pet dog WIP breakdown (Patreon)
Content
When I was informed via education that working over an image before everything was in it, I really took that to heart, and I learned a lot TRYING to work that way, and so it wasn't wasted effort, but the reality is that my brain works in such a way that, to keep the ball rolling, I sometimes must work backassward and render pre-composition. It's not ideal, and I'm aware of it, but to function and make artwork I need to work not-ideally sometimes.
As a response to this, I am learning how not to be sorry in destroying work. Really it's more like a ceramics mindset in a painting discipline. Some parts might explode in spite of all my best efforts and I have to remake them totally and painstakingly, and that's OK.
I may have to re-render, or de-render some part of this figure. That's alright! As for adding to this image specifically, I am going to try simply leaving it as a study, making some shadowy figures for the rendered figure to interact with, rendering some kind of surface. I may try all three, roughly, and pick whichever I like best. If none of the additions work, I'll leave it as-is.
Something I learned from my very skillful (both in art and in teaching) drawing instructor is that sometimes a figure floating in space IS a finished work. The thesis of the image is: look how fascinating the form of this figure is. And when that's the thesis, you don't NEED interaction with another figure, or a surface. That finished work does not have to be a rendering of a whole space, or even a rendering at all. The feeling that I've done this too much in the past and need to build up other art muscles has made me expand past it, but that doesn't mean the rendering of a figure only is a Wrong Art. I need to remind myself that it's fine, so long as it's interesting to look at. I actually do enjoy looking at this As-Is, although I might be making the mistake of making art for me rather than art for sale. There's nothing especially Wrong with that, either.
A lot of the time the internet tries to tell you that making art you like is wrong. It doesn't follow the rules. It isn't composed in the right illustrative way. I feel this may be technically correct, but philosophically flawed. It treads too far into the area of art as MERELY product. I see a lot of illustrators falling for this and then falling out of love with creating. This is the downside of illustration.
I find myself very often having to defend fine art to illustrators, and illustration to fine artists. So many people fail to see that both have a lot of value and some pitfalls, and it can be useful to study, and draw (double entendre!), from both. That really, they are two sides of the same coin.
I am extremely grateful to my college teacher, who was so intelligent and careful and scrupulous about this. He was able to walk that line, and speak thoughtfully. He was skillful in the idea of personal boundary as a teacher and a fellow artist. He told us that if we had a strong feeling we knew what we wanted, to go with that, no matter what he said, because art is personal, and when it becomes depersonalized, you are losing a huge part of why you, as a human being, need to make art. He was giving us permission to retain our autonomy, in a world and a field that asks us repeatedly to give up our autonomy.
As far as this specific image goes, I could, and will, tinker with the qualities of contrast, to make it more maximally interesting to view. But I need to remind myself repeatedly that I shouldn't accept being told that he NEEDS to exist in deep space.