Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Note: This piece contains spoilers for both parts of Kill Bill, which were first released over two decades ago. It’s a very good film, and it’s worth checking out The Whole Bloody Affair which is playing in theatres now, even with the weird and unnecessary Fortnite sequence.

Something very interesting happens when Kill Bill, Vol. 1 and Kill Bill, Vol. 2 are combined together to form The Whole Bloody Affair, whether by simply watching the two films back-to-back or attending a screening of the recent theatrical release of the two features.

There is and always has been a clear contrast between the two films. Kill Bill, Vol. 1 takes place in a very heightened and stylized world. A clear break from Quentin Tarantino’s earlier Los-Angeles-set triptych of Reservoir Dogs, Pulp Fiction and Jackie Brown, Kill Bill, Vol. 1 clearly takes place in what Tarantino describes as “movie world.” It is heavily stylistically indebted to the Hong Kong exploitation films produced by studios like the Shaw Brothers.

The Bride (Uma Thurman) wears the same tracksuit that Bruce Lee did in Game of Death. There is a silhouetted samurai sword fight that very overtly evokes Samurai Fiction. The back story of the villainous O-Ren Ishii (Lucy Liu) is delivered via an anime interlude that was animated by IG, the studio responsible for Ghost in the Shell. The Bride even earns her blade from the swordsmith Hattori Hanzō, played by the legendary Sonny Chiba, who was the subject of much fannish enthusiasm from Clarence (Christian Slater) in Tarantino’s script for Tony Scott’s True Romance.

Tarantino’s films always had a postmodern quality to them, with his directorial debut Reservoir Dogs opening with an extended discussion about the meaning of Madonna’s “Like a Virgin.” However, Kill Bill, Vol. 1 pushed Tarantino’s films to an even more heightened unreality. It didn’t unfold in anything that looked like the real world. It looked like a movie – or several movies stitched together. Tarantino boasted he wanted “each reel to play like it's a reel from a different movie.”

There was some critical pushback to this, with some observers feeling that Tarantino was slipping away into empty referential fantasy. In The New York Times, A.O. Scott opined that the film unfolded in “a highly artificial world, a looking-glass universe that reflects nothing beyond [Tarantino’s] own cinematic obsessions.” Manohla Dargis complained that “there’s little in this private fetish of a movie that relates to the natural world.”

There is some truth to these criticisms, and they carry through to Tarantino’s later work like Inglorious Basterds and Once Upon a Time… in Hollywood. At a time when many directors have retreated from modernity, Tarantino did something even more postmodern by retreating into constructed realities. This is not to suggest these movies are flawed or that they are bad. Indeed, some of them – like Death Proof – feel more personal than his earlier films. But the shift is palpable.

This makes the transition into Kill Bill, Vol. 2 quite surprising and effective. Kill Bill, Vol. 2 begins within that same “movie world”, shifting its focus from Asian martial arts cinema to the American western. In its early stretches, Kill Bill, Vol. 2 feels very heavily indebted to the movies of Sergio Leone, right down to quoting music from Ennio Morricone. However, from the start of Kill Bill, Vol. 2, the movie is much closer to the borders of “movie world.” From the opening moments, reality is bleeding in at the edge of the frame.

In Kill Bill, Vol. 1, the characters and their world are abstracted. The protagonist is known only as “the Bride.” She is denied a name and anything beyond the most basic back story. The villainous Bill (David Carradine) appears only briefly. His voice is heard and his hands are seen, but his face is kept off-screen. The world of Kill Bill, Vol. 1 is a very broadly drawn cartoon. Even the suburban violence in the opening scene, as the Bride kills Vernita Green (Vivica A. Fox) in her family home, is outlandish and colorful.

In Kill Bill, Vol. 2, from the outset, the world becomes more real. The Bride’s real name is revealed to be Beatrix Kiddo. The film opens with an extended sequence depicting the massacre that prompted her revenge, granting her back story more emotional weight. Bill appears on screen almost immediately, and his own troubled relationships with his brother Budd (Michael Madsen) and surrogate fathers Pai Mei (Gordon Liu) and Esteban Vihaio (Michael Parks) are brought into focus.

