Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello everyone,

Just a writing update today. I've spent the last week reading tremendous amounts of material on the medieval period in Europe, deepening my understanding of what life was actually like for ordinary people of the time. You'd be surprised by how much of what popular culture teaches us is completely and utterly wrong. A few highlights:

  • Medieval people bathed regularly. Bathhouses (distinct from brothels — which commonly centred around bathing) were common and regulated for decency in cities, and even peasants in rural communities washed up before and after meals. The reason people wrongly believe nobody bathed is because the act of taking a big bath (such as filling a tub by the fire with warm water or going to the bath house) was regarded as an enjoyable luxury, the equivalent of having a spa day, and so the religious texts of the time exhorted people not to "bathe" often but to focus on piety. This wasn't about cleanliness: it was scolding people who liked to gossip/have sex at the local bathhouse.

  • What we know as Feudalism didn't really exist. The reality of how society was structured was much more bespoke, ornate, and varied across region and period; social relations couldn't be reduced to a simple feudal hierarchy. Even the peasantry were not all one class, but divided along three separate axes of legal status (freemen without legal obligations, land tenants under legal obligations to their local lord, un-landed tenants under local legal obligations to their lord, and slaves), economic status (wealthy land tenants with surplus, subsistence land tenants, un-landed day labourers and other workers), and social status (old families of good standing, ordinary families, and strangers/outsiders). While royal law nominally prevailed across each kingdom, everything else was idiosyncratic, and everyone got along mostly on shared social norms and conventions.

  • Amusingly, all the warring families stuff from reality TV is literally how the peasants in the villages used to behave — and the origin of the phrase "the devil makes work for idle hands." When there was no shared agricultural work to be done in the cold months, they'd end up drinking, screwing, and quarrelling. The local bailiff (who was essentially the local overseer for the lord) worked closely with whoever the village elected to lead the community for the year to try to keep a lid on things. Some of the court records I've read are hysterically funny, as you see the same families coming before the court repeatedly, to the extent you can feel the exasperation of the clerk writing the record when he resorts to using phrases like "troubles of old" to explain the recurring dispute.

  • Oh, and the local "tavern" was just the home of whoever in the village had most recently brewed ale and opened their doors to their neighbours. Most ale and beer were brewed by women — hence "brewster," from the same etymology as "spinster."

  • The oppression of women was real but not as intense as we're led to believe. Women did have legal rights, albeit restricted compared to men, and they could practice many professions independently so long as they abided by the overall social compact on how they were to conduct themselves. Curiously, sex work was tolerated (even accepted as a necessity by Saint Augustine and Saint Thomas Aquinas), and while sex workers were sinning by engaging in sex for reasons other than reproduction, all they had to do to reform their social standing was either stump up the money to join a convent as a nun or get married. There wasn't much lasting stigma against former sex workers.

(Edit: the above is my comment on 'trad' portrayals of how women behaved In Ye Olde Days; a lot of it is the invention of modern misogyny, mere political propaganda. I'm not saying that women weren't oppressed, I'm saying that the notion that women in medieval Europe were little more than chattel slaves who had no independent lives apart from their families is utterly fictitious.)

  • This reflects a major cultural difference: the Christian principle of forgiveness was very, very important. Refusing to forgive someone who made restitution and undertook penance was intensely shameful, even sinful; and choosing to forgive someone their debts was considered pious and demonstrative of great virtue. There's an example in one of the court records, wherein a couple publicly maligned one of their neighbours – in the church yard! – and were subsequently found guilty of slander and fined heavily, with the slandered party then forgiving all the awarded damages but for a token amount and an apology. This apparently wasn't uncommon, and it makes sense when considering how long-running feuds could wear on communities. Why pick a fight that your great-grandchildren might carry on?

Research is taking longer than anticipated, but I'm getting good stuff. To be clear, I'm not going to be writing an entirely authentic medieval society — what I'm looking to do is check my assumptions and correct my ignorance before I proceed to write a grounded fantasy in which magic exists. If, while reading TEWWBAD, you've ever wondered "How does a medieval society in which some people can conjure precious metals actually engage in trade?" then you'll be pleased to hear that my original explanation (which was irrelevant to the first story and so left out) hasn't yet been contradicted by any of this additional research. My aim is for the societies I write to feel human, to better contrast with the fantastical elements.

I've also been plotting. The next book is outlined but for a few minor beats, and I have a good idea how I'll be writing it; the subsequent books are broadly outlined, but need a little more time to develop. Without getting into spoilers, I'm increasingly confident that this story is going to satisfy existing readers while also working as a good starting point for people who didn't see the appeal of the first story.

Fingers crossed, I'll begin the exploratory draft on Wednesday/Thursday.

Otherwise? The business side of modern authorship continues apace. The cover of the next story has been commissioned, and I'm meeting with an expert this week to discuss how I might position the first story for launch in the wider Amazon market. I've also been told by contacts that there's a fair few indie publishers who're interested in bringing it to market, but none of them have made an approach yet.

