Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Ask a Question For Our Hearthside Chats! (Patreon)

Published:
2018-07-23 21:58:01
Imported:
2026-06

Content

July's Mixed Bag of Holding is going to be a Q&A so leave your questions in the comments below. We're likely recording this Tuesday evening (7/24), so don't delay! 

Comments

Anonymous

After this series comes to a close, would you consider switching up roles for a new campaign (AKA like a new DM, etc.)?

Israel Solis

QQ for the direct messenger: would you ever consider giving Hardwon a level or extra feat if Jake ever squats more than you?

CHUHCK

What was the white faceless thing trying to do to Hardwon? What would have happened if he had lost the wisdom saving throw?

Seth Holly

Question for Jake, Emily, and Caldwell. How did y’all come up with your characters? Class, race, names etc...

Paul jackson

Could Ol’ Cobb become a mainstay in the BoB after this arc? Sort of character for Murph?

Later McSkater

Would Bev ever pick up a 2nd class, or is his class just too ingrained into his character to be committed to anything more that sweet P himself.

Rich Hilborn

Were there any inspirations for your characters?

Anonymous

Is the Seattle live show going to continue the story or will live shows be more like one off episodes?

Joseph P

Any update on the tee shirts??

Dantizzle

Jake, now that you've got some experience with dnd and read some resources. What other classes appeal to your tastes?

John Nguyen

Would you guys actually consider doing Short Rests for earlier episodes, or "what-if"/new-game+ episodes where you "redo" an old episode but take it in a completely different direction?

Anonymous

Emily- Do you know when the song “Rosalean”(sorry if I spelt the wrong) is coming out?

Anonymous

Are you guys ever thing about doing something in Texas?

Frankenjam

Are you guys planning to continue levelling the band of boobs for a long period, entering them into new sub quests etc, or is there a specific end point to the campaign that you're looking to? If you are planning on a finale, would it be to a real world end date or narrative story end date?

Victor T (Balnor's Boy)

If there was an item that forced a change of race of each of the band of boobs, which race would each member become?

Justme

Have you ever considered having a guest come on as the DM instead of as a character?

Anailater

Does the campaign have a definitive end point in mind? Also are any revival mechanics in play once characters die.

Anonymous

Obviously the main story is incredible, but are there any fun one-shot ideas you want to play? Any chance of Emily DM'ing?!?!

Thomas Basile

Does Ole Cobb still have feelings for his former flame or will he explore the splendor of Nana KindLeaf. If Ole Cobb was to eventually finish his arc, I think reuniting and falling for Nana would be just.

Justme

Was there any strategic thought process between picking your characters races/classes? Where you trying to build out a succesful team or just picking things fun narratively?

Anonymous

Murph- If you were to let someone else dm for a change, what would your character be like?

Anonymous

Have you guys considered doing a graphic novel of your campaign?

Justme

If you could go back and change one thing that you've done knowing what you know now what would it be?

Anonymous

Would the bob consider doing a murder mystery one shot campaign

Justme

If your character gets killed and you need to re roll a new one what would you pick?

Frankenjam
>>14062225

Follow up suggestion: for a bonus series/ep, a short mini series prequel story for Young Cobb. Maybe another for Elias, Red and the SS Stormborn!

Anonymous

First off, I very much look forward to when you all meet back up with Erlin and he's become a fucking badass cleric, best healer boy Second, what are your favorite parts of eachothers and your own characters? and third, the most important thing, does your character prefer being big spoon or little spoon the most or something else? favorite cuddling position is very important info

Anonymous

Do you know who the next guest is going to be?

Justme

@murph any advice to new DM's? Any rules you think should be changed for more fun play or stuff you recommend doing like playing music or drawing maps? what does your DM set up look like?

Anonymous

Murph- where do you shop for your dnd handbooks

Jordan Suleiman

2 Qs for all: 1) Which NPC was everyone's personal favorite? 2) Can we expect you guys to revisit Sonic Adventure Metal City Mayhem as a one off? Maybe Jake was the missing link to making these decisions. Or maybe the BoB can help Sonic save the day and overcome his existential crisis via some form of homebrewing?

Feared AL

Q for everyone (incl Murph): If you could change one decision you've made in the campaign so far, what would it be?

Anonymous

@Murph: What kind of characters do you like to play when you aren’t dming?

Brad Donaldson

By the end of the campaign, is the airship going to be like in FF6, where you just have a bunch of potential 4th party members milling about until you decide to take one with you? (Ol' Cobb, Egwene, etc)

Marsh Land Monster

I know Hardwon's interest towards drug use has been touched on, but will Moonshine and Beverly do their best to make sure Hardwon doesn't get addicted to R. Cane? I'm worried he might go too far with R. Cane and I might not be able to handle all that =(

Anonymous

Murph, as a DM, how do you come up with all your ideas for the story?

