Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

The Core 4 are back and the squirters are squirtier than ever. Join the somms as they sink their teeth into the great apple debate. Which apple will be the one... of their eye?

The following varieties were considered:

Fuji

Pink Lady

Envy

Gala

Cosmic Crisp

Honey Crisp

Soluna

Granny Smith

Files

Comments

Kellyd

Oh hell yeah

crawdaddy

This is content specifically for me as a food scientist who lives in central New York

Nick Neverman

Honey crisp or nothing! Honestly tho, by name alone, Cosmic Crisp sounds spectacular

Lark is Here

I love when they switch up the pictures for the episode art cause it’s like a sneak peak to the chaos to come.

Chris

They’re calling it the least-audio-friendly podcast of all time (I haven’t listened yet I’m sure it’s not that bad)

syzmon

Sad that my personal fave the HunnyZ didn't make it to the championship but with things as it is I'm rooting for Cosmic Crisp to take the crown

Bee H

Let's goooooo! Best listening as I'm travelling into London for tonight's show.

wick

6 am💀

froggy

this is so up my alley

Isaac K

Red and golden delicious apples are both in the negative. Those are bad apples

Billie Ash

It's granny smith and it's not a competition

syzmon

started shaking my head in frustration when caldwell talked about loving mealy apples.... the panel is compromised

Nathan Rogers

Cosmic Crisp became my number 1 this year, dethroning the previous champion Pink Lady.

Gabe Benninghoff

Looking forward to the end ranking - I’m thinking that this is the apple I eat for the rest of my life 😂

Scrumblina Brumblina

What a magical world to live in, to be so excited to listen to people ranking apples.

Just_another_queer

Frustrated af at my insomnia but at least I can listen to apple sommeliers

Annie Bleveans

Incredible new Emily word: “decrepitude”. Wow

A yu

Niche apples I wish they could've tried: crimson crisp, ever crisp, and ludacrisp.

Ro

Ahhh hard to know whether I should listen to this on the way to seeing the show tonight or on the way to make cider this weekend! Also as the daughter of a cider brewer this is peak autumn content and I love it

Jonathan

Cosmic crisp is a phenomenal apple

SeminoleDVM

No SugarBees? You guys are missing out 🤣

londonfiasco

Quite sad to see my favorite McIntosh apples not even in consideration

rosebramblewolf

BEETS are nature's candy, haven't you philistines ever seen Doug???

Cyrus

Emily is right! Bananas are a monoculture crop, the Cavendish is the main banana that people in the US eat (if you’re eating a ‘classic’ banana it’s a Cavendish). And they are indeed threatened by being a monoculture crop because the lack of diversity leaves them susceptible to plants diseases. (I read about this whole deal in Emily Monosson’s book Blight which was really good & I’d recommend!)

Isaac Robinson

10 minutes in and Murph is already having a Normal One

rosebramblewolf

They used to be good but capitalism ruined them

Hunter Leach

What happened to Cat wine ???

NOBLIVION

I love these guys playing DnD so much that I’ll listen to them describe apples any day. Fujis have always been my favorite but I need to try different apples I guess

jackalope503

This is Fuji slander and I won’t stand for it

rhyan mcneill

Cant wait to see what they think of the cosmic chisp the regulation apple

Gabe Benninghoff

Emily were you kidnapped as a child? “Being locked in a basement and not being able to leave”

Evander Oleander

Apparently the Soluna is a very new apple breed, hopefully it will become a grocery store standard in the future

Figgy Blue

RAAAAAHHHHHH after a summer of absolute golden perfect 0 fault action movies, this is the exact kind of vibe we need going into Fall

commas-and-ampersands

As someone with extremely strong opinions on apples, this was tailor made for me.

Ellie

I love an episode where it quickly becomes apparent that Caldwell doesn't actually like the food being reviewed. between this and the m&m taste test fiasco in which he mainly just wanted mints, almonds, or dark chocolate instead, my man has some of the strangest food opinions I've ever heard

Parma Jorts

As an apple loving Washingtonian this is basically a wet dream for me

Figgy Blue

I'm shaking and static with joy at Em's hate at Apples. I absolutely agree, a fuji tastes what it feels like to fall as a kid and eat a lil bit of dirt n leafs on the way down. It's awful and traumatizing.

Nicolas R

Last night I spent the whole of my sleep dreaming of my high school best friend and the dreams we shared of an adulthood unburdened with the corrosion of shame and responsibility. I found myself feeling wistful beyond reasoning, ive spent much of my adulthood envious that he got to live those dreams just a bit more than I. And then I saw this mixed bag in my phone's notifications, and that wist and envy was replaced with a nostalgic mirth as I discovered that, despite the consensus of Murphs in society that say that all apples are just pretty good, there are also those like me that hesitate in light of the great truth, that some apples are mealy and have bad skin and are not worth the effort. I do not know why this continuum of experience makes so much sense to me, or why it feels so right, but it does. And I am grateful that I got to enjoy it with my dogs on my morning walk today. Thank you

Parma Jorts

Honey crisp actually tastes better imo. The main thing that the Cosmic has going for it is the absurdly long shelf life. They can sit in your fridge for months and still be delicious

wick

Murph’s right. All apples are solid

riddle me grinch

Same! Might as well just throw a red delicious into this farce.

James B

Never clicked on a post so fast what are we doing

riddle me grinch

For some reason my pre-caffeinated brain thought murph was saying the pink lady name was from Greece and I was racking my brain thinking of Greek myths that involved pink women...

Jude

Devastated as a honey crisp lover

Brandy

Comic Crisp is by far my favorite apple!

Brandy

Same process!

Brandy

Cosmic crisp apples are the best. And I happen to know they have a history of supporting podcasts that support them. They are a ride or die apple.

Tori

i really like fuji apples 8(

Stumpfourth

Find an apple orchard! There’s one near me that has the best Golden Delicious apples I’ve ever had.

riddle me grinch

Both courtesy of the University of MN. If you like honey crisp I think you'll like cosmic crisp. It's bred from a honey crisp and something else (idk Goorgle it).

