Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this week’s episode, breakfast sullies its good name with national prayer, we learn about a fake treatment for autism that's dumber than ass bleach, and we’ll explore yet another of the abundance of dark recesses in David Icke’s brain.

---

To make a per episode donation at Patreon.com, click here: http://www.patreon.com/ScathingAtheist

To buy our book, click there: https://www.amazon.com/Outbreak-Crisis-Religion-Ruined-Pandemic/dp/B08L2HSVS8/

To check out our sister show, The Skepticrat, click here: https://audioboom.com/channel/the-skepticrat

To check out our sister show’s hot friend, God Awful Movies, click here: https://audioboom.com/channel/god-awful-movies

To check out our half-sister show, Citation Needed, click here: http://citationpod.com/

To check out our sister show’s sister show, D and D minus, click here: https://danddminus.libsyn.com/

To hear more from our intrepid audio engineer Morgan Clarke, click here: https://www.morganclarkemusic.com/

---

Headlines:

First rebranded version of the National Prayer Breakfast takes place: https://www.npr.org/2023/02/02/1153705297/congress-takes-reins-of-prayer-breakfast-from-secretive-christian-evangelical-gr

AOC ripped into MTG on Twitter about hypocrisy regarding antisemitic remarks: https://www.lgbtqnation.com/2023/02/aoc-ripped-into-marjorie-taylor-greene-on-twitter-she-ended-it-with-a-laughing-emoji/

Satanists are opening an abortion clinic named after Samuel Alito's mom: https://friendlyatheist.substack.com/p/satanists-are-opening-an-abortion

Less than 10% of anti-LGBTQ+ bills proposed in 2022 actually passed: https://www.lgbtqnation.com/2023/02/less-than-10-of-anti-lgbtq-bills-proposed-in-2022-actually-passed/

Naturopaths 'not bound by science,' lawyer argues in hearing on fecal transplants for autism: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/bc-naturopath-fecal-transplants-jason-klop-court-hearing-1.6504615

https://www.hopestandard.com/news/fraser-valley-naturopath-still-banned-from-selling-fecal-transplants-to-treat-autism/

Comments

Bryce Blankenagel

That shit was classy. TY for addressing what's on all our minds right at the top.

Sarvis

You all have my condolences. It hurts to cut off a friend when something comes to light about them that you just can't ignore. But it also takes a lot of strength to do it. Thanks for having that strength.

SonWinks

Noah and the whole team! …. Listening now! Thank you! So much — thank you! Seriously thank you!

Michael Usocchi

I love you boys. And Lucinda. And Anna. This one must have been hard as shit to tank through. Thank you for the transparency, and for the ongoing efforts to improve the community as a whole. In a way, you've always been the pioneers of this. This is a community that, despite its many imperfections, never stops striving towards becoming the best version of itself. You guys have been a critically important variable of this dynamic equation for years, now, and I don't doubt you'll continue to be for years to come. You are appreciated. You are loved. ❤️

Andrew

Sitting here welling up listening to that intro. People got hurt, really hurt and are going to be hurting for a long time. It wasn't due to an intentional or malicious intent of the PIAT team or community but a blind spot. Shining a light on it and bringing it painfully into view is going to be uncomfortable for many, but we can see it better now, we can look for it and we can act. We all evolved from filthy monkey men (and women) but we can adapt and evolve to be better together. ❤️

Joshua

When I stumbled onto the news about Andrew Torrez I was really worried about what this meant for PIAT. You guys are a really big part of my media diet and I was worried about that going away, but I was also worried about supporting a company that lets things like this happen. I really do believe that you’re trying to build a community where people don’t just feel safe but actually are safe.

Mama Llaga

*HUGS* As heartbreaking as the intro to today's ep is, thank you for committing to making the rest of the show at least as hilarious as always. In case it helps you laugh a little easier yourself... I couldn't help but hear that fecal pharmaceutical fraud's name as "Jason Plop".

Daniel Culver

I've been a fan since 2017. The news about Andrew Torrez is heartbreaking. Still rapping my head around this whole thing.

