Is It Wrong to Crave Love (In A Dungeon)? Chapter 34 - Kindness (Patreon)
Content
Author's Note: Redrafted and rewrote this chapter four times before I finally decided to publish as is.
She had a long dream.
In the dream, everyone she knew perished. In the dream, she became a monster. In the dream, after becoming a monster, she took a knife to her chest and stabbed until the hilt was buried between her breasts. Stab. Stab. Deep within her chest, she stabbed. She drew the blade and stabbed again. Jab. Jab. She jabbed again. She stabbed and jabbed until the blade was bent and broke. She stabbed and jabbed until the hilt was in her chest. She stabbed and jabbed until her arms were numb. She cried and wept: the monster inside of her refused to die.
In the dream, she took a knife to her own throat. Slice. Slice. Her flesh fell off. Cut. Cut. Her pharynx was carved. Snick. Snick. Her throat was diced. Slice and cut and dice and carve, the monster inside of her refused to die.
In the dream, she found others and attacked them. Bang. Bang. She crushed their skulls. Smush. Smush. She mangled their spines. Many begged before they died. Many cursed before they died. Many screamed before they died. She envied the ones who died as they died. She prayed to be killed by the ones who died. She tried and tried, but the monster inside of her refused to die.
The monster inside of her refused to die.
In the dream, there was no one to save her from the monster. There was no one who could love the monster. Other monsters wanted to use the monster. Monsters befriended monsters. Monsters cherished monsters. The monster inside of her stopped being the monster inside of her.
The monster inside of her ate the inside of her.
There was no part of her that was not monster. There was no monster that was not part of her.
There was only the monster that refused to die.
The dream was sad. The dream was bad. She did not like the dream. She was sinking within the dream. Sinking deeper into the monster. Deeper and deeper, she was drowning in the monster.
Please, please, I want to wake up!
Please, please, let me wake up!
Please, please, I don’t want to be the monster!
Please, gods, please, don’t let me be the monster!
Please… someone… anyone—-
Please—
Please.
“Okay.”
A flame appeared within the dream. A blue flame that turned white. A white flame that turned blue.
“Okay,” said the Flame. “I’ll save you. In exchange, you have to give it to me.”
‘Give?’ She asked.
“Your heart. Your soul. Your body. Your mind. Your devotion. Your time. Your love. Your life.”
The Flame danced about.
“Give it all to me. Feed it all to me,” It said happily. “I want it all. I need it all. I crave it all.”
In the dream, she had to make a choice. A choice. A choice. She had to make a choice. Two of them were there, and she had to make a choice.
The monster that could not die and the flame that could not be sated.
In the dream, she reached for the flame.
=====)+(=====
At the Denatus, the God of Travellers and Thieves quietly observed the Goddess of the Hearth.
Hestia was glowing. Accompanying her luminescence was a rosiness of cheeks, a blush of health, springiness of step, and perkiness of breasts. She bore the glow that Hermes only saw from the most delighted of wives and the most job-satisfied of courtesans.
She may as well have been wearing a sign that said: I’ve been fucked good.
“You didn’t think it could be kept a secret, did you?”
Hephaestus, of forge-colored hair and one-eyed fame, spoke with a chiding, dry voice to the recently unchaste goddess.
“I didn’t think everyone would notice.”
“Hestia, sweet Hestia, dear,” Demeter, of bountiful breasted fortune, provided softly. “We’re gods.”
Discerning whether an individual recently engaged in sexual intercourse was hardly a challenge in a room of beings each possessing pseudo-omniscience. The mortal children with their enhanced senses of smell were able to do so just from the remnants of dead skin and the presence of certain scent profiles.
“Goddesses especially always draw attention,” Demeter added, drawing the gaze of at least three further gods to her cleavage as she breathed. “No matter what we do, no matter how little, the gods are always watching us.”
“They’re always watching you.” One of Hephaestus’ arms crossed underneath her chest as the other moved to rub her brow. “For two specific reasons.”
“Don’t sell yourself short, Hephaestus, dear. You have your own share of admirers.”
