Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

PiaTPJParty2022:

As always, the gang will be doing a live Q&A as part of the video.

Submit your questions below and Tim will aggregate the best questions to be answered during the live stream.

Helpful hints:

1. Ask questions that will have a broad appeal.

2. Questions that have not been asked on previous Q&As.

3. We will ALSO need some Qs for Andrew, Thomas, Anna, Lucinda, and Marsh as well.

4. Be creative!

5. You can ask Qs to any individual, a group, or about a particular podcast. 

Note: All Patrons will get an email next week with an exact time and link for the live stream. For now, pencil in Saturday, July 9th in the late afternoon-ish ET.

The event will be recorded for later viewing. 

Files

Comments

Unofficial_Opinion

Do you have any pieces of the shows that you’ve done that live rent free in your head? That stand out to you as individually hilarious amongst the whole catalog of great things that you guys have said? I’ve always sort of wondered that. Like what things in this whole repertoire do you remember? What things tend to stick with you?

Mark H

Where did the cool A from the Scathing Atheist logo come from, and shouldn’t it replace the other symbols for atheism?

Kay Gaffney

What’s the best way to say ‘fuck you’ to religious doctrine being shoved down your throat at work that wont get you fired?

Ian (no, not that one)

"Fuck, marry, gently escort from the premises" the whole Supreme court. What are your choices?

MrHolbyta

Marsh: Who is the nut job you most want to get on Be Reasonable?

Religion *is* Politics

For folks who once identified as religious: - What is some trivia you learned or moments you remember that really knocked your socks off or made a big impression on your way to identifying as atheist? For folks who have never identified as religious: - What trivia/moments most radicalized you into atheist activism?

Someeffingguy

Eli, your comments about the beloved TV show Supernatural and your inane rant in regards to guinea pigs have sparked much conversation in the PIAT community. Will you rectify these transgressions and amend your statements to more accurately line up with objective reality, or will you double down and continue this counter culture, shock value tirade?

Michael

What films polarise any members of your group? Is there one heath likes/dislikes that Eli doesn’t? Etc

Psilocybin made me silly (and sober!)

Are we ever going to have a guest hosted episode of DnD minus, or any guests again like with Fon dord? Or will there be other one-shot tabletops? I'd love to hear y'all do something like misfits and magic from dimension 20 (kids on brooms mechanic) as a small side game, or any of the other incredible one-shot that are out there!

Stormy Decisis

What would you do if you had a 24 hour period in which you personally were immune to laws (and could not be charged afterward for any acts committed in that time period), but morality and physics remained?

Stormy Decisis

What is the BEST decision you have made / action you have taken while heavily intoxicated (on any mind-affecting substance - alcohol, cannabis, toads, etc.)?

Psilocybin made me silly (and sober!)

Also! Do the Dad's want to talk about the full inspiration for the podcast? My wife and I love it and being so rural with few friends it is wonderful to feel included in a dad conversation, however parasocial that may sound

MrHolbyta

Andrew: What's the worst law thingy in a Law'd Awful Movie? What about in one of the hearings/depositions you've done as a LAM?

The Worser Angels of our Nature

When PiaT is forced to relocate to Canada after Atheism is outlawed under America's new fascist theocratic regime, what will the new flagship show be called? (Assuming you don't just go with the obvious The Scathing Eh-theist)

Benjamin Kimberlin

Do you guys refer to each other by your by your real names when hanging out, or do you use your pseudonyms?

Scifi Wars

If you could be part of one of the nation's in Avatar the Last Airbender, which one would it be, and why (assuming you gain that elements powers)

Jo

I believe this was asked in a pervious q&a. And i believe they use the pseudonym even outside the podcastaverse. But correct me if I'm wrong.

Andy Tague

We need some info about Heath's supposed Canadian girlfriend. Is she real? I'm seriously invested in this situation 😂

Jo

Did you get waaay more patreons then expected? Was there real anxiety over potential name changes / other promised goals?

Jo

GaM vs LaM, You're suddenly forced into the last movie that was reviewed, which do you choose?

Kroll the Swolbold

Who in your immediate podcasting sphere would you most want to join you all in D&D Minus?

Steven

What are the groups thoughts on leaving the US provided you have the means to do so if we lose congress in the midterms? I struggle with the thought of getting out while I still can compared to staying and doing everything I can to help but honestly it feels pretty bleak right now

LustAndLeisureSexToys

I want to make y'all a custom crokinole board. It won't be until late fall at the earliest that I can get to it, as I'm getting married in October. So, when is the next time you will be doing a show anywhere near Asheville, NC so that I can deliver it to you? Also, would I be able to play it with you when I do?

Trev

For OA Andrew: during a trip around 17 mile drive at Pebble Beach I was told that no one can commercially sell an image of the lone cypress tree because the Pebble Beach has trademarked the tree itself. While I understand that they use the tree in their logo, how can they trademark a living thing and the view of the tree?

Bobby Tropicana

For anyone that wants to answer, what's one piece of entertainment media (movie, music, book, etc) that you think is underrated and should be engaged by more people?