Kendallyn Frost

This is why I'm glad to be a part of this community specifically. When shit is awful & dark, we don't just sweep it under the rug or look around helplessly with "thought & prayers". We act. It's messy and hard to act, but we act. And we put guards in place so that we can better take care of each other.

Snowstar

Thank you so much for this

Pär Dahlström

First, the whole story about Andrew is depressing on all levels. But what I wanna tell is that in the fifties we had in Sweden our own crazy homeopat trial where a manufacture cheated by making fake [sic] homeopati pills and in the trial there lawyer used the defense "this is fake and everybody knows that so this cant be illegal".

That sickeningly in-love powercouple

I needed several minutes after the open. I can't imagine how the team feels. Doing better sounds great, I'm in. You all don't know me but hugs

V0ldek

This episode is brought to you by: fuck. Fuuuck. Fuck, because fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuck.

Bailey Sandlin

Even if bound by legal issues it would be nice to have Heath and Eli officially encourage the new group. I am sure they are a part of this and feel their failing was an understandible one that the new group will help address, but if they can't officially say they handled it wrong at the very least in retrospect, hearing them officially support the group that will handle it better will be nice. I am sure they do but I am hoping to see that at least. Also adding the link to Andrew story in the show notes would be a good idea.

The Scathing Atheist

If you are interested in supporting this new project (Creator Accountability Network (CAN)) please send an email to support@creatoraccountabilitynetwork.org

Jim Phynn

You’re not the only one.

Els

This is a good start. I'd love to help, but not sure if I can, and have the spoons (and have other communities with the same issues, that also need this, but have way more issues with funding). The one thing I am missing here, which might be part of the "can't say because of legal reasons", is the thing that has been going around that you knew earlier than november when the investigation thing etc, started. I'd really like it if you'd address this, or at least address that you know of this, and will get into it when it's possible.

Jim Phynn

One thing I absolutely hate about our species is how it takes a tragedy to get us to realize when we’ve been doing things wrong. (Think: we wouldn’t have maritime safety rules were it not for the Titanic.) In hindsight the fixes we make after the tragedy should have been obvious before the incident but it’s just a failure of our brains and the biases to which we all fall victim. The problem with waiting until after the tragedy is that the people who were hurt prior to or during the tragedy, can’t be “un-hurt” (for lack of a better term). The “never again” attitude might be a small comfort to the people who were the reason for the need for the word “again” in the first place, but when we say it’s the least we can do, it really is. Now for me personally, I’m about as far removed from the actual incidents as anyone can be: I’ve never attended a live show, never met anyone in or close to PiAT in person, and were it not for pictures on the internet I wouldn’t even know what the people involved look like. That said, this isn’t about me. And as I wipe the tears from my eyes listening to Noah’s diatribe, I feel an optimism that, despite the very real pain that I know I’m not involved in in any material way, there is a truly good path forward. Thank you!

Diziet Sma

I've been rattling around in confusion and pain since this all came out, feeling utterly betrayed and desperate, finding myself thinking maybe it really *is* all men. This has helped. Because when something like this happens, in many ways it's a massive version of the reality that we fuck up, we're human, bad shit happens, etc. Some of what matters is how we respond to it, what do we do to fix what we are able. I'm also social media free for MH reasons, like another commenter, so this was how I found hope again, after a totally fucked 50th birthday as the news broke in real time. Love you folks, a privilege to meet you at QED, and thank you all for struggling through this with us. 🤍💔

Michael Rops

Hi Els, Noah did address this in a Facebook post. In summary he knew but was asked to keep quiet about it by the victims. I'm also sure that since AT was a part owner of PIAT, there's going to be a LOT of things they can't say until they are fully disentangled.

Els

Thank you for your response! I am not in any of these groups on facebook, so this is something I've missed.

Christine M

I tried to send an email and got this message: Message not delivered Your message couldn't be delivered to support@creatoraccountabilitynetwork.org because the remote server is misconfigured. See technical details below for more information. The response from the remote server was: 554 5.7.1 : Relay access denied

BT

Facebook and Twitter have been having a lot of issues over the last day. Try reaching out later on in the day.

