Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

It’s been a hot minute since we’ve done an AMA, so it’s about time again! Right? 

Pose your question(s) below and Tim will curate them sometime on Friday (or so) of this week and get the best of the best to the gang for a Scathing Atheist Patreon Only AMA. We’ve answered a lot of questions over the years, so if you want to hear yours answered on air… be unique, creative, and ask things you think a wide audience might be interested in learning the answer to. You can ask Qs about any of the podcasts.

Once recorded this weekend, the AMA will be posted to Patreon exclusively for your ears… cause we love you the most!

Files

Comments

Teresa Gomez

Now that you have played D&D for a while is there another class (Fighter, Bard, Rogue, Ranger, Barbarian, Druid, etc) that you are interested in playing. Obviously your current characters are great, but character creation is one of the most fun parts of playing.

GrassyknollMan

For Noah: as a fellow stoner, do you have a glass pipe/bong collection? If so, can we see your favorite piece with a demonstration of how it works ;)

Jacob Davis

For Heath: How bout them Yankees?

GrassyknollMan

for Heath: what’s your favorite dispensary/restaurant in the Ann Arbor area? Do you have a favorite glass pipe/bong that you would like to show?

Yness Boily

What is the animal, insect or living multicellular organism that terrifies each host the most and why?

Rebecca Throop

When and where will your next live show be? And which show will it be? (Please say west coast!)😉

Max Grivno

In the course of my life, I have lived in states where being in atheist is not really much of an issue and in states (Mississippi) where being an atheist means being shunned (and having your family shunned, too). Do you find that there are pronounced regional differences among atheists in terms of their behavior, their activism, and their willingness to be open about their beliefs? To put it another way, are there things that Heath and Eli can do in their daily lives that Noah cannot?

Mark

Obviously, legal weed and the lack of Mitch McConnell makes Canada seem like a utopian paradise. That said, was there anything about Toronto that as Americans you found weird or surprising about Toronto that other potential visitors should know?

Cody

quite a while ago on an AMA i think it was noah said he considers PIAT part of a loose podcasting network, what other shows would you consider in that network? bonus question what shows are on your rival network?

GeekOfDoom

Setting aside the rule of not telling people about your dreams unless you're fucking them; dreaming about being at work is fairly ubiquitous. How does that manifest when you're a podcaster?

Cody

do you think you guys will do a show in australia again anytime soon?

Bunny Bismuth, Bun-Bun of Seething

Have you ever considered a PiaT bar? Heath can bartend, Cecil can cook, and everyone has some kind of talent that works onstage.

I don't care what JKR says. Fawkes was Dumbledore's horcrux.

When a host (okay, when Eli) is bleeped out during a show or ad, is the bleep covering words that would actually give Andrew a heart attack? Or are things planned enough so that an audio editing mistake wouldn't expose Andrew's nightmare fuel to the world? In short, do you honestly bleep real things, or is Eli just talking about a cute thing Max did for ten seconds, just to be on the safe side?

Andrew S

Have your views on eating baby changed since seeing Eli's PiatPodling, and if so, in what way?

Troublemaker Jake

You all seem to enjoy (to varying degrees) movies and pop culture. Quality of the overall film aside. What movie creates the most compelling world and mythology in your opinion. Regardless of whether or not you would want to live in that world.

Ian from wine country

What's your average weekly work schedule, i.e. how far ahead are you writing/editing/recording each episode of each show on a normal week?

Teresa Gomez

To get it read on the show my question can just be “Define invaginate and who was right Andrew or Dr. Lindsey Osterman?” if you don’t end up picking my question above.

Murmur Tapiridae

When y'all get the extra money, which crazy billionaire remake is first? Blood freak?

Ian from wine country

Aka, have you guys considered running a Catskills Resort? (Nobody puts Eli in the corner)

Ad Astra

What's something you're each proud of or enjoy having contributed to any of your shows (particular bit/skit, segment, story, headline, movie choice, etc). More specific than a show concept, and not necessarily a favorite; just wanting to hear what comes to mind as "this was my contribution and it makes me smile". Alternatively, same idea, but something your co-hosts contributed that you love.

