Straight A's | Christmas Special E7 (Patreon)

Everyone is over the age of 18

From Troy’s POV:

---------------------------------------------

“What did he say?” 

We waited a whole day for Caleb’s response after sending the video. You know, the video where I completely owned Joe’s tight ass. We thought after a couple hours that the situation was too weird for him. Joe said that Caleb’s a nerd like him, so it’s not that surprising that he needed time to process.

“He asks if we're in an open relationship,” Joe says, laying his head on my chest. It's been snowing out so we've been spending our afternoon in bed. Strangely enough, we haven't fucked today yet. Not that we don't want to, but cuddling and looking at the lights Joe hung up in our bedroom sparkle is a different feeling. 

“That shit means we're banging everyone right?” I ask.

“I guess so. I've never been in one.” 

“We did it with Ben,” I say. “That counts as an open relationship then, right?” 

Joe lifts his head to look at me. Sometimes, I think his glasses get in the way. When he's not wearing them and looking at me like this, it almost feels like a different person is in bed with me. 

“I think we can call it whatever we want,” Joe says. I give him a little peck, and he returns to his comfortable position on my chest. “Closed relationship with appointments required?”

“You want him to fuck you, don't you?” 

“I think you want him to fuck me. You can’t let it go,” he says. Maybe both are true. Thinking about someone else inside my boyfriend makes me want to fuck his hole raw again. 

But this isn't a Ben kind of situation. Nobody can love that asshole. We used him and dumped him, like he deserved. 

This is the guy he lost his virginity to. A guy with brains as big as Joe’s. 

“Your heart is beating really fast,” Joe murmurs. Naturally, his hands investigate below the belt line. 

“What did it feel like when you lost your cherry to him?” I grunt as he massages my balls. “Did you cum?” 

“I did,” he says, humping my right leg as he grips different sections of my shaft. 

“Do you think about it a lot?” 

“Sometimes. It was a good first time.”

“Is he rough like me?” 

“No one is rough the way you are,” Joe says with a little nibble on my pec. “You’re a whole nother thing.” 

“A fuck machine?” I chuckle. He called me that last night when I drilled two loads into him. 

“The love of my life,” he responds and my throat constricts. I blink back the sudden rush of tears to my eyes and comb his hair. “Do you want a blowjob?”

“Not yet.” I hold his face to my chest so he doesn't see the drops leaking from the corner of my eyes. I don’t have the vocabulary to describe how I feel about this boy. “Text him. Tell him to come over.” 

“You know I’m more than happy with just us,” Joe says, pushing his boner against my thigh. 

“Call it a Christmas gift.” My wood flexes in his hand.

As expected, Caleb came through. I knew he wouldn't be able to resist. He’s kind of a strange mix between nerd and jock. He's about as tall as I am, and he's in decent shape, but there's something about his posture that doesn't say “athlete.” He probably just hits the gym to look like this. 

“Wow, Joseph, it's been a long time.” I watch them hug, the internal jealousy already sparking up inside me. 

“Yeah. How you've been?” Joe has to look up at him like he does with me. 

“I'm good! I've been working on a new project on aerodynamics. I…” Caleb's voice trails off as I stand behind my boyfriend. Then, he puts on a fake smile. “You must be Troy.” 

“You've heard my name then,” I say, remembering the video we sent him of me plowing Joe. 

“Troy! Troy! My hole belongs to Troy!” 

Caleb looked flushed as he searched for a response. I decide to take it further and make it known how it's going to go down. 

“Let's be clear here, man. This,” I grab Joe’s ass with both hands, “is mine. Now, I'm willing to share today, but no kissing, no rimming, and no cumming inside him.” 

“Geez.” Caleb tugs on his shirt’s neckline. I can see him sweating bullets. “Joseph, is this what you…” 

“His name is Joe,” I assert. “And I call the shots here.” Joe nods in front of me. “If you don't like my rules, then get out of here.” 

“Okay.” Caleb looks at Joe for the last time and fixes his eyes on me. “Can I… Can I touch him?” 

“Go ahead.” I nod. I back up enough and watch the ex-lovers reconnect. They touch each other's arms and waists, lips moving close but never touching. Slowly, they remove each other's clothes until they stood naked in front of me. 