Isaac Hall

Will you do a stretch goal for reviews and ratings? Desperate for some extra content

Anonymous

Are the bob ever going to go back to moonstone?

David

@murph what is the most outrageous thing the band of boobs has done that threw you for a loop?

Yvonne Russell

Is the podcast now Murph's full-time job?

Anonymous

One a scale of one to ten how much does everyone want nadpod porn/hentai? I’m sorry.

ExcArc

What would you call the central theme of the campaign?

Andrew

I’m trying to organize a DND session for me and my friends and none of us have ever played before. Since I’m organizing it I figured I take on the role of DM and I was wondering if you had any advice for a DM whose never played DND ( what kind of “story” to do, good ways to prepare, etc.)?Thanks for all the great content!

Isaac Hall

Murph, have you ever had to bluff or nerf an enemy or character mid episode or between episodes? And maybe also you could give us some examples from early episodes of things you planned for that never happened

Anonymous

Last question. Who is everyone in the groups favorite character other than themselves?

Colin Giebner
>>14062217

I think there is something on 8-bit Book Club that goes into their characters! Still a great question for those who might not know.

Anonymous

Will you ever potentially do a live show abroad (...like in the UK)?

Colin Giebner

I drive back and forth from Western Mass to Pennsylvania every other weekend. I have relistened to the campaign many times. My question is does Bev still have all those teeth he had collected? If so, where is the tooth shield?

DonLemontheDwarf

@murph Do you plan on any big NPC deaths that will shock the players.

Mark Lanter

What do you think your character do if granted a Wish spell?

Anonymous

A technical question, because I know nothing of DnD: if the unfortunate event strikes, and a character dies, will the new character you get, be the same level as your old one, or start from level 1? Or does Murph decide that when it happens, so it’s in the best context?

DonLemontheDwarf

Jake have you ever thought of DMing your own games. If so with you and do you plan on recording

Anonymous

Favorite episode so far??

DonLemontheDwarf
>>14062866

Usually for myself when a character gets killed i make my players make a character of the same level as everyone else but they cannot be the exact same character as the one that got killed unless they give an awesome backstory that works with the world and story.

Micah Keyser-Rothgery

If each character could have access to one spell, what would it be and why?

Anonymous

Would you consider doing any special episodes telling some tales of the Legends of Bahumia, with the players taking on the roles of other characters, such as Mishka and the legendary heroes?

Bpzsculpts

Once the story is finished, do you guys plan on doing another with the same characters? New characters in Bahoomia? New world altogether?

Anonymous

Hey direct messenger and the two crew! Do you have a go-to one shot for curious friends who don't want to commit to a long campaign? Should I create characters for them or let them create beforehand?

Emily Lentz

at the crick, are all youngins direct decedents of memaw, or are other elves allowed to have youngins together? How long is the gestation period of one baby elf that memaw can have so many? Or are a lot of them just triplets and such? I think about this literally every day

Expedia the Forbbiden One

Murph do you have any tips on how to organize my DM info. I’m working on a campaign and it just feels like my head’s gonna explode from all this information!

Anonymous

This one is for Biron Murphiel! Do you write the stories on a weekly basis not knowing where the next week goes or do you have a general outline for the next month or so? Is this how you usually write campaigns?

Rae Clo

1. Bev obviously has his beautiful romance with Erlin, but is there going to be any romance on the horizon for Hardwon and Moonshine? (I want my hot magic mushroom mum and strong dad to hook up I'm SORRY) ((kind of related follow up, does fanfic exist for naddpod yet? If so, have you read any? If not, are you hoping there will be?)) 2. For Emily, your music is so great. Does the inspiration for your songs hit you while you're doing the podcast as the scenes are happening or do you come up with them on recall? (P.S. I love Doomsday Diaries, I listen to that album like non-stop)

Melvin Marasigan

For brand new starting DMs, can you explain what exactly is in a DM screen and what’s the best one for starting DMs to get?

Arod

Murph, what was your original intention for Ol' Cobb? I'm assuming when you first introduced him you didn't expect him to play such a large role in the adventure...or maybe that was your plan all along!?

Anonymous

Murph, have you ever used modules for DMing? Or do you always write your own campaigns?

Griffen Bier

In an alternate universe where the Band of Boobs had never crossed paths on that fateful day in Moonstone, what would each of your characters be up to?

Anonymous

Do you ever plan on incorporating any members of the council of elders into the plot? I'm thinking cameos, nothing major that will really affect the plot.

bunbee

What's your favorite thing that your or someone else's character has done that was definitely a mistake, but also you don't regret happened? I joined my first campaign recently and my idiot ranger, their first time meeting, accidentally shot one of her party members in the shoulder with an arrow, and while my character deeply regrets this whoopsie, me and my friend who plays the character that got shot thought it was really funny.