The three goddesses chattered amongst themselves as if unaware, or uncaring, as to how Hestia was at the center of collective discussion. Amongst the myriad gazes and opinions, Hermes heard more than a few whispered voices dripping with eagerness.
“Hey, if the shop’s finally open, does that mean we can get some, too?”
“Sounds like it. If she really did it with a mortal… give it a few thousand years tops, after he’s long dead and buried, and we’ll have our shot.”
“I can’t wait to have a taste. Those tits of hers have always been driving me crazy! I want to suck on them so hard!”
“Come off it. You know she’ll never agree to it.”
“Maybe if we teamed up, we could have some fun… She’s only got one measly Level Two Adventurer, after all."
“Are you blind? Can’t you see who she’s got beside her? You really want to piss off Hephaestus? No? What about Demeter? You want your Familia to starve?”
Hermes drummed his fingers on his hat. Impressive. The Cheerleader Effect of Hestia’s choice of acquaintances was impressive.
Did she know?
The eyes of the God of Merchants narrowed into thin, polite slits.
No. The Old Man has got me paranoid. This is Hestia we’re talking about.
“You’re suspecting her.”
A red-haired, flat-chested, jean shorts-clad goddess walked up beside him. Hermes only offered a polite smile, but retracted it as he took in the language she spoke with her body. Loki’s arms were crossed, and her gaze was sharp. There was none of that playfulness he usually saw in the Trickster Goddess, none of that lackadaisical, devil-may-care mien, none of her usual pseudo-drunken disinterest.
“You should.”
I should…? Hermes studied Loki. He looked from Loki to Hestia and from Hestia to Loki again, and his own thoughts started to race.
“You’re worried over nothing,” Hermes chuckled. “Using her chastity and its liquidation as a tool is a maneuver far beyond her.”
Or rather, it’s far beneath her.
Hestia lacked the guile, Hestia lacked the cunning, and Hestia lacked the needed ambition. Even in Olympus, Hestia had always been expressly nonpartisan. She explicitly refrained from disputes, conflicts, and power struggles. If she gave her virginity to a mortal, then she did so because she cared for that mortal.
“Then that love-crazy child of hers that’s responsible. He’s the one responsible for all of this.”
Love-crazy?
“This?”
Loki gestured around. “This.”
Silence was his question. An exasperated click of the tongue was her reply.
“Look around.”
Hermes did. All around him, he saw the same thing. Gods talking about Hestia. Gods watching Hestia. Gods looking at Hestia. Gods lusting after Hestia. The Denatus, the Gathering of the Gods, had temporarily become the Hestia Discussion and Appraisal Meeting. The lust in the eyes of some of the gods made him curious. The way some of the gods had their lips watering as their eyes were glued to her breasts, the way some were paying close attention to each and every single one of her barefoot toes with fervor made him shudder.
“Does any of this feel normal to you?”
Normal…?
Was it normal? Hestia had rejected advances from every male god for thousands of years. Yet, even if the fact that she lost her virginity was something of note, was it normal for it to be this noteworthy? Hermes could not say. An event like this had never happened before, so there was no frame of reference to compare it to.
Wasn’t it normal for the gods to be this enthused about Hestia’s virginity? Especially because a mortal had taken what it was they wanted?
Loki ran her hand through her hair, cursing. “Get closer and tell the shortstack to tone it down. I’m hosting this damned event, and we need to get started.”
Tone it… down?
“And the reason you don’t tell her yourself…?”
Loki didn’t answer him. Hermes let out a sigh and sauntered towards the day’s center of attention, clearing his throat as he interrupted Hestia’s conversation with Demeter.
“Congratulations are in order.”
Hestia groaned. “Not you too.”
It was more a chirp than a groan. There was no true sense of irritation or frustration around her. She was not embarrassed, she was not mortified, nor was she resigned to the helplessness of her chastity and lack thereof being the object of mass discussion.
From her, there was only warmth. From her eyes, the warmth of the sun. From her skin, the warmth of summer. From her presence, the warmth of an old friend. The warmth around her made him want to kick his feet up after a long, tiring day, lean his head back, and drink divine liquor as he broke out into soliloquy.
“You’re all too nosy for your own good, you know?”
Hermes shuddered. Her words carried a warmth that spread through his body.