Caleb is a nervous looking dude. While he's got muscles and all, he doesn't seem to know how to show them off. Joe, slutty as he is, is already at full mast, while Caleb’s dick looks soft and sad. 

Another chance to show him who's the alpha here. I strip out of my clothes, and pull them apart with a hand on each of their chests. I see Caleb look down first at my big hard cock, and the red flushing spreads to his ears. 

“Suck, beta.” 

Joe drops to his knees and swallows my cock in an instant. I turn to his ex, and show off proudly how I have my beta trained. 

“You're going to need to get hard if you want to fuck him,” I say to him. Then, I look down at Joe, and caress his hair. “That's it, good beta. Show him how we do it.” 

“GahHHh!” Joe deep throats me. 

“Oh yeah.” I hold him down there. I look at Caleb again, and his gaze is fixated on my junk getting slobbered on. He's a beta too. That's why he and Joe were never going to work out. I pull out and my boyfriend licks at my shaft like it's his favourite thing. Because it is. “That's right, beta. Service this big cock.” I spit on him, and Joe moans with pleasure, beating himself off to being dominated.

Caleb is getting hard without touching himself. And his gaze hasn't moved an inch. 

“He wasn't like this when you knew him, was he?” I taunt, shoving my cock down Joe’s throat and making him sputter. 

“No,” Caleb says in amazement. “That's hot.” Proud of myself, I pull out again and lean down to give Joe a possessive kiss. 

“It's time,” I snarl into his mouth, then roughly push him onto all fours. “Go,” I say to Caleb. “Joe, look at me.” I kneel in front of him. 

“OhhHh…” His big eyes widen as he gets penetrated by someone else for the first time in a long while. 

“You look at me.” I recognize that look in his eyes. That dirty submissive look. He's been craving another dick. Joe bites his lips as he wills his eyes to stay open. “I love you.”

“I love you too.” We kiss, and Joe moans in my mouth with each pump that he receives. 

“Oh shit…oh shit…” Caleb moans. We ignore him, kissing passionately in our own world. I hold Joe up as he uses one hand to jerk me off. 

“You're going to need to fuck him harder if you want him to feel something,” I say to the man inside my boyfriend. 

It's almost a little sad looking. With the muscles that he has, Caleb can't fuck for shit. Instead of rolling his hips, he propels himself slowly into my beta’s hole. 

“That's not how you do it,” I say. I get up from my spot and push Caleb out of the way. Within two seconds of him being out of Joe, I spear into his guts. 

“Oh! Oh! Oh!” Joe cries out. I pound into him, giving him rapid and hard thrusts that I know he loves. “Troy! Troy!” 

“Like that.” I pull out and step aside for Caleb to go in again. As soon as he's in, all the colour drains out of his face. 

“You made him loose… oh fuck, I'm going to nut.” His hips finally start moving properly.

“Not in him!” I roar, loud enough to make the tall man jump. He pulls out just in time, and ejects far shooting streams of cum on Joe’s back. 

“Oh my god,” Joe says, turning his neck to see his ex jet copious amounts of jizz on him. I watch Caleb prepare to reenter his ass and I hold him back. 

“You're done.” 

“I'm not done cumming,” Caleb whispers. 

“Yes, you are.” I pull on Joe’s hips and he rotates like a rag doll for me. I push myself in him and plug his hole up. “Say bye to your friend, Joe.” 

“Bye… Caleb… oh fuck.. oh fuck! Oh fuck!” Joe’s composure melts as I fuck him into oblivion. 

“Tell him whose hole this is.” I stare Caleb right in the face. His jizz rolls off Joe’s back as I pummel him. 

“Troy! It's Troy's hole! It belongs to Troy!” Joe shouts and I wink at his ex. Caleb puts on his clothes, unable to look away as I give Joe the real fucking he needs. I'm talking face down on the carpet with his ass up like a good beta bitch. “It's Troy's! My hole is Troy's!” I fuck him non-stop until Caleb leaves our apartment. 

“Good job, beta.” I finally let up. I'm dripping in sweat and completely breathless. He flips around and lays flat on the carpet, with a look of total disorientated haze on his cute face. “You good?”

“Oh, I am so good,” Joe giggles. “I have you.” 

“That you do,” I pull his ankles to be on my shoulders and slide in him gently. “Now, fast or slow to finish?” 

“You're the alpha.” He smiles at me. “You tell me.”