Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

We landed this plane. But how smooth was the final descent? I’ll start with what I absolutely loved. 

LaValle stayed committed to the fairy tale motif with the troll swallowing the child whole. I went from what the holy hell? to Oh, of course. 

Of course, there are the Metaphors. Honestly, William isn’t even a metaphor. He’s an entitled racist and misogynist and a murderer. It requires little suspension of disbelief to accept that this person does, indeed, exist. But the troll itself is the stories families tell each other across generations. WE keep feeding the troll because we cannot bear to move forward. The family (the father) is infallible, and to deny His history is to deny our own future. That is bunk, of course, and here we have the troll being both the life and death of William’s whole family line. 

I love Emma’s character, and the reveal that she has been draining all of her lifeforce just trying to keep her son alive. And I think Apollo had a real redemption arc here. I buy it fully. But idk, what do y’all think about Apollo in the end?

The only part of this novel that I had a tough time with was the technology. It felt a bit preachy about privacy issues and finger-waggy about social media. I think caution is important, but it went a little hard for my taste. Plus, it’s funny how quickly tech sounds dated. This book is barely a decade old.

Final thoughts:

  • Emma’s final wish on the red string was “to have a life full of adventure?” How do we feel about that choice? I thought it was going to be something like “Protect my child from harm” or something related to Brian. Interesting that the wish was so idk simple?

  • Can we see the police report for Forest Hills on this final night? Wtf do we think the NYPD made of all this?

  • Where are Cal and the others these days? I hope they’re doing all right.

Comments

Karlee Liberty

I have thoughts. They are very jumbled though haha Maybe I'm reading it weird but... Emma got her final wish right? This was certainly an adventure. Didn't say it had to be fun. She said that I immediately thought, "so this was all your fault" William was a troll too, right? An internet troll. Did you catch the claw marks? Cal really was being literal. I also felt a little bit of the finger-wagging regarding posting your kid on socials, but I get it. It's still kind of a thing. The idea that Emma was so strong because she HAD to be really struck me. The moment she felt like someone could help, that well of power faded because it was no longer necessary. And how true does that feel? The things people achieve because there is no other choice I almost wish there hadn't really been a troll. A lot of this story could be explained up until the actual changeling form and then the troll itself. I loved the fable concept - but I really wanted the bad guys to just be bad people. Horror is sometimes scarier when its just people. I did like the story overall though! I have Lavelle's quartet so I might jump into another one soon

Robynne Blume

The line that stood out to me the most in this section was "The world is full of glamour, especially when it obscures the suffering of the weak." And then not just one line, but the reveal of Emma draining her lifeforce. I loved the whole sequence with Apollo expecting Emma to start glowing and her explaining that she was only doing that because she had no other choice but to dig into every last reserve she had in a way that was completely unsustainable. It felt like a microcosm of the gender relationships that the entire book critiques. Apollo and his father both saw their wives as miracle workers and trusted them to take care of impossible tasks, thus excusing their own inaction. There's a nod to the happily ever after, and how much it glosses over the difficulties of life in the years ahead, but I couldn't help wondering about the more immediate future. Speaking of the police report, what happened to Brian in the next few days? His mother is wanted for his murder, and his father is in violation of his parole. They have also now each committed murder, and arson, although I could easily see the fire and deaths in the house being written off as accidental. Still, I don't see a world in which Brian doesn't at the very least live with Kim or Lillian for some time while his parents are both in some form of prison or treatment program.

Juliette Birkner

That last point was exactly my issue with the ending. I loved so many things about this book, but I found the very very ending to be deeply unsatisfying because it left these big gaping irreconcilable holes. The book has so much about how the system is unkind to black folks and how all Apollo wants is to be there for his son. But now Apollo is finally back with his family and we get no indication that he will be able to keep the real world prison system from tearing the family apart

Sarah

I'm not sure how I feel about these last few chapters, so for now I'll just make some observations while I let it sit. Jorgens rant about social media and over sharing does turn a bit into a brain dead Atlantic op-ed, and I wonder what the authors views are. The characters obsession with tradition and belief that true "greatness" can only be found in the past also speaks to the psychology of conservative politics pretty well: "Apollo had been in the windowless den, talking about the past at the expense of the present." It was nice to see Apollo be a good attentive partner, and it only took a few personal near death experiences and grisly murders to get there. Wasnt at all surpised that Wheeler was the kind of guy to seriously use the word 'beta cuck', I half expected for LaValle to mention that his fingers were also cheeto dusted (earlier LaValle uses the word 'shook' to describe a police officer and I remember thinking "wow, its been a while since I've heard that word used like that." I wonder if the context of these words will be lost on someone reading his book 50 years from now, and is that just the risk of using slang?) And Robynn absolutely called it with the flashlight app, that had completely left my mind, even if it didnt end up being the thing to take down the troll. I didn't get more background about Emma like I wanted, though glad she got the final swing that took down Wheeler, that was satisfying. I guess I feel the ending was a bit rushed? That might be because I'm used to books with ambiguous endings full of yearning and ennui. I feel there were hints of world building that werent fully sketched out; I have questions about Cal and the island, the other people in Kinder Garten. Were they just normal people? Was Cal actually the witch Emma met in Brazil who gave her the bracelet? I was convinced that photograph of her in the rundown building would come up again. Hope none of that is unfair to the author, writing a novel must be like trying to balance spinning plates on straws. It could be that the inclusion of the occult and magic were just literary devices and not core elements of the story like I thought. I did really appreciate one of the final scenes where Apollo and Emma fumble their way in the dark trying to mend the emotional gap between each other and think it reads like a lovely metaphor about relationships. In the end I think LaValle faced age-old demons and conquered them, at least for today. On the whole a really good book. Funny, morbid, and gives a lot to think about. Also, does anyone else remember Fabian? The apartment maintenance worker who was kind to Apollo after his release from prison? Bless Fabian.

Juliette Birkner

I loved so much about this book. I loved that magic and fairy tales weave in and out of reality and it mostly didn't bother me that not everything gets explained or followed up on (in life we don't always get to see the ends tied together, sometimes you get a tiny glimpse of something and thats all). I was blown away by Emma confronting Apollo about "the first time you took my light from me" even while she is starting to accept his help. I loved the bit about Emma gaining magic/unexplained power because there was no other option but that they are stronger together even if there isn't magic. I underlined "What lengths will people stretch to believe they're still good?" Because it felt like something that the narrative had sort of bee circling for much of the book. I was super frustrated at the ending (I actually wrote about it in my journal 😅) because I don't see how Apollo (in breech of parole) and Emma (wanted for murder) and move forward in the real world. What i landed on is that maybe in that moment, to Apollo, nothing matters except that he has his family right now and right now is all he has and therefore all that matters. Im not sure im satisfied by that, but it certainly left me continuing to think about the story long after setting the book down

Juliette Birkner

Not sure if anyone was interested in tracking, but here's my final list of various literary allusions I/we caught: Books: Outside Over There Fields of Fire To Kill a Mockingbird (and to a lesser extent Go Set A Watchman) Great Gastby (green light) Macbeth Wizard of Oz (or maybe the movie i guess) We Have Always Lived in the Castle The Odyssey Films: Child's Play Quilombo Airplane The Smurfs (TV show, not movie) Mythology/folk tales: Apollo Callisto Rupunzel Red string of fate Scottish/Celtic/general European changelings (honestly pretty embarrassed this wasn't in my initial list...) Hansel and gretel (trail of breadcrumbs pg 328) Askeladden (Norwegian fables) Vampire

Karlee Liberty

Are we doing another book thru the holidays? 👀