A yu

For my birthday one year, I got a banana box from Miami fruit- in case there truly will be a banana taste test

Lee030

Cosmic Crisp I am rooting for you!! 🍎

Blobby5678

What an amazing way to start the day 😋

CSN

Squirt sharks?

Julia

Sugar bee lover reporting in 🫡

Cortney Cline

This episode had me crying laughing, thank you for this. I'm going to try to find a soluna to try now. I think it might be a newish variety because there's no entry on https://applerankings.com/ for it.

Scott

They must have had a bad batch of Envy's. The skin is never great but the inside is the best apple. Eating way less now that my store has me over on and I have to grab a crisp

Blume

Empire apple lovers represent! Tart, crisp, small, perfect

Big Baby J

I would like for them to predict comment section controversy more often.

Devin

granny smith + peanut butter >>>>>

Anders Nackerud

As a Minnesotan, Honeycrisp apples are the best hands down. Everybody thank the University of Minnesota for the greatest cultivar of apple, and if you don’t like it remember that Cosmic Crisp is a Honeycrisp without the enterprise apple cultuvar.

Zarina Munoz

Can someone make the over the shoulder meme for Caldwell?

Gold

Surely the regulation apple, the Cosmic Crisp, will win

Terrell Swanson

Honeycrisp is by far the best apple in existence

TeamLouie

I am also a Cosmic Crisp simp and I was worried it wouldn’t be tried because it wasn’t one of the “main“ apple types people usually know about so I’m glad that it was the first apple that Emily mentioned. They’re so good

Kat

The Apple: A Mouth Delight

Adrian Woodhouse

Murph can NEVER be on gastronauts 😭😭😭😭 brother has no pallet nuance

Houston

This is the perfect prep for Apple Fest in Chicago this week

Ivy!!

My top apples this year are Envy and Cosmic Crisps, honorable mentions to honey crisp and galas

Smoke

They’re really out here like “you’ll listen to anything we put out.” But yeah, I sure will, justice for the pink ladies

Gustav Persson

what is the thing the ranking is based on? a cutie?

Lee030

I wish there was an apple with the texture of Cosmic Crisp and the flavor of Granny Smiths

Brandy

Hello fellow comment leaver!

Andrew

Saying you don’t like an apple because it reminds you of childhood is insane to me. I do not understand Emily at all this episode.

tay w

i’m with emily on bananas, i hate them and anything banana flavored i do love sugarbees though those were an instant favorite for me when they popped up on the scene. cosmic crisps are pretty good, and recently i’ve had wild twist apples (i think that’s what they’re called?) and those are solid too

tay w

oh wait i also love mcintosh apples but those are very mealy

Hardcore Mustard

I would like to open an official dioulage on pink lady apples. My long time favorite and go to ple', has fallen off a cliff, mightily. It's very sad. rockit underrepresented.

Emmett Moon

My cats are named Macintosh and Gala after the apples and every time they said gala she meowed in response

Emmett Moon

The important question is were any of these apples scrumpt

Dave 3D Art

Personally, I'm a Cortland kind of guy.

robthlz

man, I can't wait for part two, this is almost as good as When Did Things Come Out? also Richard Scarry mentioned, time to go watch Snakes with Legs

Zanna

I know this is about to make me crave apples

Tony

The next sommelier tasting should be a bottled water taste test

cole huston

Big apple hater here, no meaningful nutritional value & any mealiness tastes like tv static. Cant recommend golden kiwis enough, only 50 calories and 140% of your daily required vitamin C, versus an apples 9%

Stations & Starships

Literally rating apples to oranges... I would expect no less from these legends.

CSN

"Your mouth is wrong!" is so funny, and in this case fully true.

Patrick B

No longer varieties, apples are now breeds

Emma Henson

I'm begging for the fruit rating

Hanna Wen

I tried Wild Twist apples last year and I'm a forever fan now. It's the best apple! 🍎

Wilder Cosaboom-Son

Started listening to this episode on my way back from the grocery store, had to stop at a deli to buy an apple the debate was getting so heated

jens_defender

As someone who requested exactly this, I feel so special right now 🥰

Jessica

I NEED TO TRY THE SOLUNA APPLE AND NO STORES NEAR ME SELL IT

Figgy Blue

This is why there are like 50 god damn apples. They need to "Breed" more to appease these FREAKS who just want a fuckin' banana.

jens_defender

We need a sequel where you try the Lucy Glo apple, which was bred to taste like a Jolly Rancher.

BigBoyMan

Cosmic crisps are the GOAT

Gregory Moskowitz

Waking up to pee in the middle of the night and seeing this in my notifications made me genuinely consider just fucking my whole sleep schedule.

Bulph

I would pay for a podcast of just taste tests

Grays the Fae

IRT apple breeds: there’s an Ologies episode about pommology where she interviews a scientist who created a new apple breed (the Snapdragon apple, solid 3 cuties to me) and it’s all about different types of apples and what it takes to create new ones and it’s really interesting! Based on the stuff she reads, I feel like Emily would really get into Ologies, it’s a great podcast!

Caitlin Sales

Thank you for this energy to get me through the work day!!! My lunch time apple is trembling

CSN

Honey Crisp X Starspawn 🍎🪱

Brock Gabbert

The only explanation for their Honeycrisp takes is that they got a specifically bad Honeycrisp.

CSN

Smosh just beat them to it, but I want the NADDpod take.

Fargoth Ur

I feel like the same thing is happening to Honeycrisp. Used to be the best, but not the same anymore.

CSN

There is more variation in quality of apple than there is between breeds. I would bemoan the lack of scientific rigor in this taste test, but I think squirtlessness and childhood trauma were bigger elements in the end. 🫦💦🍎

Stefan UrKILL (Figgy)

As someone who loves to go apple picking every year for my birthday I want to turn everybody onto Roman Beauties. Also not all apples are built equal, a lot of them are not great for snacking but are great for baking.

