Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

UPDATED POLL, PLEASE VOTE AGAIN - Next Series to Read for Book Club - (Shoujo/Vibesy edition)

  • Orange 47
  • Aqua/Aria - (Aloha's Pick) 93
  • Yokohama Shopping Log - (Jello's Pick) 213
  • Revolutionary Girl Utena 187
  • 2025-04-16
  • —2025-04-22
  • 540 votes
{'title': 'UPDATED POLL, PLEASE VOTE AGAIN - Next Series to Read for Book Club - (Shoujo/Vibesy edition)', 'choices': [{'text': 'Orange', 'votes': 47}, {'text': "Aqua/Aria - (Aloha's Pick)", 'votes': 93}, {'text': "Yokohama Shopping Log - (Jello's Pick)", 'votes': 213}, {'text': 'Revolutionary Girl Utena', 'votes': 187}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 4, 22, 23, 15, 12, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 4, 16, 23, 52, 10, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 540}

Content

EDIT: PLEASE UPDATE YOUR VOTES IF YOU VOTED FOR UTENA

It's come to our attention that the manga for Revolutionary Girl Utena is both very difficult to find in English and also has a dubious reputation among fans of the series for a variety of reasons, namely for being a slightly different take on the series and, critically, less gay. SMH. It seems it would be best to read it as part of a holistic look at the franchise including the anime, which is a little outside the scope of this book club. As such, we'll be taking Utena off the poll.

I cannot update the poll on this post without deleting it and starting over, so instead of Utena the fourth option will now be Rose of Versailles.

If you would like to vote for Rose of Versailles, please click the Utena option below.

It's time once again to pick the next manga we'll be covering in our Patreon book club!

Up until this point we've mostly focused on series with big action/adventure/shonen/thriller elements, so Aloha and I want to shift gears and read something lighter. We've selected four options that are either shoujo or slice of life.

For those new to the Patreon, book club meets every two weeks (usually on weekends). We assign a number of volumes to read, everyone goes their separate ways, finds a place to read the series in question, and then we come back and talk about it. Fun! Previously we've covered Golden Kamuy, Pluto, Dungeon Meshi, Pokemon Adventures, and other stuff.

I've put some images and basic descriptions of each of the four options below.

Please vote for the option you are most interested in reading at the bottom of this post. The poll will close on Sunday the 20th and we will schedule the first meeting afterwards.

Orange (2012) - 7 Volumes

One morning, Naho Takamiya receives a letter in the mail claiming to be from herself 10 years in the future. The letter reveals a series of events that are supposed to take place that day. At first, Naho thinks it's just a prank; but when the letter mentions a transfer student named Kakeru Naruse, who really does end up transferring into her class later that day, she is forced to believe in its contents.As Naho continues to read the letter, her future self mentions several regrets, urging Naho to take the right decisions now. Somehow these regrets all seem to be connected to Kakeru, and with the burden of the knowledge that the boy wouldn't be with her and her friends in the future, will Naho be able to make the perfect choices that will alter what seems to be fate?

AQUA (2001) - 2 Volumes, and its sequel ARIA - 12 Volumes

The year is 2301, one hundred and fifty years since terraforming operations began on the planet Aqua—formerly known as Mars—causing it to be almost entirely covered with water. Aqua's capital, Neo-Venezia, is a near-perfect copy of the city of Venice back on Manhome—previously known as Earth. Citizens and tourists alike take their time exploring the city and admiring its rustic charm, especially by riding one of the many gondolas gliding along the waterways.

Chasing her dream of becoming a tour guide of Neo-Venezia (called an undine), Manhome native Akari Mizunashi begins her training as an apprentice at the Aria Company.

Yokohama Shopping Log (1994) - 14 Volumes

Set in a peaceful, post-cataclysmic world where mankind is in decline after an environmental disaster. Exactly what happened is never explained, but sea levels have risen significantly and climate change has occurred. The reduced human population has reverted to a simpler life, and the reader is told this is the twilight of the human age. Instead of raging against their fate, humans have quietly accepted it.

Alpha Hatsuseno is an android who runs an out-of-the-way coffee shop, Café Alpha, on the lonely coast while her human "owner" is on a trip of indefinite length. Though she spends much of her time alone, Alpha is cheerful, gregarious, and—unlike the slowly declining humans—immortal.