Kill Bill, Vol. 2 unfolds in a much more mundane world. Budd lives in a trailer and works as a bouncer and janitor in a seedy strip club where he argues with his manager Larry (Larry Bishop). When Beatrix tracks Vihaio down to a brothel in Mexico, it is not the sort of brothel that usually appears in a genre film. It is instead a real brothel, with the film employing the actual sex workers who worked there as background extras. Beatrix has come a long way from the first half’s Beijing soundstages.

Film critic Bilge Ebiri has argued that, as a whole object, Kill Bill “does actually conform a bit to The Odyssey”, one of the earliest recorded stories and an archetype extremely common in media. Over the course of the two films, Beatrix confronts her own cyclops, Elle Driver (Daryl Hannah), makes a journey to and return from the underworld by being buried alive, communes with a prophet in the form of Pei Mei, and then finally makes a homecoming where she confronts a usurper.

This is certainly a valid reading of the film, one that becomes much clearer when both halves are viewed together. However, if Kill Bill is a version of The Odyssey, perhaps the most famous journey in the history of storytelling, it is worth considering where Beatrix is travelling from and where she finds herself heading to. Beatrix begins in the imaginary world of an exploitation revenge movie. She ends it in the intimacy of a family sitting room. She journeys from fantasy, into reality.

In the final stretch of Kill Bill, it becomes clear what the film is really about. What initially appeared to be a fairly cliché revenge story is ultimately revealed to be a drama about the dissolution of a family. Beatrix discovers that her daughter B.B. (Perla Haney-Jardine) is alive and has been raised in a fairly mundane (if admittedly luxurious) home by Bill. Suddenly, Beatrix isn’t living in an homage to Samurai Fiction, but instead watching Shogun Assassin on a television set with her daughter. A gigantic television sits in the middle of the living room that takes up most of the film’s final half hour, as if enforcing a boundary on reality.

When Beatrix arrives at that house, planning to murder Bill, she is shocked to find B.B. playing with a toy gun. B.B. shoots her mother, and Beatrix immediately slips into play acting, falling to the ground in a pantomime of death that feels like a less blood version of the destruction that cut through the first half. Tellingly, when Beatrix does kill Bill at the end of the film with “the Five-Point Palm Exploding Heart Technique”, he dies in a similar way. It is less a literal death than an abstracted one. It is telling that some fans refuse to believe Bill is “really” dead, despite Tarantino’s assurances that Bill has, in fact, been killed.

Watching Kill Bill, Vol. 1 and Kill Bill, Vol. 2 back to back makes this journey from fantasy into reality a lot clearer. When the films were first released, the sharp shift in tone between the two halves felt somewhat jarring and distracting. Audiences who left the heightened world of Kill Bill, Vol. 1 six months earlier didn’t have a chance to adjust to the shifting nature of the films’ reality, but were instead thrown straight into the more grounded Kill Bill, Vol. 2. Tarantino has always made it clear that “the tone changes at the beginning of the second movie” were deliberate.

While this arc was always there, it feels much more organic in The Whole Bloody Affair. Indeed, it serves to answer those criticisms of Tarantino’s descent into empty reference. If anything, Kill Bill, Vol. 1 begins as Tarantino’s most heightened movie and Kill Bill, Vol. 2 ends as perhaps his most intimate and personal work. That journey is surprisingly effective when rendered over four hours, adopting a symmetrical structure that begins and ends with two very different forms of violence in a family home.

Kill Bill, Vol. 2 doesn’t just draw from reality in general. It draws very specifically from Quentin Tarantino’s reality. The film’s focus on Budd’s trailer, which is presented as a deeply tragic and ultimately violent space, feels informed by “the most disturbing period in Quentin’s entire childhood”, when his newly-divorced mother sent him to live with her alcoholic mother in a “flea-pit trailer” in Tennessee. Accounts vary as to how violent that period was, but it feels formative for Tarantino.