What in the—
“You—” Hermes took a moment to collect his words. “You’ve changed, Hestia.”
“She has,” Hephaestus sighed. “It’s hard for me to believe she’s the same goddess who spent weeks mooching off me, reading books and eating jagamarukun.”
“Hey, Heph! You don’t always need to bring that up, you know!”
“I know, but— I didn’t believe you had it in you to take running a Familia seriously.”
“I was always one hundred percent serious!”
“Hestia,” Hermes interrupted. “Do you know what you’re doing?”
Hestia tilted her head. “What am I doing?”
She doesn’t…? She doesn’t realize…? How can she not—
“You’re—”
Hephaestus shot him a look. Beside her, Demeter also shot him a dangerous look. A warning look.
Hephaestus knows and Demeter knows. They both know, but both didn’t tell her? Hermes cleared his throat again, smiling. “You’re… no, it’s nothing.”
Hestia’s brows furrowed in concern.
“Are you okay, Hermes?”
“I—”
Hermes looked into her eyes and he saw himself.
He saw himself with his head on her lap, his eyes tired, and his lips confessing of a long and weary day. He saw a tray, a warm meal set before him, a comforting, nodding Hestia-faced woman of his favored preferences and proclivities in an apron. He saw himself spilling his thoughts, his complaints, about the terrible journey through the countryside. He saw himself giving his lamentations about Ares and his damned army wreaking havoc and disrupting supply lines, his frustration as to the task the old man had given him, and the nature of the question as to whether or not he would ever find a ‘Hero’ in Orario.
Hermes saw these all and more before he answered, and his voice hitched in his throat, and no words came forth. Then, he did the wise thing of looking away from Hestia’s eyes. He did the smart thing of masking his decision to look away with a pull-down of his hat to obscure his eyes.
“Hermes…?”
This is what Loki meant.
Hermes gave a smile. “It’s nothing to worry about.”
The shorter goddess did not appear convinced, but Hermes was not trying to be convincing. He only gave a helpless smile and offered one of his usual default perverted remarks about her body. Hestia rolled her eyes, and Hermes returned to his internal world of thoughts with too many to organize.
That feeling was undoubtedly her Authority.
Looking into her eyes had triggered an effect that nearly had him confiding in Hestia secrets that under normal circumstances could not be tortured out of him. Had he not caught himself, Hermes was certain he would have blabbed even about everything from his embarrassing disinclinations to his erotic predispositions without pausing to stop for air.
What changed?
There was only one thing that had changed. The campfires.
Is it possible the campfires are doing more than just helping Adventurers?
The possibility was high.
If each and every one is an altar to Hestia, then Hestia is, whether she knows it or not, the most worshipped Goddess in Orario. The only Goddess to whom every day, there are Adventurers going to her ‘altars’ and her ‘temples.’
The nature of those hearths as well… they reportedly draw upon Olympos’ Flame. It would mean each one acts as a small ‘faucet’ allowing her to draw more and more Divine Power.
Yet, that alone doesn’t explain it. There’s something more. Her power…
While she was in the heavens, was her power… limited?
The gods did not consider themselves family. None of them were related. Not a single one of them. Not in any sense that could allow for familial connection. Hestia’s Authority had always been limited by her surroundings.
Home. Hearth. Family.
Could one truly embody a loving home if they had never been in one?
Could one truly personify the bonds of family if they had never experienced one?
The more time she spent with her earthly family on Orario, the more time she spent growing her home, and the more of the campfires that were constructed…
Hestia… you’re…
With a look, a gaze, perhaps even a smile from Hestia, one would feel as if they had found a place where they belonged, a shelter from their deepest worries, a refuge from their anxieties.
With a laugh, they would find family.
A power capable of opposing charm—
‘Familia.’
Hermes rubbed the bridge of his forehead with his thumb.
That’s why at a gathering of gods, the gathering of heads of families, she draws the most attention. Her Authority itself demands it.
The very word we use to organize ourselves falls under her Authority. Every Familia is considered a Family.
Can, in a gathering of heads of families, the Goddess of Family be ignored?
That would be as impossible as a Goddess of Beauty being ignored at a beauty pageant.