Most chapters are self-contained slice-of-life episodes depicting Alpha in daily activities, either alone, with customers, or on occasional trips through the countryside or into Yokohama for supplies. Whole chapters are devoted to brewing coffee, taking photographs, or repairing a tiny model aircraft engine, sometimes with only a few lines of dialogue. Through Alpha's experiences, the author brings out the small wonders of everyday life and makes the reader aware of their passing: the aircraft engine runs out of fuel; her scooter breaks down; the rising ocean encroaches on her coffee shop; the neighborhood children she loves grow up and move away. In evoking a nostalgia for this loss, Ashinano follows the Japanese tradition of mono no aware (sadness for the transience of things).

Rose of Versailles (1973 👵) - 14 Volumes

A historical fiction and one of the most influential series of all time, particularly for "Lady Oscar" who basically invented the "princely girl" trope.

In a time of class stratification and rising tensions amongst the impoverished population, the Austrian Empire sends Princess Marie Antoinette to France to be wed to Crown Prince Louis XVI. The political marriage is arranged to strengthen the alliance between both countries, but the future queen is deeply unsatisfied with her fate being decided for her. Upon arrival in the country, Marie Antoinette is acquainted with Oscar Fançois de Jarjayes—Commander of the Royal Guard.

Due to her father's desire for a son, Oscar is raised as a boy with an expectation to inherit his title as The Commander. As Oscar reluctantly serves the young, spoiled queen, the growing resentment and suffering of the poor become harder for her to ignore—especially when Marie Antoinette frivolously spends her wealth.

If you would like to cast your vote for Rose of Versailles, please click the "Utena" button below.

Files

Comments

Crimson Claw

For purely selfish reasons: Utena I've been really putting off watching it and listening to a book club about it might make me finally get around to that

Huebert Keeper

*whispers into the night* kageki shoujoooo

Jules

The poll only lets you vote for one option. With that said, I’d love to see you cover Orange or Utena!

JelloApocalypse

Shhh shhh I forgot how awful Patreon polls are and that you can't edit them after posting even if nobody has voted yet, so it's just one vote per person now shhhhhh

JoeJoeBinks97

I'd suggest for a future one either After the Rain (10 volumes; 5 two-in-one volumes) or Skip and Loafer (11 volumes-).

Champ Bob

You've been betrayed by Patreon polls yet again!

Huebert Keeper

Yeah that's valid. I'm just in the middle of rereading what's out so far loo

Dephony O

"and legendarily gay" say less sir

Jurei

I’ve wanted to read Orange for a little bit, this would be a good chance if it wins

dizzy ditzy

Utena, mostly because I wanna see how everyone reacts to the differences between the manga, the anime, and Adolescence

Crystal

Utena would be interesting but the manga is wildly different from the anime (and is simply not as good. it's not even that gay. there's a character who's a lesbian in the anime who gets straightwashed in the manga.), so I'm voting for Orange.

caramel

nooo not the utena manga

PrettiestBeardedLady

I'll be happy with any but I voted for Utena because while I haven't read it yet, I do own the collectors edition box set lol

Aqua Allison

My thoughts as I read this post. “Oooh, Aqua and Yokohama both sound really good, I’d be down to read either of those and actually join the book club this time-oh god DAMMIT there’s no way Utena doesn’t win.” Not to beat the deadest of internet horses, but I know Utena is on record as being one of Rebecca Sugar’s inspirations for Steven Universe, and that instantly makes me less interested to be frank. I have cast my vote for Yokohama, I hope we at least do it next.

Violet DB

Ooh, I recently watched the movie Flow, which covers a lot of what Yokohama's themes look to be but isn't very good, so I'm voting for yokohama to hopefully explore them in a better way.