Winterbat

Proof that I will listen to these people talk about anything

Isabelle

I need to spread the praise of my beloved Opal apples

Marissa Ho

Cosmic crisps have my whole heart, I would die for them

Aspen

Caldwell is a monster

allison

for more taste tesing options, you could do oreos. ooh or maybe different cereals

Caitlin Sales

Caldwell has some wild apple takes, but as a fellow texture-reactive food enjoyer I can totally relate. Sometimes it's just bad mouth feel

CommodoreBlue

Can’t believe none of you have one of those round apple slicers. They’re just so much more convenient and the slices are all even and the core is removed

Barpo Goodbarrel Bard-Barian

The fact that Caldwell Tanner hates good apples is shocking. Cosmic Crisp is the best type of apple and I will not stand for his slander. I demand him be disbarred from the court! We can no longer trust his judgement. May Dice Christ have mercy on his soul

Fikon

I always love the DnD, some of the most engaging and beautiful storytelling I’ve ever heard BUT if the show fully just became this I would adore that the same lol

Dysole

Apples are such a weird fruit for me. I don't love them but don't hate them. Granny Smiths are the only apple I can eat without slicing it up. Every other apple I get two bites in and just can't eat it unless it's sliced and then I can probably eat just about any of them. I am gonna need to try this Soluna one though.

Melanie

i feel like i was always being handed an apple snack as a kid but it was always a fuckass red delicious which is objectively the worst apple

Mikel

My apple hot take is it tastes better when cut into slices. Also I've never heard anyone pronounce Cavendish like that 5 cuties for me

Lamp

The moment mixed bag fruit draft was mentioned I have never switched into my old franchise mode habits to judge who’s the centerpiece fruit

Emma Robinson

Yo can someone report back on whether this episode is a misophonic nightmare? I simply cannot risk it.

Alex W

next taste test should be the bonne maman jam advent calendar!! do weird jam sommeliers!!

Frank

Would rather never eat another fruit than take a single bite of a Fuji….

Emily Bocchino-Rojas (Emily BR)

Im allergic to apples and was trying to figure out if Caldwell was to justify his insane opinions. I don't think he is - he's just allergic to good taste in apples 😔

Tyler S Anthony

Y’all ever have a moment of piercing lucidity where you realize that you will unquestioningly listen to four people you’ve never met taste test apples?

jackrabbit

if you think im not one hundred percent genuinely here seated vibrating with joy at naddpod crew hour long fruit draft youre kidding yourself. fruit draft now

Polly Theobald

I've been listening on the way to their London show and this was a beautiful thing to prepare seeing the crew live with!!

Grass

I’m a pink lady lady

Elana Danielle

love you guys but as a washingtonian your apple opinions across the board are certifiably insane. this was a tough listen LMAO

Nudd

Highly recommend checking out applerankings.com. The top rankers introduced me to some of my favorites and the bottom rankers are hilariously described. A couple of my favorites are "coffee grounds in a leather glove," "a teeth shattering oddity," and "long island's sand filled condom."

Will W

As someone that grew up in the "Apple Capital of the World" - I'm insulted that I wasn't consulted for this ep. Also Caldwell's love for mealy apple is diabolical

Chris Ingham

As a lifelong apple lover who developed an extremely unlucky allergy in college, I'm living vicariously through y'all

Kendra Waters

FYI, Washington state produces over 5 billion pounds of apples each year. New York State produces about 1 billion pounds of apples per year. The cosmic crisp was bred at my alma mater Washington State University.

Zacharey Hand

Anyone who likes a mealy apple cannot be trusted

Ninar Nuemah

“Ear candle your squirters” is possibly the most cursed thing I’ve ever heard. It’s the first time I’ve audibly said “ew” to this podcast 😂

Kendra Waters

The cosmic crisp was actually bred at Washington State University. I’m from the area of Washington that produces apples and went to WSU

Jude

i have eaten 2 bees and they taste very acidic and bile-forward. I haven't had a sugarbee apple so I don't know how it compares but I support emily.

Guy

Jake, did you end up eating that sweet soluna apple?

Austin Beasley

As someone who planted two cosmic crisp trees this year i was very excited for this episode!

Madeline

Okay so your squirter can get clogged. My partner had a huge goiter on his neck because his salivary gland was clogged. ER said yeah that happens try sour candy or waiting for it to heal. PS I want that Soluna apple I guess they're an Australian thing.

Argonautica

I think Caldwell is broken

Jae Beezy

Would love to hear their take on my favorite: the golden delicious (It's been 10 years since I've eaten an apple, and I'm now allergic in general)

Smiththebat

I think I’m definitely on the Emily/Jake train when it comes to apples. Tart and sweet baby! Honeycrisp and Cosmic Crisp apples are by far my favourite eating apples and I’m genuinely surprised Emily doesn’t like both seeing as the Cosmic Crisp is a hybrid of Honeycrisp and Enterprise apples developed to bring out Honeycrisp’s best characteristics of texture and balanced flavour with a better shelf life of Enterprise! It was invented by Washington State University actually very relatively recently! When did things come out? Only finally commercially released in 2019! But realistically if anyone’s mad at anything it should be at how Caldwell pronounced “Cavendish”.

Robert S.

Murph’s applethy sickens me.

Smiththebat

Also a giant Tupperware of apple and orange (or watermelon) at half time brought by a rotating list of players parents is an absolute childhood classic and I guarantee a LOT of you out there will back me up.

Smiththebat

Calling one “foul” made me laugh out loud! I’m with Jake, all the breeds are good at worst! …except red delicious. They can go to hell!

Erica H

Respectfully, I am appalled by all the apple-pinions in wildly different ways. 10/10

Nicole Jordan

Eating the Granny Smith last feels like sabotage! You’ve been eating so many sweet apples it’s gonna taste much more extreme than it would on first bite!

Anthony

Oh I wonder which orchard in Connecticut belongs to Jake’s cousin

CommodoreBlue

I am begging you people to start writing down your ratings 😭 every sommelier video you all do ends with none of you remembering what you thought of the earlier tastes/sips

Emily Bishop

released the week of the famed upstate NY Apple Fest I said "oh im sure"

Old Man Ballz 03

Wonder what Tucker thinks of these fruits. I think yall should bring him on the pod for a mix bag

Lili McGee

Not me googling every apple so I have a visual and screwing up my entire algorithm

austinoxner

How about them apples? Or those? Which apples will it be?

Jenna H

I developed an apple allergy as an adult and am no long able to eat them and I miss them all the time. I will defend you to my dying day my beloved Pink Lady.

