Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The Cruel Ivy Killer is the subject of much debate.Many believe she had ‘antisocial personality disorder’.But most accounts of her make this unlikely. 

In fact, evidence suggest she fails to meet criteria for any onespecific personality disorder. This isn’t to say she is entirelyneurotypical, but I don’t believe any divergence can beentirely blamed for the blood she spilled, if at all.

I believe she was something far more terrifyingthan the average person is willing to consider,and far more common when it comes to killers.

She was a typical person who got a taste of the ultimate form of control.Someone who simply loved power more than she loved people.—Daisy Whitaker, “Cruelty in Color”

That was very likely the moment that truly defined Violet. It would be what she remembered as the real catalyst, anyway. After everything she would go through, every choice she would make, and every life ended by her hands from that point forward, she would revisit that moment and recognize it as the instant she became the Cruel Ivy Killer. Decades after she passed—once her identity was finally determined with certainty—historians and biographers would make their own guesses. Psychologists and sociologists would make others. 

Some would speculate that it was the moment she killed Derek. That the discovery of her calling itself forced her down the path she walked. Violet, however, would never even consider that idea. She was in control of her calling, not the other way around. She was no victim of fate. She ruled her own life, and she earned the blood on her hands with a smile. She chose to be who she was. Plenty of people hated their calling, whether it was truly a manifestation of their soul or not. But Violet reveled in it. She loved it. It would be suggested in a historical fiction or two that she was in love with it, while others found it more likely she was simply in love with herself. Violet would have rolled her eyes at either suggestion, were she given the chance to read them. She loved being in control, and it was as simple as that. It was not her calling that made her kill. She was certain of it.

A few would suggest Daniel’s death had done it. Once a dead woman was identified as the Cruel Ivy Killer, her life had been subject to an intense examination. Daniel’s own calling, a “Truthseeker,” was quickly revealed after that. No one knew for sure whether he’d actually been a victim of the infamous serial killer, but most considered it likely. There was some debate whether Caitlyn or Daniel were the first victims who Violet had killed out of self-preservation. But there was a lot more evidence for Daniel. If anyone had discovered Violet’s nature early, it would have been him. She’d obviously learned to guard against scrying talents before reaching the Chromatic Academy, and the first person she met who had one… died while alone with her, less than fifteen hours later. In any case, he was widely considered the first kill she’d made without revenge as a motive. Violet had considered the same herself, while she’d lived, but ultimately rejected it all the same. Daniel had been the first innocent she’d killed on purpose. But she’d done it to survive. That was the same reason she’d done anything in her life.

Of course, a few got close. A few thought it was Caitlyn’s death. Most agreed Violet killed her as well, and a few dug deep enough to find the transcripts of the council meeting. This revealed that Caitlyn had likely been murdered despite being a strong supporter of Violet's. It was largely agreed on, however, that Violet wouldn’t have realized this. Still, Violet seriously considered Caitlyn’s death as the moment that made her. The first person she had killed who neither deserved it, nor needed to die to keep her safe. It was almost the moment that defined her. 

But the reality was this. This moment with Chase. A moment that wasn’t recorded in history, to be fair to all the biographers and true crime writers. Even then, they likely wouldn’t have realized its impact. Because it wasn’t simply killing Caitlyn that got under Violet’s skin. It wasn’t the lack of necessity or the innocence. It wasn’t even that Caitlyn had turned out to be on Violet’s side. All of this knowledge hit Violet harder than any wound or betrayal she’d suffered so far. She politely ended her conversation with Chase and dismissed him, asking the boy to give her a few moments before sending Alex in.

The guilt was boiling in her like it never had. Daniel had been the closest. But this knowledge was a deep, gaping wound. She didn’t have an excuse for this one. Or rather, she didn’t have an excuse she could accept. She refused to blame ignorance. That would just be passing off her choice to kill to something out of her control. And she was in control. She was always in control. Derek had deserved death. Stephanie had deserved death. Daniel, well. It was him or her. That was simply how the world worked sometimes, and she could suppress the guilt over that one. But Caitlyn. She had no excuse for killing Caitlyn.