Drew

For all: how does the group get a sense for comedy tastes changing in their audience? For instance in episodes from years ago there might be multiple pedophilia or necrophilia jokes. However in the last year or more I can't recall a single instance of dusting off Jonbenet or Phyllis and taking them for a test run. Also to put Andrew at ease. These are all jokes, harmless jokes for only fun and entertainment, with no basis in fact. Especially no act that any reasonable jury could find incriminating no matter how convincing a Phyl-benet ventriloquist act Eli might perform.

Josh O

How did your relationship with Andrew Torrez start?

Mark H

I think someone is actually doing Blood Freak. But why mess with perfection?!

DZ

What does PIAT look like in 5yrs? More / different podcasts? Other non-podcast projects? OR just keep kicking ass with the current activities?

Mark H

Have you considered a scripted audio fiction podcast? Something that could be done if that crazy billionaire money never comes through?

Ann Pollard

The Astronomical Society would like to know how much Noah would take just to stay away from all future astronomical special events. Ann Pollard

Cayenne

Do any of you ever call Noah and Heath by their non-pseudononymous names or are they just Noah and Heath to you now?

Adam Martin

When the gag is “Eli has to be bleeped out for legal reasons,” does Eli still actually say the terrible thing that gets bleeped or does he just say bleep goes here?

Paul Freelend

It doesn't happen a lot, but every so often there's a GAM episode like Boondock Saints or Ember Days where one host is left on the defensive. The squirming alone can make them a fun listen, but it also sounds like there might be an opportunity there. What movie do you love that you're sure your fellow co-hosts don't, and how would you convince them that it's actually good or at least enjoyable?

LiberKaos

There has been Scathing episodes where you express a careful optimistic attitude towards the decline of religiosity, like seeing pew research statistics and the like, and then comes a blowback like the expected supreme Court leak. Where are you now? Conflicted? Optimistic? pessimistic? Where do you speculate the US goes from there?

GrassyknollMan

for Eli: how do you plan on one-upping the slingshot bikini? Speedo w/ pasties/tassels? for Eli - would you ever consider doing something along the lines of Penn and Teller’s Fool Us?

Matt Griggs

I have been really wanted to know 2 things and I always forget to ask when these pop up. 1. What's your process for doing GAM episodes on new z/in theatre movies? Especially if it's a crowded theatre. 2. Noah, what 3d printer do you use? What made you get it? And what are you printing? Thanks! Matt Griggs

philly_ratking

Favorite relax music and hype music? Just thought I'd ask the perfect first date killing question

Ann Pollard

Could we start an "Ask April" advice column?

J. Vizzle

A question for all 3 of you. When are you coming back to, Seattle?

Jo

I believe they've answered this in the past, and if i remember correctly they tend to just use the pseudonyms all the time.

IngloriousBaxter

When is the Ann Arbor sex cult thing happening? Asking for a friend

Cayenne

Thank you, Near Uncertainty!! I’ve often wondered.

Dustin Hanson

Any new stories about advertisers who didn’t like the ad reads?

John Corcoran

What's it going to take to get your guys to do a live show in Grand Rapids now?

Everett Abbott

Are you rescheduling your show in AZ?

B. King

At least two of you have worked in the food industry at some point, so what are the things customers should never do and what are the consequences those customers receive?

Alastair Lichten

What's sports if any do you follow or play, and what do you think of ‘rationalist’ snobbery about 'sportsball'? I’m taking on a new job in humanist community organising. What do you think are the most effective ways we can make local atheist/humanist groups more inclusive, welcoming and diverse? How can we best call out and marginalise toxic aspects of the atheist community, while not overstating their size or influence? What is the thing you are objectively the worst at, that you love the most? If you had to teach a high school class for a whole year, what would it be and why?

Chris Kiser

Do you prefer the Copenhagen interpretation (Schrödinger's cat) or the Many Worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics?

PM_DM

In several of the GAM movies, something will happen and then, the movie will be dishonest later when the protagonist describes the scene to another character. In your expert opinions, what do you think is going through the writers/directors heads when this happens in the movies? Do they think the audience won't notice, do they think the audience won't care that the protagonist is clearly misrepresenting what happened, or is it some third thing?