Hermes looked at Hephaestus. The one-eyed goddess also looked at him.
But… if the Familia System itself can be considered as part of her Authority the way Hephaestus considers smithing part of her Authority… the ramifications…
That’s why you did not tell her.
Hermes scratched the back of his head letting out a wry laugh.
And I thought Freya’s Charm was a cheat ability.
But this power…
Familia…
Could it… possibly?
The origin of the alteration that the Old Man spoke of, the altered history—
Could it be…?
A boom off in the distance. An ear-trembling blast that shook seats and reverberated through the Babel Tower.
“AAAAAAH!”
A wild, frenzied scream burst forth at the Denatus.
Eyes slammed collectively towards a location in the rafters. Dian Cecht was flat on his buttocks on the ground, pointing with a trembling finger at someone in front of him. The source of the scream had not come from Dian Cecht, but from the god clutching his head in front of him—
“AAAH! AAAAAH!”
The God of Wine let out a baleful wail—
Before his head caught ablaze with bright white fire.
=====)+(=====
Guild workers were running to and fro throughout the Babel Tower. Moving in a frantic, hurried mass, alongside numerous High Level Adventurers, the merchants on the lower floors watched the ensemble gathering and rushing of individuals with whispered mumbles and grumbles.
“Oi… What’s going on?”
“They said something happened at the Denatus.”
“A deity tried to blow themselves up and take all the other gods with them back to heaven.”
“You’re joking. Why would they—”
“No one knows. The Denatus has been on lockdown since! The gods are discussing how to handle it amongst themselves. They say no one’s allowed to leave.”
“Does this have anything to do with the massive blast that happened earlier?”
“I heard someone saying that the Hestia Familia’s home was destroyed.”
“There’s no way those two things are connected. Don’t overthink things—”
On the twenty-ninth floor of the Babel Tower, a bespectacled half-elf clad in the attire of Orario’s Guild slipped into a set of large red doors with ornate golden handles. She adjusted her glasses as she looked down the hallway. Taking a breath, she closed the door and locked it shut behind her.
The coast is clear.
Eina Tulle shut the door behind her, letting out a breath. Fortunately, there are resources allocated for this…
Above the 20th floor were the living areas of the most prominent Gods in Orario, known as the Private Rooms. The room she was in was one such room, initially meant to be resided in by deities. The cost of residing in these rooms for a night was enough to bankrupt smaller, lesser guilds.
Eina could not say it was not worth it.
The room reeked of elegance. Everything glittered and everything shone. From the grand living area to the silvered kitchen sink, the bar stocked with liquor, to the bedroom and the dual King-sized beds with fine linen, wool, and silks.
Eina moved into the bedroom, where she paused at the door, hurriedly adjusting her glasses and glancing away at the bare, muscled back of a man a full head taller than her. The back was broader, larger, bigger than the very same back she’d examined not too long ago, to the point that if told they belonged to the same person, she would never believe it.
The male guild uniform she had hastily provided him had been the largest she could find, but even then, it was tight on his body.
“Will Miss Arde be alright?”
Diverting her gaze from the back, she focused on the bed in the main room, and the naked pallum in the covers beneath it.
Had she not known Moses Vanderzee, had she not been familiar with the kind of man he was, she would have had a far different reaction when the man arrived inexplicably in the Guild’s female restrooms, with only a loose cloak around himself, and holding not one, but two unconscious and naked young women in his arms.
Eina would be lying if she said there hadn’t been a tiny moment where she’d feared she’d entirely misjudged him and a moment where her imagination had taken her to the most… uncouth of places. She quickly chastised herself for that lapse in imagination once he provided a narration of events.
“The attack nearly disintegrated her faster than I could heal her. I kept healing her. I kept healing her and healing her. She was conscious through most of it. It was only a few seconds, but…”
He ran his hand through his hair.
“It felt like hours. It felt like hours. Hours where I thought, I thought for a moment…”
He moved closer to the unconscious pallum, gently placing his hand on her head.
“She’s alive. That’s all that matters.”