Violet loved fiction. She loved stories of every kind. The heroes and the villains alike. She’d read enough to know what “everyone is the hero of their own story” actually meant. After killing Derek, she was aware she didn’t belong among the noble heroes she loved. But she’d cast herself in the role of the anti-hero. She couldn’t call herself good, but she could call herself justified. She knew she enjoyed it too much. She knew she liked the fear and the taunting. And that perhaps blurred the line between anti-hero and villain. But she was always justified.

When she killed Daniel, she accepted that it was self-serving. When she’d taunted him first, she’d accepted that it was cruel. But… she had saved him first. And still, he’d tried to betray her. He shouldn’t have made her choose between his life and hers. As she’d gotten used to suppressing the guilt of his death and reveling in the act, she could’ve even almost convinced herself that it would have made a difference. That the thought of “justice” had so much as crossed her mind when she’d decided to kill him. When she’d decided to make sure he died afraid.

But Caitlyn? Now that she knew about Caitlyn, she had none of that. And the guilt would strangle her, if she couldn’t control it. If she couldn’t control it. She had been internally celebrating Caitlyn’s death since she’d left the hanging body behind. That was what it was, ultimately. It was the fresh guilt over an old crime. The mix of the pleasure and the shame. The euphoria and the regret that threatened to take it away. It was knowing that a memory she owned could be twisted and turned on her with a few simple words. It was the realization that a moment when she had been in control could suddenly make her feel powerless.

Pressure built in Violet’s mind. Like a glass box narrowing around her skull. Pushing and mixing her memories up. Mixing her emotions. Thrill and shame fighting for their place at the forefront of her mind. She had to calm the guilt. She’d been doing so well. Nothing she’d done had bothered her for long, if at all. But Caitlyn had died slowly, afraid, and after trying to save Violet. That reality struck her through the haze she’d allowed to form around her heart and made everything feel too real. She had to regain control. 

But Violet was learning, day by day and life by life, that there was nothing she couldn’t control. She would only feel powerless if she let it be true. If that moment could—with a few words—be taken from her, she would take it back. 

So, Caitlyn had been innocent of the crime that Violet had killed her for. So what? Violet had been weak. She’d been powerless. And for years, Caitlyn had done exactly what everyone else in the damn city had. Ignored her. Let her struggle and fight. Ignored the ridicule and the disdain, and that was when she wasn’t contributing. Caitlyn had said it herself. She’d thought Alex was too good for Violet. Alex. That cowardly limp fish of a man was too good for her? Because she didn’t have a fucking calling? 

The shame started to dull while indignation took its place. It was like fire and wood. The solid block of emotion weighing her down was slowly turning to ash under the flame she was fanning.

Caitlyn had participated in eleven years of cruelty towards Violet. So what if Violet had been cruel for a few minutes in return?

She stomped on the sudden churning of her stomach. She reminded herself of every sneer. Every scowl. Every subtle indignity she’d ever suffered for her lack of calling. She reminded herself what it was like to lack control. And it was working.

Her entire life, the message had been clear. If you could take control, you had every right to do so. If you couldn’t, then you didn’t deserve it. Fuck Caitlyn. Fuck Daniel. Fuck the very concept that either of them had any “innocence” at all. She had been losing a contest for control with them and everyone like them for her entire life. And she was supposed to feel guilty that she’d finally started winning? 

The shame melted off of her a little at a time. Nearly as quickly as it had assaulted her. She was angry she’d allowed herself to entertain it, and the more she shed, the faster the rest followed.

That was a ridiculous thought. That was their influence. The lie they’d told her since she was a child. That if she managed to win any control over her life, any influence at all, that she should feel guilty for it. No. She wouldn’t accept that. She pushed every ounce of shame deep into her soul and smothered it. She was in control, now. She was in control, and she wouldn’t apologize for finally having an advantage in the constant arm wrestle that was her life.

Violet was in control. 

And she wasn’t ashamed of what that meant.

And just like that, she had that precious memory back. Caitlyn, struggling with her arms behind her back. Flailing. Choking. Dying. Innocent? No. She hadn’t been innocent. She wasn’t an innocent victim. She was simply the loser of a lifelong contest. And Violet, on the other hand, had won. And that felt incredible. Killing Caitlyn had felt incredible. Killing all of them had.