NicoNico

On a vacation currently and definitely was tearing up. My tour group member asked if I was ok. It hit me how emotionally connected I feel to this community. Thank you for working to do and be better. ❤️

Els

I wasn't at QED, so that's impossible! But thank you for the link, I'll check it out <3

Diziet Sma

Must have been another Els! Sorry. This has triggered issues in many of us. If you're struggling I hope you can find the help you need. 🤍

Syngen

So Lucinda's well fuck at the start just voices with inflection tone exactly how most of us are felling right now. Thank you so much for this weeks episode

Stakes so low, they're ground beef

Listening to Noah's intro had me tearing up, much like many others. I have an idea for how you can help the network. This will hurt your bottom line, but offer to give anyone who makes a recurring pledge to the creator accountability network access to the patreon RSS feed for one or more shows. It keeps your hands off the organization while still very actively incentivizing supporting it. Just a thought. I'm sorry you have to deal with this, and to the victims who felt silenced by the popularity of the guilty party. Thanks for doing what you could with an absolutely fucked situation.

Keaton

As someone coming in blind to the news, I first thought it was a bit and I was waiting for the turn. Then I slowly realized that there was no turn coming and it was not a bit. Then I read the article Noah mentioned... Fuck.

John Corcoran

I've been a lurker in the community since the podcast started. I'm male, socially awkward and a total introvert. But this situation has me pushing that aside and stepping out of my comfort zone by offering my help with this organization in anyway I can. I don't know if there is anything that I CAN do, but I know I cant continue to NOT do anything.

Danielle

G’morning fellas. “Just… just… fuck” pretty much sums it up. This episode inspired me to become a patron. I appreciate that you addressed this mess directly and that you’re taking steps to make the community a safe place. Be the change you want to see. ✊

Peter Kyrouac

I just listened to the intro. Thank you, Noah for not simply apologizing, but for having already invested in a solution before the apology was given. Thank you also for the posting the Google forms in these comments. I will definitely be supporting financially once I know how. I was involved in local kinky communities years ago, and SA/SH was not commonplace, but still occurred. So I'm interested in learning how an accountability group can be created and function. Thank you for shining a little bit of hope in what's felt like a hopeless past week.

Spacesuit Spiff

You're navigating this better than I could've imagined, while trying not to piss off a lawyer. Love you all

J. Vizzle

I just wanted to say that I (and I'm pretty sure I speak for most members of "LA Familia PiaT") when I say, I fucking love you guys. Thank you for being a good example for everyone, and for living your values, even when things are super fucking difficult.

Genevieve Ruble

Holy fuck thank you. I'm sorry. And what a fucking beautiful episode. Thank you!

Genevieve Ruble

Holy fuck thank you. I'm sorry. And what a fucking beautiful episode. Thank you!

Rawrbecca

This morning from my friend was the first time I heard 'spoons' used. Now I'm seeing it again. My thought is... What's it even like to have spoons? I just don't know. But I like seeing it mentioned and I wanted to comment. (Auto text put connect instead of comment... But I don't think it's wrong.)

Rebecca Oxford

Thank you for being you. For doing all you can to keep this “family” together. Love y’all so much for your good heart and your helping hands. 💕

FruitbatStudios

I feel like a lot of us have been grieving in this open nebulous space, and this episode feels like something to hold on to - something that gives us a direction to go in out of this awfulness. Thank you, and I hope that ya'll are taking good care of each other and yourselves.

Bob Brady

This isn't the first time I've cried listening to the Scathing Atheist but it might be the first time that it's because I felt culpable. I also feel betrayed. I thought that this couldn't happen to us because we were actively looking for this sort of problem. I *knew* that you were looking for it. If it can happen in this community I worry that there may be no hope. I never thought I'd feel hopeless here.

Bob Brady

That said. FFS. Let's keep moving forward. If there's a community that may be able to keep moving forward it's this one. Fuck you. Fuck me. Fuck this. I'm going to do what I can. I'm sorry.

Whitty

Just burst into tears when Lucinda did her "warning". Feeling for everyone.

Michael Rops

Thank you for posting this. I had never heard this before and now I know something new.