Crystal

Okay, as a Big Utena Fan I really gotta lock in and advocate *against* Utena here. For several reasons. 1. Not only is the manga out of print, but one of the volumes is *nowhere* online (not in English, anyway). There was supposed to be a reprint of the deluxe boxset (which contains the original 5 volumes + the Adolescence manga - that's the one that's impossible to find - but does NOT include After the Revolution) like three weeks ago but it got delayed by like two months. If you want to read this manga, you are going to have a bad time. In particular, if you consider the Utena manga to be 7 volumes, you're going to be pulling teeth tracking down volume 6 (Adolescence), because again, it's not even online (unless you speak Spanish)! Right now *only* ways to read the manga are to either A. try your luck at the secondhand market (which gets expensive - I've seen listings go for hundreds of dollars, and Adolescence is especially tough to find so you pretty much have to get the boxset - and AtR is still sold separately), B. read a shoddy scanlation (it is not very good, especially the early chapters - it's also tedious to even find a complete translation of the original 5 volumes, and I haven't seen Adolescence in English *anywhere* online. AtR *does* have good scans that are relatively easy to track down, but that's literally the last volume), or C. learn Japanese (or Spanish, if you're a dedicated pirate). This is not an accessible item for the vast majority of people who would be interested - it's not even easy to pirate. 2. It is, frankly, a mistake to treat the first five volumes (parallel to the 39 episode TV anime), the Adolescence manga ("volume 6" - an adaptation of the movie), and After the Revolution ("volume 7" - a 20 years later epilogue) as one continuous story of 7 volumes. An understandable mistake that no sane person would be mad at you for making, but an error nonetheless. The first five volumes are their own continuity, Adolescence is separate from that. Same goes for the 39 episode TV anime and the movie (also called Adolescence). They are companion pieces, but as far as continuity is concerned they are mutually exclusive. You cannot reconcile these differences, and frankly it'd be missing the point to even try. They are all different takes on the same premise with some of the same core beats shared between them. As for After the Revolution, that one picks various bits from every other piece of Utena media (and different Utena media actively contradict each other), so it's not really a coherent sequel to any of them. Not the show, not the movie, not even the 5 volume manga, despite expecting you to be familiar with all three. It is its own beast. 3. The manga (as in the first five volumes - Adolescence and AtR are their own separate things) is, quite frankly, the *worst* way to experience Utena. It's not the worst read in the world on its own, but it is very drastically different from the anime in a way that is *guaranteed* to disappoint you if you're only familiar with how hyped up the anime is. The story and themes are very watered down (or rather half-baked, as it was made while the show was still in pre-production) and it's not even that gay (at least by comparison - this is in part because the mangaka, Chiho Saito, simply could not comprehend a love story between two women that does not end in tragedy being publishable in the late 90s. she actively tried (and did not succeed) to push back *against* the anime and film being gayer because she was certain it would be miserable. yes, really. the only reason people are pretty sure she's *not* homophobic is because the Adolescence manga has an unambiguously gay happy ending). The only thing I can honestly say the manga has going for it is the artwork is gorgeous, but you can't carry a manga off eyecandy. You would have a better time going into the musicals blind and I am not kidding. TL;DR: the manga is nigh-impossible to get your hands on in consistently decent quality, and is not only inferior to the show (it is overly reliant on the tropes and conventions the show routinely criticizes, and more specifically you can kinda tell that it was written by a girlie who thought everyone else in Be-Papas was being too mean to the pretty boys - especially Touga, the prettiest boy), but by the end will be nigh-impossible to follow *without* the show because AtR *expects you to have seen the anime*. Godspeed when it wins anyway. It's gonna be rough.

PurpleIsDebeste

Honestly all of these sound really good and cool but im voting for the yokotaro shopping log cus i work at a cafe. Tho the addition of rose of Versailles is a tempting offer… Why havent we been doing shojo this whole time? These are awesome

Azelhia

If Witch Hat Atelier was finished I'd be so annoying about recommending it for a future poll. Let's just hope Yokohama can beat Utena's... frankly kinda terrible choice for this format. A companion piece manga just doesn't work for a book club without also watching the series, and that's so much bigger of an ask.

Foxowl

I missed Golden Kamuy bc I was busy so I’m excited to do whatever’s next!

Fan Trades

You can't possibly expect any of these obscure mangas to compete with FUCKING REVOLUTIONARY GIRL UTENA. SURELY YOU KNOW HOW GAY YOUR FANS ARE.

JelloApocalypse

Thanks so much for the info. You're not the only person I've seen who shares these sentiments, so I've decided to update the poll and replace it with "Rose of Versailles"

Dompap

Baked potato fandom rise, I vote for Aqua

Utilitarian

Hmm I've been curious about Yokohama Shopping Log. It's actually on my list of potential reads for Japanese practice since it apparently has pretty straightforward language, even though it lacks furigana

Crystal

Of course! It'd be a real shame if people went in expecting an abstract queer masterpiece and got the weird straight version instead, lmao. Lotta people probably would've felt kinda cheated.

Zayn Ryzen

Just gonna say, all of these are great picks. And even after taking Utena off the list I'm still going to keep my vote. Mainly because Roses of Versailles is such a classic and I Love reading old manga.

Ani C.

oh man all of these are good picks. I remember reading Orange when I was younger and having a STRONG emotional response, so revisiting it with others would be fun~

PurpleIsDebeste

damn, just learned vixen’s in the aria anime and now i’m kinda wishing i voted for that then again isnt vixen in every anime?

MJ Damsen

I got so overzealous when the updated poll ended… I read all of Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou in about two weeks and then ended up being inspired to make a large painting inspired by the atmosphere. Cannot WAIT for the book club on this one.