Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Note: This piece contains full spoilers for the second season of The Caped Crusader, the animated Batman series that premiered on Amazon Prime Video today. If you’re looking for a capsule review: I had a good time with it. It’s maybe a little weaker than the other two animated superhero shows on at the moment in terms of animation quality: My Adventures with Superman and X-Men ’97. It’s also quite deliberately and slowly paced. But it has big ideas and a fresh take, and is clearly committed to what it is doing. 

The Caped Crusader takes Batman (Hamish Linklater) back to his roots.

The series unfolds in a version of Gotham is that firmly anchored in the middle decades of the 20th century. It obviously evokes the aesthetic of Batman: The Animated Series, the earlier beloved adaptation of the character from producer Bruce Timm that also unfolded against a hazy and nostalgic backdrop, populated by blimps and radios and retro car designs. However, The Animated Series was set in a somewhat more ambiguous blend of past and present.

There, Bruce (Kevin Conroy) was frequently seen working at a gigantic computer. Edward Nygma (John Glover) was introduced as a video game designer. Jervis Tetch (Roddy McDowall) was an electronics and cybernetics expert who developed mind control chips. In an homage to the neo-noir of Blade Runner, the show even cast William Saunderson in the recurring role of Karl Rossum, a designer of androids so lifelike that they could pass as human.

While it is difficult to situate The Caped Crusader in a specific year, the series takes things even more analogue. The closest thing Batman has to a computer is a bulletin board. News is disseminated via radio. Reports are printed and delivered on paper. There is a sense that black-and-white television is a somewhat new invention, one that is already being weaponized by cynical forces like pundit Hattie Tetch (Laraine Newman), “the Mad Hatter of Media”, host of Hattie’s Tea Party.

Towards the climax of the series, the villainous Joker (Matthew Needham) quotes repeatedly from W.B. Yeats’ Second Coming. “The blood-drenched tide is loosed and everywhere the ceremony of innocence is drowned,” he taunts Batman. The Second Coming was published in 1919, in the wake of the First World War, and is often read as a “prediction of the savage birth of the modern era”, the nervous wait between the First and the Second World Wars, with existential dread hanging in the air.

It is interesting that the release of The Caped Crusader should coincide with the recent premiere of Spider-Noir, another streaming superhero television show that situates its hero against the backdrop of the mid-20th century, in that case offering a version of the classic Spider-Man mythos built around private detective Ben Reilly (Nicolas Cage) and his battle against New York mob boss Finbar “Silvermane” Byrne (Brendan Gleeson).

There is, perhaps, something in the air. These stories of pulp heroes operating against a retro backdrop resonates. Over the past decade or so, for example, income inequality has soared to a level that has not been seen since the 1930s. It has been argued that the current American presidential administration “is the most corrupt since at least Warren Harding’s, of 1920s Teapot Dome fame.” The administration’s policies of isolationism and xenophobia hark back to the 1920s and 1930s.

More broadly, the old monsters of the 1920s and 1930s seem to be on the rise again. Fascism and authoritarianism are ascendent, at home and abroad. At a time when the superhero blockbuster is undeniably in decline, it makes sense for the genre to cast its gaze backwards. The genre emerged against the backdrop of these fears and anxieties, speaking to a world wracked by the same uncertainties and terrors. Why wouldn’t the superhero genre go back to where it began?

However, there is something else at play in The Caped Crusader. The series isn’t just returning the Dark Knight to his mid-century origins. It can often feel like the show is pushing a little bit past the character’s very beginning into his pre-history. This is a series about Batman being thrown into conflict not just with his own history, but with the influences and the wider context from which he was spawned. It is a show about the forging of the superhero genre from its baser elements.

The show leans very heavily on the genres that would inform and shape the superhero. There is, for example, a lot of mid-century horror in these episodes. The season premiere, “Brute Force”, pits Batman against monsters engineered by Doctor Hugo Strange (James Urbaniak). The fourth episode, “The Devil’s Due”, finds Batman fighting a cult led by the mysterious Monk (Blythe Melin), whose followers worship the bat demon Barbatos.

These episodes draw heavily from writer and artist Matt Wagner’s classic Dark Moon Rising duology, two six-issue comic book miniseries set in the early days of Batman’s career between his emergence in Year One and his first confrontation with the Joker in The Man Who Laughs. Wagner’s miniseries, in turn, drew from the earliest Golden Age comics, the adventures of the Caped Crusader in the months before the superhero genre was codified, and so Batman fought monsters and vampires.

More to the point, though, these episodes – and others, such as “The Spectral Hand” – situate the emergence of Batman in the context of the horror movies of the 1930s and the 1940s; the Universal Monster Movies, German Expressionism. They suggest that the earliest Batman comics resonated because, with their depiction of a cloaked figure dressed like a bat stalking the night, they spoke to the same anxieties and uncertainties as those classic horror films.