Kill Bill arrived as Tarantino was working through some of his own personal anxieties. His father, Tony Tarantino, had abandoned his wife and son when Quentin was just a child. However, he had “crawled out of the woodwork” when his son became famous. Tony would try to leverage his son’s fame, giving interviews to Premiere magazine in 1996 and lending his name to movies very consciously designed to evoke his son’s work. He also hung out with Al Pacino’s estranged dad, Sal Pacino

Tarantino has talked about his father trying to reconnect with him at a café, and how Tarantino’s response was that he “waved him away.” It also feels notable that while Tarantino was writing Kill Bill, he was spending a lot of time with Uma Thurman and her family. Tarantino had pushed back production on Kill Bill so that Uma could have her second child. “If Josef Von Sternberg is getting ready to make Morocco and Marlene Dietrich gets pregnant, he waits for Dietrich!” he explained. As a result, Kill Bill, Vol. 1 arrived six years after Jackie Brown. There was a sense that it was a product of an extended down period.

However, Thurman’s family dynamics were not particularly comfortable either. Thurman filed for divorce from actor Ethan Hawke in 2004, the same year that Kill Bill, Vol. 2 came out. There were rumors that Hawke had engaged in an affair with the family’s nanny, Ryan Shawhughes. Though Hawke denies these allegations, he would start dating Shawhughes almost immediately after the divorce and the pair would marry in 2008. It is also worth stressing that Hawke and Thurman still get along well, with Thurman describing Hawke as “a wonderful person.”

Still, Tarantino’s time with Thurman inspired his work on Kill Bill, particularly the movie’s ending. It was only in the last four-five months of the writing process that I realized that B.B. was alive,” Tarantino explains, recalling his time in the Thurman and Hawke household. “I'm getting to know Maya, her daughter, and I'm being warmed by that. And all those things started coming out. And during that time, Uma was a mother, that's what she did. So as you start learning about her, that's what you start taking away."

It’s hard to overstate the impact that time with Uma and Maya had on Tarantino. “I can honestly say that all that baby stuff would not have been in Kill Bill if I hadn't written the part for Uma,” he recalls. “We are best friends, and when I was writing the script it was a good excuse to hang out with her. And if you hang out with Uma, you're going to hang out with her kids. I had a wonderful connection with her daughter, Maya. Actually, the truthful answer is that Maya made me want to have kids. [She] showed me I'd be a good father.”

Taken as a whole object, Kill Bill is a story about fatherhood. After all, the Bill that is being killed is the father of Beatrix’s child. However, Bill himself had his share of bad fathers. As Beatrix wryly observed, Bill “collected father figures”, often repulsive and abusive men like Pei Mei and Esteban Vihaio. Bill seems to be trying to be a better father figure to B.B. than they were to him, but he is still a cruel and violent partner who responded to Beatrix’s attempts to leave him by murdering an entire church.

There is some level of introspection here. Kill Bill arrived at a point when Tarantino was interrogating his own relationship with his exploitative father, as he was considering fatherhood himself. Certainly, Bill feels like an overt stand-in for Tarantino at both his coolest and his most pathetic. Bill is the kind of person who punctuates an argument with his ex by delivering an extended monologue about Superman. Tellingly, Tarantino himself voices Bill in the additions to The Whole Bloody Affair, despite sounding nothing like Carradine.

In this context, it is perhaps worth acknowledging the accident that happened on the set of Kill Bill, Vol. 2, after Tarantino pushed Thurman to film a sequence driving a car instead of employing a stunt driver. The car crashed, and Thurman was severely injured. She suffered with pain for years.  “Quentin came in my trailer and didn’t like to hear no, like any director,” Thurman would later recall of how she came to be driving that car. “He was furious because I’d cost them a lot of time.” It is perhaps unfair to think of Bill and Beatrix in that moment, of the dictatorial man in control placing the life of his subordinate and partner-in-crime in serious danger, and unable to cope with her discomfort.

Thurman is still friends with Tarantino. Whatever bad blood brewed between the pair has been resolved, with her daughter Maya even appearing in Once Upon a Time… in Hollywood. While Thurman has talked openly about how she does not blame Tarantino for the accident, Tarantino has described the accident as “the biggest regret of [his] life” and it feels telling that his next movie after Kill Bill was Death Proof, about a foot fetishist (Kurt Russell) who kills women in a modified stunt car, and is himself brutally murdered. Still, that accident haunts Kill Bill.

All of this was obviously in the original text of Kill Bill, Vol. 1 and Kill Bill, Vol. 2. Tarantino talked openly about a lot of it at the time. Still, when these two films are combined into a sweeping single narrative, the arc and the themes become a lot easier to follow. With The Whole Bloody Affair, Kill Bill becomes a journey from the outlandish heightened absurdity of exploitation cinema to a much more devastating personal form of violence with the home of a broken family.

