Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

We couldn't hold off on it any longer. In this month's visit to the lounge, we talk about the generational new RPG, Clair Obscur Expedition 33.

Reserved Seat members: If you'd like to submit a question for us, join the official Discord server and submit it in #The-Intermission-Lounge room!

Comments

Taylor York

I picked the Maelle ending and I wish I hadn't

Joshua Bolong

Somehow I knew that this was how the ending discourse would go between them

Juicegot

Verso is the correct choice.

Isaac Brown

I feel like John's take would have been better informed if he had played through all the content in the game. A lot of the Act 3 stuff gives that final choice more nuance.

Miracle Joe

"It would have been a beautiful life" JOHN 💀

extradecentskeleton

Ehh I stand by Maelles ending. Versos suffering doesn't matter more than anyone else's and if everyone "isn't real" then hes an npc who doesn't deserve a choice in the first place.

extradecentskeleton

I definitely dont agree with John but its interesting seeing him choose Verso.

Mateo Fountain

I am shocked that woolie thinks that most people picked that ending, almost everyone I know of has picked the other ending and talked about how sad Woolies ending was when they looked it up

Brendan Micheal Trick

Personally I feel as though Verso is the better option for one reason only, Maelle's ending is akin to a suicide. As someone who had tons of suicidal and martyrdom-ish thoughts, Maelle's ending felt awful as it feels like I'm letting someone fall into the same pit I fell into. Another way to understand it is that with Sciel's final rank she learned to live after loosing her husband after she attempted suicide, but that was only because Esquie was able to save her from herself, Much like what Verso is doing to Maelle. And even though saying that she can paint another world to help her with reality sounds uncaring to the people of the canvas, much like how Aline was able to recollect and revisit Verso's essence when she went back in, so can Maelle with the people of the canvas. They might not be the same but they can help her heal when her body is ready

10ToesOfJuriHan

Woolie having moral indignation about other people's choices in an RPG is kinda hilarious. Also if Gustave knew the shit Maelle is doing in her ending he would be on the same kind of crusade Verso was on.

AV

No spoilers in this comment beyond what was discussed in the episode: This was an extremely interesting listen. My partner and I finished E33 a few weeks ago and honestly discussed the question of if the people in the painting were real or not almost not at all. To us the most interesting angles was about the characters and their decisions: Why did Verso NOT want this life, why is Maelle willing to force it on him, what each member of the Dessendre family was doing and their cycle of trying to force decisions on each other each thinking they know best and using their godhood to their fullest extent both on each other and on the people in the painting. What about this? Each member of the family and how they feel about each other, how you can see it represented in their respective art. Renoir makes an Axon of his son called "He Who Masks Truth with Lies". One of the enemies in that area is a twisted version of Esquie. The Axon that represents Clea was dead before the story even started. What sort of father is he? What sort of mother was Aline? What did Alicia DO and why did she do it and what is each member of the family dealing with in regards to her? Which of the tracks you find were created by Verso, what do they say? To us the people both inside and outside the painting being real and valid is a given. On the morality side it is to me a question of "are you team Omelas or team genocide" basically, haha. But I hadn't considered John's angle of likening the people in the painting to AI: human creations that lack some fundamental element of humanity and must be destroyed if it can save even one person. I really like this idea because honestly, I didn't feel that much empathy for Aline or Renoir watching her deteriorate, so I enjoy I have some additional layers of feeling about that angle on it now. But here are some counter perspectives: -Are the Dessendre's humans, or are they gods? Between a family who can lose themselves in the act of creating and destroying entire worlds across generations, who can be reborn and live an entirely second life or resurrect manifestations of their dead loved ones, or the powerless people who do not have the answers and are facing down inevitable destruction for reasons they do not understand and only have the power to either accept or rage against the dying light -- which experience is fundamentally 'more human'? I saw the Dessendres as gods immediately and continuously, but I was raised Very Christian, and I see the hand of selfish creation everywhere. -Alternatively, if someone loses themselves in 'fiction', is that fundamentally worse than losing themselves in reality? If the fiction is indistinguishable from reality, at what point is it still considered fiction? To those outside the painting, they see someone being consumed by paint that eats away at their features. But inside that person can well be living a rich and complex life with other rich and complex people. This isn't a kid sitting at a computer leveling excessively in Warcraft living an empty existence, it's a colorful, physical experience with other people indistinguishable from being fully human who can be talked to, loved, fought, and create art with. -and, if you combine the two, if you are a god who creates a fiction that is indistinguishable from reality -- isn't the fundamental point of distinction for you that you have absolute control over that reality? CAN creators and their creations co-exist in a universe where that power differential will always be there? Where a Dessendre can always resurrect Verso one more time until they are satisfied? Where they can erase anyone they take issue with? So... is what makes something 'reality' the fact that you can't control it, and is the lack of control over reality then what makes one 'human'? Anyway best game of the year for sure. I hope Woolie and John talk more about this in the future.