Mark H

Oh really? Is it an atheist fiction podcast?

Mark H

Who’s Dawn Ford?

Mark H

Oh Jon! We all love you!

Birder Stuart

If you had crazy stoned billionaire money, what GAM movie universes would you combine - The Fast and The Vultures of Horror, Gramps of Thunder?

Mike

Have any of you ever watched Taskmaster? If there was an American version would you want to be on it? Which one would do the best? I feel like Heath is the obvious answer, but I imagine Eli would come up with some creative ways to do the tasks.

David Morgan

There was an American version of taskmaster.

Not Ketchup Banksy

Suppose (and this is completely hypothetical; I'm broke) someone gave PIAT 10 million dollars to be used for any new projects you want, as long as they work toward radically supporting the growth/triumph of your values in society (skepticism, atheism, liberalism, progressive causes). What are your ideas? As this is hypothetical, please allow Eli free reign to answer.

Johnny Dahmer

If you had to cancel/retire any of your 5 shows and replace it with another idea/premise for a show, which show would you axe, and what idea/premise would the new show be?

Jess Donovan

In one of the GAM eps (I think) Edna the pugapegacorn, Carl's sister, makes an appearance. Will she ever make it onto D&D minus? (may have asked this before, not sure)

Kurt Montandon

What non-PIAT podcasts do you guys recommend? Especially any that offer the same level of vitriol and dark humor. (This question is open to anyone else in the comments).

Kendallyn Frost

Growing up mostly in the 80s & 90s, can you describe how your views about LGBTQ folks have evolved throughout your lives? (Did you have bigoted views from your childhoods that you've discarded over time?)

Jess Donovan

Have to be GAM the movie right?

Scifi Wars

If you could cameo in a Jurassic World movie, what dinosaur would you want to kill you?

Esteban

What is everyone's top 3 secular movies? Whether you've already reviewed them for GAM or not

Mike

There was but it only lasted 1 season and has been cancelled apparently.

Dani Cav

How many death threats do y’all get? I’ve been concerned about that since I first started listening.

Michael

What are your favourite films?

Joannasephine

I’d add and Thomas Smith – how did y'all intersect, and how on earth did you manage to catch them both after they ran screaming in the other direction? Or was it more of a tonic immobility effect?

Joannasephine

What is one thing about each of your fellow cohosts that we don’t know, but you think we should? (Eli, this is not an excuse to dox Heath.) (Well …)

Joannasephine

And piggy-backing a little on an earlier question – can you talk a bit more about why you use your pseudonyms? Given the level of … um, "frankness", that Eli regularly attaches his own name to? Jokes aside, it's something I think maybe we don't really appreciate, living outside the rapidly spiralling theocratic hellscape that the US is becoming. I’d love to hear your reasons, and if they’ve changed as the podcast has grown.

Sarah Hoskovec

Any future plans to offer merch online instead of just at live shows?

Al Yako

Fuck Marry Kill, the "Heath isn't allowed to avoid answering this time just because he's the one reading them out" Edition: Round 1: a Long Omicron positive Steve Doocey, a (/still/ property of Jen Psaki) gimp-suit clad Peter Doocey, or a fully conscious Brian Kilmead. Round 2: Russia, North Korea, Idaho Round 3: The Supply Chain, Election Integrity, Abortion rights. Round 4: Twitter, Facebook, Truth Social Round 5*: Heath's step mom, Heath's step sister, Heath's step daughter If you require more specification, you're playing the game wrong. Interpretation is key. Lawyer it up *the word "Step" may be removed from this edition at the discretion of the players

Claudia

Why did Heath move to Ann Arbor? Is Putin genuinely a religious nut or just using religion like Republicans do here?

McMurple

Who is Tim & why does Tim get to curate?

Anastasia Marsden

It looks like Margaret Attwood has written a good chunk of the future for women in the USA. Which writers would you like to have written your futures, dystopian or otherwise?

Mattbox

What are your thoughts on the vaporwave phenomenon that has gripped the internet? How long will its tendrils keep hold of my brain. Why am i addicted to nostalgia dripfed and laced with good beats?

Julie Shepherd

When, if ever, will you tour the US? Come back to Ohio?