Kill Bill is in some ways Tarantino’s most postmodern film. In others, it is his most personal.

Files

Comments

Austin Barnes

I just saw 'The Whole Bloody Story's last night and I also was struck by how personal it was, but more in the sense how this movie has all of his fetishes out on full display, as well as references to the cinema that he loves. Like he was cramming all these things from HK, Kung Fu and Western movies and while pouring them into the mix, those things that are hidden inadvertently came through as well, though granted the movie is so intensely personal in parts, it can be tough to gage what is intended and came through just because it was Tarantino.

Ryallen

I never saw Kill Bill, and I haven't had the pleasure of going to the theater to see the recut yet, but I did see the monologue about Superman from Bill on Youtube and what stuck out to me is the fundamental misunderstanding that Bill exhibits in his monologue. He asserts that Superman is the true person and Clark Kent is the mask but that's never really been the case, nowadays especially but it was still present at the time. Clark might pretend to be more mild-mannered but Superman was always the icon, the mask so to speak, of the person that Clark was raised to be. He had normal parents, a normal upbringing, and works a normal job. He isn't pretending to be anything, except maybe someone that needs glasses to see. His name, ultimately, was Clark Kent the moment he was adopted in Kansas and that's what he always called himself. Superman is just what he tells other people so he's able to live like a normal person. There are two ways to interpret Bill's monologue as a reflection of Quentin Tarantino, in that Tarantino either understands that Bill fundamentally doesn't understand Clark/Superman and is making the point that Bill only ever saw (and loved) the assassin or that Tarantino doesn't understand this fact and is trying to say that Beatrix is simply a formal name to the world's greatest killer. I prefer the former interpretation personally, I think it lends to a greater depth to the film that Bill never really saw Beatrix as a whole person

Andrew White-Winter

I watched both earlier this year when you reviewed them on (obligatory shoutout!) The250 podcast. Maybe in one sitting it would make more sense, and Vol. 2 certainly has its moments (Michael Madsen in particular as the near philosophical trailer trash is a brilliant performance) but it just felt like it ran too long for me to finally get to that excellent ending. (I also have to say, cause sorry controversy, but it’s telling the car crash is his greatest regret, not the decades he spent enabling or ignoring Harvey’s indiscretions and abuse…)

Davsau

I do get the sense from his later movies that he has a fair amount of self loathing kind of boiling under the surface. He didn’t burn it all out with Kill Bill. You can see shades of Tarantino in the villains in Death Proof and Inglorious Bastards (the hands thing). Also his guest appearance in Planet Terror (ew).

Darren Mooney

I mean, Landa is explicitly a foot fetishist in "Inglorious Basterds."

Darren Mooney

I tend to be of the mind that intent is interesting, but not essential in parsing the personal nature of the work. It's a cliché, but I think of Steven Spielberg talking to James Lipton about "Close Encounters", and not realising that he had a movie about his parents' divorce until Lipton spelled it out to him. It's one of my favourite examples of criticism, in large part because it gets the magic of this sort of art. The artist is present, even in ways that they would never plan.

shadowscribble

I have to watch the recut, but thinking about the two got me thinking about Revenge as a driver in movies. Part 1 fittingly stars The Bride, less a character and more an unstoppable engine of revenge. A classic trope of revenge tales is the empty futility when it's done and the avenged is still there. There are shades of that when the world becomes more real, and The Bride becomes Beatrix.

Darren Mooney

The piece was long enough, but here is a recurring motif in the second half of the idea of cycles of violence, endless loops of trauma. Bill was victimised by his fathers, so he victimises his children. He tries to raise B.B. well enough, but there are suggests that there's a lot of him in her. She murders her gold fish just to see what will happen. There's a deleted scene of Michael Jai White as a guy attacking Bill, claiming that Bill killed his father, which ends with White dead, which feels like it reinforces the sense of how pointless all this is - everybody has their revenge story. You even have Budd's, "That woman deserves her revenge. And we deserve to die. But, then again, she also deserves to die." There is a real ambivalence to the second half, in contrast to the fun catharsis of the first half, where I don't think you question the Bride's righteousness and you don't doubt this is a straight, linear narrative.