Home
Creators
Search Recent Missing Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

BOOK CLUB QUESTIONS: Fallen Angels & A Thousand Sons (Patreon)

Published:
2024-07-05 11:30:29
Imported:
2026-06
Tags:

Content

It's last minute I know, but TONIGHT we record our book club episodes for the two above Horus Heresy novels. Any questions and observatons? Please put them in the comments and we'll answer them - if we can - in the episodes!!

Comments

Ian Millington-Davies

How do you 2 feel the HH Dark Angels centric story arc's line up to with what we now know from the Arks of Omen story progression?

Snoop Hogg

Love to get your opinions on what's the balance of fault (in destroying the webway project) between Magnus' fault for doing literally the thing he was told not to do, and Emps' fault for not explaining the true dangers of the warp (or even just what his plans on Terra are) to his "trusted" sons? Another classic Shakespearean tragedy from the Heresy series I think!

Jake Merkel

What do you guys think the real point of the trial was? I feel like the emperor knew what his decision was already. To me it looked quite targeted like he almost wanted to humiliate Magnus in a similar way to Lorgar.

Ingimar Bjarni Sverrisson

Did this book significantly change the fan perception of Magnus and did the mirror novel change the perception of this one?

James Larner

Will you be reading anything special to celebrate when Mira reaches 10k subscribers? 🤩

WellenInspektor
>>142766094

Giving a curious person a locked door and not telling them why they shouldn't open it can only have one result. Magnus was a researcher and most of research is finding a way around paths that were once closed off to you.

Sam Dawes

Why did the emperor, create Magnus with a thirst for knowledge, then tell him he can't know about something? Seems like a bit of a dick move, right?! 😂

WellenInspektor
>>142766094

P.S. my name is pronounced Wilkinson's Catalyst Tris-triphenyl rhodium chloride. Chlorotris (triphenylphosphine) rhodium (I) if you're nasty.

Alistair

Did Magnus do the wrong thing for the right reasons, or the right thing for the wrong reason?

Robert Ferguson

The Dark Angels and the Thousand Sons seem like an good example of the dichotomy between legions that would have no point after the crusade is finished and legions that have non martial things going on. What’s your thoughts on The Emperor’s intentions for the astartes post crusade? Also what cool psychic powers would you like to have that would make the Thousand Sons pick you for an apprenticeship?

Chris Davis

What are your thoughts on the on going theme that Primarch seconds in command are utter bastards? My examples being Luther, Erebus, Kor Phaeron and Ahriman?

Nathaniel Westwood

Just an in general question. What do you make of the dialogue across heresy and 40k books? Particularly the Space Marine dialogue, brother. Personally, sometimes it's too much for me. And since tiktokkers and you-tubers have started making shorts and reels with it, it's sounding like gratingly vaccous tripe. But your opinion is more educated and better than mine, please enlighten me. I am autistic so I have certainly missed something others are picking up on.

Happy Haribo

How do you think Inquisters would react when confronted by Horus Heresy reenactors with blank-firing bolters and replica power armour?

ArbitorIan
>>142973800

I'm in agreement. SOMETIMES it's done well, but a lot of the time it's just a lot contractionless 'Yes Brother, honour the chapter brother'. I really dislike the tiktokkers currently attempting to act it out like it's an ultra-serious action movie. It just never sounds as good in real life!