The events, had it been anyone but Moses Vanderzee who told her, Eina would have doubted them. Yet, she did not doubt him. He was the only one with an Essence-Shell Link. His body, connected to his soul as he theorized, meant his soul would still inhabit, move, control, and possess his body even if it was flayed down to nothing but bones.
It was a blessing and a curse.
If he were ever to be crushed into powder or turned into a pile of fluid flesh, Moses Vanderzee’s soul would remain in every grain and every drop, conscious of his scattered existence.
If it weren’t for the fact he has such a ridiculous Abnormal Resistance, even his bones would likely have…
From what he described, no Level Three Adventurer had any business surviving an attack of that level.
But the results of regenerating his flesh…
The guild uniform was straining with the newfound musculature on his body. When last they met, he had not been as thin as he was when she first saw him, but that was nothing compared to the body he now possessed.
There was almost no part of him that was not lean, fine, clear, and defined muscle. It was a form of body that would not be out of place on a masterwork sculpture, dedicated to the gods themselves. Eina had never been quite as shallow as others; she had never quite paid attention to the bodies of others, but there was something, some undeniable result of being a woman, that was intoxicated with a body that could only be described as the pinnacle of mortal physicality.
“...any information you can.”
Eina blinked. “I— sorry, what?”
“You’re staring at my pecs, Eina.”
Her head snapped up. “I—I— “ Words failed her. Blood flooded her cheeks and face. “I’m j-j-just…” Eina stammered. “E-even if you tell me you regrew and regenerated your body, the difference s-still takes some… adjustment.”
“This wasn’t my intention. I had nearly no body fat at all. When I healed my body, it created a healthy body with muscle that held an identical fat percentage to what I had before.”
It’s more than just that, Eina theorized. The Falna redefines and strengthens the soul, acting as a layer over the body, and with each Level Up, the ‘definition’ of the soul and the layers stack over each other, acting as an invisible base.”
It was why even someone could look as dainty as the Sword Princess, but still be able to lift twenty times their bodyweight.
But your soul and your body are intrinsically linked. It means the more you Rank Up, the stronger you become, and the more defined your body becomes…?
He was only Level Three, and he was already this defined. Eina shuddered to think of the results once he was Level Four, Level Five, or higher.
“I’m sorry for imposing on you like this, when we still haven’t had that dinner date.”
“That’s…” Eina adjusted her glasses. “I’m your Advisor, so this is hardly an imposition. Besides… we… before we discuss that, there’s still the other matter to handle.”
“Yes.”
Moses Vanderzee left the main bedroom, and she followed him into the guest room. There, on a smaller but still as elegant bed, was the second woman he had arrived with. A naked, blue-haired, pure-blooded elf, whose beauty instinctively brought heat to Eina’s cheeks.
“You said you know her.”
“Her hair color is different, and she’s…” Undeniably more beautiful. “Prettier.” Eina chose her words carefully. “That's why I had trouble recognizing her at first. However, there’s no mistake. She’s—”
Moses lifted a hand.
“Don’t tell me.”
His eyes, his blue eyes, flickered as he stared down at the slumbering elf.
“I don’t want to know who she was,” Moses said. “She’s not that person anymore.”
Not that person? “I… I don’t quite understand.”
“She’s a member of our Familia now. Her past doesn’t matter.”
Eina’s head snapped to him. “W-what?”
Is he serious?
“You— she… You said she’s the main culprit responsible for nearly killing you and destroying your—”
“She is.”
Eina was having trouble grasping his thought process.
“If… if I may ask… why?”
Moses’ gaze was locked on the unconscious elf.
“What happens when someone, anyone, in Orario, dies?”
“We covered this in our lessons.” Eina adjusted her glasses. “Their soul gets sent to the afterlife where—”
“Where it’s washed anew by the gods and sent back,” Moses nodded. “What about monsters? Do you know what happens when a monster dies?”
A Monster…? The thought gave her pause. Eina scratched her cheek. What happens when a Monster… dies?
“Do monsters have souls?”
“I—” Eina hesitated. “I don’t… know.”
The admission was almost embarrassing. It was undeniably a lapse in her knowledge, but it was also something she had never stopped to think of. Monsters had cores, but did they have souls?
Was she really supposed to look at a terrible, mindless creature who had caused so much pain and suffering, and ask if it had a soul?
