra Straps and Bitch Slaps

My cousin gave me a bunch of used children’s books for my 14 month old. Some are great, but there’s a bunch of “toddler bibles” and Christian themed kids books. Any suggestions on what to do with them? Eli, how are you handling the subject of religion with your kid if/when it comes up?

Tom Colbert

What happened to Noah at security at Dublin airport? I never heard the story.

Stormy Decisis

The question is whether an animal suffered in the creation of the sandwich. If you needed a new, fresh pulled pork sandwich as the template for the replicator pork, then every time you eat replicator pork, real pork had to be used. On the other hand, if you could use one template forever, and the new molecules came from a sustainable source, then no problem. Put another way, if I sold salads, but for every salad you bought, I kicked a dog, those would not be animal-friendly salads, whether or not there was animal products in what you ate.

Stormy Decisis

Like, just once? Or as many times as desired?

Stormy Decisis

I'd love to know more about how these companies (dis)approve of your ads.

Stormy Decisis

Noah gave his real name following the Charlie Hebdo massacre.

Stormy Decisis

And here all I have to offer Heath is emotional distance, physical distance, and the cuisine of Rochester, NY. *sighs in inadequate jealousy*

Dan Duivel

Thank you John for your reply, not sure if you will see this. I've been listening to the podcast for a while, but am a new patron, so thank you for taking the time to write that out. And I'm glad my question was understood; I'm not looking to dox them or find out who they are - their identities are none of my business - I was just curious as to the rationale behind it initially and if and why they felt it was worthy to continue. So thank you again for taking the time, greatly appreciated. (It doesn't look like there's a way to @ someone here. If anyone knows how, please let John know about this message. Thanks)

DJA

Who had the worst anti-vaccer/masker experience and wat was it?

Joel Turner

Noah - what is the clicking noise on your feed every time you guys return from a break / skit? Is it part of the sound FX used? Gets me every time

Stormy Decisis

To Heath: Have you ever had Lucky Charms with Bailey's instead of milk? If not, why not try it right now? If so, why not have more right now?

At least fascists are dumb

If we become a quasi-Gilead state and Atheism is Outlawed, which religion would you declare on your yearly tax filings?

Cheryl L.

Will Eli ever blog again? How old is Noah's cat Loki? What does Heath actually do all day?

Ethan Heyer

To Eli: I was just wondering if you ever got the Carl the pug-a-peg-acorn illustrations me and my wife mailed to you?

@MarkisSkeptic

Y’all produce a ton of content. What’s the secret to your productivity? Also, I would love to see y’all live if you ever come to San Antonio!

Lucky McChancey

Did Heath actually get into ASMR when he found out about it? If so, who does he listen to?

Chriss

Best product or service you’ve purchased that’s exceeded your expectations and worst that didn’t meet your expectations in 2021?

Amanda

I know you often get asked about how you first met. I'd love to know some details. Those early moment. Maybe a conversation you had, or something that you saw the other person do, that made you go "yeah, this guy is really worth knowing."

lisa drury

My husband and I got kicked out of our home of 10 years so our landlord could turn the house into flats (our new home is soooo much better so fuck that guy) I know you have moved around alot over the years so whats your best and worse moving stories? Thanks for all the shows - 2021 was a shitshow and you really helped take my mind off it! 😀

Andrew Barner

Is it possible for me to be forgiven by you?

Gavin Dillener

Ego, Superego, Id. Who best represents each one and why?

Kirsa Moonwhisper

What’s the best way to become the “Future Mrs. Enright?”

AshesBashes

What do you all think of the church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster? And… weirdest dating stories?

Hypatia

When do you think live shows might be possible again?

Not Ketchup Banksy

GAM Episode 59 (Vaxxed) between 1:00:00 and 1:02:00, do I hear a bong hit? Awesome episode, BTW, ages well with COVID antivaxery.

Stephanie Groth

Which show is your favorite to record and why?

Birder Stuart

An alien race comes along and steals DNA from all 3 of you, which it then uses to creates 1 new amalgamated being. What can this being do well, and what shouldn’t it attempt?

Alastair Lichten

If you could go back in time and had to choose a new nom de plume, what would it be and why?

Ethan Heyer

Can we have more Morgan on other podcasts. Love him on d&d minus and would love to hear more from him.

Jlynn

If given the chance to remake any crappy movie what would it be and what director would you force to do it?

Alastair Lichten

How can we best counter the co-option of the term "skeptic" by various climate deniers, covid-conspiracists and anti-SJW types? I feel like "climate sceptic" used to be a propaganda term used b y right wing press, and mainstream press would use terms like "so-called climate sceptics", but now they don't even bother with that. A similar thing has happened with the term "critical" as in TERFs rebranding themselves "gender critical", despite a noticeable absence of critical thinking about gender.