Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Note: This piece contains spoilers for last night’s episode of House of the Dragon, which is currently streaming on HBO Max, down to including the last line of the episode. That said, if you’re looking for a capsule review: it continues to be a lavish, well-made drama series that is both less ambitious but also more tightly contained than Game of Thrones. It’s good, solid fantasy entertainment. But no need for this spoiler warning to drag on any further.

Power is a central preoccupation for both Game of Thrones and House of the Dragon. Indeed, one of the core themes of House of the Dragon is the question of whether those who hold power actually meaningfully exert any agency over its application or whether it is all illusory. “Power resides where men believe it resides,” Varys (Conleth Hill) warned Tyrion Lannister (Peter Dinklage) in Game of Thrones. “It's a trick. A shadow on the wall.”

However, as House of the Dragon has developed, the series has offered a somewhat more complicated conception of power and the relationship that those in positions of authority have to it. Early in the third season of House of the Dragon, Queen Rhaenyra (Emma D’Arcy) seizes the Iron Throne. However, she quickly discovers that taking the seat of power and actually governing from it are two radically different propositions.

Rhaenyra consults with her old friend Alicent Hightower (Olivia Cooke) on how best to rule. “You may not rule and remain yourself,” Alicent warns her old friend. “There are choices to be made and you may on occasion have to turn your face away while people suffer and die. There is in you a door that must shut. You will do things that your heart would have recoiled from before you came to the throne.” To become a king or queen is to become a vessel through which power flows.

“I acknowledge the struggle, but I dispute that I must become what I am not,” Rhaenyra insists. Alicent is unconvinced, observing, “Time will tell.” In the season’s penultimate episode, Rhaenyra consults with her half-sister Helaena (Phia Saban). Helaena expresses concern about the dynasty’s dragons, the show’s primary metaphor for power. “You believe the dragons alter us in some way?” Rhaenyra asks. Helaena replies, “You now have many dragons. Are you yourself not altered?”

Throughout House of the Dragon, the dragons – and often the subjects – sworn to these royal houses prove themselves ungovernable. They feud and fight, with little regard for what their superiors seemingly want. In that penultimate episode, an emotionally-charged family reunion with Rhaenyra’s step-daughter and cousin Rhaena (Phoebe Campbell) turns into a feud between the dragons as tempers reach boiling point, resulting in the death of Rhaena’s pet dragon, Sheepstealer.

However, it is not simply the dragons that exist beyond the control of Westeros’ ruling class. Throughout the show, the continent’s elite find themselves beholden to forces that should logically be beneath them. King Aegon II (Tom Glynn-Carney) flees into exile as the war seems to turn around him. However, despite once ostensibly ruling Westeros, Aegon II finds himself caught in a tug-of-war between two of those who claim to serve him.

Larys Strong (Matthew Needham) hopes to secret King Aegon II away to the foreign continent of Essos, to live in exile in the City of Bravos. In contrast, Tyland Lannister (Jefferson Hall) seeks to convince King Aegon II to remain in Westeros and rally his forces at Casterly Rock, the ancestral seat of House Lannister. These two options are inherently self-serving for the two men advocating for them, each treating King Aegon II as a pawn in their own political maneuvering.

Rhaenyra is also manipulated by the people around her. Her husband and uncle Daemon (Matt Smith) constantly undermines her. When Rhaenyra orders the Gold Cloaks in King’s Landing to come down hard on those who slander her family, Daemon instructs members of the force to be selective in following her orders. “The Queen’s son is dead,” he warns. “She must be excused her impulses.” He advises, “Tend to her humors. Not every whim needs to be pursued with equal vigor.”

When Daemon discovers that his daughter Rhaena was responsible for the death of Rhaenyra’s son Jacaerys (Harry Collett), Daemon lies to Rhaenyra to cover up his daughter’s culpability. He presents Rhaenyra with a skull that he claims is from the man who killed Jacaerys. It is more than just a lie of omission; it is an active deception. It is a fundamental betrayal of the woman to whom he is married and the queen to whom he is sworn. It is treason.

Daemon is not the only member of Rhaenyra’s Court who seeks to manipulate the would-be ruler. Mysaria (Sonoya Mizuno), a former sex worker who has long spoken on behalf of the commoners of Westeros, seeks to maneuver herself into Rhaenyra’s good graces. Rhaenyra accuses Mysaria of trying to put her at odds with Daemon. “You have sought to turn me from him,” Rhaenyra protests. “Pouring your honey in my ear. Whispering. Encouraging. Seeking to make me in your image.”