Yness Boily

I think you are the prank that Eli is playing on us!!!!

Tom Colbert

What happened at Dublin airport Noah?

Niamh Coghlan

I've been curious about this myself :)

Someday Sera

Noah talked about that in the episode 100 diatribe (regarding the charlie hebdo shooting) The short answer iirc was mostly just for the hell of it/for marketing purposes, coupled with wanting to maintain a certain level of anonymity in ultra conservative GA if need be. I think he said heath had similar reasons, but don't recall. Likewise Eli has said he uses his real name because...he just didn't get the memo, and used his real name so many times in early guest appearances that it was too late by the time he thought about it. (likewise there is one early episode with a pre bosnick anna making the same mistake)

Someday Sera

I missed the reefer madness gam for a family emergency, and thanks to covid they've never been back, here's hoping they tour again soon.

Poogan

Not an atheist podcast, but for dark humor I really enjoy Anthony Jeselnik's podcast: "The Jeselnik and Rosenthal Vanity Project".

Poogan

I've heard you guys mention Morgan occasionally on the shows (e.g. apologizing for future painful editing), and of course Tim handles the social media. Could you tell us a bit about them and any other behind-the-scenes worker(s) that make the shows possible each week? A lot has been made of Heath's few defining personality traits (liking scotch, incest porn, being tall). Heath, if you could add one trait to this list, to be enshrined in show canon for all eternity, what would it be? If Heath is the "comedy ballast", what parts of the ship are the rest of you, and why? Feel free to answer for Tom and Cecil as well-- I'm sure they wouldn't mind :)

Jay Reynolds

I have trouble telling when seemingly mean statements are supposed to be funny and when they are genuine. This is to the point when I have felt that a line has been crossed into cruelty and everyone yells at me for not getting the humor. How am I supposed to tell when you are being funny and when you are being genuine? I really want to keep liking the show, but I have trouble when you go back on things you say you aren't going to do like making fun of someone for how they look instead of just what they do. I'm genuinely not trying to be a problem. I had thought I had figured out all this, but over the last year I have more and more trouble with telling someone saying they are trying be funny from being a genuine ass for absolutely no reason at all. Maybe I shouldn't have asked this at all, but I am about at my limit of being mocked at not getting a joke when it's the other person not creatively communicating their meaning. I've always thought if the person you are making fun of isn't laughing, then you are being cruel. Maybe I'm wrong in that.

Subatomicfish

Fan theories about breath of the wild 2? Mechanics you’d like to see? Story beats? Ganondorf redemption? Stalynels?

Not Ketchup Banksy

How many differnt deadlines do you all have in any 2-week period? It seems very clear that despite your levity, PIAT succeeds because of a huge work ethic. Are there days when you all have tons of stuff due- submit ideas, scripts, edits, conferences? What's the work flow?

FRED R GROOTHUIS

Do you think historical figures should be graded on a curve based on the time and place of their birth and life. Otherwise it’s basically almost everyone in history was horrible in the past. It seems almost all people of European origin believed in white supremacy until my lifetime (even now way too many) but some of those people moved the ball forward on societal issues or stood against horrible tyranny. I for example think Ulysses Grant was our greatest general ever. Bad choice for president but he knew what had to be done to defeat the confederacy. Winston Churchill a 19th century aristocratic who believed in empire and was by my standards a white supremacist but I can’t imagine where our world would be today without him in 1940 after the fall of France if Britain made a separate peace with the nazis. I have no problem with statues or monuments to either of these two. The list could go on but those two came to my mind.

Mark H

Are we ever going to get that album of songs?!

Alex Hencken

Fuck, marry, kill: Madison Cawthorn, Matt Gaetz, MTG?

Mark H

But he’s wearing clothes, using power tools, and we don’t know the bronziness of his nuts. What’s the connection?

Tantallon (Andy T)

Any situations of real life harassment from the religious, especially in regards to Noah in Georgia, but the others too? And why does Eli not use an alias like Heath and Noah?

Jennifer Nollan

If you could ask your listeners one question, what would it be?

Anders Norup

how did cara come to be part of the gang?

