Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

So this unfortunately isn't affecting just the new one, but all Halloween videos, and random videos in the rest of the catalog.

As some of you have already noticed and messaged me, some videos have been vanishing and reappearing with different bits cut, or timestamps being out of place etc. That's because I woke up this morning to discover a bunch of videos have been getting random claims of things, both valid and inaccurate, and also manual and automatic. I was fucking baffled why this is happening out of nowhere, but I've gotten some answers.

I hit a million subscribers recently (fun!) though this appears to have come with a drawback. Apparently due to the rise of AI sludge/scam content that can quickly rise to the top, YouTube has introduced a relatively new process of re-evaluating channels when they hit this mark for doing considerations for things like the other special backend services, the gold play button, etc. Part of this deal appears to be that you're both turned over more to the wolves to have all your content rescanned and you also enter the fun list for triple scrutiny from random scouts scouring videos to try to find things to claim for holders. The first part is annoying because something that may have been fine 5 years ago now has someone claiming a SoundCloud cover of it they made 2 years ago and are trying to grab it. That second part will be ongoing and has always been a part of YouTube (though it'll be trickier now) but the first part is what's biting hard since apparently this "legitimacy evaluation period" can last anywhere from 10-14 days. Doing some test uploads of bits from the new video got sounds in the background claimed as music and right now I'm trying not get another downright strike so I'm having to be careful.

It's fucking awful, but it looks like (assuming something worse doesn't happen) I'm going to have to wait for the heat to die down, which will be anywhere from 10-14 days. So for the first time in many years I won't have the Halloween video up in time for Halloween. This probably feels more devastating to me than it should be, but it does mean letting a lot of people down. The silver lining there is that this was going to be the last of the standalone Halloween videos anyways for "long/eternal Halloween" and instead rotate to doing them more regularly, but this feels like the website itself forcing me out of it rather than doing it on my own terms which feels fucking awful especially when I took time off from work for editing before a friend came down to visit and now I'm bouncing between this and seeing what else will break.

As for the state of the old videos, if you're wondering why some might have entire parts chopped off in the beginning instead of just erased/muted the answer is because I can't since those got manually claimed.

Of course having a video's entire first minute or a long section be silence isn't great either, so it's bad either way. And no it's nothing like Goosebumps was blanketly grabbed or some specific holder is after me, the randomness is what's made it so bizarre until I got answers. Some I -could- dispute on and have on a few that aren't trying to block the video, but my experience with that is they sometimes hold out the entire 30 days before suddenly declining just before to keep anything they gained, or they just wait out the timer entirely, but it means a good chunk of videos that would be blocked in random regions for a month while risking escalation. This isn't something I can really @ TEAMYOUTUBE or whatever either since this seems to be the machine working as intended. Getting a cut done that's unlisted would still be the same problem and this has already burned a stupid amount of time getting things figured out, plus I think the general public would have my head if they thought I was making the Halloween video a PATREON EXCLUSIVE or something else that sounds like I'm being mega shitty. Typically I've been quite careful, even sending emails to ask about things sometimes, but contacts can leave and systems change, so it just means I'll have to be even more cautious from now on though safety for these things is never guaranteed. I of course do have originals backed up, but I'm not sure how to handle those at the moment since right now my brain is spinning at the schedule knock on effect this will have. It might mean I need to delay milk game, or push it into December or even January playing catchup with plans since I can no longer line things up how I planned. I'm mainly worried about something being gone permanently and needing a reupload, since Anonymous Agony got extremely close to that a while back when it was gone a month (though I did win that dispute).

Anyways it fucking sucks and I'm sorry this is happening. I'll figure out what to do about milk game, though I'll update next Friday about my status in YouTube jail. With luck I'll be out and can just upload the thing then and be mostly back on schedule but we'll see. Right now I'm figuring out how to make the public announce, so that'll come later tonight or tomorrow.

Files

So Depressed

David Lynch on location making 'Inland Empire'.

Comments

Mar Sadeh

Wow, that's... stupid and bad and corrupt and fucked up. I'm super sorry you're dealing with a bunch of AI bullshit as a consequence of being productive and successful, which seems like the opposite of how that's supposed to work. Here's hoping the heat dies down quickly and your schedule returns to form quickly!

Hawkwing2652

Thanks for the transparency. It sucks, but we can be patient while this crap is sorted out.

Andrew Hess

1. Obviously, this sucks. Keep fighting the fight, I know you can get through it. 2. Imma just watch other videos from you in the meantime. Happy Halloween, don't feel bad, this isn't on you.

Matteo.YB

Can't trust corpos with AI.

HawkBeak25

Sending you the obligatory tools to dig a tunnel out of that shitty jail time…

Cowit

Situation sucks!!! I'm happy to be patient for what's the come though!

LastTrueborn

Hey bud, you do what you need to do. Just be kind to yourself. We're all in your corner otherwise we wouldn't be here in your comments.

Mr. Pie

That sucks dude. Would you be willing to upload the video on Patreon in time for Halloween? For the subscribers?

KitsuneBot

Quick! Someone cut the undersea internet cables while we still have time!

Rory

Fucking awful, there really is no end to the YouTube ride of suffering. Hope you're at least able to have an enjoyable Halloween, take a break from the YT torture cube for a bit.

Bigman Johnson

This reeks of "congrats on all your success, now we want a bigger cut!" So congrats for 1 mil I guess. Sad about no Halloween video, but hearing you have to deal with that shit is legitimately worse.

dFour

You've been crazy dedicated too all of this Halloween tomfoolery, i genuinely feel for you. I nonetheless think people will spiritually understand what and why stuff happened! I wouldn't even sully the video with this information, a separate tiny video on hakoween or a pinned comment should be enough. Also Divine Frequency came into early access today, and I wanna shill it here, because it might be GOTY for some of you!