Matthew Millions

If each of you, in real life, could learn one D&D spell, what would it be? (excluding the wish spell)

Anonymous

if your character would die what would the new ones be and why?

Emilie

I'm always amazed that the BOB can do something completely out there that seems to fit perfectly (and be almost requisite) for the plot. Murph, has there ever been a time where you weren't sure you could fit the shenanigans into the plot? How do you work around completely unexpected occurrences?

Shawn Magill

What do you do for prep, as a dm Also just like any all purpose dm advise for a first timer

Andrew durham

What are you guys most nervous about for the first live show? Also is middleditch a possible future guest?

Anonymous

What is your favorite character you have played in a tabletop rpg campaign?

Kasandra

Which character do you think is more likely to die due to a crime of passion?

Anonymous

Story daddy, do you have any bit of the end game planned out yet (like final confrontations, characters returning, or locations) or will it all depend on where the Band of Boobs take the story?

Jeffrey Steck, Lord of the Fjord

Emily - you currently have 10 spell slots and 3 cantrips for Moonshine?!? Are the cantrips unlimited use while the slots can only be used once a day? If you want to use a spell more, can u stock the same spell in multiple slots? Does Caldwell/Bevs spells work the same way and how many does he have?

Anonymous

What was one of your most devastating losses in a D&D game, PC death, equipment loss or otherwise?

Arod

Jake, I know you said in a recent short rest that Jill was interested in playing. Is there any possibility of her coming on as a guest? It would be interesting and pretty funny if she played a former or current love interest of Hardwon.

Anonymous

If any of your characters were rendered unplayable (permanently injured, trapped or dead), would you make a completely different character? Or would you guys make a clone to fill your role within the group like hardones twin hardbuns surefoot the squat god?

Sweet Karoline

When running NPCs like Ol' Cobb or any other NPC that has to contribute to combat and the story, how much do you change the die rolls to not take away from the players? And Murph, do you enjoy playing a character as well as DMing?

Justin Harris

Does Hardwon still have Galad's head? Also, what other random items do the Band of Boobs still have?

Scott.

I've been doing a bit of podcasting myself. How do you guys rarely say "like" and "um"? Is it just a conscience thought, or do you never say it anyway?

Sam Ostrin

Who is your dream guest? My vote is Michelle Obama. You guys should contact her people and get her on the pod

Anonymous

Caldwell, was it always your intention to make Beverly a LGBT character? Or was that something that kind of progressed naturally as the story went. Either way love the inclusion in the story.

Anonymous

Now that Hardwon and Beverly both have named weapons, will Moonshine name her scimitar or new trident? If so, what would be some potential names?

Anonymous

Question for Murph: how do you balance letting your players have fun and bending the rules a bit while still keeping the game mechanics fair and challenging?

CHRIS RIOS
>>14067527

I know they are supposed to be answering the questions, but in case they dont get to this one I will gladly explain! The way spell slots work is like a mana pool. You have so many spells "memorized" for the day, and the spell slots are ways they can cast then and drain their "mana". It's the equivalent to having arrows in a quiver that regenerates with rest. Otherwise spell casters would be really unbalanced and would just be a glass cannon from level one. They can use any spell that they have memorised for the day by expending a slot. When she talks about the "level" of the spell slot, that is talking about a different level of power that is required to cast a spell at. Some spells require higher level spell slots but often do better things. They can even cast their lower level spells through higher spell slots for greater effects. As spell casters level up, they get more spell slots of lower and higher quality. So she has 10 now but will likely end up with around 26. And yes! You were correct about cantrips. Unlimited use, but still takes one action to do.

CHRIS RIOS

Question to Murph. I am a long time player, but new to Direct Messaging. I am currently dealing with a player that loves to play, but consistently tries to over throw my story telling to the newer players by being "that guy" (the know it all rules lawyer). How do I prevent this from happening without being a huge dick about it?

Michael McDougall
>>14070849

Was just about to ask this, with more people than ever like Vin Diesel making their love for D&D known, and the increase in popularity of shows like Critical Roll, who would be each of your dream guest. (and my vote would go to just Caldwell doing his Adam Driver impersonation)

Anonymous

Question for Murph: how much of Ol' Cobb's back story was planned when you originally created his character? I think you mentioned in a short rest that he was originally intended to give more information on the widow, but now we know all about his history with Jolene and Mirabelle. Was this always the case, or did you add more depth to his backstory when the boobs decided to make him a party member?

Anonymous
>>14073738

Also, when Nana and Ol' Cobb get married, and if Bev and Erlin get married someday, Ol' Cobb will become Beverlin's grandad. Just sayin'.