Lexy

I appreciate the shit out of you all for this. And thanks for still making an episode this week. Hope you're taking care of yourselves 💕

Rawrbecca

Thank you so much for the link! My comment was more... My depression is so bad I don't have any spoons and people that have spoons to do stuff just is beyond me.

SQuark

Thank you all. I'm not on facebook; does anyone know if there are non-facebook ways to get involved in the movement Noah was mentioning in the diatribe?

Lost in the Podcastaverse

This is from their Facebook page, there’s a link to a Google survey for volunteers: Recent events have highlighted an unfortunate but vital need in the secular community. To address these ethical concerns, a coalition of community leaders, philanthropists, volunteers, and advocates are starting the Creator Accountability Network. We envision this to be a tool that helps our community establish a code of ethics and create a system for reporting allegations of misconduct. If you are interested in supporting our efforts and receiving updates on our work, please reach out to us at http://creatoraccountabilitynetwork.org.

Joannasephine

On an unrelated note – I just found out that my husband (textile scientist) worked with the company that became Allbirds … on a wool-based running shoe. Does that make me godmother to the Wool dasher Mizzle?

darkora

Hella proud of you guys for doing the right thing in the wake of these awful revelations. All hope is not lost.

The Scathing Atheist

If you are interested in supporting Creator Accountability Network (CAN), please fill out this Google form:

FruitbatStudios

Ha - ok I get that, I misread at first. I'm absolutely the wrong person to ask what its like to have spoons XD

Kevin McKinney

Hi there. I am a patreon for a lot if your work. My wife and I want you to know we support you guys. We don’t know what we can do other than still be patrons, but if there is, let us know. From the Atheists on Mission road

Seth Swanson

Very sorry to hear about the issues with Andrew. I'm glad that you've cut ties and the moves that you're taking with the accountability project.

Julie Wine&Reason

Thank you for being so candid. Y'all did the right thing. There's so much I want to say. It all comes down to the fact that Noah and all of you shouldn't feel guilty. You learned what happened, acted appropriately, and are taking action to guard against predators getting into your " house" again. I wish my grandparents had been that strong.

Julie Wine&Reason

So did I! And my lips completely disappeared like someone denied sweet tea. ( Not a joke about Lucinda. I live in Tennessee.) Broke my heart & infuriated me at the same time. I hate that everyone's hurting.

GrassyknollMan

You guys can’t be held responsible when someone lies to you. When the truth was brought to light, you acted accordingly. The community will be better for this. Thank you for your support.

Diana Sokoly

Cried twice. Hard for me to find the words. It’s scary and heartbreaking but I am so fucking proud of you guys and thankful to you for doing what’s right like I knew you would. Behind you all the way.

Meadhands

In 2019, during peak Trump, I had to step away from politics. I was a supporter of The Skepticrat, Scathing Atheist, Cog Dis, and a handful of other atheist news collators and content creators. However, Trump got to me. I had to start going to therapy. I lost a lot of my innocence and faith in humanity. I cancelled all my subscriptions, stopped listening to anything political. I had to take time to get my head in the right place and recover. Since Biden got elected, I started slowly dipping my toe back in the waters. I started supporting God Awful Movies, Citation Needed, Dear Old Dads... and Opening Arguments. That latter, no longer. I have to say, I am glad I am a stronger person now than I was in 2019. If this happened then, this would have been the killing blow to my involvement with this community, perhaps even the killing blow in more... literal terms. However, these past few days of reading Google doc dumps, screenshots, apologies, official statements, and news articles, not to mention hearing recorded statements from every creator in my life who matters, has lit the fucking match. Not only am I back in with my financial support, but you'd better believe I've already put my name in with CAN. Let's see what we can do. Let's never let this happen again.

Meadhands

And thank for having a completely normal episode after that heavy opening. It was much needed.

Fame and fortune guaranteed in the state of Tintucky

Thank you Noah. I should have said it sooner but thank you. I became obsessed with OA after you invited Andrew, I still listen to OA but It's uncomfortable. I needed a full episode beyond the diatribe. You are going above and beyond for the community.