Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Join us as we bring our discussion of Kurt Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse-Five to an end. So it goes.

Special thanks once again to our reader, Sean Langenecker!

Don't forget to scope out COSMIC HORROR: Supernatural Horror in Miniature from our sponsor, Spectre Miniatures!

Today's episode features selected arrangements from Bach's Concerto No. 5 in F minor, BWV 1056: II. Largo and Bach's Concerto No. 3 in D major, BWV 1054: II. Adagio e piano sempre.

Next up: A POEVEMBER Classic Episode, an Extra Credit episode on Mysterious Island, and FAIRY TALES for December!

Comments

Robby Haentze, a consumer of silliness

Five identical twins? Maybe they were 5 identical Poes? Kurt Vonnegut wrote this in collaboration with Derleth? I've also been using the phrase "And so it goes." In my daily lexicon at work and it brings me a small amount of peace. That my shitty overnight retail job will be over eventually.

Graham Pilling

Many years ago I was on my own flying from San Diego back to the UK. The flight was really quiet and there was nobody else on my row, apart from one guy who was in the window seat on the other side of the plane, mirroring where I myself sat. I had bought a copy of Slaughterhouse Five a few days earlier and after reading for a short while, I looked down the row at my fellow mirror passenger to notice that he was also reading Slaughterhouse Five. Same unmistakable cover, with bright pink fist on it. A strange story indeed!

Oleh R

Chad, if you and Chris aren’t literary scholars, I don’t know who would qualify for that title. You have recorded thousands of hours of literary analysis and critique, so if you claim this is a budget version of Quantum Leap, then a literary scholar has indeed said it!

Jim Cannon

The airplane crash MUST be the cause of Billy's psychosis, right? Otherwise its too much of a hat on a hat. One life, even a fictional one, can only absorb so much tragedy. How did Billy survive both Dresden AND the plane crash? Survivor's guilt plus neurological damage = Tralfalmadorians. ... Unless he really did experience his first time shift during the War. Not that it matters, ultimately. The aliens and the time travel are just a device to try to process the trauma. As much for Vonnegut as his character and maybe a little bit for his readers. I know when I read this as a college student I was blown away by it (although I never read much more Vonnegut) just as a structural exercise, the tone, the language, the little sci-fi bits. But listening to you guys covering this thirty years later, with all the life I've lived between... the only thing I wanted to do at the end of this episode was have a good cry. So it goes.

Ben A

I’m excited for the upcoming month of fairy tales. The soldier and death was one of the stories adapted by Jim Henson for his The Storyteller series (with John Hurt). That series was pretty great and cutting edge for puppetry when it was made. It’s worth checking these out, maybe as bonus material? And I have so many thoughts about Slaughterhouse Five. I’ll post those in a little bit.

It's a Ghost.

I absolutely loved The Storyteller series as a kid. Also, I never realized that was John Hurt!

Jim Cannon

Really? That voice is unmistakable, even under the makeup.

It's a Ghost.

Well, the last time I watched the show (and absolutely loved it) I was probably 7 or 8, so I probably didn't know who John Hurt was at the time 🙂 I remember just loving it as a strange anthology show, as I also really liked Amazing Stories and the 1980s Twilight Zone at the time.

KateSherrod

Campbell's appearance in his strongly cowboy-coded uniform always puzzled me until I learned about Ol' Shatterhands, a wildly inaccurate German version of a pulp hero cowboy that was really popular in late 19th/early 20th century Germany. Adolf Hitler himself was a massive Shatterhands fan boy as I learned some time ago from no less a literary scholar than Robert "Behind the Bastards" Evans. The writer who created Ol' Shatterhands was a piece of work in his own right, btw! https://youtu.be/Rm1K9-VMLVU?si=RMp2rNoGm_sWks2_ Thanks for studying this one strangely, fellas. I first read this book when I was a teenager and it's the first book that really just made me ugly cry. So many times. Vonnegut was a treasure who definitely made me aspire to be a better person.

Bugberry

The origin of Bikinis is another odd connection between marketing and a bomb.

REO Jackwagon

I came to Vonnegut pretty late, but I feel like hat on a hat is squarely his style. Like he doesn't want to write science fiction, but summarize it as another thing in his overstuffed grab bag of things. He's clearly a very clever writer, but I'm not sure he's as clever as he tries to present. I think he'd have been a revelation and an inspiration had I found him sooner in life. In my 20s when I was already a pretty prolific reader and writer myself? Less so.

Pagurus

Even the British were not too proud of the Dresden bombing, at least in hindsight. As renowned English historian A.J.P. Taylor notes: "The civilian leaders from Churchill downwards hastily repudiated responsibility for the raid on Dresden which they had in fact endorsed. Bomber Command was consigned to obscurity. Churchill did not mention it in his victory broadcast. No campaign medal was struck for it. Alone among the successful war leaders, Sir Arthur Harris was not elevated to the House of Lords."

ESTY

It’s a cook book! The Tralfamadorians are just like the Kanamits from the Twilight Zone episode “To Serve Man”. They are just gaslighting the humans to keep them docile captives.

Mr. Splitfoot

As an historian myself, hearing Chad refer to David Irving as a "controversial historian" made me chuckle. In the very first historiography course of my undergrad many moons ago, Irving was called a revisionist, the greatest insult one historian can level at another. Other accurate discriptors include "Holocaust-denier" and "asshole". Friends don't let friends cite Irving.

Ben A

I'm late to post my thoughts, but I wanted to share how happy I am you guys finally got around to covering Slaughterhouse 5. And that in many ways I think of this story on a regular basis, especially the framework of enjoying the best moments for what they are because you never know when they will be coming. This is exemplified in the book, where Billy's happiest moment on the cart is immediately followed by one of his most traumatic, coming to terms with all the death and despair he experienced across his whole life when confronted with the injured horses. As for the story as a whole, I'll also note that I think this is in many ways a Vonnegut response to the likes of the Shadow Out of Time. Both stories reflect a kind of temporal transcendence, but in the Lovecraftian version the protagonist is left only with foreboding and trauma, while in the Vonnegut version the protagonist is left with acceptance and, perhaps, detachment. The Yithians are also constantly trying to escape their circumstances and time, while the Tralfamadorians are resigned to their fate and don't need to change, let alone escape, their circumstances. Of course, these reflect the difference between Lovecraft and Vonnegut; Lovecraft was fixated on trauma, fear of others, and cosmic indifference, while Vonnegut thought the universe presents us with a joke that we're just not in on. I prefer Vonnegut's absurdism, knowing as well that the truth he writes is that in accepting the absurdities we can better manage the highs and lows of life.

RebeccaR

I was a nobody in all of the past lives I can remember

Casey

What a great novel. Devastating. A must-read for SF fans. It has been many years since I read it, so thanks for covering it on the show. Of course, I love Andrew Leman and your other regular readers, but it was fantastic to hear a new reader accomplishing such an excellent handling of the material. Well done! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Bryony Marsh

HardThrasher (on YouTube) has recently done a two-part documentary on the firebombing of Dresden, bringing a perspective that appears to challenge some of the widely-held truisms about Bomber Command and the politics of the time. I found it hard to get through, but couldn't fault the analysis.