Book Club: The Changeling (Final Session) (Patreon)
Content
We landed this plane. But how smooth was the final descent? I’ll start with what I absolutely loved.
LaValle stayed committed to the fairy tale motif with the troll swallowing the child whole. I went from what the holy hell? to Oh, of course.
Of course, there are the Metaphors. Honestly, William isn’t even a metaphor. He’s an entitled racist and misogynist and a murderer. It requires little suspension of disbelief to accept that this person does, indeed, exist. But the troll itself is the stories families tell each other across generations. WE keep feeding the troll because we cannot bear to move forward. The family (the father) is infallible, and to deny His history is to deny our own future. That is bunk, of course, and here we have the troll being both the life and death of William’s whole family line.
I love Emma’s character, and the reveal that she has been draining all of her lifeforce just trying to keep her son alive. And I think Apollo had a real redemption arc here. I buy it fully. But idk, what do y’all think about Apollo in the end?
The only part of this novel that I had a tough time with was the technology. It felt a bit preachy about privacy issues and finger-waggy about social media. I think caution is important, but it went a little hard for my taste. Plus, it’s funny how quickly tech sounds dated. This book is barely a decade old.
Final thoughts:
Emma’s final wish on the red string was “to have a life full of adventure?” How do we feel about that choice? I thought it was going to be something like “Protect my child from harm” or something related to Brian. Interesting that the wish was so idk simple?
Can we see the police report for Forest Hills on this final night? Wtf do we think the NYPD made of all this?
Where are Cal and the others these days? I hope they’re doing all right.