Casey Wittner

I start skeptical of all apples, they’re my least favorite fruit. I could not disagree with Murph more. The ones I like are tart and crisp, any hint of sweetness and mealiness, I’m out.

Decafybara

Not having Cortland or McIntosh apples on this list is depressing. They are the GOATs and should be in season now

Jo Wright

Emily! We did apple bobbing with pink ladies at my wedding this solstice!! All the women there got super into it and gloriously fucked up our makeup and hair. but we also had to throw other fruit in for my niece because she couldn’t fit her teeth around one, so… 7 out of 5 cuties

A$

As someone who’s been researching the absolutely insane names of apples in England’s history, this episode is very enjoyable for me 😂 Here’s a few funny English varieties from the 1800s and some still grown today: Mr. Cox’s Orange Pippin Bloody Ploughman D’Arcy Spice Devonshire Quarrenden Diamond Jubilee Dog’s Snout Dumelow’s Seedling Feltham Beauty The Martian Apple

Kelly Gilbert

I eat a cosmic crisp apple every day with my lunch! They are so very good.

Bryce Peterson

Emily is absolutely correct about subjective restaurant ratings. I watched someone call their food perfection, say “compliments to the chef” unironically, and then rate it 3 stars.

Calic Tolentino

*insert obligatory hate comment on murph for having a mild take*

Ollie

Caldwell is so wrong smh… can’t believe they let a dude who doesn’t like apples be an apple judge 😔😔

Val

Segway to my favorite rabbit hole, the retired engineer turned orchard owner in NC who’s spent 30 years discovering and re-planting over 1,200 lost apple varieties. 2Crew? Nah, Tom Brown Crew 🫡 https://www.applesearch.org

Julie Penn

Gala and Cosmic Crip are best red apples, Granny Smith is a honorable mention. it’s hard to compare her to other apples because she is so distinct. Fuji and macintosh are by far the worst. Ever so slightly above Macintosh because I’d rather have a sweet apple compared to a soft mealy one.

Val

Dibs on Bobbing for Fujis as a band name

my guy

you guys gotta look into brian frange and his lifelong work. at least half of yall would go nuts finding the extent of that rabbit hole

Eugene

As a Washingtonian apple fan, the cosmic crisp is the hometown hero. I'd even go so far to say that they're the regulation apple.

jj-scout

I was looking up Soluna Apple's and came across Tom Brown, a retired chemical engineer from North Carolina who has been searching for and saving heritage apples since 1999. So far he's found over a 1000 varieties! https://www.applesearch.org/index.html

jj-scout

There's a US heritage variety called Greasy Skin

Davis

Cosmic crisp is my favorite too!

Grass

I feel a sense of patriotic pride for it

Brandon Burgess

I identify so hard with grabbing an apple due to low blood sugar after a workout. Glad it’s not just me that feels like I’m gonna die when it happens

Del

My history with Apples is that the Portland Nursery used to have an Apple festival every September. We would go every year. The main event was an Apple (and pear!) tasting. It was a huge line of tables of pre sliced apple varieties. They would give you a sheet to rank and remember the apples, then you could go buy them from big baskets. So this is honestly very normal to me. My favorite is pink lady, my dad was a Honey crisp man. But he was on the Cosmic Crisp hype train even before they came out. Really sad they no longer put on the festival.

Doc Fountains

I wish they tried Cortlands! They’re my favorite. Honestly though, Caldwell has the right of it

Connor

“You’re squirtless by choice because you could ear-candle your squirters at any point.” Is precisely the content I pay for

Dylan Adams

Unrelated to this mixed bag but a request for a future mixed bag. Ya’ll need to watch PROJECT ALF which gives everyone the much needed closure of what happened to Alf after the series finale (because not everything can hit the heights of the Dinosaurs finale). And of course it’s free on Tubi

Michael McPhee

Yeah absolutely, I learnt about this in my microbiology class! Panama banana disease is caused by a type of fungus and the global Cavendish population is at risk because they're grown clonally. We also didn't learn our lesson because the Gros Michel banana was basically wiped by this previously and we found the Cavendish was resistant to that strain of fungus and went we good now, and continued to grow them clonally. Thing about living stuff is it adapts eventually though, and the bananas can't really adapt without genetic diversity

Evan

The honeycrisp slander in this episode had me ready to crash out tbh

Austin Soren

Suggestion for popsicles taste ranking ,like the ones you would get from an ice cream truck as a kid.

Dandelion O’Candles

The panel is compromised until Caldwell gets his squirters ear-candled.

riddle me grinch

Oh shoot you're right. I wanted MN to have all the glory.

Marshal Adkins

If I had to guess I'd say Soluna apple is named that after the Greek and Roman goddesses of the Moon Selena and Luna respectively. Which is why it's the darkest, probably.

Olivia C.

I'm an SLP and actually just took a course on the intricacies of saliva, causes of salivary problems, and therapeutic interventions. There's help out there for you Caldwell!!

Stefan UrKILL (Figgy)

tbh I assume Simon Cowell hates music but he’s an extremely successful music judge 😂

Stefan UrKILL (Figgy)

loving all the Washingtonians in the comments activated like sleeper agents

Stefan UrKILL (Figgy)

there’s like one big munch sound when they all take a bite of each apple, but no gratuitous chewing.

Stefan UrKILL (Figgy)

also I’m pretty sure the name of Cosmic Crisp comes from all the small star-like spots?

Patrick E. (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-02 14:00 After Emily's immediate Fuji apple opinion I knew I was on her side big time. The sad apple of my childhood was red delicious but even still what a core memory. Then Emily cemented her babyface turn for the ep. She can klump
2026-10-01 01:34 After Emily's immediate Fuji apple opinion I knew I was on her side big time. The sad apple of my childhood was red delicious but even still what a core memory. Then Emily cemented her babyface turn for the ep by having to defend her rating system vs everyone else on the pod. She can klump

After Emily's immediate Fuji apple opinion I knew I was on her side big time. The sad apple of my childhood was red delicious but even still what a core memory. Then Emily cemented her babyface turn for the ep by having to defend her rating system vs everyone else on the pod. She can klump

Boots

Does anyone else here feel like Fuji apples aren’t the same as they used to be? They were once among my favorites, but now for the past decade, every time I’ve tasted one, it seems like it has no flavor. Did something happen, or is it just me?