Anonymous

Questions for Murph: Since the characters are such an integral part of the podcast and they love some shenanigans, do you find yourself twisting the rules or the rolls to ensure they don't die? How much longer are the sessions compared to the edited version we hear?

Adrienne

1) what’s your advice to a new player? I’m playing an elf ranger for the first time because of this podcast (who will have a raccoon named Oliver)

Adrienne

2) If you each had to play as someone else’s character (body swapish) who would you pick?

Ken McGeachie

Why haven't Hardwon and Moonshine hooked up yet?

John Dowse

Any chance we might get a second campaign going with someone like Emily dm'ing with new players as well?

John Dowse

How long does one of your dnd sessions last? For instance when i play with my group we play for 4 hours. Or do you just record as much as possible on that day you play?

Anonymous

In the next campaign, if one of the band of boobs was to become the main baddy, who would it be and why?

Thomas Jansen

Question to the DM: Since the Mad Gnoll was described as a dog-pig-man-thing, are the Gnolls in your world different from the hyena-men in vanilla DnD? Or was this a case of the characters not having knowledge of hyenas and gnolls?

Humble Goblin

Will we ever get a DM guide for the adventures you guys have been on? The galaderon saga and the bubble saga seem like they would be real fun to play

Michael McDougall
>>14078972

Bev will continue to grow stronger with the intent of being able to better protect Erlin, but will soon become too powerful and accidentally kill Erlin which will drive him insane. (essentially an Anakin/Padme situation)

Michael McDougall

Can August's Mixed Bag of Holding be a playthrough of Metal City Mayhem with Jake?

Eric Saxon

Question for Daddy: Was the naming of Mirabelle - former lover of blunderbuss-totin' Ol' Cobb - inspired by the RPG Jade Empire, in which you obtain a blunderbuss *named* Mirabelle?

Anonymous

Question for the amazing DM: Have you ever come across a situation where your players completely failed at progressing the plot forward, like they killed someone and didn't get necessary information out of them or if they had bad case of the 2 crew and pass necessary checks to progress the story? Do you quickly try to add another plot point to help them get back on track? Ignore their fails? Question for Beverly:

Anonymous

Question for Beverly: any chest hair yet bud? Toe? Arm?..... armpit?

Just Alex

Jake, can you talk a little bout how and to what extent Hardwun identifies himself as Elias Stromborn II? Do you think there's an inner storm brewing (pun intended) as his uprbringing was in every way imaginable completely contradictory to how his parents lived their lives? Where's he at right now concerning the whole revelation?

Hannah Miriam

Question for everyone: if you could change one critical decision you all made (after learning the consequences), what would it be?

Anonymous

Can you talk about what the widow's character arc would have been?

Resteasy

Do you guys all agree with the drawings you have seen of your characters or do you have something entirely different in mind?

Anonymous

If you had the chance, is there anything you would have changed with your characters?

Anonymous

Do you guys have any ideas for second characters should any of the current band of boobs bite the bullet?

Luke Rainbird

Are there any decisions you've made during the campaign that you regret?

Kevin Alman

What food did Hardwon eat before he got addicted to Moonshines crick cooking?

Ashley Jamieson

What happens if a character dies at the start of a session? Do you have back ups ready or do they just sit quietly and think about their mistakes for the rest of the session?

Anonymous

Is there any issues with taking a little artistic ingenuity in writing a short story off shoot? I have an idea in mind and want to roll with it but I don’t want to step on any beard hairs or halflings. It’s mainly for my own entertainment and I’d send it to naddpod to critique as well.

Anna Todd

How's Galad's head doing? Is it starting to rot? Have any critters secretly taken residence in it since the BoB entered the Crick?

The Soviet Dog

What animal familiars would Hardwon and Beverly have? And if she hadn’t had a possum what animal would Moonshine have?

PJ

Will the Band ever play a true gig? Also, will Paw-Paw ever obtain lil possum armor?!

Don Cheadle Jr.

What would each of your characters' favorite movies be? (if they had movies in Bahumia)

Marisa

What first got you into DnD? Did you guys listen to other DnD podcasts like The Adventure Zone or Critical Role/ do you guys have a favorite?

Anonymous

My god so many questions

Dorothy

Everyone but muph: have you had any theories that came true. Murph: have any of their theories or fan theories been surprisingly close? How do you react to that?

Boris DeOnion

Have you guys considered taking a page out of the McElroy's book, or Caldwell's Drawga series (which I'm still highly anticipating), by incorporating fan made items into the campaign? Would love to see what nods your fans can make to your other content. For example (not very well thought out and just from the top of my head) a Metal City Mayhem book that when activated, sends the user into a rage and adds a +2 bonus to attack rules for the duration. Or perhaps a fake Paul Blart mustache, that when worn adds +1 to sneak checks.