Straight A's | Trouble in Paradise E5 (Patreon)

Everyone is over the age of 18

So you read the first story arc of the Straight A’s special, and you might have some mixed feelings about it. Bringing Ben back into the mix? I was asking for a riot here hahaha. Troy can’t seem to be able to satisfy the submissive side of Joseph anymore, and Joseph has had to resort to some secret dildo time. One day, he brings up how Troy was more passionate in bed when Ben was still around, and that’s where we’re picking up…

-----------------------------------------

“We don't have to.” 

That's what Joe keeps insisting.

“I'm happy with just you. You're my dream guy,” he says and kisses my wrist.

He was falling asleep in my arms. Normally, this is the position post-sex that knocks me out too. But tonight, there was a question that kept repeating itself in my head. 

Does he want to fuck around with Ben again? 

Questions, actually. With an S. A lot of questions. 

Didn't we finally get rid of Ben? 

Why did Joe cum so hard when we talked about him? 

Did I really fuck better when he was in the picture? 

“Joe. Tell me honestly. Is that what'll make you happy?”  His face scrunches as he tries to make sense of my words, but he's too far asleep to give me a real answer now. He snuggles into my chest, and I wrap him up tighter. 

Do I have to share him to make him happy? 

I didn't get a ton of sleep that night. I have to admit that the idea isn't completely a turn off for me. Yeah, I don't want Ben’s literal asshole anywhere close to me, but it does turn me on to put him in his place. Imagining fucking Joe's ass in front of him gave me a boner most of the night. That dumbass will probably be turned on by it too.

But Joe will want more, wouldn't he? 

He stretches with a yawn in my embrace like a cat. “You smell good.”

“It's your soap.” I kiss him on the forehead. I hate this feeling when you're wide awake all night, but then by the time morning comes around, you're exhausted. 

“I know,” Joe says. “Your old stuff was very…bro-ey.” He has a habit of feeling for my morning wood when he wakes up, and today is no exception. “Whoa.” He looks up at me as he closes his fist on my rock-hard cock. I guess I've kinda mentally edged myself thinking of the situation all night. And I’m ready to drain the pole now.

“Want to hop on?” I run my hand down his back, travelling along his spine before making a grab at his ass. 

“I want to suck it.” Joe moves to do it, and I stop him. 

“I want to talk to you,” I say as I pull him on top of me. I grind my boner into his ass, humping him until he gets into a natural position. 

“What do you wanna talk about?” He leans down to kiss me. I hold him down at the position so I can explore his mouth while I dry hump him. “I don't know if you've forgotten, but we need to take off our underwear if you want to get inside.” 

“Wait, I have something to say.” His hands press on my chest and I feel like my heart might explode under the pressure. “About last night.” 

“Troy, I already said we don't have to do anything about that. It's just a fantasy.” Joe plays with my nipples before feeling up my abs. 

“This is the happiest I've seen you in a while,” I say. He really is glowing. I caress his smooth skin and slim sides while gently thrusting upwards. 

“That's because of you. Not Ben.” 

I felt my cock flex when Joe said his name. I know he felt it too. 

“I want us to try it. But I want us to have rules too,” I say.

The glimmer of excitement in his eyes told me that that's what he wanted me to say. I touch the front of his underwear and confirm what I already knew to be true. He's so turned on by this. 

“I don't want you to kiss him, okay?” 

“Of course.” He reaches back to grope my rigid package. 

“And I don't want him to cum inside you.” The words are hard to get out, but I try my best to be clear. 

“You want him to fuck me?” Joe’s eyes widened. “But…”

“If that's what you want,” I say. “But I don't want his jizz inside you.” 

Joe nods, and then chuckles. “Oh god, what are we even talking about?” 

“We're talking about making sure my beta is satisfied.” The eye contact we make is electric and he leans down to kiss me. “Oh…” I moan in his mouth as he grinds down on me.

“The thing is, I bet Ben is totally submissive now. Remember he got off sucking my dick? And there was that other twink he was going to blow too.”

I push up with my hips to meet his grinds, shoving my fat hard-on right in between his cheeks. 

“Can we fuck now?” Joe groans.

“Was he good?” 

“Huh?” Joe bites my ear. He's clearly in heat now, and I couldn't think of anything else I would rather do than to breed him before the day even starts. 

But I want to know. 

“Was he good at sucking dick?” 

“He was…ok.”

“Do you think about it sometimes?” I massage his body. The fuck me vibe is just emanating off him. 

I have to control myself. I want my answers.

