Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

If you're unhappy with anything I say here blame my discordians cos i'd actually deleted this by mistake and was happy leaving it in the ether BUT they like when I don't like things so HERE WE ARE!

Hope you fill up the comments hunnies.

So overall this felt very uninspiring and I hold TXT to such a HIGH bar because they're usually creative and brave and this was anything BUT. The title was a Deja Vu remake that isn't as good or original and the solo songs ... god, besides Taehyun's.

Upside Down Kiss is at least something though.

I suspect Love language's poor performance made them go the safer route because the boys were clearly excited about it, judging by how they sang it in the recording but sadly the knetz weren't feeling it. They'll be in a box like TWS I fear, such a shame but i hope they won't be discouraged for long.

That's my theory anyway.

Enjoy

Files

Comments

🐠

Idk to me it just feels like each solo was a different type of txt bside but... made less interesting lmao Definitely liked taehyun's the most I definitely agree it feels uninspired in comparison to their other projects and i hope they find their groove again soon. I like how much Beomgyu's voice stood out though

🐨

this is my first time commenting haha #kindanervous. as a huge moa, i do wish you enjoyed the album more but i do agree with some of your critiques 😞 i personally love the title track because txt trained as a hiphop group originally & it’s their first time doing the genre as a title track. also the note you made about the album sounding like a disbandment album is very interesting because the members actually mentioned this era being a ‘full stop’ to the lore they’ve been building since debut! they are actually in the middle of contract renewal too. i think with song of the stars, if you watched the concept trailer first then maybe this era would click more for you. i believe this album is purposefully more catered towards hardcore moas who have been following their storyline. my only issue with beautiful strangers is there being no bridge (2 minutes is criminal) 💔 but i do hope you check out the performances when they come out as yeonjun choreographed most of it!!! also upside down kiss choreo is pretty cool as well. i do agree with your comment about solo songs on albums. i was disappointed since it was their first full studio album in a while and i wanted more ot5 bsides, but i really enjoyed all the solos since it fits each members vibe. my only problem with it is huening kai and soobin having 0 credits on theirs. but anyway, on the bright side, with their ‘lore’ kinda coming to a stop, i’m sure they’ll have more of a chance to experiment with their music without having to tie it to their storyline any longer :)

old face magenta 1994

this must be how soobin feels when he gets degraded because i still enjoyed this regardless 😩 after letting it marinate for a bit i do agree that it feels a bit more uninspired than their other projects but also at the same time i think its full of some of their best vocal moments to date. taehyun’s solo is also my favorite out of the bunch ANYWAYS i never write long comments but i might be one of the discordians in question so 🩷 hopefully now that the lore is officially over they start bringing some new and fun stuff to the table like they always do!

old face magenta 1994

also forgot to add this but if/when the recording videos come out would you still be interested in those? or nah

🐨

just realised how long this comment is 😓 my bad … i’m just very passionate about txt ❤️ but i do hope you won’t rule them out based on this era hehe

Bamtorist

It’s very interesting the see the reactions to music wether good or bad cause I just love seeing the difference. To me this was an okay album and I think the main reason for that is the song lengths. All the songs are extremely short! Just when I started getting into the songs it ends… it’s a shame really. Overall it’s not like it’s horrible, but like you mentioned txt just has great music and I hold them to a high standard compared to other groups. The song that I enjoyed the most was taehyuns! I honestly can’t wait until he begins a solo journey, his voice is amazing!! I have hope that txt will regroup and big hit will finally let go of these short songs and really put their effort into their next comeback.

mereliza

this level of production on the solos is what i've come to expect whenever a project has a fan dedicated ballad + now member solos that seem to feed dedicated fans more than anyone else. they almost always feel a bit too OST-like to me, not horrid on the ears by any means but more placeholder/background music than a track that might provide them with a decent chance to show their charm and talent as individuals. definitely sounds like a transitional period for them but considering they're about to embark on a tour, i really wish their team had pulled this together in a different way!

🐠

STOPPP

Micah's K-Spot

I'd never rule them out lol they've built up a lot of goodwill. The long comment is fine but PLEASE use more paragraphs so it's easier to read. That's interesting lore regarding the contract and end of the era for the sounds!

meg k

i have the same sentiments about group albums with solo songs on them, they never really feel complete and just seem to be ticking the solo songs box and moving on with minimal effort. it’s a shame because txt albums are always so creative and typically expand into new sounds. this felt too safe for what they usually do. i was hoping for a full album of group songs, since this album is a wrap up of their lore. i have a theory this was just a familiar and easy end to all that lore stuff so they can experiment with more interesting sounds moving forward (theory or just wishful thinking?) i do think taehyun’s bird of night was the stand out of the solo songs. it’s a shame they put it at the end of the album. i think he has a good sense of music and what he wants to show through it, so i hope an actual solo debut is coming for him next. thanks for the video! i’m glad it didn’t disappear into the ether because it put words to what i was feeling while listening to the album. as a big txt fan, i wondered why this listening experience didn’t feel like the previous albums did. hopefully we get some more excitement on the next project! also sorry for the long wordy comment, i had a lot of thoughts i wanted to let out lol

Micah's K-Spot

Thank you!! Reading this makes me glad it didnt go into the ether also and i love long comments esp when they have beautiful paragraphs lol. Yes, Taehyun having a good sense of music is the best way to put it

Joy

I personally really like the album but I personally think of it as minisode tomorrow part 2. It’s very lore centric and it’s the closing of their lore from the members and companies statements so I’m assuming the next album will be very different (or at least I hope) I can see your “safe” comment and why you and I’m sure a lot of people think that but I believe big hit is focusing back on Korea and so far Korea is charting the whole album on all the charts so unless they focus back on the west I don’t see anything changing for this year.