Only him. Only Moses Vanderzee would ask such questions. Only he would ask her such questions. How and why he thought of such things, why he was thinking of such things, completely eluded her.
“That which is above is like to that which is below, and that which is below is like to that which is above.”
The words were unfamiliar. “What?”
Moses’ blue eyes turned to her, twinkling.
“It’s a concept known since antiquity and theorized by several ancient philosophers. Plato and the Stoics often proposed the synchronicity of the macrocosm and the microcosm. The same thing happens here. The Dungeon recycles the souls of monsters slain, puts them into new bodies, and births them anew. The Dungeon does the same thing to monsters below as the gods do for mortals above.”
“As above… so below?”
“Exactly.”
It was in moments like these that Eina was reminded that Moses Vanderzee was one of the most educated men she knew. There were few people, so few people, in Orario, that she would not mind sitting back and listening to them speak for hours, and hours, without ever tiring, and without ever continuing to be entertained.
“The theory may be plausible,” Eina admitted. “But I fail to see what that has to do with her.”
“When I touched her, she had the feel of a monster, not a person.”
Eina froze.
“Her soul was on its way to be recycled when I heard it calling out. Do you know what I heard?”
Moses’ blue eyes rippled.
“I heard it saying: Please don’t let me be the monster.”
Eina slowly adjusted her glasses again.
“That’s why you saved her.”
“She would have been reborn in the Dungeon. Reborn as a thing she feared so much that her soul was screaming out for anyone to save her from becoming it.”
“Mr. Vander… Moses,” Eina exalted. “I’m not saying I don’t understand your reasoning. But by your own accounts, she’s an unknown variable who displayed power vastly superior to her recorded capabilities. She destroyed your home, killed innocent workers, almost killed you and—”
“She did,” Moses said. “She did do all that. For that reason, I killed her. I killed the person who did those things.”
Moses gently laid his hand on her forehead. Gently, ever so gently, he caressed her forehead.
“The debt is paid. To condemn her to a fate of being eternally reincarnated as a monster for the sins of one lifetime is a punishment disproportionate to the crime.”
His head swayed from left to right, and his shoulders went up before coming back down.
“I can’t be that kind of being. There is nothing crueller, nothing, than being that kind of being. The kind that can license infinite punishment for a finite crime.”
His blue eyes shot to her, with a twinkle.
“If she’s going to be punished anyway, she might as well do so wearing a maid outfit, bent over my lap and receiving playful spanks. Don’t you think that’s far kinder?”
“Y-you—” Heat flushed Eina’s cheeks again. “That’s—”
“It is,” he said, nodding. “Rather than clawing, fighting for her life, dying and being reborn as a mindless beast until the end of time. At least, if one is going to be punished for their transgressions, then at least, at the very least, those punishments should be…”
He paused.
“Kind.”
His words made Eina recall a conversation they had almost like a lifetime ago. A conversation between a woman doing her job and a man searching for an Advisor.
“You can state a preference. Do you have an inclination for a specific gender or race?”
“No. I just want someone… Someone kind.”
“Kind…?”
“Kind. I’m going to be in over my head, so what I need more than anything… is someone kind.”
Eina’s heart was beating.
“That defeats the nature of a punishment.”
“I suppose it does,” Moses chuckled. “I suppose it does.”
Eina could no longer deny it.
“Moses.”
“Ye—”
Eina would blame Misha later on. She would blame Misha for the way she grabbed Moses Vanderzee’s head, stood on her tiptoes, and planted her lips against his. It was easier to blame Misha for these types of behaviors because her coworker had corrupted her. Yet, her corruption had only gone surface level, because beyond her lips landing on his, beyond her tongue entering his mouth, she floundered with inexperience, with uncertainty, with a slight trepidation as to the possibility that the action would be rejected.
When he leaned in, when his tongue mixed with hers, that fear of rejection melted, as did her body melt in his grasp. As his tongue explored her mouth, as his hands wrapped around her waist, as the sparks of electricity ran through every cell in her body, Eina Tulle could no longer deny it.
She had fallen for this man.
She had fallen, shamelessly in love with Moses Vanderzee.