AdversityHire

Bruh, if you got a mealy fuji apple that's a skill issue, respectfully. You picked the wrong one at the store, my guy

Emma Robinson

Not all heroes wear capes, unless you in fact are wearing a cape. Thank you my figgy friend.

Lucia V.

The apples were referenced in the London Live Show today and, as someone who regularly listens to the pod while scrumping for apples from people's gardens, to compare them all at home, I could not be happier with this content

Jeffrey Steck, Lord of the Fjord

Each individual apple can be different and they taste different as they get older. Your sugarbee seems dull looking. I individually pick my apples and only buy the shiniest ones. No dull apples!

Tyler Fontaine

DUDE MEALY APPLES ARE UNIVERSALLY HATED I THOUGHT OMG Also everyone not being in love with pink ladies? I feel like my core understanding of reality is shifted.

K. Diane

Thought you all had already done a patreon episode on grapes, then realized that was another headgum podcast (hey riddle riddle) that ate one grape every minute for an hour 🤣

Michael Singer

Had to go get some golden delicious after this ep to show them some love after being completely shunned

Michael Singer

Bro we listened to them talk about dragon pussy on day one, nothing gonna phase us

Courtney F.

Idk what this leads to but Fuji imho

Ross Wright

Yall should try cookies there's so many kinds of them and if you dont have one available you can make them

Young Hemlock

My personal fav at the moment is Sugarbee. Most disappointing apple has been snapdragons, don't live up to the band at all

Calenrow

Just want to say, it's awesome to see y'all still have the Pawpaw festival poster we sent up on the wall :) so glad you liked it

Courtney F.

The apples made me realize I am Caldwell

Madeline kane

"Tastes like childhood" she spat with disgust. Iconic

Clio

I can’t believe Murph and Caldwell can be this wrong about apples- I was so with them at the beginning but as soon as the ratings started I was SHOCKED

soyyyyyysauce

This was my favorite piece of media you guys have ever put out ❤️🍎🍏 (justice for red yellow apple)

soyyyyyysauce

Pink lady makes me think of nurse joy!!! 🏥🩷

Joel Jansen

Fun Fact: the cosmic crisp is named that due to the colouration/pattern. The dark color with white speckles is reminiscent of a night sky, hence the name Cosmic Crisp

Ágnes S

Jake is correct strawberry is the best fruit

Doctor Ransom

Just learned from Taskmaster UK that what that squirting in the mouth is called, it’s known as ‘gleeking’

A$

Please excuse my grave error. Yes yes I meant breeds of apples of course. *tips hat to you*

Sean Hutton

To be fair to Macintosh, it is really just a baking apple. Im that regard it is top tier. Definitely not a good snacker unless you just picked it off the tree.

Jen M

But Cosmic Crisp is a dolphin?? Confused 🫤 😂

xtinawhtvr

This was very triggering to those of us who are kindergarten teachers and just survived apple week at school last week.

Katy Tacik

Fuji and honeycrisp are two of my faves 😥

jake the fighting fucker

Im a apple farmer from Cornwall and i promised you a fresh queen cox is unbeatable and you are welcome to try that (side note its varieties not breeds )

Scrumblina Brumblina

I feel as though there's potential for some sort of social study based on the visceral reactions (or lack thereof on Murph's part) from these apples. Also, I will defend mealy apples until the end! Fruit shouldn't be hard or crunchy. That's just morally wrong.

Dom Lehn

Macintosh apples are my favorite. Small apple so it's the perfect snack but it's sweet so Em might not like it. I think it's a late fall apple though

Sarah Sullivan

Yes Macoun all the way! I love eating baking apples. I love firm and tart. NE apple orchards rise up

The Fun Yaunt

Emily and I have the opposite taste in apples 😅 And don’t even get me started on Caldwell!!! To be fair, I’ve never had a Soluna!

Peyton Raber

Nothing makes me laugh more than Murph getting slightly pissed off about something 😭 (also yall influenced me to grab a Granny Smith from my college dining hall as I was listening to this)

Leomund's Tiny Nut

I’ll add that the way Caldwell pronounced Cavendish is a minor apple hate crime

frances alice black

This is such a good call! There are so many of them and some of them are so weird

Unfitmoviebuff

You know you’ve made it as a brand when you can taste test apples and it’s a goddamned delight

Lindsay Blake

Whe you MANIACS said you LIKE A MEALY APPLE I freaking SHRIEKED.

Martian

Glad to see Emily joining team knife sharpening! It can actually be pretty meditative!

Baz C

insane world where i'm agreeing more with emily than murph in a tasting episode

Arillusine

The correct answer to apple rankings

Julia Thompson

My aunt has an orchard and she got exactly 1 apple this year and this ep made me so sad thinking about how ill have to purchase my own apples this year. Also they are crazy for saying huge apples are bad. Huge apples are the best. The bigger they are the better. Yall just a bunch of apple cowards

Arillusine

As an avid apple-lover, some of these takes were WILD. Good to know that I share some table apple preferences with Emily/Jake (a sweet tart apple with an incredibly crisp bite are my fave) but I feel like they were let down by the individual apples that were grabbed at the store. How can you like cosmic crisp and not honeycrisp, the cosmic is literally a hybrid derivative cultivar!

Sam Johnston

Havent listened yet. Have yall heard of applerankings.com? It's hilarious.

John the Spaceship

Doing an apple tasting in late August is… I mean, it’s crazy. Unless you’re tasting exclusively Paula Red and Ginger Gold. Wait a month and you’ll have a bunch of brand new apples to try. I manage a produce department and in August we literally run out of certain varieties because the last of the previous years crop is running out. August is as far away from fresh apples as you can get, except for a couple early varieties. Sorry, I’m a little passionate about this topic Edit: Caldwell doesn’t think Honeycrisp is sweet. The inarguably sweetest mainstream apple. This test is bonkers

Alexander Fryer

NADDPOD Contending for no1 apple podcast. Andrew would be furious.