“Yeah,” he admits. I have him lay chest to chest with me so I can pull down his underwear. “Troy…I want you to fuck me.” 

“Do you think about it sometimes while I fuck you?” I ignore the pang of jealousy and channel it into small spanks on his bubble butt. 

Smack! 

“Oh god… Troy…”

Smack! 

“Tell me the truth,” I push him back up to sit on my crotch. “Then, maybe I'll fuck you.” 

“I…” His cock is so hard, it stands rigid as he grinds against me. 

“The truth, beta!” I lick my hand and place it on his shaft, and then I feel his entire defense melt away. 

“Oh… yes! I think about it sometimes when you fuck me!” His shoulders are hunched up like I'm giving him electric shots. My own rod experiences a surge of energy through it as I heard the truth. “Troy, I need you to fuck me. Please!” 

I want to.

I want to fuck him until he's raw. Until he’s too sore to even think about another man. 

“OhHHh…” Joe squirms on me, and I increase my grip on his boner. 

That asshole tasted this before I did. 

“Fuck me, Troy. Please fuck me.” Joe settles his breathing, rolling his hips against my covered shaft. 

I take a deep breath and then push up roughly with my hips, making Joe kneel on the bed. I push him forward until his rock-hard cock is in front of my face. 

“Troy?” 

I take another deep breath, and make a dive for it. It's now or never. 

“Oh my god…oh my god…oh my god!!!” His fingers run through my hair. “Troy!” 

Jesus, I have no idea what I’m doing. I never thought Joe as big down there, but it fills up my mouth and I don't know what else I can do. 

“Oh..” Joe moans at the small movements I make, and I decide to suck it like if it was a lollipop. “Oh my god…”

“GuHHH…” I resist the urge to cough as his dick touched a part of my throat that I've only felt at the doctors. 

“Ohh…oh my god…” He didn't seem to notice. His thighs are trembling beside my face.

It's so hot. 

Acting by instinct, I pull his cheeks apart, and he shoves his dick deeper in my mouth. Giving up on the sucking, I probe his sweet hole with my middle finger. 

It opens up willingly for me, but it's still too dry to go in. I take him out of my mouth and spit on my hand. His slobbered on cock is veiny so up close to my face. I never noticed them before.

“I want you to cum in my mouth.” I look up into his eyes. I think he only started to understand what I said when I pushed his ass again, putting him inside my mouth while I searched for his hole again. 

“OhHHHh!” This time, my finger goes in easily. His warm hole tightens around me and then relaxes, and then tightens again. 

“MMMFFFff…” I cough as he moves his hips. Whatever I'm touching inside him is driving him wild. It's like he's forgotten what he's doing as he tries to get more of my finger and my mouth at the same time. 

“Ohh…OHhhhuh…” The way he's grabbing my hair kinda hurts.

“GuHHH!” 

I can't take too much more of it, so I think about what I can do to make him finish. Knowing what he likes, I add another finger in his ass. 

Bingo.

“Ohh…oh my god! I'm gonna cum! I'm gonna cum!” Joe pulls himself out of my mouth. I growl and crunch my neck forward to take him in. “I can't hold it! I'm cumming!” 

I dig my fingers into him, and his inner walls tremble around them. 

“AhHHHH!” Joe collapses forward, pushing his flat stomach against my forehead. 

Then, the liquid came. It was a taste that felt like it should be familiar but it was my first time. 

Do I swallow it? 

“AHHh…aHHHH… oh my god!” His asshole clenches strongly against my fingers. “AHHHhH…” Then it relaxes. 

At the same time, I feel his cock soften a bit in my mouth. 

“Ahh…” A little weak pulse around my fingers. “Oh…” His fingers relax their grip on my hair. He leans backwards, and his softening cock pops out of my mouth. 

Joe’s chest heaved as he took big breaths. He looked up at the ceiling, and I saw his shoulders relax with each exhale. 

He looks so happy. 

“Did you swallow?” He looks down at me. I shake my head no with my mouth full of his cum. Joe lays beside me, and puts his hand on my chin. “Give it to me.” 

I turn my head towards him. Is he sure?

“I want it,” he confirms and I lean down to kiss him, opening my mouth and letting his juices flow down into his mouth. 

“MMm…” Joe sighs as he drinks his own seed. “You are amazing.” 

“I'm sorry it took me so long to do that.” The texture of his cum is all over my lips. 

“You are amazing,” Joe repeats. He kisses me, cleaning my lips of his orgasm. 

So I guess we're going to do this Ben thing.