Michael Rops

For all the hosts: Each of you please tell us about your favorite hate mail. I’m gonna bet Marsh has the best hate mail. You are all awesome and your podcasts help me get through my week…. Or in the case of Marsh, random time period between one month and 6 months!

Jason the Beav

I have an idea. Not a question. But please hear me out! Remember D&D minus Murder most fowl Part 2? That room was 5x5 but Eli was convinced to go with 10x10. But even 10x10 would be hilarious. Get ready for PIATpod psydo twister! Guys, please. Act out that episode! Get some tape or rope for the room. Then the props. A desk, laundry basket (shit optional), a bass guitar, 1 pug, 2 wolfs (maybe squish-mellows?) and the 5 Characters. Then have Eli Read out the actions and let the fun begin!

Pyre Temb

Andrew, Thomas, Lucinda, and Marsh: if you joined D&D Minus, what would your character's species/class/alignment be?

Kevin

For Andrew: Can you talk us from the ledge? I'm living in existential fear that the 1/6 hearings and the terrible Scotus decisions won't make any difference this November, and that 2022 will tee up a democratic collapse in 2024. I think more than a few of us need a silver lining or some cautious optimism.

steven burritt

andrew: being an optimist is there a law or rule that if the supreme changed would have you saying "our system is a joke" or where people should stop trusting in the system? Marsh: have you ever interviewed somebody that later changed their mind about that topic or you thought was not genuine in their beliefs?

Jess Donovan

Is Carl's sister Edna ever going to appear on D&D Minus? Please?

Liz Rosenberg

This could be revealing: for everyone— what was your favorite fairytale as a child?

Liz Rosenberg

Ps I know what Eli’s LEAST favorite was

Lime Green Morpheus

I meant to ask Heath this when I was talking to him at the Citation Needed live show in New York but I was so drunk that I forgot.

james devine

Heath. If you could make one change to capitalism without destroying it. What would it be. I'd like to hear from Heath first but I am sure you all have strong opinions.

Paul Freelend

Question for the panel, but particularly the sports-minded among you. How do you handle "voting with your wallet" when it comes to teams or organizations you love with ownership you loathe? For example, the Ricketts family owning the Cubs or Marsh's club Newcastle getting bought by Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund. It's easy to ditch Chik-fil-A as there are better chicken sandwiches elsewhere, but what do you do when there are no easy replacements and your support for the organization predates the bad ownership? Do you walk away and be a "bad fan" or stay put and agitate for positive change from within while knowing your money is flowing to ownership you wouldn't otherwise support?

Al Yako

Fuck, Marry, Kill: the "Heath, I promise the next one won't be about you" edition. As previously mentioned, lawyering of terms is heavily encouraged: Round 1, first complete set wins: just start yelling supreme court justices until Andrew grabs the mic. Round 2: The plaque buildup that's not doing it's job in Mitch McConnell's aorta, the nug of shit perpetually between Mike Lindells butt cheeks, the 4 entire chromosomes devoted to Marjory Taylor Greene's cro-magnon brow ridge. Round 3: Lauren Boebert now, Lauren Boebert in the womb, Lauren Boebert during the "Pretty Woman" Montage with Ted Cruz that we all know happened. Round 4: mango nectar, scotch, hot pockets Round 5: Michelle Obama with $2 million life insurance payable to you, Tomi Lahren with a prenup that heavily favors you, Bizarro Universe Megyn Kelly.

K

I don’t know if this has been asked because I seriously never thought about it until I listened to this diatribe, but would you still do your shows if it was illegal?

Bowl of Piss Water

What are your favorite kinds of names for pets? I like people names that were popular like 100 or more years ago - Eleanor and Agnes for my cats. Some people like food names, etc. Also, how many of you can sew? I feel like Noah can probably sew.

Athelstan

Heath, we all know the original blitzkrieg ended with the nazis pushing the British expeditionary force to Dunkirk, the modern project blitz lead to the theocratic Supreme Court, A great name for the fight back, is operation overlord, the famous return across the channel to crush the nazis, any alternative project naming suggestions, for crushing nazis ?

every voice listening

For each of the podcast hosts: is there anyone you've always wanted to interview or have guest-host on your respective shows, but haven't had the chance to?

Scotticus Maximus

Is the line "[name of product] is so good, our wives stole it/them" in the copy of the ad or does it actually happen?

Yness Boily

For any of the hosts that want to answer, what is the batshit craziest thing you've ever done to get a crush's attention? For Thomas specifically Metroplex or Omega Supreme, who wins in the fight?

Religion *is* Politics

I bet we’re there now with Gorsuch writing alternative facts into the first sentence of Kennedy v Bremerton

Ezra

Question for everyone: What thing that we might not know about or expect do you most appreciate/value in each other?

daniel martin

@Marsh how do you feel about the guys not realising that you aren't actually from Merseyside and so don't have a Merseyside accent? Possibly you don't give a fuck .....? From a scouser 😁

daniel martin

@Andrew have you ever studied English law and, if so, is there anything that stood out as particularly egregious or particularly good?

Lost in the Podcastaverse

How do you want to be remembered by the Atheist/Skeptic community or in general?