(If an indie or trad publisher happens to be reading this: I'm not against being approached, but to contemplate signing I'd be looking for a strong offer that respects my creative control while including a concrete, dollar-denominated plan for bringing the work to market and advertising it. What can you do for me that I can't do myself?)

Anyway, that's how the work's going for now. More to come next Monday.

Thanks for reading,

LJ

Comments

Cacus Magic

Maybe check out "the Shining Wyrm" by Nighzmarquls on Royal Road they seem to have done quite thorough research on medieval times for their story and they post their sources from time to time. It's also just a great story.

Arusalan

On bathhouses, I don't know much about medieval ones but Roman ones were quite foul. Communal bathing is gross

CastorInvictus

The believability of the Woodlands society was a load-bearing pillar of the story. A less plausible society couldn't have been Saphienne's antagonist successfully. So it's great to hear that the human societies she'll venture through in the future will be no less believable. Unrelatedly - I wonder if Sapphienne can still cast magic in the elven style or if her magic is now all obviously draconic (to the second sight of other practioners). It'll be harder to hide from elven spies if every mage marks her castings as draconic.

Circux

Not me reading this then going into a deep dive because I thought beer (specifically the use of hops for its aseptic properties) was invented only in late middle age / early renaissance and wanted confirmation (I was wrong. It was created by nuns in the 11th century. Monastery had a big role in beer making (and lots of other social stuff). Makes sense: while fasting you could still drink beer.)

Circux

Oh, I was wrong^2, the creation is 9th century, but perfecting the craft and spread is 13th century and later. Reinheitsgebot is 1516.

Vitor Bosshard

Speaking of research, let's talk demographics. If people live up to several thousands of years, then the density of children we observe in the Eastern Vale must be highly atypical for society as a whole. Having entire cohorts of children only a few years apart would imply that the woodlands are growing explosively and can't possibly be stable for thousands of years. In pre-modern times, a human society might be 30%+ children under 15. I roughly eyeballed this from a world population pyramid of 1900. That is with short lifespans and high child mortality. In a demographically stable elven society, let's take the average lifespan to be 750 years (based on 1000 being considered an elder, which is respectable but not vanishingly rare), and we assume that children actually have lower mortality than adults (consistent with the story, investing resources and care into children on par with 21st century developed countries, and magic being at least as good as modern medicine). I don't feel like drawing up an entire population pyramid, and in any case the causes of deaths for elves have not been discussed much. So let's just ballpark it very sloppily and assume that 15/750 = 2% of the population would be under 15 at any given time (This is equivalent to stating that all elves spontaneously die at exactly 750 years old, having produced exactly one offspring). To support any kind of "school system" with dedicated minders and so on, you'd need a population of around 2.5k (= 50 children) *within walking distance* of the town center, which is way larger and denser than the story describes. This density would imply that pretty much all land in the town is dedicated to housing (since we have no apartment buildings). But I got the impression from the story that houses were scattered few and far between (perhaps in small clusters) with most of the land covered in forests, glades for frolicking, etc. Now, you did mention offhand that some other location was an "older community", so the eastern vale might be more focused on raising children, and thus attract parents from all over, and could plausibly have 3-5x as many children as other places. Furthermore, since property is essentially shared, parents would have ample opportunity to move close to each other without financial impact. Hmm, now that I did some back-of-the-envelope math, I think the story remains within the bounds of the plausible. I'm curious if my mental image is off in some way though :) ETA: oh, and food is mostly imported from outside their own communities, so land use for that is close to zero.

Vitor Bosshard

Speaking of bathing, consider the German term "Katzenwäsche" (cat's bath). It means cleaning yourself with a sponge, washcloth, etc, not sure if there is an equivalent English term. I assume in medieval societies daily hygiene went more along these lines than bathing. Another possible source of confusion is that chivalric orders sometimes had it in their code of conduct to bathe at least once a week (I vaguely remember reading about this in a book, but it was decades ago and it might itself be an anachronistic claim). However, to me it makes sense to interpret it as a requirement *while traveling*, i.e., don't neglect hygiene even under adverse circumstances. It also brings to mind the islamic requirement for frequent handwashing, which was in practice often satisfied by using sand instead of water, which sounds crazy on first encounter. However, sand is abrasive and absorbs fats reasonably well, so it's not just a ritual substitute. Cold ashes are also a great way to clean your hands, I can confirm this from personal experience.

L. J. Amber

I am sharing nothing, other than to say I sat down and worked out the demographics of the elves very carefully. The story is constrained by Saphienne's perspective, in that there are things she doesn't think about that don't get commented on.

tristan howard

Might I ask what sources you are usibg for your research, I d be interested in learning more about Midieval Europe

L. J. Amber

I'll recommend my favourites when I'm done.

oneirosophis

The term "cat's bath" is cute, the English language equivalent is rather more vulgar and refers to sex workers quickly washing themselves between clients.

Ornery Walrus

She was shown to have been able to use both. I believe her main impediment to elven magic outside the vale will be lack of access to runes of increasingly higher tiers. I don’t believe she has any elven runes of the 4th tier.