TheWiseWolf

John doesn't need kindness or to necessarily be right on his take. Kinda hate the "what is the correct ending" conversations around this game cause both are fucked up on their own way and morally grey. Both endings are meant to leave a sour aftertaste on your both which was clearly the intention. (I chose Maelle ending btw before anyone comes at me)

TheWiseWolf

*aftertaste in your mouth Grammar is hard

mmmpants

if verso is just “an npc” the same as all the other painted people, then what makes maelle’s ending the better one. why not choose the ending where the “real” people benefit, where they begin to mend their family.

Alex Dinet

Love this game, great combat, great story, great voice acting. I feel the only problem that keeps it from being COMPLETELY perfect is the platforming. It’s like, not good at all. And I know a lot of it is optionnal but it doesnt warrant it being so bad. Like why do your caracter HAVE to roll when he falls from half a feet.

Macy

I am top tier of the patreon how do I get access to the discord? I've become addicted to gunpla and need people to talk to about it

Macy

If you do the combat initiation melee (right bumper) then you cancel the roll

Higgle

JOHN IS 100% CORRECT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!🚨🚨🚨

Kevin Amadi

I honestly don't get this take. Not existing is not suffering. What Verso is experiencing is very much suffering. Also, 99.9% of the people in the canvas are already gone, anyway...

Em Gravesong

So, I am an Anglophone, but if I am not mistaken, does "Clair Obscur" mean roughly "Open Secret" or "Hidden in Plain Sight"?

Jesper Schinkler

JOHN! So wrong, compare your opinion to ”The troubles” so Catholics shouldn’t exist…

Jesper Schinkler

Question! So I’ve got a bare knuckle debut fight in August and more to come. What should my walkout music be? I’m between ”Pull up” by 2 Mello or the forever classic ”All I want for Christmas” Any thoughts?

Ben Egerton

I don't think John has ever been more wrong

drewseefus

This is why the choice is so good. Both Woolie and John have a point, good ones, and can easily argue for and justify their point of view. On top of which the fact that they both seemed to believe that the other chose the option they did shows, to me, how there is no cut and dried clear answer. John's argument is more logical, Woolie's is more emotional.

Bradley S Grosser

How did John turn this into a conversation about AI? AI doesn’t have feelings or relationships. AI doesn’t have families or loss. The people in that canvas are as real as anyone outside

Jose

I think this game very much could be connected to AI. How many Sci-Fi films involve robots or AI who gain sentience? You could rewrite Clair Obscur to replace every mention of "painted" with AI or robots.

Bradwin Legaspi

I fell for the same trap as John. I thought Verso was right. If there is a "right" it is that I completely forgot the themes of the title Clair Obscur as Woolie so kindly points out. The title is filled with contrast, of light and of dark. The "wrong" should in turn be taking only the parts you like, only the parts that feel justified or convenient in your single personal perspective. The game began with Gustave and ended with Verso. The light shifting from one perspective to the other. Gustave's death and last stand had a purpose other than just shock. It was a forceful turn to open your mind once more to the very concept of "Verso", the left hand page, the other side, the reverse. John and Woolie, the confidence that Maelle's or Verso's choice is "right", that confidence is what is "wrong". As a player we were given a choice, and that choice in a cruel way was forced upon us by the very story we spent hours following. There are 3 groups of people in this story. The Painted, the "Real", and the players. Of these groups of "people", the game makes a point that outside of their group, the others might as well not be alive, or allowed to live. Why "Writers" are the villains of this story. I hope you can see why we see the word bigotry as something that is wrong.

Maidenless

it means "light-dark" and refers to the artistic technique of chiaroscuro in italian, which is painting with stark contrasts and strong shadows.

Kyle Williams

Maelle's ending starts with telling Verso she'll allow him to die (Presumably including his soul, which will end the canvas), we know staying in the canvas is going to kill her, and we know Renoir is going to destroy the canvas as soon as she's gone. I don't think the choice is the Dessendres vs Lumiere, it's the Dessendres vs another ~30 years for Lumiere. The third act also goes out of its way to frame the ending choice as beautiful escapism vs painful reality, with Lumiere and its people being kind of secondary to that choice. Act 3 Maelle doesn't care about Lumiere as a real place with real people, or about Verso as a human being - She cares about them as the only pieces she has left of the brother she lost. If Lumiere could be truly given a future I think Maelle's ending could be compelling, but the city's continued existence would be a few more years under the thumb of a petulant goddess and then total erasure once she finally dies. At best they suffer another cycle of apocalypse if Aline comes back to grieve Maelle's death and starts another battle with Renoir.