Kevin O.

Them using cuties to rank apples is like comparing... apples and oranges

Erin Gardiner

As an LA resident, I just need to know which grocery store has the Soluna apples

CommodoreBlue

Hearing Murph and Emily interact with dogs would be interesting, since they’re both clearly cat people. Jake and Caldwell are both dog dads (and actual dads), so I’m sure they’d be great with them. The childless cat people, however…..

bungle

this could’ve been twilight sanctorum 😭😭😭

Kathryn Martin

Anyone reading this who has a teacher please give them an apple and say “to knowledge”

John the Spaceship

Apparently before the advent of grocery stores, and before they started being selected for their ruby red appearance rather than flavor they looked and tasted very different. But you have to hand it to the red delicious, it reigned supreme for 50 years.

Geshem420

As a farmers market employee and apple devotee this episode is SO for me I can’t BELIEVE it. I’m so happy.

electric_claire

There are a ton of non-Cavendish bananas.

electric_claire

Murph claiming the superior sense of taste when his assessment of every apple is "tastes like an apple".

Nic Q

Well now I feel the need to go on a quest to try cosmic crips and soluna! Pretty sure we don’t have them in my country but maybe I haven’t been looking. Loved this episode. Caldwell’s apple preferences are an abomination.

frankenmorgue

imagine the timeline where they included red delicious. in a way perhaps it is better that we weren't exposed to a potentially lethal psychic blast

Rachel Marie

Did y’all buy these apples at a grocery store? I demand a recount from a local farmer’s market. 😁 *edit: Please pet dogs. And invite your fans. I’m there.

frankenmorgue

also, washington pride driven cosmic crisp comments BLAST

Ash James

This is true...BUT here in the Philippines, and presumably other tropical countries, people still grow so many varieties and everyone that only gets to sample the Cavendish is missing out big time because they are really different from one another and lots are way more delicious. A banana with a deep acid fruitiness to it is amazing, then there are little delicate ones with a subtle candy taste, ones with big hard dark seeds in that you spit out on the plate like cherry stones, big meaty ones with red skin, ones that are most delicious when boiled etc. Bananas travel much worse than harder fruit though so a lot don't make it around the world.

Elizabeth Gunn, sickly but cruel

I said EWW MURPH out loud in my car when he said he likes mealy. I never want to yuck anyone's yum except for right now, y'all are perverts. Please try a cortland and a haralson next time. Emily, I'm sorry for the apple trauma you suffered, Jake, you're perfect.

Elizabeth Gunn, sickly but cruel

I didn't know I could still get this heated about a stranger on the internet's opinion, but I profoundly disagree with the curator of applerankings. That said, a great read.

TayJulia

Listening to this episode while munching a Granny Smith, which I argue is the best apple hands down

Gregory Moskowitz

Somebody tell Emily that theres a new star wars game coming out with a confirmed sabulba cameo!

Av

Never heard of soluna apples before but I’ve got to try them now… also Jake having a family member in the Apple business?? Why is his whole lineage business makers LMAO

LouieTheDog

Honorable find from Reddit

Brant

“Emily were you a nerd??” asks the man who grew up watching anime and who is a professional D&D player

Toni Wakefield

Are American Granny Smiths different to Australian ones? Because in my world they are the only apple for me, my love

Mik Rustand

There’s a podcasts about cosmic crisp apples out there that fundamentally shaped my worldview

Aidan Felker

If you stand for nothing, murph, what will you fall for?

NowWhatComix

I think a gummy test would rule, the world market in Burbank has something called squashies and the texture is Psychotic it’s like a near marshmallow

tautcarabiner

Agree that Fuji are bad eating apples but great for baking

Austin

Just because it was mentioned in the episode.. Taste a bunch of Doritos flavours, maybe with different Mt. Dew pairing!

Spencer Epstein

i love you knuckleheads. Bad luck that I love to listen to this stuff too. keep doing what sparks joy xD

Hooples Rich

My god you're right. What is the name of this feeling lol

Andy H

wow, I’m absolutely honored. I hosted an apple podcast in high school called “Bunches and Baskets”, and I’m shocked to see such blatant stealing. ps. hate the show

Nick Neverman

I’m also pretty sure at one point Caldwell mentioned that he thinks peanut butter and jelly is overrated/not good. I love my chaos prince but lines must be drawn.

Lindsey

wait doing an apple tasting mixed bag when jake specifically has covid is very funny, sorry jake

Jeremy Bartley

What happened in Emily’s childhood to give her such horrendous Apple takes?!?

Prettyinblack

Taste test suggestions that I think would be funny: 1. Alternative milks (almond, oat, rice, etc) 2. Protein drinks (Fairlife, muscle milk, nurri) 3. Gatorade colors 4. Nuts 5. Canned soups

Oru

I think this is my favorite taste testing! For other potential subjects, I think mangos could be a good one. Maybe even cake. Jake, we need your cake opinions NOW. U can't run.... also maybe decaf coffee so Emily can be in it lol and see how Murph reacts to it :)

Oru

Also since I'm pretty sure I have the tastebud where I can't taste the good stuff of alcohol, I'd love to see your takes on it! The only thing I've liked so far is peach alcohol >_< ill never understand alcohol lovers haha but its still rly fun to hear the hit takes 💕

snoogans

Murph is right. Also fun fact: putting a little bit of lemon juice on apple slices will keep them from browning quickly and make them taste like tart candy!

Aisling

I'll be reading this as a companion piece to the London live show

Pamphleteer

I can't believe I recently switched my lunch fruit from apples to plums, and then they drop this. How could I be such a fool?!

senna

Crazy how relevant this episode was to the london live show

jmjs

Where’s the love for the red flesh apples? I got converted to Lucy Glo’s a few years ago and I can’t go back.

BBI

No ambrosia?! Straight to jail

jc franco

Love the 2 Crew, but these apple takes were just plain wrong. Emily immediately writing some off after smelling the skin? Caldwell’s toon taste, where everything is opposite? Jork having to sit out the last portion because he didn’t get the same apples? Murph daring to say Red Delicious is “fine”? Excuse me? That is the definition of a garbage apple. Oh, and don’t get me started on the Honeycrisp slander. Honeycrisp takes a back seat to no apple! The selection was questionable too. All reds, one purple, and one green? Where are the Opals or Golden Delicious? I demand a 2 Crew Redo (Re Dew?)! Something like the previous sommelier eps, with separate categories to rate: snap, flavor, looks, mouthfeel and, of course, squirter response.

