The Economics of Self-Publishing (Patreon)
Content
A few people have asked whether The Elf Who Would Become A Dragon will be released as an eBook and in print.
My answer is that I don't know.
Most people don't realise that publishing properly is very expensive. The labour costs involved are not trivial. To help you understand why, allow me to break down the expenses associated with publishing your 100k-word book; we'll assume the manuscript is finished, and we won't include the costs of living while writing it.
A key fact to internalise is that people value work based on perceived relative quality. This means that for a book to succeed, it has to match the professionalism of the marketplace it's being published in. If the cover looks cheap, or the content reads poorly, it will be passed over and fail to sell.
Cut corners, lose sales.
First step: editing. Let's assume you're god's gift to literature, and so you don't require any developmental editing (someone reading the story and advising you of changes to make in order to improve it) or line editing (someone reading the story and proposing changes to paragraphs and sentences to improve the flow). You're still going to need a copyeditor to read through the manuscript and hunt for obvious grammar issues and typos.
The standard rate for a qualified copyeditor is $0.02 a word (or $45 an hour at ~2250 words an hour). Some people charge less than this because they're new and want to build a portfolio, but not by much, and the lower they charge the less experienced they are and the less confident you can be in their work. You get what you pay for, and if you cheapen out on a bad copy edit, that's money down the drain.
Copyediting for 100,000 words is $2000 on average; by comparison, being fantasy, TEWWBAD's first volume is ~126,000 and each of the three thereafter are 200k+.
Next up is cover art, which requires commercial licensing rights. In practice, you want to outright own the rights for the cover art – including the rights to any design work done to create it – so that you won't run into issues further down the line; this can often double the cost of commissioning the art. You also need a good artist if you want to both match your genre and stand out within it, and good artists are expensive.
I am not joking when I say that the cover art for big books can cost as much as mid-five figures. If you hunt around to find a cheaper artist with a good style you can bring the cost down to low four-figures, but the lower you go the more work you have to put in keeping the artist on track. If you have strong art direction skills and can take the time, you might get good work for less. Assuming you do and you can, cover art will probably cost $2500.
For print editions, you're also dealing with the spine and the back of the book, needing larger art to cover them. Expect to pay more.
We now come to the issue of cover layout, putting the text on and making it look good. You might assume this is trivial; you would be wrong. Look carefully at the title on the web serial cover for TEWWBAD:
Note that the font lettering has been modified from the standard font, and then look closely: see the very subtle red bordering the letters, and the different red shading the background behind them? This work to both identify a good title style and then make it legible against the art is professional. I had to pay a designer for this. Without it, you're relying on your own skills.
By the way, do you know the dimensions for book sizes on Amazon? Do you understand resolution specifications and colour spaces, and how they differ between art for digital and print editions? Have you thought about the cover art as it will fit with the title etc? The less you know, the more you definitely need the services of a designer to help you, and you need to talk to them before commissioning the artist.
For cover layout from a professional, you're probably looking at $500. Print edition also needs the spine and back cover laid out, which includes correctly calculating the spine width based on the number of pages, which depends on interior layout...
And so we come to interior layout of the book. For digital editions, this can be done yourself if you're prepared take the time to learn how XHTML works and assemble the ePub using a program like Sigil. You can try relying on automated conversion tools, but unfortunately they're not perfect, and actually not very good at all if you have anything approaching complicated layout or text effects.
If you can't do these things, have advanced text effects, or you're intending to do a print edition, a layout designer is likely necessary. Expect to pay at least another $500 for a straightforward layout.
What about the blurb? Many successful authors hire expert blurb writers to make sure the text recommending the book is good sales copy. Prices vary, but $500 or for a solid blurb isn't unusual.
Let's summarise. For an 100k word eBook, assuming you are very hands-on (and therefore spending time doing things other than writing), only have copyediting done, and handle the blurb and interior layout yourself, you're looking at around $5000 to create the finished product. If you're also doing a print version, $5500. Budgeting for costs overrun, you'll want to add another $500 on top.
We haven't talked about the costs of advertising, both on Amazon and through the many, many different promotion methods outside of Amazon. $1000 is a conservative estimate for a decent book launch; I've spent that much on advertising for the web serial on Royal Road alone, just to grow my readership (and by extension this Patreon).
So rolling it all together, for a single 100k word book launched in eBook and print semi-professionally, you're looking at needing to budget ~$7000. If you want to lower that cost you either cut corners or learn to do things yourself, but cutting costs directly impacts on returns.
How much do you get for selling? Margins on eBooks are roughly 70% of list price, so for every $10 in sales you receive $7. Print books, including print-on-demand (which is the only viable option unless you have warehouse space and are prepared to handle shipping) have large costs (Amazon's example is $1.00 plus $0.012 per page for a standard sized book, so $7 for a 500 page book), and readers have a limit on how much they'll pay, which means your margins shrink significantly. Assuming you charge $10 for a 500 page book, you're left with $2.10 after the costs and Amazon's cut are subtracted.
Let's run the numbers. You're spending somewhere in the region of $7000 launching your book properly, and you're probably selling it for $5 eBook and $10 print, earning $3.50 and $2.10 respectively per sale.
You would need to sell 2000 eBooks or 3334 print books just to break even, not counting the opportunity costs of the time you spent overseeing the development of the editions rather than writing. And again, this is assuming you're spending the bare minimum while matching professional quality to compete in the market.
TEWWBAD's first story is four books. That's not an arbitrary division: there's limits to the spine size of print-on-demand books that put a limit on the maximum number of pages, and too many pages in an eBook puts off potential readers (there's a reason the first volume of TEWWBAD is shorter, close to the conventional 125k for fantasy novels). Averaged, the four books of the series come out to 188k each, which means the copyediting costs for all four would be in the region of $15,040 at $0.02 per word.
Add commercial art and a designer to do cover layout, and even if I'm handling everything else myself with zero budget for cost overruns, we're talking ~$27,040 just to release all four volumes as eBooks. I can probably push that down to $24,000... but it's money I don't have.
I'm making $3,320 a month on Patreon. It's my sole income. I pay my rent and groceries with that money, and I'm going to get smacked by a double-sized tax bill this year thanks to the Payment on Account rules for people who're self-employed in the UK.
Okay, self-publishing sucks. What about traditional publishing?
Absolute shitshow.
To get your foot in the door there you need an agent who'll take 15% of everything you earn. Then the publishers screw authors in many ways, often causing their work to underperform or fail: they assert creative control over title, cover, and blurb; they decide everything about release and usually spend nothing on marketing; and they pay around 7% of the cover price per sale.
This is just scratching the surface. In practice, they don't want anything from new authors that isn't a sure bet, and they're all ridiculously out of touch with the market.
What about indie publishers? They don't have much money, so they're quite reluctant to gamble on books that don't have a clearly established market to sell to (i.e. there's an identified audience who're hungry to buy books just like it). I spoke to an indie publisher, and they said that TEWWBAD had too few readers and, bluntly, they didn't know how to market it.
This is the reality I'm dealing with: I'm earning just enough from the Patreon to cover my immediate household expenses (which are higher than I'd like thanks to my disabilities), with nothing left over for emergencies or to increase my savings. I've not hit my income target for the Patreon; I hope you can see now that it wasn't arbitrary.
Thanks for reading,
LJ