Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The Cruel Ivy Killer was dangerous.

But not because she was anything particularly special.

She was dangerous because she was profitable to powerful people.
—Vernon Vale, Interview

“No. Do not do that. Absolutely do not, under any circumstances, approach Koral Kiln with any of this,” Lyle ordered.

He was already exhausted, and this was the last thing he needed. Sitting across from him was Chase Cook, a child with too many years on his skin. Heavy bags under his eyes and the gaunt look of illness around his cheekbones. The boy hadn't looked well a few weeks before, but the brief period between meetings had clearly been unkind. Lyle really didn't like what that implied even at a glance. He liked it less after hearing Chase’s amended story.

“She deserves to know who is doing this to her. Doesn't she?” Chase asked. “And she can help us!” There was desperation dripping from every word like cracks in a dam. And Lyle had a problem.

He stared at the box on the table. It sat in front of the student like a headstone. Lyle had been the one to suggest a meeting over dinner. He was hungry, and Chase looked like he hadn't eaten all day. It was late, and this felt like the sort of conversation to have over midnight waffles. But the “gift” Violet Asher had delivered to Chase had stolen Lyle’s appetite.

The rope was a clear message. And the card... it lined up perfectly with Chase's statement. It was possible Chase had commissioned the art himself, of course. That would be John's theory. The official police story was that Chase had been threatened by Koral. That his false testimony about an Asher was meant to distract from the real killer. 

It was bullshit.

Lyle didn't even have to check. This tarot card wasn't invented evidence. It was real. It was circumstantial at best. A card like this could mean anything. And it would never convince John. Not when used against an Asher. But it was real. Worse, it could be literal confirmation. With his red threads, Lyle could easily connect these two objects to the Cruel Ivy victims. It wouldn’t be terribly difficult to confirm that they’d belonged to Violet. ALl he had to do was bring that card to the school.

That was Lyle’s problem. 

He believed Chase, and he was struggling to convince himself not to. He’d been looking into Violet ever since Demetri’s death. Because the details simply lined up too well to dismiss her any longer. He hadn't found anything particularly suspicious on its own. But there was a lot of death surrounding the girl. Even before she’d made it to the city. Lyle knew a pattern when he saw one. And this was a pattern drawn in blood.

He really fucking hated that he believed Chase. There was just something undeniable in the fear behind a child's eyes. That and some of the details just explained things a little too well. Even if Lyle had chosen not to see that at first. He couldn't believe he was doing it. He wasn't sure when he’d stopped thinking it was possible Violet was involved and started assuming it was probable. 

Maybe he always had, as soon as Chase had offered her name. His sense of self-preservation was all that prevented him from realizing it. Any other last name and Chase's statement would have inspired an enthusiastic and immediate investigation.

He was going to fully investigate a fucking Asher.

He sighed. “You can't do that. Because Koral is probably guilty,” Lyle answered. That still seemed likely to him, even if that certainty was fading every day. He couldn't find more than a faint connection between any of Koral’s belongings and the Cruel Ivy victims. It was there, but it was weaker than it should have been. It was probably weaker than the connection that tarot card had, in fact.

There were explanations for that. Since Koral hadn't been officially charged. Lyle couldn't access more than a few minor items. More importantly, and more relevantly to the boy in front of him, Koral likely wasn't the main culprit. 

“She is innocent. Maybe more innocent than me, I swear to God! And if she knows you're investigating the real killer, she’ll probably open up to you!” Chase insisted.

Lyle shook his head. “I believe you. I do,” Lyle assured. “But you don't have the full picture. There is more than one person involved with these deaths. I am investigating Violet. Your story makes more sense the more I learn, in fact. But she couldn't do this alone. There is someone pulling the strings, and they have more than one puppet. Violet is probably one of them, if your testimony is true. But Koral most likely is as well.”

It had to be either Caleb Shepard or Abel Bouvier. And Lyle had his money on Shepard. Multiple killers with the same therapist? Primarily hunting other names only the therapist himself would know? It would explain everything.

“Violet killed Alex before she even made it to Prism!” Chase protested.

“I understand that. But there is strong evidence Koral has killed as well,” Lyle answered.