Grimmie

Thank you 2crew for today's Enrichment Activity

Juniper the Imp loves Jens Lyndelle

My first trimester I was throwing up multiple times a day fo weeks. Nothing helped until I finally got medicine and I ate so many apples because they're easy in the stomach. They part of the BRAT diet

Jolly Bee Happy

No apple review is complete without Sweet Tango.

Dr Golabki

No representation for Cox's Orange Pippin?!? It's almost like they aren't taking this seriously.

Clotilde

Was it at the same time, or two different instances of bee eating?

Clotilde

Guys, please help me- everyone on earth hates Red Delicious except me. Are the RDs in your area crisp, snappy, and delicious? Because I swear mine are.

Roy Prishkulnik

Yes! And plantains ARE different! You have to cook them before eating and they're awesome

heyspoons

im with Murph, never been offended by an Apple. Apple is Apple

Kelso of the Sea

Cosmic Crisp apples and Cougar Gold cheese are the best things to come out of Washington state university

Kelso of the Sea

I went to UW but I will always stand up for cosmic crisp apples and cougar gold cheese 🫡

Mr. Dude Sky

Is it weird that this has happened to me multiple times?

Mr. Dude Sky

It’s the regulation apple!

Mr. Dude Sky

I eat a cosmic crisp everyday. It has reinvigorated my love of apples.

Mork

I will always beg for more Twilight Santorum around this time of year, but this nails the fall vibes for me :)

Ethan Caleb

Caldwell needs to try the Winter Banana. It’s an apple

Mighty Turtle

Whoever was editing this did a good job of keeping in the crunchiest bites of each apple. Something really funny about them recording each bite of an apple.

DungeonMama

I would like to point out that the Granny Smith is operating on a different level because it's usually used in baking (pies, crumbles, etc.) rather than consuming raw (although you can also eat them raw). As such, I believe they deserve an honorable mention 🥧 🍏

Leo O.

Listening to this apparently led me to apple based delirium as I proceeded to buy every variety of apple at my local store

Bella Poore-Furolo

This is perfectly timed! The week after next my city is holding the Granny Smith Festival, in honour of the real Granny Smith who invented the apple in Ryde, Sydney!! It's literally my most favourite occasion of the year, we missed it last year because I gave birth a few days before but this year I have an apple loving 1 year old ready for a day of apple themed fun!! So Caldwell, if you're going to do an impression of Granny Smith, make sure she's Aussie next time!

Roy Prishkulnik

Eating a juicy Pink Lady while listening to this, shaking my head at the disrespect.

Natural Dragon

I don’t trust big banana. If it’s the only affordable source of food I have no issue with people eating them but the banana industry is super corrupt. At least apples are mostly grown in America or in countries with some workers rights.

Smiththebat

Fully agree. Cavendish bananas are probably the worst varietal. You haven’t lived until you’ve had a fully ripe little mini-guy fresh off a tree in the hot sun on a beach.

Smiththebat

Huh… I thought you could only get Cavendish by having a Gros Michel go Extinct and getting lucky enough to find a Cavendish in a later round. You learn something new each day.

Smiththebat

Absolutely! But Cosmic Crisp is a Washington apple.

Smiththebat

Golden Delicious can be good… especially fresh from the tree. Red Delicious… I think I’ve had ONE in thirty-three years that was decent.

Nathan Mills

I can’t believe there wasn’t a single “apple a day keeps the doctor away” joke. Must have been low hanging fruit

Zeon Liberation

What we’ve learned is that Murph and Caldwell have terrible taste in apples.

Zeon Liberation

Also Emily. Everyone is wrong except Jake.

Clemming

Amongst apple lovers I've gotten flak before for loving Macintosh, but when you get a good crisp one they have a level of tart juicyness that ive havent found elsewhere

Marquise

This podcast made me question the quality of apples available outside of our beautiful, evergreen state.

Stefan UrKILL (Figgy)

As a Washingtonian at heart who now lives in California, I promise there are also fantastic apples in our state. I go pick Roman Beauties, Gravenstein, and Golden Delicious every year.

Sam

no macintosh is diabolical

Michael Graham Abernathy

There are some surprising takes in thi episode, but somehow, the most shocking one might have been Murph saying that red delicious apples are "also fine." Red delicious apples are like 5 dooties for me. Worst apples in the world.

Maurice Khayat

Me prior to start: "I think they may be running out of ideas" Me 10 min in: "What is wrong with Caldwell?" Me at the end: "Man I really wish I had an apple"

Jude

two separate times within a few years of each other. The first was an accident, the second time I needed to verify my data.

Aedan

For sure. Sometimes I try to get my friends into naddpod, and then the new episode comes out, and they're reviewing M&M's or something, and I dont know how to explain why i like this

Courtney🐈‍⬛️

Granny Smith is my husband's absolute favorite apple so this is hilarious to me

BullgogiFrankie

I was once pleasantly stoned at a Sprouts after a workout when a lady approached me and said “hi would you like to try a Cosmic Crisp Apple?” And I stared at her in disbelieve. She smiled and said “it’s free!” Handing me an ice cold apple and she walked away. I did my shopping, cold apple in hand as I didn’t want it confused with my standard purchase, and went to check out prepared to argue that someone gave me this apple, some sort of apple rep, and that I’m not stealing it but it never came up. Stepping into the late afternoon heat as I exited the Sprouts, I took a bite of the still cold Cosmic Crisp apple and it changed me. One of the best Apple experiences I’ve ever had. 10/10 (I still think that lady might have been some sort of Apple witch with no association to sprouts)

Val

We are one

Justin Valentine

Cosmic crisp is named that because the white speckles on the skin are like stars!

EllActually

listening to this after seeing the London live show, heavily featuring apple cars??? I've connected the dots!