Dani Cav

What is the funniest/weirdest death threat y’all have gotten?

Fraa Paul

Question for Andrew: When was the last time Clarence Thomas was on the right side of history with an opinion?

Matt Ensminger

For Lucinda - What properties should you look for when choosing a quality varmint hammer? I've always pictured it as an old-timey circus mallet.

Roy Thompson

Not Andrew, but Ellie Mystal pointed to a Thomas dissent that he agreed with in his book "Allow Me To Retort." Kelo vs. City of New London which has come up on OA. "Reluctantly, I agree with the Republicans about this issue. Clarence Thomas, in dissent in Kelo, said that the majority was converting the “public use” allowed by the Fifth Amendment into any vague promise of a “public purpose.” And, God help me, I think Thomas was right about that. The government should not use its powers of eminent domain to essentially acquire land on the cheap for business interests, just because those businesses promise that there will be some public purpose behind their profit motive." Mystal, Elie. Allow Me to Retort (pp. 93-94). The New Press. Kindle Edition.

Magnus the Great Dane

What is the silliest thing you have been zucked for on social media. Context, just got done for posting “the federal reserve is a Ponzi scheme. /s” during a discussion on how people don’t understand finance and politics.

Andrew

For Marsh - please explain 'Collective Worship' in UK schools to the PIAT crew. I just want to watch their reaction... For all, if you had crazy billionaire / lottery win and didn't need to work, what pet project / good cause / dream would you want to pursue in a life without financial pressures?

Ray Kosby

Noah, which diatribe do you consider your masterpiece?

Brian1127

I remember this being answered too—they use their pseudonyms on and off air—so much so that they forget other people will still use their real names. Correct me if I’m wrong tho!

Scifi Wars

For everyone there. Tomorrow you are magically turned into a Transformer robot body. Andrew calm down, breath buddy breath... Which faction are you in, and what do you transform into?

Scifi Wars

You are somehow almost out of GAM worthy movies, what movie do you save to be the final episode?

Scifi Wars

To everyone, except Heath, Noah or Eli You get to choose a GAM movie, secular or normal feed, which one do you review with them?

Scifi Wars

We genetically engineer the resurrection of dinosaurs, but they are domesticated by default, which one do you have as a pet?

Scifi Wars

For Andrew What is the most insane thing anyone has filed against one of your clients (or someone elses clients you know the details of)

Scifi Wars

For everyone What food do you like, that everyone else you know doesnt like, or what food do you hate that everyone else likes...

Scifi Wars

Another Andrew question What is the most sus sounding transformers name? I mean like the 'headmaster' that only really released in japan. Something sexual thats totally not sexual.

Scifi Wars

Designate the person next to you a marvel style super power that suits them. They they choose one for someone else until you have gone around the room and everyones been given a power. (Read this after powers are given out) Taking those powers, who would win a free for all?

Tim, Yes that Tim - the social media guy

Last chance to get your Qs in for the #PiaTPJParty2022 so Tim can curate them for the AMA. If you’re a patron, you will get an email invitation in the next day or two.

Dawn D

What's the worst, most inappropriate/awkward/cringey question you've ever been asked in a Q&A?

Rebecca Throop

This is a question my kiddo wanted to ask at the last OA q&a but Andrew was out with covid: How come sometimes in supreme court cases there's the v like roe v wade but other times there is no v like in dred scott? (My 13 year old's question but I wasnt sure of the answer!)

Scifi Wars

You get a single, round trip, in a time machine. You get to nigh omnipotently observe the time period you go to got a few weeks. You cant interact, just watch. Where do you go and why?

Scifi Wars

Is there a fictional book/series of books you would suggest to the audience in audiobook form?

Scifi Wars

What tv show are you watching atm and really enjoying?

Grace Hughes

I have a few questions: 1) Anna how did you meet, and the start a relationship with Eli? Essentially asking for y'all's Meet Cute. 2) Same question for Lucinda. How did you meet Noah, and then start dating? 3) Andrew, and/or the whole pajamers, have you (any of you) considered running for local political offices? 4) Lucinda, what does your average day consist of? We don't get to hear much of your day to day goings 5) You could command 1 single person to drop dead publicly (think having a single page line from Death Note), who would choose to die that would have largest benefit to the world? Biggest bang for your death buck? 6) How's Max doing? 7) Andrew, are you only licensed to practise in Maryland, or is there other places you are licensed for? 8) Eli, do you still do magic consultations for movies/tv? 9) Anna, what other hobbies do you have? 10) If you could erase a single movie from existence, which one would it be and why?

Matt

For everyone but especially Marsh: The past few years have seen a large decline in religiosity, along with an increase in the acceptance of conspiracy theories. Do you think people are getting better or worse at skeptical thinking or are they just trading one crazy for another? Are you hopeful for the future in this regard?

Els

And if possible, also answer it :P

Els

I didn't know about this situation, but am now invested!

Olivia Wolfe

For everyone: I've been asked to say a few words at a pro-choice rally in my city next week, and I'm planning to focus mostly on the political side of things. I haven't done any public speaking since grade school. What advice could you give me, and other people who are new to public speaking?