Devlin Caldwell

I do think that if he did the reacher he might double down on verso's choice. But I do feel like the discussion was a little bit lacking because he did miss that piece of side content. I want to know why the developers made an optional it felt very important to the story

Jeffrey Moore

What John fails to realize is that it’s a videogame so none of it is real

John doe

The argument here is mainly centered around whether or not the painted people are real people or not, but honestly, I think that even with acknowledging the fact that they are just as real and human as the Dessendres, I still think the Verso ending is the correct choice. I fully believe that the colorful cheerful Lumiere where everyone is happy and together again isn't an honest depiction of what's happening, and is instead a delusion that only Maelle can see. In the last 30 seconds, once everything is in black and white, Sciel and Lune both look different, and the expressions on their faces are awful. It feels like they're suffering just as much as Verso is, while Maelle looks so distant and deluded that it reminds me of someone dissociating or experiencing hallucinations of some sort. Everyone there in Lumiere is probably in the same position that Painted Verso was while in the canvas, being tortured by a life that he doesn't truly want to live. The happy future where everyone in Lumiere is reunited and Everything is Fine is a lie, and everything about Maelle's ending feels like it's trying to convey that to you. Expedition 33 is a story about grief, and the Maelle and Verso endings are representations of how you respond to grief in your life. You can deny it, try and comfort yourself with the things that remind you of what you lost, even try and recreate it if possible, but ultimately what this is is trying to delude yourself into thinking that the bad thing didn't actually happen, and therefore you don't have a reason to be sad. The example John uses of AI is an especially notable version of this: if you miss someone or don't want to accept who or what they are, you can just create a version of them that's just how you remember them. It doesn't matter that it's hollow and fake, or that it's directly interfering with the process of healing and moving on, it's something that in some way soothes the giant gaping wound that is the hole where that person used to be in your life. The Verso ending is painful, but it represents the reality of moving on. You have to say goodbye to not only who you lost, but also to the person that you were before that loss. The saying that "time heals all wounds" is ultimately true, but indirectly: the thing that actually heals all wounds is changing and growing as a person, something that is ultimately unavoidable as we move forward through time. You will change, meet new people, move to new places, experience new art, and also experience new loss in turn. You are not the same person at 10 as you are at 20, 30, 40, etc. The core element of grief is wanting to hold on to something forever, instead of swallowing the pain and accepting that everything comes and goes, even the most important and wonderful parts of our lives. You can't go back to who you were before, and trying to will only ever hurt you and leave you to stagnate and die.

Guilherme Alves

Here I am, less than 48 hours after finishing the game. First place I wanna hear a conversation about E33

Homtanks

As someone who works on machine learning, a lot of people are getting bamboozled into thinking big complex linear algebra operations and pattern recognition are "real intelligence", but even John said that he was able to poke at the system he was afraid of and get it to show its inhumanity within an hour or 2.

Lukeshef

Haha same here, just beat it last night

Daniel Watson González

I think the point of John is that AI is nowadays sophisticated enough to fool people into thinking its real and wasting time building meaningless relationships with it. And that the canvas can be compared to it in that sense specifically, the issue being that we real world humans who know the history of AI, are able to understand it as fake despite it being sophisticated. Humans in the E:33 universe can also likely understand the dimensions of reality paintings are able to construct, and as such, people like Renoir are stern on the fact that paintings are "fake".

Vic Cutting

Hmm. I chose the same ending John did, but I see the reasons. The main reason I did is because … I needed closure I suppose, and that’s what that ending gave me

Lemon

John made the right choice for the wrong reasons, Woolie made the wrong choice for the right reasons.

Rus Gabriel

I'm super late, but I chose Verso's ending too. For me, it was not about the painting as much as it was about the painter family. I lost my brother a couple of years ago and grief is just something you have to endure with grace and patience. Denying it and running from it is unhealthy. One of the painters can just make another world and it'll be fine. Keeping this sick and tortured consequence of your inability to accept reality will keep them from creating a new, healthier masterpiece

Sol Prince

John has never been more right. But I agree with him for a different reason. Because as soon as Maelle dies after being in the painted world for so long. Renoir will just destroy the painting and it won't matter. So Maelle's end doesn't matter at all.

Marco P

Versus Wolves Extended Universe Tournament of Champions

Davies

Woolie is 100% correct.

Spencer Pommier

If you're not paying attention to the games story sure

Spencer Pommier

If the painted people aren't real how did Gustav create the lumina converter? The fact that they can affect the painters and go beyond 100% is all the proof anyone needs that Maelle is the only choice

That's Why You Twin Podcast

Im late on this one, but hey. John has a point, Woolie has a point. I chose Verso's ending because I look back and think about what the game was trying to show me, and what it showed me was a family agonizing over the last vestiges of their son's SOUL forcing it to do something it doesnt want to, doesnt even like anymore, just to make them feel better. That, plus the fact that Baby Verso's suffering is mandatory to keep this world alive, is NOT something I could deal with. If living my life means someones else is forced to suffer, then what good really was my life? and its odd to me that Woolie and John both have Christian Guilt and never came to that aspect of it lol.

Waitsell V Jones

I went with the Maelle ending. My actual line when I was given the choice was "We're not destroying this canvas, Verso". Aline is responsible for creating life and we don't get to destroy it because she became addicted to it and can't grieve. I'm SORRY your family can't grieve properly Verso, but we're not killing an entire city to help.