There is also a lot of film noir in this season episodes. “Deep Cover”, for example, finds Batman going undercover in prison as “Matches Malone” in the hopes of discovering information about the criminal organization of Rupert Thorne (Cedric Yarbrough), only to find his loyalties conflicted when he strikes up a friendship with crook Mark “Dez” Desmond (Zach Lazar Hoffman). It feels very firmly like a throwback to the culture that informed those early comic books.

“Her Dark Reflection” offers a film noir twist on the classic Batman villain Poison Ivy, reinventing her as florist Rose Forrest (Fryda Wolff), who is so traumatized by the death of her father (Artt Butler) that she reinvents herself as the sultry seductress Thorn to avenge herself upon Thorne’s lieutenant Edward “The Riddler” Nygma (Ronan Raftery). It is a much more literal take on Poison Ivy as the femme fatale archetype, rather than as a traditional supervillain.

Indeed, the series offers a similar reinvention of Nygma. In the comics, Nygma is known as the Riddler because he tends to leave a series of elaborate clues for Batman to follow and solve. Here, Desmond helpfully explains, Nygma earned the nickname because of his fondness for the Thompson Machine Gun. “He shot up so many places they called him the Riddler,” Desmond explains to Bruce. Nygma does pop the occasional riddle, but he is not by any measure a supervillain.

This is also an example of The Caped Crusader delving into the pre-history of Batman. While the Riddler technically appeared a couple of times in the comics of the 1940s, the character only really cemented himself as a classic Batman villain in the 1960s, in large part due to Frank Gorshin’s incredible take on the villain in the Adam West Batman show. Gorshin's Riddler was an over-the-top impression of Richard Widmark's character Tommy Udo, from the 1947 noir film Kiss of Death, and that is what this take on the character is referencing.

The series does something similar with the Joker. The Joker was rather famously modelled on the performance and design of the eponymous character in The Man Who Laughs, an American silent film directed by German Expressionist filmmaker Paul Leni and starring German-British actor Conrad Veidt. To underscore this connection, the British Needham affects a soft German accent for the Joker, tying the supervillain to his own influences and inspirations.

Of course, with his German accent, his sinister medical experiments and his use of deadly gas as a weapon of mass murder, the version of the Joker presented in The Caped Crusader very directly evokes the industrialized horrors of the mid-20th century. Rather pointedly, the Joker refers to his victims as “vermin”, “Insects” and “bugs”, evoking the propaganda of the Third Reich but also the language of so much contemporary political discourse.

The Joker is an over-exposed villain. He is one of a handful of characters to have earned two separate actors (Heath Ledger and Joaquin Phoenix) an Academy Award. The Joker is almost required by law to appear in any Batman adaptation, and the character can become a little routine and familiar. The Caped Crusader manages to offer a relatively fresh and interesting take on the character by pulling him back to his origins and trying to understand the things that he spoke to in his earliest context.

In an era where comic book adaptations can tend to over-complicate their characters or their worlds, there is something charming in the way that The Caped Crusader takes the opposite approach, dialling it back, in boiling these characters down to their essence. Jarvis Tetch doesn’t need mind controlling computer chips, when Hattie Tetch has a device that lets her beam herself into every home across Gotham so she can tell the “weak-minded, passive people” what to think.

The Caped Crusader pushes the superhero genre back to its earliest days, unravelling it to a set of influences and ideas swirling around one another. However, the series understands that this is not some abstract intellectual exercise. The things that made the emergent superhero genre so urgent in the 1930s and 1940s are suddenly relevant again, in ways that they have not been for decades. The Caped Crusader seems to argue that the genre needs to engage with this.

“All over the world, people are starving,” announces Roxanne Sutton (Wunmi Mosaku) in her film reel presentation of her new rocket technology. “Epidemics kill millions across the globe. Nation wage war over territory and resources. Generation after generation, century after century. Is humanity fated to repeat these horrors forever?” That is an argument that makes sense in the 1930s and 1940s context of The Caped Crusader. However, it also resonates with the modern world.

To return to the Joker’s fixation on W.B. Yeats’ Second Coming, that poem is built upon the implication that history is inherently cyclical in all of its horror and brutality. The Caped Crusader understands this, and makes a convincing argument that this is what the superhero genre was built for.

Files

Comments

Brian S

Great article as always, Darren. I will add one thing: placing the show in the past isn’t just a stylistic choice. It allows the writers, and by extension the audience, to face enemies and scenarios that are created and need to be overcome by humans and our ingenuity. Our present era doesn’t really allow for that. Technology Is either a crutch or an insurmountable obstacle, but neither exists in the setting. This makes it easier for the writers and cathartic for the viewers.

Darren Mooney

I mean, I think what works for a story works for a story. Nolan's "Batman" is a very Bush era "Batman." I think of Reeves as very nineties - the "se7en"-ness, the Nirvana. That said, as somebody who loved "X-Men: First Class" and "The Incredibles", I'm stunned we've not seen more period-set superhero films. Although it can be done lazily (I didn't think it was used as well as it could have been in "Captain Marvel" or "Fantastic Four"), it does open possibilities. I'm not hugely fond of Snyder's "Watchmen", but that opening montage is one of the best pieces of superhero cinema ever.