“Strong evidence? Something other than what you announced in the bulletin, I hope. Those train records could easily be doctored. You don't even know where they came from!” Chase challenged.

Lyle shook his head. “They can't be, no. Forensics has examined them. They have a digital watermark like all official records do. They are real and unedited. I’m sorry,” he corrected.

“Well, then Violet faked her name! She hides her calling and talents; she probably has a way to hide her name, too! Fuck, it's probably the same talent!” Chase hedged. He was gesturing at nothing in particular as he spoke, simply too upset to prevent excessive animation.

“That doesn't line up with your statement, Chase. You said Violet met Koral a couple months ago. But these records under her name go back nearly six. Not just the records, either. Many stations have working cameras. Once we had timestamps and a target in mind? It was easy to find. Pink hair and a school uniform are a bit hard to miss. Koral is seen getting off the train at the marked time in quite a few of these records,” Lyle countered, crossing his arms and leaning back in his booth.

“And they showed her face?” Chase asked, his expression communicating certainty more than anything. To Lyle’s chagrin, the answer was no. Not a single goddamn time. Which made sense at first glance. The cameras weren’t hidden, and a killer would know not to look directly at them. It was odd, then, that Koral so often failed to change clothes and hide her hair. There were artifacts for that, even with the absurd quantity the girl had. It was obvious Chase knew the evidence had holes, because he continued to push.

He leaned forward, pushing the open box of rope to one side. “Those two don't exactly look like opposites. Violet may not have met Aubrey’s girlfriend until recently. But that doesn't mean she didn't know who she was. Even that timeline is just what she told me, and it could be a lie, for all I know. I never know what is real with her. Violet probably picked Koral because of the blue eyes and long hair. That's not a contradiction!” Chase argued.

It was a good point on its own. Better, if Lyle considered the psych files. Those had been delivered with the train records. Which meant someone with access to both had sent them. If Violet could read student files, she'd know Koral was a good candidate. Reclusive and rarely with an alibi. Noticeable, but not particularly close with anyone. The girl’s notes literally mentioned how dangerous she could be without treatment. Even with a redacted diagnosis, that would make her a good choice.

But, of course, Violet wouldn't have had those records. Caleb Shepard would.

Lyle hadn't worked out why the man had thrown a pawn under the bus. But he was fairly certain that was what had happened. Shepard offered a suspect as soon as staff started to be investigated. And there hadn't been a new Cruel Ivy victim since Koral's name was announced. It could’ve been an exit strategy. Or it could’ve been something worse.

The problem was that Lyle couldn't say as much. Chase needed help, and Lyle was willing to offer it. But he couldn't just announce a significant person of interest in a major investigation to a child. And not just to protect Chase, but to protect the investigation. Shepard was likely using Koral, Violet, and other students to eliminate targets. And this wouldn't end until all of them were stopped. If Chase went to Koral, and Koral went to Shepard...

If Chase was being honest and Violet was involved, it would be dangerous to let Shepard know Lyle was investigating her. He would lose the one possible advantage he had. Koral would probably not still be on good terms with Shepard, but it wasn't a certainty. There was even a chance she’d have no choice but to report it. 

It was a terrible idea, and Lyle couldn't tell Chase why. 

So he decided to redirect and ask Chase a few more questions about Violet Asher. If he was very lucky, Chase would reveal the Asher girl wasn't actually involved at all. Lyle still really wanted that to be the case. 

“Look. With the information you have, I’m certain this feels like a good idea,” Lyle allowed. “And I understand you feel the need to do something. With the story you told, anyone would be desperate to find a way out. Especially after...” Lyle glanced at the rope in the box. His words felt hollow before they even escaped his lips. And he could see the same response in the slow fall of Chase's face. 

He took a breath, then folded his fingers together on the table. He decided to change directions. Chase might understand, on an intellectual level, why Lyle couldn't share all the details of an active investigation. And the detective could easily cite these private details as a reason not to contact Koral. It would even be valid to do so.

But it would leave Chase desperate. There was nothing more dangerous to an investigation than a desperate client, and Chase would more than qualify. Lyle’s instructions would last a week. Or a day. Or an hour.