🐨

ah yes i’ll definitely do that next time sorry 😅 & glad to hear that!!!

Shay

gonna have to unfortunately agree with most of your takes here. TXT are my ult of ults, my babies, but I just haven't been able to get behind them recently. Its such a shame falling out of love with a groups music, because I still love the boys so much. Idk whats changed, but I think they need to take a step back, maybe even a break to re-find themselves! Right now their music is almost coming off as this image their trying to force out, and its not natural. They were PRIME in 2020-2023, I wish we could go back to that era of their music. Me personally, I haven't LOVED an album since temptation, which is a shame considering its almost been two years since then. Of course I have songs that I've liked like deja vu, some songs on the freefall album, and even upside down kiss and beomgyu and taehyuns solo on this album. But as a WHOLE, their albums haven't hit for me in awhile. Also speaking of beomgyus solo, I'm definitely biased when I say this (hello, he's literally my pfp), but I actually liked it and it reminded me of his other solo song Panic. Its def beomgyus sound. anyways sorry for rambling lolol. I just hope maybe next album txt can rope me back into their music, because it didnt really happen with this one. Its a shame because as you said, the bar is just so high with them bc they usually DELIVER.

Joy

Forgot to mention so I’ll make a new comment but for the solos beomgyu produced his own (hence why it’s very beomgyu and to his taste) and Taehyun worked on his lyrical along with Yeonjun The rest of the members were given multiple song options and they picked from the options on what they wanted to pick from, so I get the not as genuine comments bc we were also shocked the members weren’t as heavily involved. Only difference is that Yeonjun’s solo has been charting higher than the title track on kcharts

Verner Cole

I was going to add a comment but don't need to now because this sums up my feelings exactly.

Andie

The title track definitely felt like Deja Vu Pt.2 but didn't expand on what was already an AMAZING title track. I actually enjoyed Song of the Stars. But I already knew it probably wasn't gonna be your vibe. I agree it's a shame Love Language didn't perform that well domestically and I was honestly SHOCKED that they didn't even include it in the album. I was under the impression that it was a single to promote this album...but I guess not :/

Andie

I forgot to add this but I wish that bighit would let txt be in there rock/punk bag again because it suited them so well. They don't need to reheat nachos but...at least go to the grocery store and pick up some of the ingredients please

Micah's K-Spot

Like it's sooo weird that they get songs to just pick and it sounds like it. I'm not surprised with Yeonjun's charting, he is supperr popular!

Kay

idk the Contract Renewal is coming soon maybe they wanted to keep it safe

Morgan

I’m so glad you posted this! I’m glad I’m not the only one disappointed. I feel bad because it seems like they’re really pushing this comeback, but I only really love “Bird of Night”—THAT SONG. I’ve been looping it; I love it so much!

lelo

Yeah I didn’t like this album that much too i liked taehyun’s song but that’s it. I also believe not everyone should make solo songs some vocalist are better with group

Nina Sera

The difference in the thumbnail between here and YouTube😂😂

Nina Sera

Am I a masochist bc I love when you hate things I love? Lolol jkjk but you always have great thoughts and suggestions for how things could’ve been better, although I could tell you were fully over this one😂 Loved Taehyun’s track, definitely the stand out, and Beomgyu’s is very him and I LOVE the vocals (partially bc we never get to hear them lol) Yeonjun and Kai I think went slightly out of their comfort zones, I would’ve expected them to do each others songs rather than the ones they picked, but definitely still safe. (One advantage of being a basic bitch who doesn’t know much about music is that I can still enjoy basic songs so I don’t mind either of those😂) Soobin sweetie…well it sounds exactly like what I expected but let’s skip the solo music and go straight to acting babe😭 I loved watching the smile slowly creep over your face during Taehyun’s song and then was yelling “no don’t do it!” at the screen when song if the stars came up cause I knew it was gonna bring the mood down all over again💀 Overall like you said pretty safe, I’m interested to see if they do switch it up at all post lore. Thanks for feeding the children!😂

lollaaaxx

I was really excited for this album honestly :( I really enjoyed hearing beomgyu he has such a rich voice that bighit doesn't utilise enough so I love hearing his solos! but other than that and song of the stars - which only really moves me as its like a look back on txt since debut - this album didn't meet my expectations.

Micah's K-Spot

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHH you are a masochist indeed. The album should've ended with Taehyun's song :'(!! Thanks for writing such a fun comment

TMJ

Couldnt agree more. This was disappointing…

Caitlyn

Haven't listened to the album yet but the title track being only 2:18 is almost turning me off completely. ENOUGH!!