“Violet?” Alex asked. Violet hadn’t heard him open the door and flinched as he spoke. Again, the needles in her skin shifted painfully, and she grimaced before responding.

“Alex, there you are,” Violet greeted, somewhat less pleasantly than she’d intended. Partially from the fresh pain, and partially because she was still harboring the anger she’d been feeding to replace her guilt. 

“I wanted to talk to you about something. Something important,” Alex replied, barely bothering to greet her. Violet flexed her fingers in irritation, turning only her head to face her useless boyfriend.

“I’m fine, yeah,” Violet replied. “I was hurt pretty bad. All three times that you hid while I was fighting for our lives, actually. All four times, if you count the time your mom tried to send me to my death. But I’m healing pretty quickly. I appreciate the concern.” She was angry, and tired, and she didn’t have the energy for the nice routine. Maybe he’d break up with her, and she could forget he existed. God, killing him would feel so relieving, she thought. She needed that release more than ever. 

Alex clenched his fists, even as he looked at his feet. “I’m sorry,” he whispered. “I’m sorry that I’m no good for you. I’m sorry about everything that’s happened. About every way I’ve fallen short, since that fu— since that stupid town meeting. But… this is about something more important."

Violet scoffed. It would be such a relief to just kill him. “More important? Do you have any idea how many times I’ve almost died? Other people did die!” Violet spat.

“Violet, I know. And listen, I love you. No matter what, I love you. But this matters more! I have to know—”

“Know what, Alex? What is so important you can’t even bother to ask if I’m okay? You love me? You couldn’t even be bothered to stand next to me in a fight! Over and over, you abandoned me! Over, and over, and over, you hid while I fought! While I risked everything! What kind of love is that? What is so important, Alex? What is so important that you can’t be bothered to care that I barely survived to have these wounds heal? These wounds you let me get?” Violet wanted to hold his skull between her palms and press, and press, and press. Until bones cracked and blood ran across her fingers, then she wanted to push harder. She wouldn’t even care how disgusting it was. Her muscles were already flexing with the thought.

“Why did you kill the lancer?” Alex asked.

Comments

Cinea Spring

That internal monologue was a bit long. Nice twist to throw another problem her way. Poor Violet just cannot have a break. So what will it be? Kill him outright? Manipulate him to stay silent until a better opportunity arrives? Or can he be trusted to never tell anyone that she killed the lancer?

Dreamer's Riot

Personally I love a nice long internal monologue, lol

ConstanTeen

I think it was needed. Her emotional reaction was necessary and well done. The narration about the future and historians, though, felt a tad out of place.

Dreamer's Riot

COnstanTeen, Patreon is useless and won't unfilter your comment for some reason. But nah, it's of average length. Hundred longer than the shortest, hundred shorter than the longest.

Reppyxz

Damn. I can’t take these cliff figures! I just need to know what happens next! Anyways, thanks for the chapter. Absolutely loved it. I love the way Violet rationalized her actions. It’s interesting with all the future excerpts. It seems to paint the picture that Violet got away with all her killings. And it was only really found out or confirmed after her death. It makes me wonder how she died? Did she die of old age? I kind of doubt that. And with the way, the monsters ignore her, I doubt she died in action. So I’m guessing she was probably killed by a person? Probably. but I also suppose she could’ve faked her death. And still be alive. With the amount of people were talking about the violet in the future, it makes it seem like she’s pretty important/infamous figure. But I suppose these musings at the start of each chapter could be from the same person. and thus not necessary, mean she was that prolific of a character. I hope you’re having a wonderful day. And thanks for the chapter.

Dreamer's Riot

I am pretty intentionally vague on how she ends up, lol. Accept that at some point in the future, people do know who she is, and at least some of what she has done.

Reppyxz

Well, I hope to see that. One of my favorite, tropes? Is the unmasking or unveiling. For her allies, friends or other characters in general to realize who she truly is in the inside. Anyway, I hope you continue to have wonderful days to come!

Beeees!

Hmm. Seems like Daniel wasn't the only one who saw something he shouldn't have

DeWhit

Seems likely that it was Alex that walked in on her killing Stephanie, and poor Daniel just had the misfortune of learning the truth through his calling. I guess we’ll see in the next chapter