In the end, fear and impatience would win out, and Chase would confess to the first of the killers. More than likely, Violet would know she was being watched less than a day later, and Lyle would be absolutely fucked. Unless John finally managed to formally arrest Koral, it would happen eventually.

Lyle really didn't want to investigate an Asher. He didn’t want to so much as touch that rope or that card, and he had no interest in bringing them anywhere near the victim’s remains. He didn't even know what he’d do if he found proof. Or... he did have one plan. But it seriously sucked. And it would make him feel like discarded grease. 

It would also immediately fail if Chase gave the game away too early. So he decided to offer something instead of taking it away. “Do you remember Lancer Curtis?” Lyle asked. 

Chase paused. He’d been staring suspiciously at the cold biscuits and gravy on his plate, and the question had taken him off guard. “Um. I think so. The one Stephanie replaced when I came to Prism?” he asked.

“The one who investigated the green hedron outside of Roseville, if the records I have are correct. He would have reported on the deaths of Lancer Derek’s team. The ones who died when Violet first got her calling,” Lyle clarified.

Chase's eyes widened. “You don't think he...” he trailed off, and Lyle nodded.

“His report went to Headmaster Bouvier, but that man hasn't been particularly helpful. So I can read it. But Curtis is returning from a mission in two weeks. I intend to meet with him at the station. He very well might have valuable insight into Violet,” Lyle explained.

Chase bit his lip and looked back down at the counter. It wasn't exactly a look of victory, but Chase never wore such an expression. There was, at least, some hope in the tension easing all across the boy’s body. 

“There is a second witness. A girl who may be able to completely confirm parts of your story beyond a shadow of a doubt. I can't share her name, but I am trying to arrange a meeting with her as well,” Lyle continued.

Chase freed a timid breath. “Will that be enough?” he asked.

“It will be a lot,” Lyle answered. “Maybe enough. Or maybe just what I need to get more. But it's significant. I’m telling you this because I want you to understand. Waiting isn't the same thing as being helpless. What you are doing? It's helping me pin her down. It's subtle, and it's slow. But it is helping. I am not sitting around and doing nothing. I am stepping closer to the truth every day. 

“Approaching Koral might feel like the only way to fight back. But it's not. You've already made the first swing, and it's having an effect. Meanwhile, speaking to the accused killer is a gamble. It might help. You're right. But it might also undermine everything and leave me with nothing. No way forward, and no justice. So I am asking you. Let me speak to these two witnesses first. One for Violet’s history, and one to confirm Violet’s calling. Can you do that?” Lyle practically begged. His voice was calm and professional, but it was begging nonetheless.

Chase looked up and met Lyle’s eyes. “Koral is innocent. I’m certain of it. There is no risk,” he insisted.

“You know that because of what Violet told you?” Lyle questioned.

“She doesn't tell me everything. But she does take credit for every death,” Chase confirmed.

“She also lies to you, though, doesn't she? To keep you guessing? To trick you into helping her? And she has a talent for it, too. That's what your statement said. You can't act based on her information. You have to trust me,” Lyle argued. That talent was one of the things Lyle had been unable to dismiss. The supposed ability to make anyone believe one lie. It was inferior to Cyan’s talents, and likely to Bouvier and Shepard’s mental manipulation as well. But in the right circumstances? It could have devastating effects. 

And it could explain some details Lyle hadn't managed to reconcile before. Like the death of the officer in the motel. Especially if the limitations were slightly less strict than she'd explained to Chase. He’d described a pretty limited talent, but there was no reason Violet would share the actual limits of her abilities. Not if she had a way to spoof her empathy ring.

Chase bit his lip. Lyle could see it in Chase's eyes. The doubt. It lived there like roaches in the walls of the kid’s mind. But there was also a growing fire behind it all. And that burned in the determination of the boy's next question. “You have a witness who can prove me right, you said?” Chase asked.

“She can,“ Lyle promised. “If I can convince her mother to let me speak to her, anyway. And... there is one other thing. If you don’t mind leaving that card with me.”

Comments

No comments found for this post.