Mysaria deflects this criticism by seducing Rhaenyra, understanding that beneath the crown sits a human being, who is subject to human desires and passions. This has been a consistent theme through Game of Thrones and House of the Dragon, contrasting the divine myth of royalty with the reality of flesh. Megan Garber argued Game of Thrones was about how “everyday people become subject, in the most intimate of ways, to the workings of leaderly minds and hearts and spleens.”

However, House of the Dragon suggests that even those leaderly minds and hearts and spleens can be manipulated by a skilled operator. Throughout the third season, the would-be kings and queens of House of the Dragon have been wracked by insecurity. Aegon and his brother Aemond (Ewan Mitchell) each bitterly insist that the other received more love from their mother Alicent. Aegon asks both Strong and Lannister if he is a good king. Rhaenyra asks Mysaria, “Do you think I’m worthy?”

Within the penultimate episode of the season, there is a strong emphasis on the desire of even the most powerful people in the world to be seen and recognized, to be validated. When Aegon decides to face certain death, he allows Strong to escape so that he may tell the tale of Aegon’s heroism. Facing down an enemy army, Aegon raises his sword and demands that they quake, “For now you see me as I truly am.”

It is not just kings and queens who are subject to this vanity and insecurity. A little power is a dangerous thing. Ormund Hightower (James Norton) is able to manipulate Ulf White (Tom Bennett), a commoner that Rhaenyra has elevated to a knight, by appealing to his vanity. “I understand who you really are,” Ormund assures Ulf, offering him a castle and a lordship. He promises, “They will laugh at you no more, when they see you as you are.” Ulf replies, “No. They will burn.”

Ormund is no less vain than Ulf. The character’s defining scene involves him rising from a bathtub. Ormund affects the appearance of an educated, refined and cultured man. He presents himself as just in public. However, his private actions belie this persona. When he loses a game of chess, he instinctively lashes out before recovering his more civilized affectation. After publicly punishing one of his men for assaulting a resident of Tumbleton, he privately has that resident murdered. Alicent observes that Ormund is not as smart as he likes to appear to be.

Even Mysaria is subject to such corruption. Trying to maintain some sense of order during Rheanyra’s reign, she reaches out to brothel owner Sylvi (Michelle Bonnard), promising to use her place in Rheanyra’s inner circle to help guide the ruler towards equity for the common folk. “You are changed,” Sylvi observes as Mysaria guides her into the throne room. “This has changed you.” Mysaria protests, “My heart is with the downtrodden as it has ever been.”

“Is it?” Sylvi wonders. “Or have you styled yourself a champion in order to access these halls? Look at you. Standing at the foot of a throne, wearing a silk worth a year of my earnings, promising to whisper into the ear of a queen. You thrill now to a tune you once abhorred.” She presses the point, “What power do you have in truth? Except to flatter and cajole? Is that why you called me here? To look on the trappings, so someone would hold you in awe?”

In its third season, House of the Dragon understands that if power as human beings understand it is an illusory concept that exists in the eye of the beholder, then the only true power that an individual can hold is to be perceived as powerful. Power becomes a sort of vacuum, a force that hollows out those who would wield it, turning them into constructs or cyphers or objects, rather than fully formed individuals with choice and agency.

This is hardly the most incisive understanding of power. It feels, like so much of House of the Dragon, like an observation shaped by the past decade of political life. Over the last ten years or so, unchecked narcissism has been the model of political ambition. It is not enough for those who hold power to be in positions of power, they must be perceived as such, printing their own names on longstanding institutions and reshaping the physical architecture to their whims.

There is a sense that even the individuals in the highest positions of power are motivated by base desires, such as an endless need for validation and love. In House of the Dragon, Rhaenyra is driven by her perceived place in prophecy, believing that her victory is pre-ordained and necessary for the long-term survival of the realm. That prophecy serves to justify every decision she makes and any compromise along the way. It is a bitter irony that the audience knows from Game of Thrones that the prophecy will inevitably end with thousands dead and the kingdom in ruins.

It is no small irony that the penultimate episode of the third season of House of the Dragon finds Queen Rhaenyra at the bedside of her half-sister Helaena, begging, “Tell me there has been no mistake, that I will prevail as the gods must surely intend. Tell me.” It is quite something for a woman who believes herself to be the most powerful person in the land to feel so impotent within her own narrative, so adrift that she longs for the lack of agency that predeterminism might offer.

If Varys was right and power is simply shadows on the wall, a performance in a puppet show lit by dragon fire, House of the Dragon understands that perhaps the only true power lies in making the audience watch.

Files

Comments

Lil' Cass (CJ)

"Power becomes a sort of vacuum, a force that hollows out those who would wield it, turning them into constructs or cyphers or objects, rather than fully formed individuals with choice and agency." As somebody who's experienced this firsthand in adulthood in so many ways, personally speaking, and is now trying to make sure never to experience that again, there is a lot of truth in what you said, Darren.