The Western Fountain

What a fucking stupid system. Hope it gets resolved in your favor.

KodyxDestroyer

Your Halloween videos are always a highlight. I'm sure it'll be worth the wait. Appreciate the updates, hoping for the best. Congratulations on the 1M subs. Sorry it came with bad news.

Gage Grady

Stay strong Mandy you’ve overcome worse 👍

Stormz23

The spookiest Halloween scare of them all AI moderation agents

Cierra_Bo_Berra

I wish there was another video platform as community centered and as big as YouTube, that wasn't so obnoxious about copyright and fair use. Hopefully it'll work out but until then, good luck fighting the good fight

AmishMechanic

Gotta love YouTube ignoring literal years of creators complaining about the garbage AI auto-claim system. No worries Mandy, we have gladly waited 6+ months for new vids before. Sorry the ass-reaming has ramped up even more

BearGrifter

Fuckin YouTube just keeps making things worse for legit creators. Sorry, man. This sucks. We have your back no matter what, so do what's best for you and we'll be here.

Connor Gelkov

When the hell are we going to get some decent Youtube alternatives?

ItisWingman

*dead_space_3_suicide_bomber_AAAGGH.mp4*

Er

Sorry you’re having to deal with this. Echoing that it’s cool, take your time

Braden Robison

Youtube's new detections suck. I spent six months making a video essay only to find that YT detected it as copyright violation, despite the heavy editing involved. I feel your pain.

Davyd Miller

Literally suffering from success, here's hoping it all works out!

Dream&Nightmare

Could it be possible to upload old videos on here, so that we can at least get to watch them without all the YouTube nonsense?

Chase Cushman

I’m sorry to hear about this stuff. Hopefully it is just front loaded bullshit that levels out. With regards to the Milk game, don’t sweat it. It is shorter than Paratopic and has what I would call a pseudo deep story. It is not something that will be worth giving attention to at this time with the mountains of other work you have. Congrats on suffering from success!

Fitzy

People will understand - you put a ton of work into your content and people know it fuck youtube

Jeanette H

Augh, that sucks. I'm so sorry, Mandy. Please feel free to push back whatever you need to push back, if it helps reduce the headache that is navigating youtube and current year bullshit.

Nomads-of-Korsun

From what you're describing, having to delay the Halloween video seems perfectly reasonable. I'm sure most of your fans don't mind waiting, your videos are often quality uploads and I don't mind if it takes you a bit of time to do them. Regardless, good luck. Hope Youtube gets off your back soon.

Skilco

I think, less of "I can't get videos out on time I'm and disappointing people" and think more "I'm working hard for my content and fans, despite many drawbacks". From what I've seen, there's plenty of arguments "FOR" the latter, And plenty more arguments "AGAINST" the former. Be proud of your success and no need to be sorry, we ain't shareholders 🤣, I'm personally happy that you are open with these issues. And I hope you can enjoy your success.

Arkennys

That sucks, I'm sorry you have to deal with this =(

Kurahen

This sucks. I saw other youtubers absolutely @teamyoutube and it worked (at least for those cases), since it seems only way to get actual human to look at the issue

C2

I'm sorry YT is shit like this. Given the big-picture uncertainty around AI, the internet and the world at large I would appreciate a downloadable archive or backup being made available if such a thing isn't too hard to arrange.

Petabik

Don't be so harsh on yourself Mandy, this isn't your fault.

Clemming

Hearing stuff secondhand within other content is really the best way to experience music. Why go to the original as a consumer when I can have it be edited down and talked over? /s

Kat S

I saw this notification while checking my email because YouTube is blocking me from seeing content I paid for from a completely different creator. Sorry this is happening. Youtube is going to make itself completely unusable soon.

Vacui

Ouch. Don't worry for my support, I will give it to you no matter your output.

NekoiNemo

Any chance you could upload the videos that got hit to Patreon? I don't mean linking a YT upload, but directly to their CDN. Granted, Patreon video playback suuuuuuuucks, but at least it will be a way to watch uncut versions

SPYDOR

Good luck fighting all the detestable parasites trying to get their pound of unearned flesh: sounds like a veritable nightmare! There should always be meaningful financial penalties for failed claims, otherwise you will naturally get spurious claims from leeches with too much time on their hands. Wish YouTube would sort this out, as too many talented creators get penalised unfairly.

John Mapley

What a nightmare. I was worried when the expected Halloween video didn’t pop up from you, but glad to see there will be one at some point (whenever you decide is safe, of course). On another note, this made me realise I didn’t support you on Patreon which I guess I kind of assumed I already did. Fixed that right away. It would be great to have an archive of the original, unmangled videos here one day in the future when you have time. In the meantime don’t let the bastards grind you down!

LapisAzure

It's incredible how Youtube always manages to make things worse for viewers and legit uploaders. At least you got the originals, so in the worst case the videos won't be lost completely. Please take care until things are sorted!

The Yolkling

This sucks as the Halloween episodes from you are among my favorite thing to celebrate the day with (alongside Ross Scott's! (Thank god he made THREE this year while youre getting the shaft)) I cant wait for it come out, but obviously non of the disappointment comes stems from you. Youtube is being youtube, predictable. Besides, the unsinkable 10 hour stream was celebration enough for the holiday.

Evelyn Oda

AI really did cause the massive enshittification of everything, didn't it?