Hot Dickson Rice

Since the Venn diagram of PIAT ethics and Satanic Temple ethics is a solid circle, can we expect any collabs of any kind in the future? Like Lucien Graeves guesting on GAM, or Stu De Haan interviewed on Scathing?

Jordan

Heath: If you could re-read a book for the first time again, what book (or books) would that be? Also, what’s your favorite insult from Dr. Cox on scrubs? Noah: You talked about covering the Left Behind series in a previous AMA for GAM, is that something you still want to do and have you made a plan for it yet? Eli: While I love the diatribes done by Noah, my favorite so far has been one that you did while he was on vacation. Do you plan to do more diatribes or will you only step in when Noah isn’t able to do them?

Spacecat

Have you ever had any death threats?

Hausdorff

How do you guys deal with the fact that it seems like nothing matters? They commit crimes in front of all of us, they steal children, they attempt a coup. No one (statistically) on their side cares. Do you have a strategy for not getting to demoralized? I find the situation very depressing.

Hypatia

How has podcasting changed you and your life throughout these years?

Luci

For Noah and Heath: Is it ever confusing switching back and forth between your real names and pseudonyms? Have you ever accidentally used your pseudonym in real life when you should have been using your real name?

Kristine VanRaalte

Which bible quotes do you think would shock Christians the most if they haven't read the bible?

Kevin

Any word on Outbreak going to audible?

John Martin

Expat Mississippian here, ditto at this question. Can’t envision an easy scenario in which I could be both an open atheist and a respected participant in too many communities there. That said, we could do a better job as a community at highlighting and supporting the lonely individuals and organizations who do carry the mantle in these places, and not just using The ‘Sip and like places as a punching bag. There are real admirable people in these places fighting small, admirable battles in otherwise mundane day to day interactions. For me this would be a topic of interest for a broader segment.

The Scathing Atheist

There's a bit of a Mandela effect that happens around this. It was actually in the diatribe for episode 107, though many people remember it the way you do.

Joannasephine

Any chance of putting together a super-cut of Heath completely losing it? Those episodes where his laugh gets into bats-hearing-only high pitch are my salvation. And any time Eli gets squeaky is also goddam adorable. (Noah, do you ever dissolve into uncontrollable giggles on the podcast? That too is something I want to hear, and why I so love the patron-only outtakes.)

Max Grivno

Thanks for the reply. I am fortunate in that my employment allows me to be more or less open about my atheism without repercussions, but my daughter has already faced bullying because she is frank and open about her beliefs. Moreover, it is hard living in a community where the assumption is that everyone is a fundamentalist Christian, and that people who do not share those beliefs are: 1) aberrant; 2) dangerous; and 3) need to justify their position to any and every asshole who fancies themselves a missionary.

Jason the Beav

Two questions I don't think have been asked before: 1. Noah, can you tell us how you really feel about Ready Play One? Can it be a bonus GAM? I ask because I just started it and kind of hate it already. Probably a minority opinion 2. Who gets the credit for the the shows political shift since Eli joined? Was that happening anyway or did he have a larger influence?

Callie Williams

What did the guys at Liquid Death have to say about your one and only add you did for them?

Ken Verleye

I’m sure this has been asked before, but I need to know: why is it called “The breakfast club close”? At the end of that movie there is no reference to what happened with the characters 🤔

Jim Phynn

As the push to legalize marijuana gains more steam around the country and the world, do you worry that corporations will come in and add chemicals to the pot they sell, not unlike what happened to tobacco? What can be done to prevent it?

Al Yako

Uhhh this is like... more of a statement than a question but... After almost 400 God Awful Movies, are you guys still even capable of enjoying media anymore, or has it just broken you? I feel like, me personally, at that point I wouldn't be able to watch regular movies without breaking them down and hating every second of visual media from then on. Like how cops and military folks can't watch those kind of movies anymore without little details ruining it. Have you guys done that to yourselves with just... movies in general?

Scifi Wars

For everyone there. Tomorrow you are magically turned into a Transformer robot body. Andrew calm down, breath buddy breath... Which faction are you in, and what do you transform into?

Scifi Wars

You are somehow almost out of GAM worthy movies, what movie do you save to be the final episode?