Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey everyone! So welcome to the first HCC Poll! this one is going to be a bit open ended, so please read through it and comment what you think!

So, by its very nature, the Chaos Gacha is chaotic. I have already stated that I have final veto rights for rolls big or small that might ruin the story, but there is another concept that I am interested in hearing the audience's opinions on.

Custom rolls.

While the gacha has a huge variety of possible roles, it doesn't have everything. So, the question is, would it be meta breaking if I occasionally inserted rolls that I thought were cool, that led the story in a certain direction, or just did cool stuff. There could be various rules to this, such as:

  • I can only do a custom roll when certain criteria are met, like when he rolls the same thing twice.

  • The option must be peer reviewed with a poll before used

  • They must stay under a certain power level

  • The custom cards must roll a curse one the curse wheel

Or, I could just put one in when I thought it appropriate.

As usual, for such an open ended, and narrative important concept, this is me more looking for what you guys think, rather than a concrete decision. Still, you guys never fail to see things from perspectives I haven't considered, so these are always very useful. If you have any thoughts, please comment!

Comments

BarrettSlayer

I wouldn’t mind custom rolling, is the idea to have a bunch of custom things you think would be cool or interesting on a separate spin and roll for which gets chosen on that instead of the normal one?

avatarjedi

I’m pro custom rolls. Make a poll of like ten and choose the top three whenever you want to do it. Or do something like adding powers from CYOAs and have the CP costs match a tier. Free and up to 150 for bronze, up to 250 for silver, 350 for gold, etc. Or if you do a worm CYOA tier 1 for bronze, etc.

Miguel Garcia

I like the idea of custom rolls requiring some low chance event like him rolling an reward he already has. Especially if you are obvious about it and the gacha says something like he gets the custom reward as compensation and the reward that was hit twice is removed permanently from his gacha. This does have the drawback (or benefit?) of it becoming increasingly likely that a double roll will occur as the story goes on. So you may want to decide if all double roll possibilities get removed when there is a hit and the double roll probability resets to 0. The latter would help with balance if you want to make the custom rewards more powerful.

Urbane_Bomber

I think Custom rolls are a good idea. I do have a question though, if we get custom rolls, does that stop things like getting modifications in shipyards?

andrew rousseau

Sounds fine to me, edit also a little sad i thought there was another chap already lol since i just saw the harrower title

Memory Dump

I mean, it works for WikiWarrior, so I don't see why not

Koren Tiquar

Do what you want. I trust you to make it a good story.

James Hyden-Shepherd

Go for custom rolls, could be good to add even more variety and give the story a but more direction from yourself rather than just rhe whims of the dice

Caelen Burrows

From my perspective the gacha is best used as an aid for creativity, not a leash. If you as the writer have something in mind that you are excited to include then the story will likely benefit from that enthusiasm. Similarly, if the story is crying out for some component to make the narrative more interesting or to solve something that is bogging it down you as the author can recognize and address that in a way a generalized and randomized list can't. The gacha can present problems and sideways solutions or paths of progression you may have never considered or wouldn't have explored as your first option. In that way it can be an interesting and useful tool to stimulate creative thinking and push you into new creative spaces. Whatever degree of use or restrictions you find keeps the gacha a tool that inspires you instead of frustrates will probably serve the story, and your experience writing it, best. Especially of note is that our protagonist has repeatedly commented that they aren't acquiring tickets at a rate they think they normally would. Add on the limited slots to that issue. Without the correcting factor of large numbers of rolls randomness very well could lead to a string of duds or over saturation of one category over others. The later can be addressed a bit by rewarding tickets that roll in specific categories, and an interesting conversation might be had about those kinds of tickets being tied to certain kinds of achievements. If our protagonist notices a pattern and develops some agency in seeking out situations where they have a chance to acquire certain kinds of tickets that itself might make for interesting creative restrictions. Personally, if I were going to put a restriction on custom rolls for myself I would probably set some kind of meta-level wildcard checkpoint system. Easiest to track would be number of chapters, another might be overall number of tickets acquired or tickets in a certain category of slot or grade acquired. Pass a threshold and you unlock the option to insert a custom roll, without the mandate to use it right then. As a writer you don't have to include something just because you rolled a double, from a Doylist/Watsonian perspective curses don't have to accompany certain rolls that otherwise might seem indistinguishable from their peers. Depending on how permissive or restrictive you set the thresholds you can ensure that the ratio of randomness to intentionality is in a place you like while being strategic about when you deploy that choice. As a reader I am here for your writing, not an interest or dedication to the chaos gacha. I want to see what you do with a story about someone who navigates the premise, how the world reacts to them, and the relationships that develope throughout. As long as you are enjoying the process of writing the story, I couldn't care less whether you ever actually rolled or they were all custom. I've already been shown across multiple works that you will write something worth reading.

C Dos

Since you were thinking of adding the curse as a result why not make it an in story thing, as in he can convert a silver gatcha token into a specific ability etc of that level in exchange for the curse or something. I just feel if you are customising the gatcha in such a way you may as well make it in universe.

icedragon512

Throw us a poll when you think something fun could be added

Fortunis

I vote do what you want. Its a writing tool not a rule book. If you think something is missing or story breaking then fix it 🤷.

Chad Wiggins

Do whatever you think will lead to the best story. Whether you poll it, or just insert it I am fine either way. I look forward to your story and can’t wait for more chapters

OdinMage

I think people are not understanding exactly what you mean by 'custom rolls'. How I took it was you choosing something specific from the Chaos Gacha that would help the story along in some way rather than actually rolling. But some of the other commenters seem to think you mean you creating custom perks/items/powers/familiars to use. Clarification might be helpful. That aside, I'm fine with custom rolls either way. I wouldn't want it to happen EVERY roll, but when you roll something a second time, or when it will benefit the story or send things in a new direction that you couldn't do without gaining that thing is more than fine with me.