Katie Lackey

I’m sorry for your loss 🙂‍↕️🍎🪦

Zodi

The worst apples according to sales in my dept are pink ladies, gala, and red delicious. The worst apples.

Nick S

No Sweetango? Understandable, they're hard to find, but they're the best

Kaidan C

The perfect fall mixed bag (of apples) Also Emily and I have spookily the same apple history. Also Emily is right, she doesn’t have to put up with flak from apple fanboy Murph. And I need to point this out - Jake: huh, the outside looks like a little constellation Ten seconds later “there’s no reason to call it cosmic!” Also, beyond the look, it was designed to last longer and stay fresher than any other apple cultivar. It really is a space age Apple

David

Your dumbest premises are always produce gold.

Kaiden Ciongoli

Murph getting "go away heat" for fence sitting

mathangi

Love this. I get a bag of gala apples every week and once I got Fuji because they look similar and it was AWFUL

Dave Hensleigh

This is why I subscribe, this is peak content. That said, pink ladies are the best. I will not elaborate.

A. N. Snow

Honey crisp is my fave (repping MN!) But they aren't as good on the west coast and Cosmic Crisp is more consistently good out here. I do love that the name is because it's a cross between Honey crisp and Enterprise breeds!

Aaoh

Y'all gotta get a "Pink Pearl" it's flesh is pink not white

lily 😦

watery apples could be good apples for horses i feel

S Bekkum

On your next tasting try to find Cameo apples. I got a free apple at lunch break for one of my jobs and I tried dozens of breeds of apple. Cameo was my favorite of them all but they can be hard to find.

Noah Mercury

I pay a monthly subscription to hear four strangers eat apples 😔

David Guerrero

Honestly thought I wouldn't like this episode, but I came around. Now I have a new goal in life to try a mythical Blue Banana and determine if it's an affront to God, science, or both 😂

David Klein

I kid you not. I think I've put strain on my friend group by asking what type of apple everyone prefers.

ACK

Enjoyed the episode, but I'm truly outraged by the lack of representation for green apples...

Mairead Like Parade

I just want to let everyone know about this website that I found called applerankings.com and I think this review speaks for itself and perfectly matches the vibes of this podcast

Jesika Thomas

Genuinely the best episode ever uploaded

Hipster

This episode is the reason I upgraded my membership subscription 😂

Taylor Manes

it’s not a taste test episode until emily says that one of the options set off her squirters frfr

Gavin L.

I love the somm episodes so much, but I was burned during the m&ms episode (they had never even heard of my favorite flavor, pb&j). Now I’m shaking in my boots seeing my favorite actually in the line up this time. I fear for the worst now that I have something to lose 😣😣

Alena

SweeTango is the best Apple!!!! I ate One in my early 30s, and it changed how I think about apples

Fox

Cosmic crisp was bread by a professor in Washington who hated that apples went brown too quick when he would make them for his kids and he spent 20years selectively breading apples to be not brown the longest 10/10 cuties

KennedyH

In defense of Caldwell's honeycrisp rating, more than any other apple variety that I've tried, honeycrisps often have a definitive flavor gradient where one side of the apple is way sweeter than the other. I think his squirters are fine, and he just got the bland bit!

OceanTorrent

I can't get over the fact that Emily kept comparing apples she didn't like to childhood when I swear to Babayaga, Gala apples are the only ones that schools ever served when I was child and that is my least favorite apple.

Hammy

This is finally the episode where Caldwell goes full Bert

Tayci Stallings

Granny Smith is my favorite apple (I don't like sweet things) and it should not be mealy! It should be super crisp and almost hard. They're also the best for dipping in peanut butter as they cut through the sweetness and fat of the peanut butter.

SaritaWolff

I used to work at an apple orchard that grew and sold over 60 different varieties. Honeycrisp were the most popular. Interesting that Emily and Jake didn’t like the mealiness of fujis but loved the gala. Galas are like the softest apples. If you ever do this again, please try Evercrisp and Ambrosia (my favorites), and add an Arkansas Black and Red Delicious (bad) for the range. Also, since Jake has access to them, Empire and Cortland to fill in the middle range. By y’all’s reactions I feel like you definitely would have different tastebuds than I.

Beau R.

This is the first time I think I’ve ever been mad at yall. Pink lady’s and honey crisps are so good

Jordan Teets

Shoutout to Red Delicious and Sugar Bee who could not be represented here today

Emma

This!! I specifically waited until I picked up a bag of the U of MN honeycrisp apples to eat while listening to this episode!!

Abraham

I was with Emily until honeycrisp… the betrayal

Finlay Cushen

Thought I would share this - might help narrow down what you like in an Apple

Mother Of Boombie

Omg Emily, try Pink Luster apples. They’re early season though so any you get now will be grainy and not a true rep of how great they are. I am an apple bitch and I live close to a really nice boujie apple orchard with like 20+ varietals. Next season try a pink luster apple. They’re so perfect.

Mother Of Boombie

The browning of apples is called “rusting” and yes some varietals rust faster than others! Loved this haha

Lyndis Cealin

I don't know if you can get these in the US, but if so, try it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belle_de_Boskoop just be aware that this is not a sweet apple. It has sweetness, but is also sour making it a very complex taste profile. It's perfect for pies or goes great as a mousse with waffles. I love slicing it up frying it in a pan and then melt white chocolate over it. But it's also my favourite to consume in general. You can get sick from it because of the high acid, though.

C.J. Smith

This episode inspired my husband and I to buy a random assortment of apples. The checker seemed confused when we didn't bag up our apples and then was clearly mad when she realized it was because we had 6 different apples. In our home tase test it was Honeycrisp, Cosmic Crisp, Gala, Pink Lady, Envy, and Opal. Opal ended up being our winner and my 5 yr old's new #1 fruit. I told her she had Naddpod to thank. She looked up at our Nadpodd 2026 calendar and said "Thanks Pawpaw ... I don't like any of the other ones" 😵

Summer Tribe

400 comments, i love a divisive episode

RJ

Super late to the party, but yes! You HAVE to get honey crisp in season (october thru december-ish). When honey crisp is out of season I switch to cosmic crisp, which is still nice and sweet in the off season 🍎

Hailey Ross

Pink Lady for life, unquestionably the best